FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

10.36 · The Slaying of Ariṣṭa, the Bull Demon

38 verses
Y Open on bhagavata.keshavaswami.com ↗
Read summary inline (18607 chars)

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) As Krishna entered the youthful age, His beauty captivated the young gopis . Their romantic relationship and amorous dancing is described in five chapters ( 29 - 33 ) known as rasa-pancadhyaya. This drama of love, untainted by any mundane passion, is considered the pinnacle of devotional intensity. After this wonderful exchange, Krishna killed the demons Sankhacuda, Kesi and Aristasura, after which Akrura took the transcendental brothers to Mathura. The gopis , who became disturbed even when briefly separated from Krishna during the daytime, were plunged into unbearable anxiety now their beloved had left Vrindavana.

Previous History of Vrindavana Next Rasa Pancadhyaya Last updated 1 year ago

Y – Youthood (29-40)

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) As Krishna entered the youthful age, His beauty captivated the young gopis . Their romantic relationship and amorous dancing is described in five chapters ( 29 - 33 ) known as rasa-pancadhyaya. This drama of love, untainted by any mundane passion, is considered the pinnacle of devotional intensity. After this wonderful exchange, Krishna killed the demons Sankhacuda, Kesi and Aristasura, after which Akrura took the transcendental brothers to Mathura. The gopis , who became disturbed even when briefly separated from Krishna during the daytime, were plunged into unbearable anxiety now their beloved had left Vrindavana.

Previous History of Vrindavana Next Rasa Pancadhyaya Last updated 1 year ago

A God that Dances

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) A God that Dances “As we begin the famous narration of Lord Krishna’s rasa dance, a dance of love with beautiful young girls, questions will inevitably arise in the minds of ordinary people regarding the propriety of God’s romantic dancing with many young girls in the middle of a full-moon autumn night. In his description of the Lord’s rasa dance in ‘Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead,’ Srila Prabhupada painstakingly explains the spiritual purity of these transcendental activities. Those advanced in the science of Krishna - the great teachers, or acaryas - leave no doubt that Lord Krishna is full and satisfied in Himself, free of all material desire, which is, after all, a sense of incompleteness or lack.” (SB 10.29.1) Five chapters in Canto Ten of Srimad-Bhagavatam famously depict Krishna’s intimate exchanges with the gopis of Vrindavana. These chapters, called the rasa-pancadhyaya, are known for their emotional intensity and aesthetic beauty. They have, however, also attracted criticism from mundane moralists and those unfamiliar with the spiritual truths which underpin such pastimes. According to Srimad-Bhagavatam, the gopis that Krishna danced with also had husbands and children, and in order to meet Krishna, they abandoned responsibility, religiosity and seemingly their very chastity. The British court judge, Arnold Joseph, for example, once criticised: “It is Krishna, the darling of 16,000 gopis, Krishna the love hero, who tinges the whole system with the stain of carnal sensualism or strange transcendental lewdness.” The Srimad-Bhagavatam thus clarifies why Krishna, the protector of dharma , seemingly violated dharma by having such intimate relations with the wives of others. Maharaja Pariksit placed this understandable confusion before Sukadeva Goswami, who offered a variety of explanations to resolve any doubts. Some of the main points that Srila Prabhupada emphasises are as follows: Physical – by material calculation, Krishna was only 8-years-old, an age at which uncontrolled lust is not exhibited. Furthermore, Krishna is referred to as apta-kama , one who is self-satisfied, not in need of any external element to fulfil a void. Familial – one may doubt whether Krishna was seduced, but Krishna is referred to yadu-pati , the most exalted of the Yadu dynasty. His glorious family lineage adds weight to his spotless character. Transcendental – as the Supreme Lord, Krishna often transgresses moral boundaries and simultaneously remains untouched, thus demonstrating His transcendental nature. For example, when the sun absorbs urine, it not only remains unpolluted, but also disinfects the contaminated place. Relational – Krishna acted in this way to fulfil the desires of the gopis , who had intensely prayed and performed unimaginable austerities for the opportunity to have such relationships with Him. Special – the Lord performed these pastimes to specially benedict conditioned souls who are attached to sense gratification, of which sex desire is the most entangling. By meditating on these pure and intimate pastimes, one’s heart is cleansed and they are freed from their lusty tendencies.

Previous Akrura’s Mission Next God vs Krishna Last updated 1 year ago

God vs Krishna

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) A God that Dances God vs Krishna The residents of Vrindavana introduce us to a spiritual world which most have neither heard nor dreamt of. Most people worship and realise God in His usual role of being creator and controller of the cosmos. In Vrindavana, however, the residents are so overcome by God’s sweetness that they forget His ontological identity as the Supreme Lord. The love exchanged between Krishna and His devotees is such that He seeks His devotees as much as they seek Him. In Vrindavana, Krishna needs His devotees as much as they need Him, and He loves them as much as they love Him. Here, God is more human than Superhuman, more natural than Supernatural. In Vrindavana, God sheds His Godhood to relish an intimate relationship which is unlimitedly more charming. The Srimad-Bhagavatam thus paints the most intimate picture of God. Generally, God is the one we fully depend on. Worshippers may see Him as the cosmic order-supplier, a convenient port of call in times of need and want. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, we witness how God becomes fully dependent on His devotees. He subordinates Himself to His parents, such that they feel the anxiety of protecting Him. We find stories of Krishna, for example, appearing as a helpless deity and requesting His devotees to ‘save’ Him. Generally, God is of spotless character. He is the all-good, non-controversial, completely straightforward personality above all kinds of suspicion. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, God steals things, kills demons, dances with married girls and is known to tell untruths. The transgressions of religious principles by the Supreme Lord not only establish His Supreme position which is beyond limit and boundary, but also demonstrate how, for the purpose of sweet relationships, He may sideline such concerns. Generally, God is the personality to whom everyone is indebted. We offer prayers of gratitude and thank Him for everything we have received. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, God becomes indebted to His devotees. Seeing their incredible sacrifice, He offers heartfelt gratitude to the gopis , and tells them: “I am not able to repay My debt for your spotless service, even within a lifetime of Brahma.” ( SB 10.32.22 ) Generally, God is that person who has all the answers. He provides the wisdom, guidance and enlightenment that we seek. We read in the Bhagavatam, however, of how God often takes advice from His own devotees. While in Dwaraka, news arrived of Jarasandha’s atrocities, and Krishna simultaneously heard of the Pandavas’ desire to perform the Rajasuya sacrifice. Desiring to intervene in both situations, Krishna turned to Uddhava for advice, who subsequently offered a perfect resolution. When Krishna appeared as Sri Chaitanya, He eagerly asked Ramananda Raya many profound questions, and deeply relished hearing his answers and realisations. Generally, God is the one we all fear. People have a multitude of superstitions that they follow just to ensure they’re not on the receiving end of God’s wrath. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, God fears His own devotees. When Krishna broke pots of yoghurt that His mother was churning, she immediately ran after Him in anger: “[Seeing the whipping stick in His mother’s hand,] He is crying and rubbing His eyes again and again with His two lotus hands. His eyes are filled with fear, and the necklace of pearls around His neck, which is marked with three lines like a conchshell, is shaking because of His quick breathing due to crying. To this Supreme Lord, Sri Damodara, whose belly is bound not with ropes but with His mother’s pure love, I offer my humble obeisances.” (Satyavrata Muni, Damodarastakam, Verse 2) Generally, God is the one who mercifully provides everything we need. In today’s world we find a plethora of prosperity churches that teach that faith, prayer, and contributions to the ministry will always improve one’s material situation. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, however, God often bestows His special mercy by stripping his dearmost devotee of everything: “If I especially favour someone, I gradually deprive him of his wealth. Then the relatives and friends of such a poverty-stricken man abandon him. In this way he suffers one distress after another.” (SB 10.88.8) Generally, God is the one who is conservative, strict and somewhat distant from our day-to-day lives. He is depicted as an old father, the witness, who only really comes into play in the role of a judge. In the Bhagavatam’s conception, God is full of colour, character and happiness. He plays a flute, dons beautiful clothes, eats to His heart’s content, dances with His devotees, and is full of humour and charm. Frederick Nietzsche once quipped: “I would only believe in a God who knows how to dance.” Srila Prabhupada beautifully sums up Krishna’s unique personality: “Sometimes the Lord, as the child of Mother Yasoda, requests His devotee for some food, as if He were very hungry. Sometimes He tells His devotee in a dream that His temple and His garden are now very old and that He cannot enjoy them very nicely. Thus He requests the devotee to repair them. Sometimes He is buried in the earth, and as if unable to come out Himself, He requests His devotee to rescue Him. Sometimes He requests His devotee to preach His glories all over the world, although He alone is quite competent to perform this task. Even though the Supreme Personality of Godhead is endowed with all possessions and is self- sufficient, He depends on His devotees. Therefore the relationship of the Lord with His devotees is extremely confidential. Only the devotee can perceive how the Lord, although full in Himself, depends on His devotee for some particular work.” (SB 6.19.5)

Previous A God that Dances Next M.A.D Last updated 1 year ago

Akrura’s Mission

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) Akrura’s Mission Chapter 38, 39, 40 Akrura’s Arrival: Akrura, enlisted with Kamsa’s orders, was overjoyed to visit Vrindavana, and eagerly anticipated his meeting with Krishna. When he arrived in Gokula at sunset, he stepped off the chariot and immediately rolled in the dust of Krishna’s footprints. He continued to Vrindavana, where he finally saw Krishna and Balarama, throwing him into eruptions of ecstasy. The brothers greeted him and washed his feet, while Nanda Maharaja served him a feast. Akrura’s Proposal: Akrura reported on Kamsa’s atrocities and his latest plan to kill Krishna and Balarama by summoning Them to Mathura. The two brothers chuckled at Kamsa’s antics and happily agreed to go. The gopis , however, couldn’t bear the thought of separation, fearing Krishna may never return. They severely berated Akrura for taking Krishna away, and tried to stop the chariot, crying out “O Govinda! O Damodara! O Madhava!” Krishna consoled them with a simple message: “I will return.” The gopis were stunned as the chariot pulled away into the distance - their lives rested on that rope of hope that Krishna may well return one day. Krishna, accompanied by a convoy led by Nanda Maharaja, thus travelled towards the city of Mathura. Akrura’s Vision: When Akrura halted the chariot at the Yamuna, Krishna touched the water for purification and returned. Akrura then went to take his bath and saw Krishna and Balarama in the river! When he returned to the chariot he saw Them sitting there! When Akrura went back to the river again he saw the four- armed form of the Lord being worshipped by eminent personalities! The whole incident completely baffled him. Akrura’s Prayers: Having witnessed this inconceivable sequence of events, Akrura offered a series of prayers to the Lord. He glorified the various incarnations of Krishna, who periodically appear to drive away the unhappiness of those who joyfully engage in the process of devotional service.

Previous More Demons Killed Next A God that Dances Last updated 1 year ago

More Demons Killed

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) More Demons Killed Chapter 34, 36, 37 Vidyadhara Serpent: After worshipping Siva, the Vrindavana residents spent the night in Ambikavana forest. While sleeping, a serpent attempted to swallow Nanda Maharaja, and when Krishna touched the serpent with His foot, it revealed its true form as Sudarshan, the Vidyadhara who was cursed for his pride. Sankhacuda: One night, when Krishna and Balarama had a rendezvous with the gopis in the forest, Sankhacuda attempted to abduct the young maidens. Krishna chased him, punched him, and thus removed the demon’s head and jewel. Krishna then gifted that jewel to Balarama. Aristasura: When the bull demon attacked the mighty brothers, Krishna threw him back, uprooted one of his horns and then powerfully clubbed him with it. Aristasura thus met his end. It was after this incident that the celebrated ponds of Radha-Kund and Shyama-Kund were formed, which are considered liquid representations of Radha and Krishna’s love for each other. Thereafter, Narada finally informed Kamsa that Krishna was indeed the eighth son of Vasudeva. Enraged, the evil King conjured up fresh schemes to kill Krishna, enlisting the help of the Kesi demon to do the needful. Anticipating that this plan would fail, he went on to instruct Akrura to bring the boys to Mathura. There, he positioned Chanura, Mustika and Kuvalayapida to ready themselves for a showdown. Kamsa’s insane intention was clear: kill Krishna and Balarama first, then annihilate Vasudeva and his entire clan, and finally massacre his father and uncle, Ugrasena and Devaka. in this way, he thought, he would reign supreme. Kesi: Having assumed the form of a horse, Kesi violently charged at Krishna, attempting to strike the Lord with his legs. After throwing him afar, Krishna approached him and launched His left fist into Kesi’s mouth, after which it expanded in size and instantaneously killed him. After witnessing this, Narada approached Krishna, glorified Him and then predicted many more miracles that Krishna would perform in Mathura and Dwaraka. Vyomasura: Later, when the cowherd boys were playing hide and seek, Vyomasura disguised himself as a ‘thief,’ abducted some gopas and imprisoned them in a cave by blocking it with a boulder. Understanding his plan, Krishna pursued the demon, who transformed into his original form. Krishna seized him, threw him to the ground until he was lifeless and effortlessly smashed the boulder to free his dearmost friends.

Previous Rasa Pancadhyaya Next Akrura’s Mission Last updated 1 year ago

Rasa Pancadhyaya

Canto 10 (Part 1)

Y – Youthood (29-40) Rasa Pancadhyaya Chapter 29, 30, 31, 32, 33 The Call: Krishna’s flute-playing captured the minds of the gopis , who instantly disregarded their various engagements and responsibilities to be with Him. When they arrived, Krishna teased them by questioning their bold decision to come. He advised them to avoid compromising their chastity and strongly suggested they return home. The gopis were devastated. They vehemently refused, and fervently pleaded with Krishna to accept them. Seeing their intensity of love, Krishna performed play pastimes of love in the shining moonlight, but when He sensed their transcendental pride, He immediately disappeared. The Search: Feeling unbearable separation, the gopis initiated a search for Krishna, questioning the animals, trees, creepers, and Mother Earth herself about their beloved’s whereabouts. Unsuccessful, they resorted to re-enacting His pastimes to pacify their parched hearts. When they saw Krishna’s footprints along with one other set, they concluded that Srimati Radharani had been especially favoured. Radharani later developed a sense of transcendental pride, and Krishna abandoned Her as well. Thus, all the gopis again united in a frantic search for their flute-playing friend. The Song: Remembering the pastimes of Krishna, the gopis sang their song ( gopi-gita ) which somewhat soothed the agony of separation from their beloved. They glorified the beauty of His form, His pastimes and His sweet exchanges: “The nectar of Your words and the descriptions of Your activities are the life and soul of those suffering in this material world. These narrations, transmitted by learned sages, eradicate one’s sinful reactions and bestow good fortune upon whoever hears them. These narrations are broadcast all over the world and are filled with spiritual power. Certainly those who spread the message of Godhead are most munificent.” ( SB 10.31.9 ) The Reunion: Krishna suddenly returned and vanquished the heartache of the gopis . Surrounding Him, they drank His beauty through their eyes and hearts. Still wondering why Krishna abandoned them, the Lord explained that His every act is meant to intensify the loving exchange with His devotees. Indeed, Krishna was truly conquered by their love – “I am not able to repay My debt for your spotless service, even within a lifetime of Brahma. Your connection with Me is beyond reproach. You have worshipped Me, cutting off all domestic ties, which are difficult to break. Therefore please let your own glorious deeds be your compensation.” ( SB 10.32.22 ) The Dance: On the picturesque riverbanks of the Yamuna, Krishna expanded into multiple forms and danced with every gopi , each of whom truly believed that Krishna was only with them. Sukadeva Goswami concluded his description of the rasa dance with a caution: one should never consider these enchanting narrations to be a mundane love affair that can be imitated by ordinary living beings. Note: In Chapter 35 , Sukadeva Goswami described the intense feelings of separation that the gopis experienced when Krishna performed his cowherding pastimes during the day.

Previous Y – Youthood (29-40) Next More Demons Killed Last updated 1 year ago

— S.B. Keshava Swami, Book Bhagavata

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.1

↗
శ్రీ బాదరాయణిరువాచ అథ తర్హ్యాగతో గోష్ఠమరిష్టో వృషభాసుర: । మహీంమహాకకుత్కాయ: కమ్పయన్ఖురవిక్షతామ్ ॥ ౧ ॥
śrī bādarāyaṇir uvāca
[shree baadaraayanir uvaacha]
atha tarhy āgato goṣṭham
[atha tarhy aagato goshtham]
ariṣṭo vṛṣabhāsuraḥ
[arishto vrishabhaasurah]
mahīm mahā-kakut-kāyaḥ
[maheem mahaa-kakut-kaayah]
kampayan khura-vikṣatām
[kampayan khura-vikshataam]
śrī bādarāyaṇiḥ uvāca — Śrī Śukadeva Gosvāmī said atha — next tarhi — then āgataḥ — came goṣṭham — to the cowherd village ariṣṭaḥ — named Ariṣṭa vṛṣabha - asuraḥ — the bull demon mahīm — the earth mahā — great kakut — having a hump kāyaḥ — whose body kampayan — making tremble khura — by his hooves vikṣatām — torn .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śrī bādarāyaṇir uvāca
śrī bādarāyaṇiḥ uvāca
Śrī Śukadeva Gosvāmī said
atha tarhy āgato goṣṭham
atha
next
tarhi
then
āgataḥ
came
goṣṭham
to the cowherd village
ariṣṭo vṛṣabhāsuraḥ
ariṣṭaḥ
named Ariṣṭa
vṛṣabha - asuraḥ
the bull demon
mahīm mahā-kakut-kāyaḥ
mahīm
the earth
mahā
great
kakut
having a hump
kāyaḥ
whose body
kampayan khura-vikṣatām
kampayan
making tremble
khura
by his hooves
vikṣatām
torn .
  • ariṣṭaḥ — the demon named Ariṣṭa
    From a- + √riṣ — literally 'unharmed' or 'invincible,' an ironic name for a demon about to be killed by Kṛṣṇa. The Vraja-līlā repeatedly turns demonic names back on their bearers.
  • vṛṣabha - asuraḥ — in the form of a bull demon
    Compound: vṛṣabha (bull) + asura (demon). Kaṁsa's agents enter Vraja in animal disguises (Bakāsura the crane, Aghāsura the snake, Dhenuka the ass, now Ariṣṭa the bull) — perversions of the gentle pasture economy Kṛṣṇa actually rules.
  • goṣṭham — to the cowherd village
    Go (cow) + sthā (place to stand) — the pasture-settlement of Vraja. Gauḍīyas treat the goṣṭha as the highest concentration of Kṛṣṇa's intimate līlā, the very ground Caitanya wept to recover.
  • mahā — great, huge
    Stock prefix in the bull's description (mahā-kakut, mahā-kāyaḥ). The demon's bulk is named to set up its dismantling by a boy's two hands — a recurring Vraja contrast (vast threat, small cowherd, total reversal).
  • khura — hoof
    The hooves that tear the earth here are the inverse of the cows' hooves Kṛṣṇa follows in the dust each evening. The same word, opposite use — Vraja's pastoral grammar bent into menace.
Śukadeva Goswāmī said: The demon Ariṣṭa then came to the cowherd village. Appearing in the form of a bull with a large hump, he made the earth tremble as he tore it apart with his hooves.

According to the Śrī Viṣṇu Purāṇa, Ariṣṭāsura entered Kṛṣṇa’s village at twilight, as the Lord prepared to dance with the gopīs: prodoṣārdhe kadācit tu rāsāsakte janārdane trāsayan sa-mado goṣṭham ariṣṭaḥ sampāgataḥ “Once, midway through the period of dusk, when Lord Janārdana was eager to perform the rāsa dance, Ariṣṭāsura madly entered the cowherd village, terrifying everyone.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Śukadeva Goswāmī said: The demon Ariṣṭa then came to the cowherd village. Appearing in the form of a bull with a large hump, he made the earth tremble as he tore it apart with his hooves.
Commentary

The thirty sixth chapter describes how Kamsa, hearing from Narada that Krsna had killed Aristasura, imprisoned Devaki and Vasudeva, and ordered Akrura to go to Vraja. As tarhi is used in this sentence, yada should also be supplied. Thus the meaning is that when (yada) Krsna began his rasa lila in the evening, then (tarhi) Arisasura came. Visnu Purana describes this: "One day when Krsna was enjoying the rasa in the twilight, Aristasura entered the village after spreading fear everywhere." Atha signifies that while Krsna was enjoying, something interrupted that enjoyment. Arista had the form of a bull with a large hump on his back. Stamping his hooves, he shook the earth.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The description continues in the next verse. Then, in the evening when Kṛṣṇa returned, as previously described, Ariṣṭa arrived. Viṣṇu Purāṇa describes this. prodoṣārdhe kadācit tu rāsāsakte janārdane trāsayan sa-mado goṣṭham ariṣṭaḥ sampāgataḥ Once, midway through the period of dusk, when Kṛṣṇa was eager to perform the rāsa dance, Ariṣṭāsura madly entered the cowherd village, terrifying everyone A very similar description is given in Hari-vaṁśa. Every day the gopīs passed the daylight hours in singing his pastimes. At the end of one evening, after finishing his dinner, he left his bedroom to go for the rāsa dance, and went beyond the village of Vraja. Śrīdhara Svāmī says when Kṛṣṇa would return every day from the forest Vraja would rejoice. At that time, Ariṣṭa came near Vraja (rather than inside). By tearing up the earth with his hooves he showed his nature as a crazed bull eager to fight. Because he tore up the earth with his hooves he must have been huge in size.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

With obedient heart, I offer respects to the great devotees, who are overjoyed with prema from just a relationship with the speck of dust of Kṛṣṇa’s lotus feet. The description continues in the next verse. Then, in the evening when Kṛṣṇa returned, as previously described, Ariṣṭa arrived. Or atha indicates that the present topic concerning killing Ariṣṭāsura, and after that, Kṛṣṇa’s departure to Mathurā, very different from the pastimes of bliss in Gokula. In the evening, when Kṛṣṇa returned to Vraja (tarhi), the demon came there. prodoṣārdhe kadācit tu rāsāsakte janārdane trāsayan sa-mado goṣṭham ariṣṭaḥ sampāgataḥ Once, midway through the period of dusk, when Kṛṣṇa was eager to perform the rāsa dance, Ariṣṭāsura madly entered the cowherd village, terrifying everyone. Viṣṇu Purāṇa This is also described in Hari-vaṁśa. After the gopīs sang about his pastimes to get relief from the pain of separation, on some evening the demon came. His name means “inauspicious for the cows.” He had the form of a bull. Because of his huge form, his hooves broke the earth

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

The bull Ariṣṭa enters Vraja the way a thundercloud enters a meadow at noon — vast, snorting, hooves shredding the same soft soil Kṛṣṇa's cows graze on. But Bhagavān stands at the center of that meadow; the storm has come not to ruin the pasture but to be undone by its Lord.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.2

↗
రమ్భమాణ: ఖరతరం పదా చ విలిఖన్ మహీమ్ । ఉద్యమ్య పుచ్ఛం వప్రాణి విషాణాగ్రేణ చోద్ధరన్ । కిఞ్చిత్కిఞ్చిచ్ఛకృన్ ముఞ్చన్మూత్రయన్స్తబ్ధలోచన: ॥ ౨ ॥
rambhamāṇaḥ kharataraṁ
[rambhamaanah kharataram]
padā ca vilikhan mahīm
[padaa cha vilikhan maheem]
udyamya pucchaṁ vaprāṇi
[udyamya puchcham vapraani]
viṣāṇāgreṇa coddharan
[vishaanaagrena choddharan]
kiñcit kiñcic chakṛn muñcan
[kinchit kinchich chakrin munchan]
mūtrayan stabdha-locanaḥ
[mootrayan stabdha-lochanah]
rambhamāṇaḥ — bellowing khara - taram — most harshly padā — with his hooves ca — and vilikhan — scraping mahīm — the ground udyamya — raising upward puccham — his tail vaprāṇi — the embankments viṣāṇa — of his horns agreṇa — with the tips ca — and uddharan — lifting and tearing up kiñcit kiñcit — a little śakṛt — stool muñcan — releasing mūtrayan — urinating stabdha — glaring locanaḥ — his eyes .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
rambhamāṇaḥ kharataraṁ
rambhamāṇaḥ
bellowing
khara - taram
most harshly
padā ca vilikhan mahīm
padā
with his hooves
ca
and
vilikhan
scraping
mahīm
the ground
udyamya pucchaṁ vaprāṇi
udyamya
raising upward
puccham
his tail
vaprāṇi
the embankments
viṣāṇāgreṇa coddharan
viṣāṇa
of his horns
agreṇa
with the tips
kiñcit kiñcic chakṛn muñcan
ca
and
uddharan
lifting and tearing up
kiñcit kiñcit
a little
śakṛt
stool
mūtrayan stabdha-locanaḥ
muñcan
releasing
mūtrayan
urinating
stabdha
glaring
locanaḥ
his eyes .
  • rambhamāṇaḥ — bellowing
    Present participle of √rambh — to roar, low. The same throat that should chew cud and call calves becomes a weapon. Demonic action in Vraja is almost always the corruption of a pastoral sound.
  • khara - taram — most harshly
    Khara (rough, harsh) + comparative -taram. Vraja's auditory signature is Kṛṣṇa's flute and the cows' soft lowing; the demon's voice is named explicitly as their opposite.
  • vaprāṇi — the embankments
    The raised borders that hold pasture-water and mark grazing fields. Ariṣṭa attacks the infrastructure of cow-care itself — exactly what a vṛṣabha-rūpa demon should fail at.
  • stabdha — fixed, staring
    From √stambh — to make rigid. The demon's frozen glare contrasts with the moving, dancing eyes of the gopīs and the soft glance (kaṭākṣa) of Kṛṣṇa. Bhāva-śāstra reads such fixedness as a mark of tamas.
Ariṣṭāsura bellowed very harshly and pawed the ground. With his tail raised and his eyes glaring, he began to tear up the embankments with the tips of his horns, every now and then passing a little stool and urine.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Ariṣṭāsura bellowed very harshly and pawed the ground. With his tail raised and his eyes glaring, he began to tear up the embankments with the tips of his horns, every now and then passing a little stool and urine.
Commentary

Roaring very loudly and roughly, he clawed the earth with his hooves. He dug out the bank with his horns and passed stool.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He made furrows in the earth with his hooves as he tore up the soil because of his crazed condition and desire to fight.

Related values
Ishvara Pranidhana (Surrender to God)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Daksya (Resourcefulness / Skill)Dhriti (Resilience / Steadfastness / Fortitude)Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Dhairya (Composure / Courage)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Santosha (Contentment)
Related verses
Concepts
ChitJiva

A bellowing animal that fouls the ground it stands on is the picture of unchecked rajas-tamas: noise, agitation, refuse — and no fruit. Kṛṣṇa permits Ariṣṭa this whole display so the pasture can see by contrast what a real lord of cows looks like.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.3-4

↗
యస్య నిర్హ్రాదితేనాఙ్గ నిష్ఠురేణ గవాం నృణామ్ । పతన్త్యకాలతో గర్భా: స్రవన్తి స్మ భయేన వై ॥ ౩ ॥ నిర్విశన్తి ఘనా యస్య కకుద్యచలశఙ్కయా । తం తీక్ష్ణశ‍ృఙ్గముద్వీక్ష్య గోప్యో గోపాశ్చ తత్రసు: ॥ ౪ ॥
yasya nirhrāditenāṅga
[yasya nirhraaditenaanga]
niṣṭhureṇa gavāṁ nṛṇām
[nishthurena gavaam nrinaam]
patanty akālato garbhāḥ
[patanty akaalato garbhaah]
sravanti sma bhayena vai
[sravanti sma bhayena vai]
nirviśanti ghanā yasya
[nirvishanti ghanaa yasya]
kakudy acala-śaṅkayā
[kakudy achala-shankayaa]
taṁ tīkṣṇa-śṛṅgam udvīkṣya
[tam teekshna-shringam udveekshya]
gopyo gopāś ca tatrasuḥ
[gopyo gopaash cha tatrasuh]
yasya — whose nirhrāditena — by the reverberating sound aṅga — my dear King (Parīkṣit) niṣṭhureṇa — rough gavām — of cows nṛṇām — of humans patanti — fall akālataḥ — untimely garbhāḥ — the embryos sravanti sma — are miscarried bhayena — out of fear vai — indeed nirviśanti — enter ghanāḥ — clouds yasya — whose kakudi — onto the hump acala — as a mountain śaṅkayā — by the mistaken identification tam — him tīkṣṇa — sharp śṛṅgam — whose horns udvīkṣya — seeing gopyaḥ — the cowherd women gopāḥ — the cowherd men ca — and tatrasuḥ — became frightened .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yasya nirhrāditenāṅga
yasya
whose
nirhrāditena
by the reverberating sound
aṅga
my dear King (Parīkṣit)
niṣṭhureṇa gavāṁ nṛṇām
niṣṭhureṇa
rough
gavām
of cows
nṛṇām
of humans
patanty akālato garbhāḥ
patanti
fall
akālataḥ
untimely
garbhāḥ
the embryos
sravanti sma bhayena vai
sravanti sma
are miscarried
bhayena
out of fear
vai
indeed
nirviśanti ghanā yasya
nirviśanti
enter
ghanāḥ
clouds
yasya
whose
kakudy acala-śaṅkayā
kakudi
onto the hump
acala
as a mountain
śaṅkayā
by the mistaken identification
taṁ tīkṣṇa-śṛṅgam udvīkṣya
tam
him
tīkṣṇa
sharp
śṛṅgam
whose horns
udvīkṣya
seeing
gopyo gopāś ca tatrasuḥ
gopyaḥ
the cowherd women
gopāḥ
the cowherd men
ca
and
tatrasuḥ
became frightened .
  • nirhrāditena — by the reverberating sound
    From nir + √hrad — to roar, resound. The sound itself is named the agent of harm; Vraja is so attuned to sweet sound that violent sound alone causes miscarriage in cows and women.
  • garbhāḥ — the fetuses
    What the demon's noise destroys is generation itself — Vraja's whole economy is calves, milk, butter, children. The threat is precisely to fertility, which is Kṛṣṇa's own gift to His pasture.
  • acala - śaṅkayā — mistaking (it) for a mountain
    Acala (immovable, mountain) + śaṅkā (suspicion, mistaken notion). The clouds' error foreshadows Kaṁsa's: an inflated form is taken for a real power. Both errors will be corrected by the same boy.
  • gopyaḥ — the cowherd women
    The gopīs, the supreme reservoir of mādhurya-bhakti. Their fear here is not lack of faith but pure parakīya-anxiety for the safety of their dear Kṛṣṇa — a bhāva, not a defect.
  • tīkṣṇa — sharp
    Tīkṣṇa-śṛṅgam — sharp-horned. The word is later inverted in this chapter when Kṛṣṇa rips out one horn and uses it against the demon: the sharpness Ariṣṭa brought becomes his own punishment.
My dear King, clouds hovered about sharp-horned Ariṣṭāsura’s hump, mistaking it for a mountain, and when the cowherd men and ladies caught sight of the demon, they were struck with terror. Indeed, the strident reverberation of his roar so frightened the pregnant cows and women that they lost their fetuses in miscarriages.

The Vedic literature categorizes miscarriages as follows: Ā-caturthād bhavet srāvaḥ pātaḥ pañcama-ṣaṣṭhayoḥ/ ata ūrdhvaṁ prasūtiḥ syāt. “Up to the fourth month a premature delivery is called srāva, in the fifth and sixth months it is called pāta, and after this it is considered a birth ( prasūti ).”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
My dear King, clouds hovered about sharp-horned Ariṣṭāsura's hump, mistaking it for a mountain, and when the cowherd men and ladies caught sight of the demon, they were struck with terror. Indeed, the strident reverberation of his roar so frightened the pregnant cows and women that they lost their fetuses in miscarriages.
Commentary

Due to his load roaring the cows and women had miscarriages. Up to the fourth month, miscarriage is called "srava" and in the fifth and sixth month miscarriage is called "pata".

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The great fear caused by the demon is described. His roaring seemed to crush Vraja. Śukadeva calls out to Parīkṣit (aṅga) with fear. Sma indicates that it was well known and vai means certainly. The word mahā mentioned previously indicates his size. He had a huge hump upon which the cloud, mistaking it for a mountain, rested. This is a metaphor since the cloud is unconscious. His hump and a mountain were both high, reaching the clouds. What to speak of the women, who are easily frightened by their nature, the men were also terrified. sa toyatoyada-cchāyas tīkṣṇa-śṛṅgo ‘rka-locanaḥ / lelihānaḥ saniṣpeṣaṁ jihvayoṣṭhau punaḥ punaḥ / saṁraṁbhāviddha-lāṅgūlaḥ kaṭhinas kandha-bandhanaḥ // udagra-kakudābhoga-pramāṇo dur-atikramaḥ / viṇmūtra-lipta-pṛṣṭhāṅgo gavam udvega-kārakaḥ // pralaṁba-kaṇṭho 'timukhas tarughātāṅkitānanaḥ / sūdayaṁs tāpasān ugro vanān aṭati yaḥ sadā // He had the complexion of a cloud and had sharp horns and eyes blazing like the sun. He repeatedly licked his lips with sound. He twirled his tail in pride. His shoulders were tough and his hump was huge and impossible to pass over. His body was smeared with urine and stool. He caused panic in the cows. Skin hung from his throat. His face was scarred by being hit by trees. He always wandered in the forest to attack the sages doing austerities. The people had to look upwards (udvīṣya) to see him, since he was huge. The animals were frightened because of his evil nature. yuddha-sajja-viṣāṇāgro dviṣad vṛṣabha-sūdanaḥ ariṣṭo nāma hi gavām ariṣto dāruṇākṛtiḥ daityo vṛṣabha-rūpeṇa gokulaṁ paridhāvati pātayāno gavāṁ garbhān dhrsṭo gacchaty anārtavam bhaṣjamānaś ca capalo goṣṭaṁ saṁpraccāra ha śṛṅga-praharaṇo raudraḥ praharan goṣu durmadaḥ goṣṭhe tu na ratīm lebhe vinā yuddhena go-vṛṣaḥ The demon named Ariṣṭa, killer of bulls and enemy of the cows, with frightful form and with huge horns for fighting, ran around Gokula. He made the cows abort and become barren. He wandered through the village, breaking everything. With anger he attacked the cows with his horns. He was not satisfied, since he could not fight. The demon had not come to Vraja up to this time, because Kaṁsa had not permitted him.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

Clouds mistaking the demon's hump for a mountain shows how a counterfeit can briefly fool even the sky. But in a moment Kṛṣṇa will dismantle the illusion with bare hands, and the same clouds will scatter flowers on Him instead.

Kāliya's pool and the same pattern

Earlier in this same canto (SB 10.16), Kṛṣṇa enters another fearful Vraja moment — Kāliya's poisoned bend of the Yamunā. The gopas and gopīs cry out, pregnant cows and women are at risk, and Kṛṣṇa goes in alone.

The Bhāgavatam keeps re-staging this scene: a localized terror in Vraja, the residents' single recourse being Kṛṣṇa, and the terror dissolved into a festival. Ariṣṭa's roar is the bull-version of Kāliya's venom.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.5

↗
పశవో దుద్రువుర్భీతా రాజన్సన్త్యజ్య గోకులమ్ । కృష్ణ కృష్ణేతి తే సర్వే గోవిన్దం శరణం యయు: ॥ ౫ ॥
paśavo dudruvur bhītā
[pashavo dudruvur bheetaa]
rājan santyajya go-kulam
[raajan santyajya go-kulam]
kṛṣṇa kṛṣṇeti te sarve
[krishna krishneti te sarve]
govindaṁ śaraṇaṁ yayuḥ
[govindam sharanam yayuh]
paśavaḥ — the domestic animals dudruvuḥ — ran away bhītāḥ — afraid rājan — O King santyajya — abandoning go - kulam — the dairy pasture kṛṣṇa kṛṣṇa iti — “Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa” te — they (the inhabitants of Vṛndāvana) sarve — all govindam — to Lord Govinda śaraṇam — for shelter yayuḥ — went .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
paśavo dudruvur bhītā
paśavaḥ
the domestic animals
dudruvuḥ
ran away
bhītāḥ
afraid
rājan santyajya go-kulam
rājan
O King
santyajya
abandoning
go - kulam
the dairy pasture
kṛṣṇa kṛṣṇeti te sarve
kṛṣṇa kṛṣṇa iti
“Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa”
te
they (the inhabitants of Vṛndāvana)
sarve
all
govindaṁ śaraṇaṁ yayuḥ
govindam
to Lord Govinda
śaraṇam
for shelter
yayuḥ
went .
  • bhītāḥ — afraid
    Fear in Vraja is always context-dependent: the residents fear for Kṛṣṇa or are made to fear by demons sent against Him. They never fear samsāra in the abstract — their bhāva is too concrete for that.
  • kṛṣṇa kṛṣṇa iti — crying, 'Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa'
    The doubled name is itself the verse's centerpiece. For Gauḍīyas this is the proto-form of harināma — uncalculated, repeated, emerging directly from love and need.
  • govindam — Govinda, Lord of the cows
    Go (cow, also senses, also earth) + vinda (one who finds, protects, pleases). Of all His names this one is invoked by the residents because the threat is to the cows; bhakti chooses Kṛṣṇa's name by the rasa of the moment.
  • śaraṇam — shelter, refuge
    Śaraṇa-gati — taking shelter — is the doorway of bhakti. Here the whole village does it spontaneously; in Bhagavad-gītā 18.66 Kṛṣṇa will ask for the same thing explicitly. Vraja does without asking.
The domestic animals fled the pasture in fear, O King, and all the inhabitants rushed to Lord Govinda for shelter, crying, “Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa!”
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The domestic animals fled the pasture in fear, O King, and all the inhabitants rushed to Lord Govinda for shelter, crying, "Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa!"
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The animals left Vraja, though they should not have done so in the evening, out of great fear. They were pursued by the demon as they fled. Śukadeva calls out to Parīkṣit in astonishment at what happened or from fear. They called out to Kṛṣṇa who was called Govinda because he had been enthroned as the king of Gokula with that name. Thus they took shelter of him. They approached him as he was coming from Govardhana where there was a place for the rāsa dance, because he heard the commotion. They shouted only his name, since they could say nothing else out of great fear. This was how they all acted.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

When the herd is spooked, every cow runs in its own direction; only the cowherds know to run toward the cowherd. Vraja's whole spiritual instinct in one line: when terror comes, the name 'Kṛṣṇa Kṛṣṇa' is already on the tongue before the mind has chosen it.

Gajendra's single cry

In SB 8.2–3, the elephant-king Gajendra, seized by the crocodile, exhausts every strategy and finally simply cries out to the Lord. Viṣṇu comes immediately, on Garuḍa, and lifts him out by the trunk.

The Vraja-version of that cry is shorter still: not a Sanskrit hymn but just the name — 'Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa.' Gauḍīyas read this verse as the prototype of nāma-bhakti as the natural refuge of those who already love.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.6

↗
భగవానపి తద్ వీక్ష్య గోకులం భయవిద్రుతమ్ । మా భైష్టేతి గిరాశ్వాస్య వృషాసురముపాహ్వయత్ ॥ ౬ ॥
bhagavān api tad vīkṣya
[bhagavaan api tad veekshya]
go-kulaṁ bhaya-vidrutam
[go-kulam bhaya-vidrutam]
mā bhaiṣṭeti girāśvāsya
[maa bhaishteti giraashvaasya]
vṛṣāsuram upāhvayat
[vrishaasuram upaahvayat]
bhagavān — the Supreme Personality of Godhead api — indeed tat — that vīkṣya — seeing go - kulam — the cowherd community bhaya — out of fear vidrutam — made to flee, or distraught mā bhaiṣṭa — “don’t be afraid” iti — thus girā — with words āśvāsya — pacifying vṛṣa - asuram — to the bull demon upāhvayat — He called out .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bhagavān api tad vīkṣya
bhagavān
the Supreme Personality of Godhead
api
indeed
tat
that
vīkṣya
seeing
go-kulaṁ bhaya-vidrutam
go - kulam
the cowherd community
bhaya
out of fear
vidrutam
made to flee, or distraught
mā bhaiṣṭeti girāśvāsya
mā bhaiṣṭa
“don’t be afraid”
iti
thus
girā
with words
āśvāsya
pacifying
vṛṣāsuram upāhvayat
vṛṣa - asuram
to the bull demon
upāhvayat
He called out .
  • bhagavān — the Supreme Personality of Godhead
    Bhagavān = the possessor of bhaga (the six opulences). Gauḍīya theology: Kṛṣṇa is the original Bhagavān (svayam bhagavān, SB 1.3.28), and in Vraja the opulence-words point not to majesty but to the boy who is precisely worshipable because He hides them.
  • mā bhaiṣṭa — do not be afraid
    The classical formula of the Lord to His devotees (e.g. to Arjuna, to Dhruva, to Prahlāda). The same syllables that ended Prahlāda's torment now travel through Vraja's pasture air.
  • āśvāsya — having reassured (them)
    From ā + √śvas — to breathe again, to give comfort. Kṛṣṇa's first move is always pastoral consolation; the killing of the demon comes after the cows have been settled.
  • upāhvayat — He called (the demon) toward Himself
    Pra-upa-hvā — to summon, to invite. Bhagavān actively calls the enemy in. The līlā is not a defensive reaction; it is staged, on Kṛṣṇa's terms, on His ground.
When the Supreme Lord saw the cowherd community distraught and fleeing in fear, He calmed them, saying, “Don’t be afraid.” Then He called out to the bull demon as follows.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
When the Supreme Lord saw the cowherd community distraught and fleeing in fear, He calmed them, saying, "Don't be afraid." Then He called out to the bull demon as follows.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Govinda however (api) acted differently. Another version has atha (then, after Ariṣṭa arrived) instead of api. Seeing all beings of Gokula, whom he should protect he spoke to the demon (vṛṣāsuram). He knew that the bull was a demon. He called the demon towards him (upa), going far from Vraja, so that he would not cause disturbance in Vraja. Later it will be said that Kṛṣṇa entered Vraja after killing the demon (verse 15).

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Govinda however (api) acted differently. Another version has atha (then, after Ariṣṭa arrived) instead of api. Seeing all beings of Gokula, whom he should protect, he spoke to the demon (vṛṣāsuram). They were fleeing here and there in fear at great speed. Or only the herds of cows fled in fear. But the cowherds, women and cows all surrendered to Kṛṣṇa. Knowing he was a demon in the form of a bull, Kṛṣṇa called out to him at close range (upa).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

The same voice that calmed the cows from across the pasture turns and calls the demon by name. 'Don't be afraid' to the residents, and a summons to the bull — both delivered without raising the voice. That is Bhagavān's economy.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.7

↗
గోపాలై: పశుభిర్మన్ద త్రాసితై: కిమసత్తమ । మయి శాస్తరి దుష్టానాం త్వద్విధానాం దురాత్మనామ్ ॥ ౭ ॥
gopālaiḥ paśubhir manda
[gopaalaih pashubhir manda]
trāsitaiḥ kim asattama
[traasitaih kim asattama]
mayi śāstari duṣṭānāṁ
[mayi shaastari dushtaanaam]
tvad-vidhānāṁ durātmanām
[tvad-vidhaanaam duraatmanaam]
gopālaiḥ — with the cowherds paśubhiḥ — and with their animals manda — O fool trāsitaiḥ — who are frightened kim — what purpose asattama — O most wicked one mayi — when I (am present) śāstari — as the punisher duṣṭānām — of the contaminated tvat - vidhānām — like you durātmanām — miscreants .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
gopālaiḥ paśubhir manda
gopālaiḥ
with the cowherds
paśubhiḥ
and with their animals
manda
O fool
trāsitaiḥ kim asattama
trāsitaiḥ
who are frightened
kim
what purpose
asattama
O most wicked one
mayi śāstari duṣṭānāṁ
mayi
when I (am present)
śāstari
as the punisher
duṣṭānām
of the contaminated
tvad-vidhānāṁ durātmanām
tvat - vidhānām
like you
durātmanām
miscreants .
  • manda — O fool, dull one
    Manda — slow, dull, low. Kṛṣṇa rarely uses harsh vocatives, but to demons He does — the Bhāgavatam preserves a register specifically for ātatāyīs (aggressors), distinct from His sweetness to friends.
  • asattama — O most wicked one
    Superlative of asat (untrue, unreal, evil). For Gauḍīyas asat carries metaphysical weight too: that which has no real being. The demon is named for the ontological poverty of his stance against Bhagavān.
  • śāstari — when I, the chastiser, am present
    Śāstā — the disciplinarian, ruler, instructor. Kṛṣṇa names His role explicitly: the avatāra-purpose of paritrāṇāya sādhūnāṁ vināśāya ca duṣkṛtām (Gītā 4.8) is operating right now in Vraja.
  • durātmanām — of the evil-minded
    Dus (bad) + ātman (self) — those whose very self-direction is wrong. The Bhāgavatam uses this for those whose hostility is settled, not accidental.
You fool! What do you think you’re doing, you wicked rascal, frightening the cowherd community and their animals when I am here just to punish corrupt miscreants like you!
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
You fool! What do you think you're doing, you wicked rascal, frightening the cowherd community and their animals when I am here just to punish corrupt miscreants like you!
Commentary

"What do you gain by frightening the cows?" Addressing the demon as "most sinful one (asattama), Krsna suggests that no sin would be incurred by killing the bull, though normally cows and bulls should not be killed.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kṛṣṇa’s words to the demon are described. Another version has sapālaiḥ (along with the cowherds). This indicates that the cows are the main entities that should not be frightened since they have less intelligence and strength than their protectors, the cowherds. You are a fool (manda), since you are frightening animals! There will be no result from frightening these animals and their protectors. “Why do you say this?” I am the punisher of evil persons like you. Another version has bala-darpahāhām: I am the destroyer of strength and fear in persons having wicked acts (duṣṭānām) and wicked minds (durātmanām). When I kill you, everyone will be without fear. You are this type of person (tad-vidhānām), to be punished. Even one who imitates the behavior of the wicked should be punished. “But I have the form of a bull. How can I be punished?” You are worst (asattama)! You are not a bull but actually a demon in disguise.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)
Related verses

A teacher walks into a classroom where a bully has been frightening younger children and says simply, 'I am here.' The bully's chest-puffing collapses the moment the room's actual authority speaks. Kṛṣṇa's words to Ariṣṭa have that quality of effortless asymmetry.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.8

↗
ఇత్యాస్ఫోత్యాచ్యుతోఽరిష్టం తలశబ్దేన కోపయన్ । సఖ్యురంసే భుజాభోగం ప్రసార్యావస్థితో హరి: ॥ ౮ ॥
ity āsphotyācyuto ’riṣṭaṁ
[ity aasphotyaachyuto ’rishtam]
tala-śabdena kopayan
[tala-shabdena kopayan]
sakhyur aṁse bhujābhogaṁ
[sakhyur amse bhujaabhogam]
prasāryāvasthito hariḥ
[prasaaryaavasthito harih]
iti — speaking thus āsphotya — slapping His arms acyutaḥ — the infallible Lord ariṣṭam — Ariṣṭāsura tala — from His palms śabdena — with the sound kopayan — angering sakhyuḥ — of a friend aṁse — over the shoulder bhuja — His arm ābhogam — (which is like) a serpent’s body prasārya — throwing avasthitaḥ — was standing hariḥ — Lord Hari .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ity āsphotyācyuto ’riṣṭaṁ
iti
speaking thus
āsphotya
slapping His arms
acyutaḥ
the infallible Lord
tala-śabdena kopayan
sakhyur aṁse bhujābhogaṁ
prasāryāvasthito hariḥ
ariṣṭam
Ariṣṭāsura
tala
from His palms
śabdena
with the sound
kopayan
angering
sakhyuḥ
of a friend
aṁse
over the shoulder
bhuja
His arm
ābhogam
(which is like) a serpent’s body
prasārya
throwing
avasthitaḥ
was standing
hariḥ
Lord Hari .
  • āsphotya — slapping (His arms)
    Tala-śabda, the wrestler's challenge-slap. Kṛṣṇa adopts the warrior-idiom of the akhāḍā — a foretaste of the Mathurā wrestling match that the rest of this chapter sets up.
  • acyutaḥ — the infallible one
    A (not) + cyuta (fallen). One of Kṛṣṇa's foundational names — never fallen from His position, never failing His devotees. Used here exactly when He demonstrates that He cannot be moved.
  • sakhyuḥ — of a friend
    Sakhā — the cowherd boys. Sakhya-rasa is named in the very moment of combat. Vraja's emotional grammar is preserved across every kind of action.
  • bhuja — arm
    Bhuja-ābhogam prasārya — stretching out the arm-coil. The arm is described almost as a separate creature (serpentine, vast), an emblem of the Lord's playful display of His own form.
  • hariḥ — Lord Hari
    Hari — the one who takes away (sins, fears, demons). The name is used in moments of removal; here, Ariṣṭa's life is what is about to be taken.
Having spoken these words, the infallible Lord Hari slapped His arms with His palms, further angering Ariṣṭa with the loud sound. The Lord then casually threw His mighty, serpentine arm over the shoulder of a friend and stood facing the demon.

Lord Kṛṣṇa showed His contempt for the ignorant demon.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Having spoken these words, the infallible Lord Hari slapped His arms with His palms, further angering Ariṣṭa with the loud sound. The Lord then casually threw His mighty, serpentine arm over the shoulder of a friend and stood facing the demon.
Commentary

Krsna challenged the bull by slapping his right palm on the base of his left arm arm, making a sound, as a show of courage. By placing his snake-like arm on Subala’s shoulder (ams) he showed his contempt for the demon.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kṛṣṇa put his arm on the shoulder of his friend Śrīdāmā, showing disrespect to the demon. His arm was like a snake because of its roundness and thickness. Kṛṣṇa is called acyutaḥ since he did move from that spot. Hari-vaṁśa says tasmāt sthānān na vyacalat kṛṣṇo girir ivācalaḥ: Kṛṣṇa did not move from the spot, being as immovable as a mountain. Viṣṇu Purāṇa says na cacāla tataḥ sthānād avajṣāsmita līlayā: he did not move from the spot and smiled with disrespect in a casual manner. In this situation, Kṛṣṇa was very attractive (hariḥ).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses

He slaps His arms and rests one of them on a friend's shoulder. The casual sakhya-gesture in the middle of a fight is itself the doctrine: Kṛṣṇa never leaves His sakhā-bhāva even when killing a demon. His arm on Śrīdāmā's shoulder is more central to the scene than the bull is.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.9

↗
సోఽప్యేవం కోపితోఽరిష్ట: ఖురేణావనిముల్లిఖన్ । ఉద్యత్పుచ్ఛభ్రమన్మేఘ: క్రుద్ధ: కృష్ణముపాద్రవత్ ॥ ౯ ॥
so ’py evaṁ kopito ’riṣṭaḥ
[so ’py evam kopito ’rishtah]
khureṇāvanim ullikhan
[khurenaavanim ullikhan]
udyat-puccha-bhraman-meghaḥ
[udyat-puchcha-bhraman-meghah]
kruddhaḥ kṛṣṇam upādravat
[kruddhah krishnam upaadravat]
saḥ — he api — indeed evam — in this way kopitaḥ — angered ariṣṭaḥ — Ariṣṭa khureṇa — with his hoof avanim — the earth ullikhan — scratching udyat — raised puccha — within his tail bhraman — wandering meghaḥ — clouds kruddhaḥ — furious kṛṣṇam — toward Lord Kṛṣṇa upādravat — he charged .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
so ’py evaṁ kopito ’riṣṭaḥ
saḥ
he
api
indeed
evam
in this way
kopitaḥ
angered
ariṣṭaḥ
Ariṣṭa
khureṇāvanim ullikhan
khureṇa
with his hoof
avanim
the earth
ullikhan
scratching
udyat-puccha-bhraman-meghaḥ
udyat
raised
puccha
within his tail
bhraman
wandering
meghaḥ
clouds
kruddhaḥ kṛṣṇam upādravat
kruddhaḥ
furious
kṛṣṇam
toward Lord Kṛṣṇa
upādravat
he charged .
  • kopitaḥ — made angry
    Causative past participle of √kup — to be angry. Note the form: the demon is made angry, by Kṛṣṇa's calm provocation. Even the anger is administered.
  • khureṇa — with his hoof
    Instrumental case of khura. The hoof that should walk gently on Vraja's soil is named again as a weapon — the demonic inversion of the cow-foot.
  • kruddhaḥ — enraged
    From √krudh. The Bhāgavatam carefully distinguishes the demon's krodha (blind rage, tamasic) from the Lord's occasional krodha (corrective, purifying).
  • upādravat — he ran toward (Him)
    Upa (toward) + √dru (to run). The demon closes the distance himself. In Vraja-līlā the Lord almost never needs to chase; opposition obligingly delivers itself to His hand.
Thus provoked, Ariṣṭa pawed the ground with one of his hooves and then, with the clouds hovering around his upraised tail, furiously charged Kṛṣṇa.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Thus provoked, Ariṣṭa pawed the ground with one of his hooves and then, with the clouds hovering around his upraised tail, furiously charged Kṛṣṇa.
Commentary

Arista showed his power by raising and twitching his tail, so that it disturbed the clouds in the sky.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

His upraised tail made the clouds disperse by its touch or by its wind. The demon quickly rushed towards Kṛṣṇa (upādravat).

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Ariṣṭa was the very form of inauspiciousness (arisṭaḥ), whom no one could oppose. With his upraised tail he made the clouds move here and there by touching them or by the tail’s wind. The tail was hard, long and strong. He ran at Kṛṣṇa, who attracted him by inciting his anger. Or Kṛṣṇa attracted him by striking his heel on the ground, to show his great courage and pride. This produced Ariṣṭa-kuṇḍa. It is said: Ghātavyitvā tatas tasmin ariṣṭaṁ vṛṣa-rūpiṇam kopena pāṛṣni-ghātena mahyās tīrthaṁ pravrtitam He struck Ariṣṭa in the form of a bull. Then in anger he struck the earth with his heel. This produced the tīrtha. Āri-varāha Purāṇa The demon approached Kṛṣṇa with great speed.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Dhriti (Resilience / Steadfastness / Fortitude)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Mardava (Gentleness)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Achapalya (Steadiness / Non-fickleness)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Goaded into the charge he was going to make anyway, the demon performs his nature exactly. Kṛṣṇa does not have to plan the encounter; demons in Vraja walk straight into the geometry of their own end.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.10

↗
అగ్రన్యస్తవిషాణాగ్ర: స్తబ్ధాసృగ్లోచనోఽచ్యుతమ్ । కటాక్షిప్యాద్రవత్తూర్ణమిన్ద్రముక్తోఽశనిర్యథా ॥ ౧౦ ॥
agra-nyasta-viṣāṇāgraḥ
[agra-nyasta-vishaanaagrah]
stabdhāsṛg-locano ’cyutam
[stabdhaasrig-lochano ’chyutam]
kaṭākṣipyādravat tūrṇam
[kataakshipyaadravat toornam]
indra-mukto ’śanir yathā
[indra-mukto ’shanir yathaa]
agra — forward nyasta — pointing viṣāṇa — of his horns agraḥ — the front stabdha — glaring asṛk — bloody locanaḥ — his eyes acyutam — at Lord Kṛṣṇa kaṭa - ākṣipya — looking sideways adravat — he ran tūrṇam — at full speed indra - muktaḥ — released by King Indra aśaniḥ — a thunderbolt yathā — like .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
agra-nyasta-viṣāṇāgraḥ
agra
forward
nyasta
pointing
viṣāṇa
of his horns
agraḥ
the front
stabdhāsṛg-locano ’cyutam
stabdha
glaring
asṛk
bloody
locanaḥ
his eyes
acyutam
at Lord Kṛṣṇa
kaṭākṣipyādravat tūrṇam
kaṭa - ākṣipya
looking sideways
adravat
he ran
tūrṇam
at full speed
indra-mukto ’śanir yathā
indra - muktaḥ
released by King Indra
aśaniḥ
a thunderbolt
yathā
like .
  • viṣāṇa — horn
    The horn pointed forward here will be ripped off and used as a club a few verses later. The Bhāgavatam often introduces a weapon and then names its retribution-use in the same line of narration.
  • asṛk — blood (bloodshot)
    Asṛk-locanaḥ — eyes bloodshot. The eye, which in Vraja is the chief organ of Kṛṣṇa-darśana, is here clotted with rage — a darśana-failure even at the moment of looking directly at Him.
  • acyutam — the infallible Lord (Him)
    Repeated from verse 8. The narrative names Kṛṣṇa as Acyuta precisely when the demon imagines he can dislodge Him.
  • indra - muktaḥ — released by Indra
    Indra + mukta (released). The simile recruits Indra's thunderbolt as the demon's measure — and the seasoned listener already knows what Kṛṣṇa does to Indra's weapons.
Pointing the tips of his horns straight ahead and glaring menacingly at Lord Kṛṣṇa from the corners of his bloodshot eyes, Ariṣṭa rushed toward Him at full speed, like a thunderbolt hurled by Indra.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Pointing the tips of his horns straight ahead and glaring menacingly at Lord Kṛṣṇa from the corners of his bloodshot eyes, Ariṣṭa rushed toward Him at full speed, like a thunderbolt hurled by Indra.
Commentary

The bull’s eyes were red with arrogance. His side long glances scolded Krsna.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

This verse describes the demon’s attack. Instead of katākṣa akṣipya the phrase is kaṭā akṣipya. This is similar to the verb kuṭa (to be crooked) as described in gāṅkuṭādibhyo (Pāṇini 1.2.1). The demon threw a side glance. In advancing quickly and not tolerating others an example is given. He was like a thunderbolt thrown with force by Indra.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

A thunderbolt hurled by Indra — the very weapon that once threatened Govardhana — is now the simile for a single demon's charge. The image quietly reminds the listener: He who already lifted the hill against Indra's storm will not flinch at a bull-shaped lightning.

Govardhana and the disarmed thunderbolt

Earlier in this canto (SB 10.25), Indra hurled his strongest weapons at Vraja, and Kṛṣṇa held up Govardhana for seven days as a single, lifted umbrella. The thunderbolt could not reach the boy or His people.

The Bhāgavatam reaches for that same image — indra-muktaḥ aśaniḥ — to describe Ariṣṭa's charge. The audience is meant to hear the echo: another thunderbolt, another effortless reversal.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.11

↗
గృహీత్వా శ‍ృఙ్గయోస్తం వా అష్టాదశ పదాని స: । ప్రత్యపోవాహ భగవాన్ గజ: ప్రతిగజం యథా ॥ ౧౧ ॥
gṛhītvā śṛṅgayos taṁ vā
[griheetvaa shringayos tam vaa]
aṣṭādaśa padāni saḥ
[ashtaadasha padaani sah]
pratyapovāha bhagavān
[pratyapovaaha bhagavaan]
gajaḥ prati-gajaṁ yathā
[gajah prati-gajam yathaa]
gṛhītvā — seizing śṛṅgayoḥ — by the horns tam — him vai — indeed aṣṭādaśa — eighteen padāni — steps saḥ — He pratyapovāha — threw back bhagavān — the Supreme Lord gajaḥ — an elephant prati - gajam — a rival elephant yathā — like .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
gṛhītvā śṛṅgayos taṁ vā
gṛhītvā
seizing
śṛṅgayoḥ
by the horns
tam
him
vai
indeed
aṣṭādaśa padāni saḥ
aṣṭādaśa
eighteen
padāni
steps
saḥ
He
pratyapovāha bhagavān
pratyapovāha
threw back
bhagavān
the Supreme Lord
gajaḥ prati-gajaṁ yathā
gajaḥ
an elephant
prati - gajam
a rival elephant
yathā
like .
  • gṛhītvā — having seized
    Absolutive of √grah. The same verb used when He grasps Yaśodā's churning-rope, the gopīs' garments, Arjuna's reins. The hand is the same hand.
  • śṛṅgayoḥ — by the (two) horns
    Dual locative — both horns at once. Kṛṣṇa's body is described again and again with this kind of precise spatial control; nothing is loose or accidental.
  • aṣṭādaśa — eighteen
    Aṣṭa (eight) + daśa (ten) = eighteen. Commentators delight in such numbers — the same eighteen as the Gītā's chapters, the Mahābhārata's parvas, the days of Kurukṣetra. Numerical winks across the corpus.
  • gajaḥ — an elephant
    Comparing Kṛṣṇa to an elephant fighting a rival elephant — a register that names Kṛṣṇa's playful adoption of the demon's animal-scale rather than His Vaikuṇṭha-form.
The Supreme Lord Kṛṣṇa seized Ariṣṭāsura by the horns and threw him back eighteen steps, just as an elephant might do when fighting a rival elephant.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The Supreme Lord Kṛṣṇa seized Ariṣṭāsura by the horns and threw him back eighteen steps, just as an elephant might do when fighting a rival elephant.
Commentary

Krsna threw the bull in the opposite direction.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Vai means it is well known. He had a very sporting nature (saḥ). An example is given to show this: an elephant fighting another elephant. It shows his capability, with a display of his power.

Related values
Dana (Charity / Generosity)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Yajña (Sacrifice / Spirit of Offering)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Santosha (Contentment)Discriminative Wisdom
Related verses
Concepts
JivaDana

Two elephants in rut clash, and the larger one steps the smaller back. The Bhāgavatam selects the elephant-image rather than a god-image: Kṛṣṇa fights at the demon's scale, in the demon's idiom, and still wins by eighteen paces.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.12

↗
సోఽపవిద్ధో భగవతా పునరుత్థాయ సత్వరమ్ । ఆపతత్ స్విన్నసర్వాఙ్గో ని:శ్వసన్క్రోధమూర్చ్ఛిత: ॥ ౧౨ ॥
so ’paviddho bhagavatā
[so ’paviddho bhagavataa]
punar utthāya satvaram
[punar utthaaya satvaram]
āpatat svinna-sarvāṅgo
[aapatat svinna-sarvaango]
niḥśvasan krodha-mūrcchitaḥ
[nihshvasan krodha-moorchchitah]
saḥ — he apaviddhaḥ — thrown back bhagavatā — by the Lord punaḥ — again utthāya — rising satvaram — quickly āpatat — attacked svinna — sweating sarva — all aṅgaḥ — his limbs niḥśvasan — breathing hard krodha — by anger mūrcchitaḥ — stupefied .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
so ’paviddho bhagavatā
punar utthāya satvaram
saḥ
he
āpatat svinna-sarvāṅgo
apaviddhaḥ
thrown back
bhagavatā
by the Lord
punaḥ
again
utthāya
rising
satvaram
quickly
āpatat
attacked
niḥśvasan krodha-mūrcchitaḥ
svinna
sweating
sarva
all
aṅgaḥ
his limbs
niḥśvasan
breathing hard
krodha
by anger
mūrcchitaḥ
stupefied .
  • apaviddhaḥ — thrown back
    Apa (away) + √vyadh (to pierce, throw). The demon has been thrown but not yet finished — the Bhāgavatam often gives the antagonist one more breath, to make the final loss complete.
  • svinna — sweating
    From √svid — to sweat. Sweat is a marker — for demons it is exhaustion, for devotees it is sāttvika-bhāva. The same physical fact occupies opposite poles depending on whose body it appears on.
  • niḥśvasan — panting heavily
    Nir + √śvas (to breathe out). Breath as labor. The contrast with Kṛṣṇa, whose breathing the verses never even note, is the entire point.
  • krodha - mūrcchitaḥ — stunned with anger
    Krodha (anger) + mūrcchita (fainting, stupefied). The Bhagavad-gītā 2.63 chain — krodhāt bhavati sammohaḥ — is dramatized here in physical form: anger so total that consciousness itself blurs.
Thus repulsed by the Supreme Lord, the bull demon got up and, breathing hard and sweating all over his body, again charged Him in a mindless rage.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Thus repulsed by the Supreme Lord, the bull demon got up and, breathing hard and sweating all over his body, again charged Him in a mindless rage.
Commentary

Being thrown backwards the bull then got up.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The demon quickly (satvaram) got up. Another version has satvaraḥ san. In anger he forgot himself. All his limbs were exhausted (khinna) because of fatigue or anger. Another version has svinna (perspiring).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Dhriti (Resilience / Steadfastness / Fortitude)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Mardava (Gentleness)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Achapalya (Steadiness / Non-fickleness)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Repulsed but unable to read the repulsion, the bull comes again. Krodha without jñāna is the loop demons cannot exit — the second charge, the third charge, until Bhagavān decides the loop is finished.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.13

↗
తమాపతన్తం స నిగృహ్య శ‍ృఙ్గయో: పదా సమాక్రమ్య నిపాత్య భూతలే । నిష్పీడయామాస యథార్ద్రమమ్బరం కృత్వా విషాణేన జఘాన సోఽపతత్ ॥ ౧౩ ॥
tam āpatantaṁ sa nigṛhya śṛṅgayoḥ
[tam aapatantam sa nigrihya shringayoh]
padā samākramya nipātya bhū-tale
[padaa samaakramya nipaatya bhoo-tale]
niṣpīḍayām āsa yathārdram ambaraṁ
[nishpeedayaam aasa yathaardram ambaram]
kṛtvā viṣāṇena jaghāna so ’patat
[kritvaa vishaanena jaghaana so ’patat]
tam — him āpatantam — attacking saḥ — He nigṛhya — seizing śṛṅgayoḥ — by the horns padā — with His foot samākramya — treading nipātya — making him fall bhū - tale — onto the ground niṣpīḍayām āsa — He beat him yathā — like ardram — wet ambaram — a garment kṛtvā — making viṣāṇena — with his horn jaghāna — struck saḥ — he apatat — fell .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tam āpatantaṁ sa nigṛhya śṛṅgayoḥ
tam
him
āpatantam
attacking
saḥ
He
nigṛhya
seizing
śṛṅgayoḥ
by the horns
padā samākramya nipātya bhū-tale
padā
with His foot
samākramya
treading
nipātya
making him fall
bhū - tale
onto the ground
niṣpīḍayām āsa yathārdram ambaraṁ
niṣpīḍayām āsa
He beat him
yathā
like
ardram
wet
ambaram
a garment
kṛtvā viṣāṇena jaghāna so ’patat
kṛtvā
making
viṣāṇena
with his horn
jaghāna
struck
saḥ
he
apatat
fell .
  • nigṛhya — seizing
    Ni + √grah — to grasp firmly down. The intensified form of grahaṇa: the demon will not slip out.
  • niṣpīḍayām āsa — He squeezed (him) out
    From niṣ + √pīḍ — to press out, wring. The verb's domestic register (used of squeezing fruit, wringing cloth) is theologically pointed: cosmic destruction in the idiom of housework.
  • ardram — wet
    The famous wet-cloth simile. The body of the great bull — clouds hovering at its hump — is reduced linguistically to laundry. Vraja's poetics deflates demonic scale on contact.
  • viṣāṇena — with (the demon's own) horn
    Instrumental of viṣāṇa. The weapon the demon brought becomes the weapon by which he is finished — a recurring Bhāgavata pattern (Kaṁsa's wrestlers, Jarāsandha's army, Rāvaṇa's boons all turn against their owners).
As Ariṣṭa attacked, Lord Kṛṣṇa seized him by the horns and knocked him to the ground with His foot. The Lord then thrashed him as if he were a wet cloth, and finally He yanked out one of the demon’s horns and struck him with it until he lay prostrate.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
As Ariṣṭa attacked, Lord Kṛṣṇa seized him by the horns and knocked him to the ground with His foot. The Lord then thrashed him as if he were a wet cloth, and finally He yanked out one of the demon's horns and struck him with it until he lay prostrate.
Commentary

Grasping his two horns in his hands, Krsna twisted him around like a piece of wet cloth. Uprooting his left horn, Krsna dealt him a blow with that horn.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Two verses describe with joy the killing the demon. Kṛtvā means he uprooted his horn. Viṣṇu Purāṇa describes this. Utpāṭya śṛṅgam ekaṁ ca tena vā tāḍayat tathā: he uprooted one horn and beat the demon with it. Hari-vaṁśa says śṛṅgaṁ cāsya punaḥ savyam utpāṭya yama-daṇḍavat tenaiva prāharat vaktraṁ sa mamāra vṛṣo hataḥ: he uprooted his left horn and beat his head with it as if it were Yamarāja’s staff and the beaten bull then died. Apatat means he died.

Concepts
Jiva

He throws the demon down and wrings him out like a wet cloth. The verb is from laundry, not warfare. Kṛṣṇa fights demons the way a washerman wrings a sheet — without strain, without anger, with the rhythm of ordinary work.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.14

↗
అసృగ్ వమన్ మూత్రశకృత్ సముత్సృజన్ క్షిపంశ్చ పాదాననవస్థితేక్షణ: । జగామ కృచ్ఛ్రం నిఋర్తేరథ క్షయం పుష్పై: కిరన్తో హరిమీడిరే సురా: ॥ ౧౪ ॥
asṛg vaman mūtra-śakṛt samutsṛjan
[asrig vaman mootra-shakrit samutsrijan]
kṣipaṁś ca pādān anavasthitekṣaṇaḥ
[kshipamsh cha paadaan anavasthitekshanah]
jagāma kṛcchraṁ nirṛter atha kṣayaṁ
[jagaama krichchram nirriter atha kshayam]
puṣpaiḥ kiranto harim īḍire surāḥ
[pushpaih kiranto harim eedire suraah]
asṛk — blood vaman — vomiting mūtra — urine śakṛt — and feces samutsṛjan — profusely excreting kṣipan — throwing about ca — and pādān — his legs anavasthita — unsteady īkṣaṇaḥ — his eyes jagāma — he went kṛcchram — with pain nirṛteḥ — of Death atha — then kṣayam — to the abode puṣpaiḥ — flowers kirantaḥ — scattering harim — upon Lord Kṛṣṇa īdire — worshiped suraḥ — the demigods .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
asṛg vaman mūtra-śakṛt samutsṛjan
asṛk
blood
vaman
vomiting
mūtra
urine
śakṛt
and feces
samutsṛjan
profusely excreting
kṣipaṁś ca pādān anavasthitekṣaṇaḥ
kṣipan
throwing about
ca
and
pādān
his legs
anavasthita
unsteady
īkṣaṇaḥ
his eyes
jagāma kṛcchraṁ nirṛter atha kṣayaṁ
jagāma
he went
kṛcchram
with pain
nirṛteḥ
of Death
atha
then
kṣayam
to the abode
puṣpaiḥ kiranto harim īḍire surāḥ
puṣpaiḥ
flowers
kirantaḥ
scattering
harim
upon Lord Kṛṣṇa
īdire
worshiped
suraḥ
the demigods .
  • nirṛteḥ — of Nirṛti (Death)
    Nirṛti — personified destruction, the deity of the southwestern quarter. The demon's destination is named precisely; for Gauḍīyas this distinguishes the demons Kṛṣṇa kills in Vraja from those (like Pūtanā, Aghāsura) who receive sārūpya — context decides the post-mortem grade.
  • kṣayam — to the abode (of destruction)
    Kṣaya — dissolution, the abode of decay. Note: the verse does not say Ariṣṭa attained liberation. The Bhāgavatam is doctrinally precise about which slain demons gain it and which do not.
  • puṣpaiḥ — with flowers
    The puṣpa-vṛṣṭi, the celestial rain of flowers, is the gods' standard kīrtana — silent, fragrant approval falling from a cleared sky.
  • harim — Lord Hari
    Used at the verse's end after Ariṣṭa's end — Hari, the remover, has removed. The two events are syntactically adjacent.
  • suraḥ — the demigods
    Sura — counterpart of asura. The cosmos's full bench-side reaction: the asura is finished, the suras pour flowers. The pasture continues its day.
Vomiting blood and profusely excreting stool and urine, kicking his legs and rolling his eyes about, Ariṣṭāsura thus went painfully to the abode of Death. The demigods honored Lord Kṛṣṇa by scattering flowers upon Him.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Vomiting blood and profusely excreting stool and urine, kicking his legs and rolling his eyes about, Ariṣṭāsura thus went painfully to the abode of Death. The demigods honored Lord Kṛṣṇa by scattering flowers upon Him.
Commentary

The bull was put into great difficulty (kasta). Yama then killed the bull, not Krsna. The bull got immediate liberation. The devatas praised Krsna by showering flowers (puspaih kirantah).

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

His death is described. He actually bled and released urine and stool bit by bit in the fighting. This verse describes that condition. Śukadeva speaks in anger in saying that the demon went to the abode of Yama. However actually he attained liberation as described in SB 2.7.34. Or the statement can mean “On dying (nirṛteḥ) he went to the abode (kṣayam) of the Lord.” After his death (atha), the devatās praised him. They could not do this immediately since they were afraid.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

The demigods scatter flowers from above the moment the demon expires below. Vraja is constantly observed from svarga — the gods are an audience for every pastime, and they signal each act's perfection by a fall of petals.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.15

↗
ఏవం కుకుద్మినం హత్వా స్తూయమాన: ద్విజాతిభి: । వివేశ గోష్ఠం సబలో గోపీనాం నయనోత్సవ: ॥ ౧౫ ॥
evaṁ kukudminaṁ hatvā
[evam kukudminam hatvaa]
stūyamānaḥ dvijātibhiḥ
[stooyamaanah dvijaatibhih]
viveśa goṣṭhaṁ sa-balo
[vivesha goshtham sa-balo]
gopīnāṁ nayanotsavaḥ
[gopeenaam nayanotsavah]
evam — thus kukudminam — the humped (bull demon) hatvā — killing stūyamānaḥ — being praised dvijātibhiḥ — by the brāhmaṇas viveśa — He entered goṣṭham — the cowherd village sa - balaḥ — together with Lord Balarāma gopīnām — of the gopīs nayana — for the eyes utsavaḥ — who is a festival .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
evaṁ kukudminaṁ hatvā
evam
thus
kukudminam
the humped (bull demon)
hatvā
killing
stūyamānaḥ dvijātibhiḥ
stūyamānaḥ
being praised
dvijātibhiḥ
by the brāhmaṇas
viveśa goṣṭhaṁ sa-balo
viveśa
He entered
goṣṭham
the cowherd village
sa - balaḥ
together with Lord Balarāma
gopīnāṁ nayanotsavaḥ
gopīnām
of the gopīs
nayana
for the eyes
utsavaḥ
who is a festival .
  • kukudminam — the humped one (the bull)
    From kakud (hump) — the bull-demon named by his anatomy. The name belongs to him only by his form; once dead, even the name is shed.
  • stūyamānaḥ — being praised
    Passive participle of √stu — being hymned. The brāhmaṇas of Vraja recognize the act and offer stuti. In Vraja, even ritual response is interwoven with daily homecoming.
  • sa - balaḥ — together with Balarāma
    Sa (with) + Bala (Balarāma). Gauḍīyas mark this with care: Balarāma is the ādi-guru, the first servant of Kṛṣṇa, and almost every Vraja-līlā names Him alongside Kṛṣṇa even when the action is Kṛṣṇa's alone.
  • gopīnām — of the gopīs
    Genitive plural — belonging to the gopīs. The verse turns toward them in its final phrase. Vraja's center of gravity is always parakīya-rasa; the demon-killing is given two verbs, the gopīs' eyes get the verse's last word.
  • nayana - utsavaḥ — a festival for the eyes
    Nayana (eye) + utsava (festival). Kṛṣṇa is named by the function He performs in the gopīs' organ of darśana. His person is recurringly defined by what He does to the senses of His lovers.
Having thus killed the bull demon Ariṣṭa, He who is a festival for the gopīs’ eyes entered the cowherd village with Balarāma.

This verse exemplifies the sublime contrast of spiritual qualities within Śrī Kṛṣṇa. In one four-line verse we simultaneously learn that Lord Kṛṣṇa killed a powerful and wicked demon and that His boyish beauty gave festive pleasure to His young girlfriends. Lord Kṛṣṇa is as hard as a thunderbolt or as soft as a rose, depending on our attitude toward Him. The demon Ariṣṭa wanted to kill Kṛṣṇa and all His friends, so the Lord beat him into a wet rag and killed him. The gopīs, however, loved Kṛṣṇa, and thus the Lord boyishly reciprocated their conjugal feelings.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Having thus killed the bull demon Ariṣṭa, He who is a festival for the gopīs' eyes entered the cowherd village with Balarāma.
Commentary

The puranas describe how Radha kunda and Shyama kunda appeared after the killing of Aristasura as a result of a conversation between Radha and Krsna. "O sinful killer of a bull! Do not touch me today." "O foolish woman! This is not a bull, but a terrible demon." "O Krsna, that may be true, but he belongs to the species of cattle, just as Vrtrasura, though a demon, was still a brahmana." "O Radha! What is the acquittal for this act?" "You will become pure by performing the austerity of bathing in all the holy waters of the three worlds." "How will I go around the three worlds? I will bring all the holy places here and bathe in them. Just watch now." Saying that, Mukunda stamped on the earth with his heel, making a hole, and said, "Come here." All the holy waters came there along from Ganga situated in Patala with their presiding deities. Krsna said to the gopis, "Behold all the holy waters!" But they did not believe his words. The presiding deities, folding their hands, came forward and introduced themselves. "I am the salt ocean. I am the milk ocean. I am the svarga dighi, I am the red ocean. I am the Tamraparni,. I am Puskara, I am Sarasvati I am Godavari I am Yamuna. I am Sarayu, I am Prayaga. I am Reva." "See all these waters and believe me." Bathing in the waters Krsna became clean. "I have made one lake in which all the tirthas reside. None of you have performed such pious work." Hearing this, Radha said to her friends, "We must also make an attractive kunda. You should construct one with great care." West of Krsna’s kunda, where Arista had made a hole with his foot, the gopis began to take earth in their hands and in two and half hours made a beautiful kunda. Seeing their kunda, Krsna began to think of having rasa. "O lotus eyed Radha, please take some of the holy water from my kunda and fill up your kunda." Hearing this Radha said, "No, no! That water is no good, coming from one who has sinfully killed a bull. I will fill up this kunda with a thousand pots of water from Manasa Ganga. By this my fame will be spread throughout the universe." Taking the cue from Krsna all the holy waters of his kunda, taking on one transcendental form, approached Radha, offered obeisances, and with folded hands and tears in her eyes, began to offer praises. "O goddess, those who know scripture do not know your glories. Brahma does not know, nor Siva, nor Laksmi. Only Krsna, best of men, who wipes the perspiration from your limbs, who decorates your feet with skilful designs and puts your anklets on your feet knows. Just getting the glance from your lotus eye, we will think ourselves superbly fortunate and will reach the highest bliss. We reside in this place made by Krsna’s heel. On his order we have come here. If you are pleased, give your merciful glance. Then our desire tree will be able to bear fruit." Being satisfied with the praises of the tirthas, Radha said, "Know that your desire has been fulfilled." The tirthas clearly stated their desire. "Our lives will be successful if we can enter your kunda. This is the boon we pray for." Then Radha, glancing at Krsna, said, "Come, come." Hearing this, the same minded gopis became submerged in ecstasy. All moving and non moving creatures became enlivened. Having attained the mercy of Radha, all the tirthas broke their bank and swiftly flowed into Radha’s kunda, filling it up. Krsna said, "O most beloved! May your kunda become more famous in the world than mine. In your kunda I will perform water pastimes I will bathe there daily. As you are most dear to me, so is your kunda" Radha said, "Along with my frineds, I will also bathe in Radha kunda. May the kunda destroy a hundred misfortunes. I will be most pleased with that person who shows devotion to this kunda, who bathes in it, and who resides near it." The lightening form of Radha, whose glory is spread throughout the three worlds, who causes a shower of blissful rasa from the cloud of Krsna, performs rasa lila at Radha kunda nightly.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He was praised by the cowherds (svajātibhiḥ). This shows their intimacy with him (being his own people). Balarāma had come with Kṛṣṇa for fun, out of affection for his younger brother, to see the demon being killed. Kṛṣṇa was by his nature a joy for the eyes but now having arrived after killing the great enemy he was especially a joy for the eyes. Hari-vaṁśa says: sa copendro vṛṣaṁ hatvā kānta-candre niśāmukhe aravindābha-nayanaḥ punar eva raṛama ha Having killed the bull lotus eyed Kṛṣṇa again enjoyed in the moonlit night. After returning to the village he again went out. This shows the intense attachment of Kṛṣṇa for the gopīs. Ādi-varāha Purāṇa says: gaṅgāyāś cottaraṁ gatvā devadevasya cakriṇaḥ ariṣṭena samaṁ yatra mahad yuddhaṁ pravartitam ghatayitvā tatas tasmin ariṣṭaṁ vṛṣarūpinam kopena pāṛṣni-ghātena mahyās tīrthaṁ prakaliptam North of Manasa-gaṅgā (gaṅgāyāh) the Lord marked with cakras on his feet (cakriṇaḥ), endowed with all powers and sweetness (devadevasya) fought a fierce battle with Ariṣṭa. Killing the demon with the body of a bull at that place, in anger (because the demon had disturbed Vraja) Kṛṣṇa produced a great tīrtha by striking the ground with his heel. vṛṣabhasya vadho jṣeya ātmanaḥ śuddham icchatā snātas tatra taḍa krṣṇo vṛṣaṁ hatvā sagopakaḥ Knowing he had killed a bull, he desired purification. He bathed in the tīrtha along with his friends after killing the bull. vipāpmā rādhām provaca kathaṁ bhadre bhaviṣyati vṛṣo hatomayā cāyam ariṣṭaḥ papa-sūcakaḥ tatra rādhā samāśliṣya kṛṣṇām akliṣṭa-kāriṇam sva-nāmnā viditaṁ kuṇḍaṁ kṛtam tiṛtham adūrataḥ He spoke to Rādhā. O fortunate Rādhā! How can you be as pious? I am sinless. I have killed the sinful bull Ariṣṭa. Rādhā embraced him, who relieves all fatigue. She made another tīrtha nearby named after her. rādhā-kuṇḍam iti khyātaṁ sarva pāpaharaṁ śubham ariṣṭa-rādhā kuṇḍābhām snānat phalam avāpnute rājasūyāśvamedhābhyām nātra kāryā vicāranā gohatyā brahma-hatyā ca pāpam kṣipram praṇaśyati It is famous as Rādhā-kuṇḍa. By bathing in these two kuṇḍas, one achieves auspicious results and all sins are destroyed. The same effect cannot be achieved by a rājasūya or aśvamedha sacrifice. It destroys the sin of killing a cow or a brāhmaṇa. There is no doubt about this. Kṛṣṇa was worried that the earth wanted to broadcast his killing of the demon. Absorbed in the pastime of the killing, the people will not appreciate the glory of the tīrtha. Therefore he pretended the killing of a bull (actually a demon) was a sin and desired purification. Since the tīrtha supposedly came from Pātāla, he made it glorious by bathing in it. After bathing there, he returned to Vraja according to Hari-vaṁśa. Then after some time, using his flute he called the gopīs for rāsa dance, and on the way to the rāsa arena, where Ariṣṭa had been killed, he met Rādhā and separating her from the rest, spoke to her. Thinking she would make fun of him, he started by saying he was sinless. “I am not sinful, but on the contrary, have become most sinless by constructing this tīrtha. If you do not construct such a tīrtha, how can you become pious?” He explains why he is sinless. “The demon was a bull in form only. He was actually the sinful demon named Ariṣṭa. He is a demon by his actions.” Thinking of this, Rādhā then felt affection for him in this meeting. In that meeting (tatra), she embraced him, giving up her shyness. Out of friendship she also made a kuṇḍa. In order make the kuṇḍa equal to Kṛṣṇa’s, she took the help of her thousands of sakhīs, since it would have been smaller making it on her own. The reason she could make the kuṇḍa was that she had embraced Kṛṣṇa. At first she dug out the earth upraised by Ariṣṭa’s hooves and then solid earth. The kuṇḍa is next to Kṛṣṇa’s kuṇḍa, northeast of Govardhana.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He was praised by the cowherds (svajātibhiḥ). He was pleased by their praise. He had gone outside of the village to kill Ariṣṭa, and thus now entered the village. Previously it was said that Ariṣṭa came to the village. This means he came near the village. Or thinking of causing great disturbance he entered the village. Balarāma had come with Kṛṣṇa, out of affection for his younger brother, to see the demon being killed. He was joy for their eyes. Without seeing him how could they experience any happiness at all? When he went away to kill the demon, they felt great sorrow and when he returned after killing him, they felt great happiness. Or they felt greatly happy on seeing him affectionately after he killed the demon. That night he performed the rāsa dance. sa copendro vṛṣaṁ hatvā kānta-candre niśāmukhe aravindābha-nayanaḥ punar eva raṛama ha Having killed the bull, lotus eyed Kṛṣṇa again enjoyed in the moonlit night. Hari-vaṁśa On striking his heel to the earth Ariṣṭa-kuṇḍa was formed. Because he had killed a bull, Rādhā joked. He then created another kuṇḍa to satisfy her, famous as Rādhā-kuṇḍa, honored by the whole world. This is described in Varāha Purāṇa. Both kuṇḍas are still present near Govardhana.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

He kills the bull and walks back into the village with Balarāma; the gopīs' eyes meet Him at the gate and the demon is already forgotten. For Vraja, the killing was a brief detour — the real event is His return, and the festival their eyes throw at the sight of Him.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.16

↗
అరిష్టే నిహతే దైత్యే కృష్ణేనాద్భ‍ుతకర్మణా । కంసాయాథాహ భగవాన్ నారదో దేవదర్శన: ॥ ౧౬ ॥
ariṣṭe nihate daitye
[arishte nihate daitye]
kṛṣṇenādbhuta-karmaṇā
[krishnenaadbhuta-karmanaa]
kaṁsāyāthāha bhagavān
[kamsaayaathaaha bhagavaan]
nārado deva-darśanaḥ
[naarado deva-darshanah]
ariṣṭe — Ariṣṭa nihate — having been killed daitye — the demon kṛṣṇena — by Kṛṣṇa adbhuta - karmaṇā — whose activities are wonderful kaṁsāya — to Kaṁsa atha — then āha — spoke bhagavān — the powerful sage nāradaḥ — Nārada deva - darśanaḥ — whose vision is godly .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ariṣṭe nihate daitye
ariṣṭe
Ariṣṭa
nihate
having been killed
daitye
the demon
kṛṣṇenādbhuta-karmaṇā
kṛṣṇena
by Kṛṣṇa
adbhuta - karmaṇā
whose activities are wonderful
kaṁsāya
to Kaṁsa
kaṁsāyāthāha bhagavān
atha
then
āha
spoke
bhagavān
the powerful sage
nārado deva-darśanaḥ
nāradaḥ
Nārada
deva - darśanaḥ
whose vision is godly .
  • adbhuta - karmaṇā — by Him whose deeds are wondrous
    Adbhuta (wondrous) + karman (action). A signature epithet of Kṛṣṇa's līlā — His acts induce adbhuta-rasa in the witness. The killing of Ariṣṭa is filed under that category.
  • nāradaḥ — Nārada Muni
    The bhakti-pracāraka par excellence — author of the Nārada-bhakti-sūtra, guru of Vyāsa, Prahlāda, Dhruva. Gauḍīyas treat Nārada as one of the chief currents through which the bhakti-stream descends to earth.
  • deva - darśanaḥ — having godly vision
    Deva (god) + darśana (sight). Nārada sees by divine perception. He is not bringing Kaṁsa speculation; he is bringing the kind of report only an ṛṣi of his rank can give.
  • bhagavān — the master (Nārada)
    Bhagavān is applied here to Nārada — a Gauḍīya note: the title extends to His pure devotees by participation, never independently. Nārada is bhagavān because he is wholly Bhagavān's.
After Ariṣṭāsura had been killed by Kṛṣṇa, who acts wonderfully, Nārada Muni went to speak to King Kaṁsa. That powerful sage of godly vision addressed the King as follows.

The term deva-darśana can be understood in many ways, all of which are consistent with the context and purport of this narration. Deva means “God,” and darśanaḥ means “seeing” or “an audience with a great personality.” Thus deva-darśana, a name for Nārada Muni, indicates that Nārada has attained the perfection of seeing God, that getting Nārada’s audience is as good as getting God’s (since Nārada is a pure representative of the Lord), and also that Nārada’s audience is as good as that of the demigods, who are also known as devas. That there are all these meanings of the term deva-darśanaḥ reveals something of the richness of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam’s language. From the Purāṇas, Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura has quoted twenty verses describing a joking conversation between Rādhā and Kṛṣṇa that took place after Kṛṣṇa had killed the demon Ariṣṭa. This conversation, so kindly quoted by the ācārya, describes the origin of Rādhā-kuṇḍa and Śyāma-kuṇḍa, Rādhā’s and Kṛṣṇa’s bathing ponds. The verses are as follows: māsmān spṛśādya vṛṣabhārdana hanta mugdhā ghoro ’suro ’yam ayi kṛṣṇa tad apy ayaṁ gauḥ vṛtro yathā dvija ihāsty ayi niṣkṛtiḥ kiṁ śudhyed bhavāṁs tri-bhuvana-sthita-tīrtha-kṛcchrāt “The innocent young gopīs said, ‘Ah, Kṛṣṇa, don’t touch us now, O killer of a bull! Alas, even though Ariṣṭa was a terrible demon, still he was a male cow, so You will have to undergo atonement, just as Lord Indra did after killing Vṛtrāsura. But how can You purify Yourself without going to the trouble of visiting every single holy place in the three worlds?’” kiṁ paryaṭāmi bhuvanāny adhunaiva sarvā ānīya tīrtha-vitatīḥ karavāṇi tāsu snānaṁ vilokayata tāvad idaṁ mukundaḥ procyaiva tatra kṛtavān bata pārṣṇi-ghātam “[Kṛṣṇa replied,] ‘Why should I have to wander throughout the entire universe? I will at once bring all the countless pilgrimage places here and take My bath in them. Just watch!’ With this, Lord Mukunda struck His heel on the ground.” pātālato jalam idaṁ kila bhogavatyā āyātam atra nikhilā api tīrtha-saṅghāḥ āgacchateti bhagavad-vacasā ta etya tatraiva rejur atha kṛṣṇa uvāca gopīḥ “[Then He said,] ‘This is the water of the Bhogavatī River, coming from the Pātāla region. And now, O holy places, all of you please come here!’ When the Supreme Lord had spoken these words, all the holy places went there and appeared before Him. Kṛṣṇa then addressed the gopīs as follows.” tīrthāni paśyata harer vacasā tavaivaṁ naiva pratīma iti tā atha tīrtha-varyāḥ procuḥ kṛtāñjali-puṭā lavaṇābdhir asmi kṣīrābdhir asmi śṛṇutāmara-dīrghikāsmi “‘See all the holy places!’ “But the gopīs replied, ‘We don’t see them as You describe.’ “Then those best of holy places, joining their palms in supplication, spoke up: “‘I am the salt ocean.’ “‘I am the Ocean of Milk.’ “‘I am the Amara-dīrghikā.’” śoṇo ’pi sindhur aham asmi bhavāmi tāmra- parṇī ca puṣkaram ahaṁ ca sarasvatī ca godāvarī ravi-sutā sarayuḥ prayāgo revāsmi paśyata jalaṁ kuruta pratītim “‘I am the river Śoṇa.’ “‘I am the Sindhu.’ “‘I am the Tāmraparṇī.’ “‘I am the holy place Puṣkara.’ “‘I am the river Sarasvatī.’ “‘And we are the Godāvarī, Yamunā and Revā rivers and the confluence of rivers at Prayāga. Just see our waters!’” snātvā tato harir ati-prajagalbha eva śuddhaḥ saro ’py akaravaṁ sthita-sarva-tīrtham yuṣmābhir ātma-januṣīha kṛto na dharmaḥ ko ’pi kṣitāv atha sakhīr nijagāda rādhā “After purifying Himself by bathing, Lord Hari became quite arrogant and said, ‘I have produced a pond containing all the various holy places, whereas you gopīs must never have executed any religious duties on this earth for the pleasure of Lord Brahmā.’ Then Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī addressed Her girlfriends as follows.” kāryaṁ mayāpy ati-manohara-kuṇḍam ekaṁ tasmād yatadhvam iti tad-vacanena tābhiḥ śrī-kṛṣṇa-kuṇḍa-taṭa-paścima-diśya-mando gartaḥ kṛto vṛṣabha-daitya-khurair vyaloki “‘I must create an even more beautiful pond. So go to work!’ Having heard these words, the gopīs saw that Ariṣṭāsura’s hooves had dug a shallow ditch just west of Śrī Kṛṣṇa’s pond.” tatrārdra-mṛn-mṛdula-gola-tatīḥ prati-sva- hastoddhṛtā anati-dūra-gatā vidhāya divyaṁ saraḥ prakaṭitaṁ ghaṭikā-dvayena tābhir vilokya sarasaṁ smarate sma kṛṣṇaḥ “At that nearby spot, all the gopīs began digging up lumps of soft mud with their hands, and in this way a divine pond manifested in the short span of an hour. Kṛṣṇa was astonished to see the lake they produced.” proce ca tīrtha-salilaiḥ paripūrayaitan mat-kuṇḍataḥ sarasijākṣi sahālibhis tvam rādhā tadā na na na neti jagāda yasmāt tvat-kuṇḍa-nīram uru-go-vadha-pātakāktam “He said, ‘Go ahead, lotus-eyed one. You and Your companions should fill this pond with water from Mine.’ “But Rādhā replied, ‘No, no, no, no! This is impossible, since the water of Your pond is contaminated by Your terrible sin of killing a cow.’” āhṛtya puṇya-salilaṁ śata-koṭi-kumbhaiḥ sakhy-arbudena saha mānasa-jāhnavītaḥ etat saraḥ sva-madhunā paripūrayāmi tenaiva kīrtim atulāṁ tanavāni loke “‘I will have My countless gopī companions bring the pure water of the Mānasa-gaṅgā here in billions of pots. In this way I will fill this lake with My own water and thus make its renown unequaled in the entire world.’” kṛṣṇeṅgitena sahasaitya samasta-tīrtha- sakhyas tadīya-saraso dhṛta-divya-mūrtiḥ tuṣṭāva tatra vṛṣabhānu-sutāṁ praṇamya bhaktyā kṛtāñjali-puṭaḥ sravad-asra-dhāraḥ “Lord Kṛṣṇa then gestured to a heavenly personality who was an intimate associate of all the holy places. Suddenly that person rose up out of Kṛṣṇa’s pond and bowed down to the daughter of Śrī Vṛṣabhānu [Rādhārāṇī]. Then, with palms joined and tears pouring from his eyes, he began praying to Her in devotion.” devi tvadīya-mahimānam avaiti sarva śāstrārtha-vin na ca vidhir na haro na lakṣmīḥ kintv eka eva puruṣārtha-śiromaṇis tvat- prasveda-mārjana-paraḥ svayam eva kṛṣṇaḥ “‘O goddess, even Lord Brahmā himself, the knower of all scriptures, cannot understand Your glories, nor can Lord Śiva or Lakṣmī. Only Kṛṣṇa, the supreme goal of all human endeavor, can understand them, and thus He feels obliged to personally make sure that You can wash away Your perspiration when You are fatigued.’” yaś cāru-yāvaka-rasena bhavat-padābjam ārajya nūpuram aho nidadhāti nityam prāpya tvadīya-nayanābja-taṭa-prasādaṁ svaṁ manyate parama-dhanyatamaṁ prahṛṣyan tasyājñayaiva sahasā vayam ājagāma tat-pārṣṇi-ghāṭa-kṛta-kuṇḍa-vare vasāmaḥ tvaṁ cet prasīdasi karoṣi kṛpā-kaṭākṣaṁ tarhy eva tarṣa-viṭapī phalito bhaven naḥ “‘He is always anointing Your lotus feet with nectarean cāru and yāvaka and decorating them with ankle bells, and He rejoices and feels most fortunate simply by satisfying the tips of the toes of Your lotus feet. On His order we have immediately come here to live in this most excellent pond, which He created by one stroke of His heel. But only if You now feel satisfied with us and bestow upon us Your merciful glance will the tree of our desire bear fruit.’” śrutvā stutiṁ nikhila-tīrtha-gaṇasya tuṣṭā prāha sma tarṣam ayi vedayateti rādhā yāma tvadīya-sarasīṁ sa-phalā bhavāma ity eva no vara iti prakaṭaṁ tadocuḥ “Hearing this prayer spoken by the representative of the full assembly of holy places, Śrī Rādhā was pleased and said, ‘So, kindly tell Me your desire.’ “They then told Her plainly, ‘Our lives would be successful if we could come to Your pond. That is the benediction we desire.’” āgacchateti vṛṣabhānu-sutā smitāsyā provāca kānta-vadanābja-dhṛtākṣi-koṇā sakhyo ’pi tatra kṛta-sammatayaḥ sukhābdhau magnā virejur akhilā sthira-jaṅgamāś ca “Glancing at Her beloved from the corners of Her eyes, the daughter of Vṛṣabhānu replied with a smile, ‘Please come.’ Her gopī companions all agreed with Her decision and became immersed in the ocean of happiness. Indeed, the beauty of all creatures, both mobile and stationary, was enhanced.” prāpya prasādam atha te vṛṣabhānujāyāḥ śrī-kṛṣṇa-kuṇḍa-gata-tīrtha-varāḥ prasahya bhittveva bhittim ati-vegata eva rādhā- kuṇḍaṁ vyadhuḥ sva-salilaiḥ paripūrṇam eva “Thus gaining the grace of Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī, the holy rivers and lakes in Śrī Kṛṣṇa-kuṇḍa forcibly broke through its boundary walls and swiftly filled Rādhā-kuṇḍa with their waters.” proce hariḥ priyatame tava kuṇḍam etan mat-kuṇḍato ’pi mahimādhikam astu loke atraiva me salila-kelir ihaiva nityaṁ snānaṁ yathā tvam asi tadvad idaṁ saro me “Lord Hari then said, ‘My dear Rādhā, may this pond of Yours become even more world-renowned than Mine. I will always come here to bathe and to enjoy My water pastimes. Indeed, this lake is as dear to Me as You are.’” rādhābravīd aham api sva-sakhībhir etya snāsyāmy ariṣṭa-śata-mardanam astu tasya yo ’riṣṭa-mardana-sarasy uru-bhaktir atra snāyād vasen mama sa eva mahā-priyo ’stu “Rādhā replied, ‘I will come to bathe in Your pond as well, even though You may kill hundreds of Ariṣṭa demons here. In the future, anyone who has intense devotion for this lake, which is on the spot where You chastised Ariṣṭāsura, and who bathes or resides here is sure to become very dear to Me.’” rāsotsavaṁ prakurute sma ca tatra rātrau kṛṣṇāmbudaḥ kṛta-mahā-rasa-harṣa-varṣaḥ śrī-rādhikā-pravara-vidyud alaṅkṛta-śrīs trailokya-madhya-vitatī-kṛta-divya-kīrtiḥ “That night Lord Kṛṣṇa initiated a rāsa dance at Rādhā-kuṇḍa, generating a torrent of the greatest mood of splendorous pleasure. Śrī Kṛṣṇa resembled a cloud, and Śrīmatī Rādhārāṇī a brilliant flash of lightning filling the sky with abundant beauty. In this way Their divine glories permeated the expanses of the three worlds.” As a final note, it should be mentioned that Nārada Muni, being a great sage, understood that the killing of Ariṣṭa more or less concluded the pastimes of Kṛṣṇa in Vṛndāvana. Therefore Nārada, anxious to facilitate the transferal of Kṛṣṇa’s pastimes to Mathurā, approached Kaṁsa and addressed him as follows.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
After Ariṣṭāsura had been killed by Kṛṣṇa, who acts wonderfully, Nārada Muni went to speak to King Kaṁsa. That powerful sage of godly vision addressed the King as follows.
Commentary

Narada is referred to as deva darsana. This means that he was endowed with transcendental vision like the supreme lord (deva), one who knows or sees the pastimes of Krsna. Narada, knowing that Krsna’s Vraja lila was ending, to make arrangements to bring him to Mathura, spoke to Kamsa.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Now we return to the topic. Two and a half verses explain. It should be understood that Nārada went to Kaṁsa long after the killing of Ariṣṭa. The rāsa dance at Govardhana took place in the middle of spring. Killing Kaṁsa took place later on the Caturdaśī of Śiva-rātri (the next year). Nārada told Kaṁsa about Kṛṣṇa’s wonderful activities in Vraja from the killing of Pūtanā to the killing of Ariṣṭa. Deva darśanaḥ means seer of mantras (darśana) or sage among the devatās. Or it means he who has knowledge (darṣanaḥ) like the devatās. Whatever he says comes true. This name indicates the following. “The prakaṭa pastimes occur in every kalpa of Brahmā. By the request of protecting the devotees like the Yādavas and Pāṇḍavas, the Lord performs his human pastimes and not more. The Vraja pastimes are completed. Now the Yādavas are suffering to the extreme and the devatās are disturbed. The killing of Kaṁsa by the Lord should happen soon. The Lord appeared for that purpose. I will inform Kaṁsa so that he will bring Kṛṣṇa to Mathurā.”

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Nārada went to Kaṁsa to relate the astonishing activities in the village, after Kṛṣṇa killed Ariṣṭa. Or he told him of Kṛṣṇa’s killing Pūtanā and others. He went after Ariṣṭa was killed (atha). The pastimes of Gokula were almost complete. The Yādavas were suffering and the devatās were disturbed. Kaṁsa had to be killed. The opportunity now occurred. I will make this happen: Kaṁsa should bring Kṛṣṇa to Mathurā and Kṛṣṇa will then kill him. This was because Nārada was omniscient (bhagavān). He was an avatāra of the Lord, or he was similar to the Lord because he was a great devotee. He also knows that the pastimes of Vraja continue eternally, though hidden. Therefore one should not hate Nārada. Or deva-darśana means he sees the devatās. To fulfill the goal since he is the sage among the devatās, he did this.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
Concepts
PunyaAvatara

Nārada, who once played the catalyst for Dhruva and Prahlāda, now plays it in reverse — kindling Kaṁsa toward his own destruction by telling him the exact truth. The Lord's līlā uses the same servant to ripen both devotees and demons.

Nārada and Dhruva

In SB 4.8, the same Nārada Muni met five-year-old Dhruva in the forest and gave him the dvādaśa-akṣara mantra. That meeting bent a child's resentment into the deepest tapasya the universe had seen.

The same sage walks now into Kaṁsa's palace and bends a king's fear into the swift trajectory that will deliver him to Kṛṣṇa's feet — by death rather than darśana, but delivered nonetheless. Nārada serves the Lord's plan in both directions.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.17

↗
యశోదాయా: సుతాం కన్యాం దేవక్యా: కృష్ణమేవ చ । రామం చ రోహిణీపుత్రం వసుదేవేన బిభ్యతా । న్యస్తౌ స్వమిత్రే నన్దే వై యాభ్యాం తే పురుషా హతా: ॥ ౧౭ ॥
yaśodāyāḥ sutāṁ kanyāṁ
[yashodaayaah sutaam kanyaam]
devakyāḥ kṛṣṇam eva ca
[devakyaah krishnam eva cha]
rāmaṁ ca rohiṇī-putraṁ
[raamam cha rohinee-putram]
vasudevena bibhyatā
[vasudevena bibhyataa]
nyastau sva-mitre nande vai
[nyastau sva-mitre nande vai]
yābhyāṁ te puruṣā hatāḥ
[yaabhyaam te purushaa hataah]
yaśodāyāḥ — of Yaśodā sutām — the daughter kanyām — the female child devakyāḥ — of Devakī kṛṣṇam — Kṛṣṇa eva ca — also rāmam — Balarāma ca — and rohiṇī - putram — the son of Rohiṇī vasudevena — by Vasudeva bibhyatā — who was afraid nyastau — placed sva - mitre — with his friend nande — Nanda Mahārāja vai — indeed yābhyām — by which two te — your puruṣāḥ — men hatāḥ — have been killed .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yaśodāyāḥ sutāṁ kanyāṁ
yaśodāyāḥ
of Yaśodā
sutām
the daughter
kanyām
the female child
devakyāḥ kṛṣṇam eva ca
devakyāḥ
of Devakī
kṛṣṇam
Kṛṣṇa
eva ca
also
rāmaṁ ca rohiṇī-putraṁ
rāmam
Balarāma
ca
and
rohiṇī - putram
the son of Rohiṇī
vasudevena bibhyatā
vasudevena
by Vasudeva
bibhyatā
who was afraid
nyastau sva-mitre nande vai
nyastau
placed
sva - mitre
with his friend
nande
Nanda Mahārāja
vai
indeed
yābhyāṁ te puruṣā hatāḥ
yābhyām
by which two
te
your
puruṣāḥ
men
hatāḥ
have been killed .
  • yaśodāyāḥ — of Yaśodā
    Genitive of Yaśodā. Her name carries vātsalya-rasa intrinsically — the moment Kaṁsa hears it, the network of Vraja becomes legible to him as a target. Even her name has now entered the demon's ear.
  • kanyām — the daughter (was the female child)
    The child Kaṁsa dashed against the stone in SB 10.4 — Yogamāyā Herself. Nārada now reveals the substitution Vasudeva and Yaśodā made on that night.
  • rohiṇī - putram — the son of Rohiṇī
    Balarāma — Rohiṇī's son by Vasudeva, transferred from Devakī's womb to Rohiṇī's by Yogamāyā (SB 10.2). The whole nativity-secret of Vraja is being declassified in one sūtra-like utterance.
  • vasudevena — by Vasudeva
    Nārada names the father. The ān ākadundubhi of the Yadu line is now exposed to Kaṁsa as the smuggler of Bhagavān into the forest. For Gauḍīyas, Vasudeva's quiet, fearful service is itself a paradigm of dāsya.
  • nyastau — (the two) were entrusted
    Past participle of ni + √as — to deposit, place down. The verb of safekeeping. Vasudeva did not abandon the boys; he placed them. Gauḍīyas notice this verb's care.
[Nārada told Kaṁsa:] Yaśodā’s child was actually a daughter, and Kṛṣṇa is the son of Devakī. Also, Rāma is the son of Rohiṇī. Out of fear, Vasudeva entrusted Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma to his friend Nanda Mahārāja, and it is these two boys who have killed your men.

Kaṁsa had been led to believe that Kṛṣṇa was the son of Yaśodā and that Devakī’s eighth child had been a daughter. The identity of Devakī’s eighth child was extremely important to Kaṁsa because a prophecy had foretold that her eighth child would kill him. Here Nārada informs the King that the eighth child of Devakī was the formidable Kṛṣṇa, thus implying that the prophecy should be taken very seriously. Having received this information, Kaṁsa obviously will now do everything in his power to kill Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[Nārada told Kaṁsa:] Yaśodā's child was actually a daughter, and Kṛṣṇa is the son of Devakī. Also, Rāma is the son of Rohiṇī. Out of fear, Vasudeva entrusted Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma to his friend Nanda Mahārāja, and it is these two boys who have killed your men.
Commentary

What did he say to Kamsa? The famous eight child of Devaki, a female, was actually the daughter of Yasoda. Krsna, commonly known as Nanda’s son, was actually the son of Devaki. Balarama, thought to be Nanda’s son, was actually the son of Rohini. "If Krsna and Balarama are Vasudeva’s children, who brought them to Vraja?" "They were brought by Vasudeva."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Though he is the son of Rohiṇī, Balarāma was actually in the womb of Devakī first. Nārada explained this. Out of fear, Vasudeva entrusted the children to Nanda. Since he is afraid of you, you should not kill him. Nanda is Vasudeva’s friend (sva-mitre). They have very strong ties of affection, or they are friends (mitre) and relatives (sva). Vai means that it is well known. Since you do not know about this, you are foolish. Nārada spoke in this way to gain Kaṁsa’s trust. They have killed your friends (puruṣāḥ). He makes this statement to testify to the facts he has just related. By indicating the two boys’ great strength, he made Kaṁsa constantly frightened of them.

Related values
Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Ishvara Pranidhana (Surrender to God)Tapas (Austerity / Discipline)
Related verses
Concepts
JivaPurusha

Nārada unties the knot Kaṁsa has been holding for eleven years: the child you let go in the dungeon was Yogamāyā's, and the boys in the forest are Devakī's actual sons. The whole demon-strategy collapses in one sentence — and the collapse is itself part of the līlā.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.18

↗
నిశమ్య తద్భ‍ోజపతి: కోపాత్ప్రచలితేన్ద్రియ: । నిశాతమసిమాదత్త వసుదేవజిఘాంసయా ॥ ౧౮ ॥
niśamya tad bhoja-patiḥ
[nishamya tad bhoja-patih]
kopāt pracalitendriyaḥ
[kopaat prachalitendriyah]
niśātam asim ādatta
[nishaatam asim aadatta]
vasudeva-jighāṁsayā
[vasudeva-jighaamsayaa]
niśamya — hearing tat — that bhoja - patiḥ — the lord of the Bhoja dynasty (Kaṁsa) kopāt — out of anger pracalita — disturbed indriyaḥ — his senses niśātam — sharp asim — a sword ādatta — took up vasudeva - jighāṁsayā — with the desire to kill Vasudeva .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
niśamya tad bhoja-patiḥ
niśamya
hearing
tat
that
bhoja - patiḥ
the lord of the Bhoja dynasty (Kaṁsa)
kopāt pracalitendriyaḥ
kopāt
out of anger
pracalita
disturbed
indriyaḥ
his senses
niśātam asim ādatta
niśātam
sharp
asim
a sword
ādatta
took up
vasudeva-jighāṁsayā
vasudeva - jighāṁsayā
with the desire to kill Vasudeva .
  • kopāt — out of anger
    Ablative of krodha. The Gītā's chain (krodhād bhavati sammohaḥ, 2.63) plays out here in narrative form — anger immediately produces a senseless act.
  • pracalita - indriyaḥ — his senses agitated
    Pracalita (set in motion, disturbed) + indriya (sense). The senses, not the will, are leading. Vaiṣṇava ethics names this state precisely: indriya-grāma in revolt against buddhi.
  • asim — sword
    The Bhāgavatam's standard image of Kaṁsa's mode: he answers every revelation with a blade. The same blade was raised against newborn Devakī (SB 10.1) and is raised now against her husband.
  • vasudeva - jighāṁsayā — with the desire to kill Vasudeva
    Jighāṁsā — the desiderative of √han (to kill). Kaṁsa's grammar is desiderative-han: he is permanently in the mood-of-wanting-to-kill. Bhakti's opposite is exactly this.
Upon hearing this, the master of the Bhojas became furious and lost control of his senses. He picked up a sharp sword to kill Vasudeva.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Upon hearing this, the master of the Bhojas became furious and lost control of his senses. He picked up a sharp sword to kill Vasudeva.
Commentary

Kamsa took up his sword, but not in the presence of Vasudeva.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

His senses and mind became agitated. This means he lost all power of discrimination.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Bhoja-pati suggests Kaṁsa had great power. Also he was the best of enjoyers. Having many desires he had little intelligence. His senses and mind became agitated. This means he lost all power of discrimination.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses

The sword leaps to the hand before the mind catches up. Kaṁsa is named for this exact reflex throughout the Bhāgavatam — his bhakti-by-fear is real and constant, but every reflex of his arm is murder.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.19

↗
నివారితో నారదేన తత్సుతౌ మృత్యుమాత్మన: । జ్ఞాత్వా లోహమయై: పాశైర్బబన్ధ సహ భార్యయా ॥ ౧౯ ॥
nivārito nāradena
[nivaarito naaradena]
tat-sutau mṛtyum ātmanaḥ
[tat-sutau mrityum aatmanah]
jñātvā loha-mayaiḥ pāśair
[jnaatvaa loha-mayaih paashair]
babandha saha bhāryayā
[babandha saha bhaaryayaa]
nivāritaḥ — checked nāradena — by Nārada tat - sutau — his two sons mṛtyum — death ātmanaḥ — his own jñātvā — understanding loha - mayaiḥ — made of iron pāśaiḥ — with shackles babandha — he bound up (Vasudeva) saha — together with bhāryayā — his wife .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
nivārito nāradena
nivāritaḥ
checked
nāradena
by Nārada
tat-sutau mṛtyum ātmanaḥ
tat - sutau
his two sons
mṛtyum
death
ātmanaḥ
his own
jñātvā loha-mayaiḥ pāśair
jñātvā
understanding
loha - mayaiḥ
made of iron
pāśaiḥ
with shackles
babandha saha bhāryayā
babandha
he bound up (Vasudeva)
saha
together with
bhāryayā
his wife .
  • nivāritaḥ — restrained, checked
    Past participle of ni + √vṛ — to ward off. Nārada plays the protective hand. The same sage who lit demonic fires has lit only the right ones — Vasudeva's life is spared so the narrative can deliver Kṛṣṇa to Mathurā with both parents present.
  • mṛtyum — (as his) death
    Mṛtyu — death personified. Nārada uses the exact word Kaṁsa has heard before, in the celestial prophecy of SB 10.1.34. Reminding him of the prophecy is what stops the sword.
  • loha - mayaiḥ — made of iron
    Loha (iron) + maya (composed of). Kaṁsa returns Vasudeva and Devakī to the dungeon they had been released from. The chains are not symbolic; the Bhāgavatam wants the reader to feel the parents' pain through this re-imprisonment.
  • pāśaiḥ — with chains
    Pāśa — fetter, noose, also the bond of the soul. The same word for Varuṇa's noose and for the bondage of saṁsāra. Vasudeva and Devakī's literal bondage is a figure for the soul's, until Bhagavān comes to break it.
But Nārada restrained Kaṁsa by reminding him that it was the two sons of Vasudeva who would cause his death. Kaṁsa then had Vasudeva and his wife shackled in iron chains.

Kaṁsa realized that there was no use in killing Vasudeva, since it was Vasudeva’s sons, Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma, who were to kill him. According to the ācāryas, Nārada also advised Kaṁsa that if he killed Vasudeva the two young boys might flee and that it was therefore better not to kill him. Rather, Nārada recommended, Kaṁsa should bring Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma to Kaṁsa’s capital city, Mathurā. Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī points out that Nārada did not act inimically toward the great devotees Vasudeva and Devakī when he revealed this information to Kaṁsa. In fact, as explained in the Eleventh Canto, Vasudeva was grateful to Nārada because he was arranging for Kaṁsa’s death at Kṛṣṇa’s hands, and further arranging for Kṛṣṇa to come and live in Mathurā, where His loving father could associate with Him.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
But Nārada restrained Kaṁsa by reminding him that it was the two sons of Vasudeva who would cause his death. Kaṁsa then had Vasudeva and his wife shackled in iron chains.
Commentary

Narada prevented Kamsa from killing Vasudeva by giving the following advice. "If you kill Vasudeva, Krsna and Balarama will flee in terror. Do not reveal to Vasudeva that you want to kill Krsna and Balarama. If you tell him, he will tell his friend Nanda, who will flee with his sons. Therefore on some pretext imprison Vasudeva and Devaki, and bring Krsna and Balarama to Mathura." One should not think that in saying this, Narada was being unkind to Devaki and Vasudeva. Rather, this was a sign of affection. After Krsna and Balarama arrived in Mathura, on seeing their children they gave thanks to Narada. Thus there was no fault in Narada’s suggesting that they be imprisoned.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

“If you kill his father you should expect that he will go into hiding somewhere.” Nārada advised him that, by binding Devakī and Vāsudeva, Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma would come to Mathurā immediately to free them. He also bound Devakī in order to hasten Kṛṣṇa coming, or out of his evil nature.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

Nārada's hand on Kaṁsa's wrist is gentler than a guru's hand on a student's — and it works for the same reason: the truth Kaṁsa already half-knows surfaces just in time. The sword is sheathed, but the parents are chained, and the wheel turns one notch closer to Mathurā.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.20

↗
ప్రతియాతే తు దేవర్షౌ కంస ఆభాష్య కేశినమ్ । ప్రేషయామాస హన్యేతాం భవతా రామకేశవౌ ॥ ౨౦ ॥
pratiyāte tu devarṣau
[pratiyaate tu devarshau]
kaṁsa ābhāṣya keśinam
[kamsa aabhaashya keshinam]
preṣayām āsa hanyetāṁ
[preshayaam aasa hanyetaam]
bhavatā rāma-keśavau
[bhavataa raama-keshavau]
pratiyāte — having left tu — then deva - ṛṣau — the sage among the demigods kaṁsaḥ — King Kaṁsa ābhāṣya — addressing keśinam — the demon Keśī preṣayām āsa — he sent him hanyetām — the two should be killed bhavatā — by you rāma - keśavau — Balarāma and Kṛṣṇa .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
pratiyāte tu devarṣau
pratiyāte
having left
tu
then
deva - ṛṣau
the sage among the demigods
kaṁsa ābhāṣya keśinam
kaṁsaḥ
King Kaṁsa
ābhāṣya
addressing
keśinam
the demon Keśī
preṣayām āsa hanyetāṁ
preṣayām āsa
he sent him
hanyetām
the two should be killed
bhavatā rāma-keśavau
bhavatā
by you
rāma - keśavau
Balarāma and Kṛṣṇa .
  • deva - ṛṣau — the sage among the demigods
    Devarṣi — Nārada's standard title. The compound names his cosmic rank: a ṛṣi who can travel among devas, asuras, and humans alike, carrying news between the three worlds.
  • keśinam — the demon Keśī
    From keśa (mane) — the long-maned horse-demon. He will appear in person in the next chapter (SB 10.37). The Bhāgavatam introduces him here by Kaṁsa's order, foreshadowing across the chapter-break.
  • preṣayām āsa — he sent (Keśī)
    From pra + √iṣ — to send forth. Kaṁsa's verb of choice — he sends. Bhakti is the opposite verb: śaraṇa-gata-rakṣaṇa, taking shelter, not dispatching.
  • rāma - keśavau — Rāma and Keśava (the two)
    Rāma (Balarāma) + Keśava (Kṛṣṇa). Keśava — He of beautiful hair, or He who slays Keśī (post-event etymology). The Bhāgavatam quietly names Kṛṣṇa here by the very title He will earn from killing this horse-demon.
After Nārada left, King Kaṁsa summoned Keśī and ordered him, “Go kill Rāma and Kṛṣṇa.”

Before having Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma brought to Mathurā, Kaṁsa tried sending one more demon to Vṛndāvana.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
After Nārada left, King Kaṁsa summoned Keśī and ordered him, "Go kill Rāma and Kṛṣṇa."
Commentary

Kamsa ordered Kesi, "Go to Vraja and kill them". This statement also means "You should attain them or merge into them (get killed)."

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He gave instructions to Keśī after Nārada left, since he feared that sending Keśī would be breaking Nārada’s instructions or that Nārada would prevent him sending Keśī. He called him (ābhāsya) saying “O my brother! O great warrior!” According to Parāśara and Vaiśampāyana, he gave instructions to Keśī through messengers. He respected Keśī by addressing him as bhavatā. Rāma means he who enjoys in Gokula. Mādhava (instead of keśava) means he who appeared in Madhu’s dynasty. Or the two words mean those two who gave up their friends and enjoy in Gokula. He finds fault with them and does not say their names directly out of hatred. Or since their names are well known he addresses them with disrespect.

Concepts
Jiva

Kaṁsa dispatches Keśī the horse-demon the way a tyrant signs a death-warrant on a passing folder. He does not see that the same hand of Bhagavān has already taken Ariṣṭa; the same hand will receive Keśī. Demonic strategy is the long parade of agents into the same waiting palm.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.21

↗
తతో ముష్టికచాణూరశలతోశలకాదికాన్ । అమాత్యాన్ హస్తిపాంశ్చైవ సమాహూయాహ భోజరాట్ ॥ ౨౧ ॥
tato muṣṭika-cāṇūra
[tato mushtika-chaanoora]
śala-tośalakādikān
[shala-toshalakaadikaan]
amātyān hastipāṁś caiva
[amaatyaan hastipaamsh chaiva]
samāhūyāha bhoja-rāṭ
[samaahooyaaha bhoja-raat]
tataḥ — then muṣṭika - cāṇūra - śala - tośalaka - ādikān — Muṣṭika, Cāṇūra, Śala, Tośala and others amātyān — his ministers hasti - pān — his elephant-keepers ca eva — also samāhūya — calling together āha — spoke bhoja - rāṭ — the King of the Bhojas .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tato muṣṭika-cāṇūra
tataḥ
then
muṣṭika - cāṇūra - śala - tośalaka - ādikān
Muṣṭika, Cāṇūra, Śala, Tośala and others
śala-tośalakādikān
amātyān hastipāṁś caiva
amātyān
his ministers
hasti - pān
his elephant-keepers
ca eva
also
samāhūyāha bhoja-rāṭ
samāhūya
calling together
āha
spoke
bhoja - rāṭ
the King of the Bhojas .
  • muṣṭika - cāṇūra - śala - tośalaka - ādikān — Muṣṭika, Cāṇūra, Śala, Tośala, and others
    The four named wrestlers and their company. Muṣṭika (the fist-fighter) and Cāṇūra (Kaṁsa's champion) will die at Balarāma's and Kṛṣṇa's hands in SB 10.43–44; the list here is a hit-list in reverse.
  • amātyān — his ministers
    Sabhā-courtiers. Mathurā's apparatus of state is named in plural — Kaṁsa rules by committee, but his committee is about to be obsolesced.
  • hasti - pān — elephant-keepers
    Hastin (elephant) + pā (keeper). The mahā-mātras of Kuvalayāpīḍa, the elephant Kṛṣṇa will kill at the arena's gate (SB 10.43).
  • bhoja - rāṭ — King of the Bhojas
    Kaṁsa's tribal title. The Bhojas were the Yadu clan-subgroup he ruled; the Bhāgavatam continually contrasts the bhoja-rāṭ with the eventual yadu-pati (Kṛṣṇa).
The King of the Bhojas next called for his ministers, headed by Muṣṭika, Cāṇūra, Śala and Tośala, and also for his elephant-keepers. The King addressed them as follows.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The King of the Bhojas next called for his ministers, headed by Muṣṭika, Cāṇūra, Śala and Tośala, and also for his elephant-keepers. The King addressed them as follows.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kaṁsa called for his ministers with respect (sam—āhūya) and then engaged them.

Concepts
Jiva

He calls in his cabinet — wrestlers, ministers, the elephant-keeper — the way a man assembles tools for a job already lost. Each name in this verse is a name the Bhāgavatam will spend pleasure rolling up in subsequent chapters.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.22-23

↗
భో భో నిశమ్యతామేతద్ వీరచాణూరముష్టికౌ । నన్దవ్రజే కిలాసాతే సుతావానకదున్దుభే: ॥ ౨౨ ॥ రామకృష్ణౌ తతో మహ్యం మృత్యు: కిల నిదర్శిత: । భవద్‌భ్యామిహ సమ్ప్రాప్తౌ హన్యేతాం మల్లలీలయా ॥ ౨౩ ॥
bho bho niśamyatām etad
[bho bho nishamyataam etad]
vīra-cāṇūra-muṣṭikau
[veera-chaanoora-mushtikau]
nanda-vraje kilāsāte
[nanda-vraje kilaasaate]
sutāv ānakadundubheḥ
[sutaav aanakadundubheh]
rāma-kṛṣṇau tato mahyaṁ
[raama-krishnau tato mahyam]
mṛtyuḥ kila nidarśitaḥ
[mrityuh kila nidarshitah]
bhavadbhyām iha samprāptau
[bhavadbhyaam iha sampraaptau]
hanyetāṁ malla-līlayā
[hanyetaam malla-leelayaa]
bhoḥ bhoḥ — my dear (advisers) niśamyatām — please listen etat — to this vīra — O heroes cāṇūra - muṣṭikau — Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika nanda - vraje — in the cowherd village of Nanda kila — indeed āsāte — are living sutau — the two sons ānakadundubheḥ — of Vasudeva rāma - kṛṣṇau — Rāma and Kṛṣṇa tataḥ — from Them mahyam — my mṛtyuḥ — death kila — indeed nidarśitaḥ — has been indicated bhavadbhyām — by you two iha — here samprāptau — brought hanyetām — They should be killed malla — of wrestling līlayā — on the pretext of the sport .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bho bho niśamyatām etad
bhoḥ bhoḥ
my dear (advisers)
niśamyatām
please listen
etat
to this
vīra-cāṇūra-muṣṭikau
vīra
O heroes
cāṇūra - muṣṭikau
Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika
nanda-vraje kilāsāte
nanda - vraje
in the cowherd village of Nanda
kila
indeed
āsāte
are living
sutāv ānakadundubheḥ
sutau
the two sons
ānakadundubheḥ
of Vasudeva
rāma-kṛṣṇau tato mahyaṁ
rāma - kṛṣṇau
Rāma and Kṛṣṇa
tataḥ
from Them
mahyam
my
mṛtyuḥ kila nidarśitaḥ
mṛtyuḥ
death
kila
indeed
nidarśitaḥ
has been indicated
bhavadbhyām iha samprāptau
bhavadbhyām
by you two
iha
here
samprāptau
brought
hanyetāṁ malla-līlayā
hanyetām
They should be killed
malla
of wrestling
līlayā
on the pretext of the sport .
  • cāṇūra - muṣṭikau — Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika (dual)
    Kaṁsa addresses his two top wrestlers in the dual — the very form in which they will die, paired, at Kṛṣṇa's and Balarāma's hands in the arena.
  • nanda - vraje — in the cowherd village of Nanda
    Nanda-Vraja — Mahārāja Nanda's cowherd settlement. Kaṁsa, the asura, names the most sacred place in Gauḍīya cosmography matter-of-factly as a location to send killers to.
  • ānakadundubheḥ — of Ānakadundubhi (Vasudeva)
    Vasudeva's epithet — at his birth, divine drums sounded (ānaka-dundubhi). The name marks Vasudeva as the prophesied father of the avatāra; Kaṁsa uses the name because it is etched in his fear.
  • rāma - kṛṣṇau — Rāma and Kṛṣṇa (dual)
    Always paired in this chapter as a unit. Gauḍīya theology: never separate them — Balarāma is Kṛṣṇa's ādi-rūpa, His first expansion, in every līlā beside Him.
  • malla - līlayā — on the pretext of wrestling play
    Malla (wrestler) + līlā (play). Tragic irony: Kaṁsa uses the word līlā for his murder-plot, not knowing that what he is staging will indeed be līlā — but Kṛṣṇa's, not his.
My dear heroic Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika, please hear this. Rāma and Kṛṣṇa, the sons of Ānakadundubhi [Vasudeva], are living in Nanda’s cowherd village. It has been predicted that these two boys will be the cause of my death. When They are brought here, kill Them on the pretext of engaging Them in a wrestling match.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
My dear heroic Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika, please hear this. Rāma and Kṛṣṇa, the sons of Ānakadundubhi [Vasudeva], are living in Nanda's cowherd village. It has been predicted that these two boys will be the cause of my death. When They are brought here, kill Them on the pretext of engaging Them in a wrestling match.
Commentary

My death has been indicated by Narada (nidarsinta).

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He repeats the words bho bho so that they pay attention. Cāṇūra and Muṣṭika were his main ministers so he addresses them. He calls them courageous (vīra) to incite them. The singular form (vīra) is approved by Śrīdhara Svāmī. The plural form vīrāḥ is also seen. O courageous warriors! O Cānūra! O Muṣṭika! Kila means certainly. The statement is supported by Nārada’s words. Nārada had told Kaṁsa about the arrangements before the birth of Kṛṣṇa. “Nārada has said that I will certainly (kila) die because of these two. They should be brought here since in Vraja you will not be able to kill them because of the strength of the place. Kill them through a wrestling match. Otherwise it will be impossible to kill them.” There is another meaning however. They should be brought here (hanyatām).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses

The wrestling-match is the demon's idea of a clever frame: kill the boys in public, on a pretext, with cheering crowds. He has no idea the same crowd will become the audience that recognizes Kṛṣṇa as the original wrestler-warrior. His plot is the stage Bhagavān asked for.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.24

↗
మఞ్చా: క్రియన్తాం వివిధా మల్లరఙ్గపరిశ్రితా: । పౌరా జానపదా: సర్వే పశ్యన్తు స్వైరసంయుగమ్ ॥ ౨౪ ॥
mañcāḥ kriyantāṁ vividhā
[manchaah kriyantaam vividhaa]
malla-raṅga-pariśritāḥ
[malla-ranga-parishritaah]
paurā jānapadāḥ sarve
[pauraa jaanapadaah sarve]
paśyantu svaira-saṁyugam
[pashyantu svaira-samyugam]
mancāḥ — stages kriyantām — should be built vividhāḥ — various malla - raṅga — a wrestling ring pariśritāḥ — surrounding paurāḥ — the residents of the city jānapadāḥ — and the residents of the outlying districts sarve — all paśyantu — should see svaira — voluntarily participated in saṁyugam — the competition .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
mañcāḥ kriyantāṁ vividhā
mancāḥ
stages
kriyantām
should be built
vividhāḥ
various
malla-raṅga-pariśritāḥ
malla - raṅga
a wrestling ring
pariśritāḥ
surrounding
paurā jānapadāḥ sarve
paurāḥ
the residents of the city
jānapadāḥ
and the residents of the outlying districts
sarve
all
paśyantu svaira-saṁyugam
paśyantu
should see
svaira
voluntarily participated in
saṁyugam
the competition .
  • mancāḥ — viewing stands, platforms
    Tiered seats around the arena. The Bhāgavatam carefully names the structure — Mathurā becomes a public theater, and Kṛṣṇa-darśana becomes a city-wide event in chapters 42–43.
  • malla - raṅga — wrestling arena
    Malla (wrestler) + raṅga (stage). The akhāḍā in the center of Mathurā that will become the place of Kaṁsa's death. Kaṁsa builds his own execution-ground.
  • paurāḥ — the citizens
    City-dwellers of Mathurā. They become a major character in their own right in 10.41 when Kṛṣṇa enters the city and they crowd the rooftops; this verse seeds that scene.
  • saṁyugam — the combat
    Sam + yuga (joining) — battle. The same root used in Gītā 1.1 (dharma-kṣetre kuru-kṣetre samavetā yuyutsavaḥ). Kaṁsa is staging a yuga of his own; he will lose it.
Erect a wrestling ring with many surrounding viewing stands, and bring all the residents of the city and the outlying districts to see the open competition.

The word mañcāḥ refers to platforms constructed with large pillars. Kaṁsa wanted a festive atmosphere so that Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma would not be afraid to come.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Erect a wrestling ring with many surrounding viewing stands, and bring all the residents of the city and the outlying districts to see the open competition.
Commentary

In order to fool Krsna and Balarama, and to increase the enthusiasm to fight, make a huge festive competition. Otherwise they will flee."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

To fool them you should arrange a festival with many pavilions, of different types suitable for the kings and ministers, which will surround the wrestling arena. By this, the city people and people from other places will see the contest which is not arranged by force but free will. Inviting everyone was another way of disguising his motives.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Prema (Divine Love)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Build a stadium, sell the tickets, fill every seat — and then bring the two cowherd boys into the middle. Kaṁsa is constructing his own dharma-kṣetra without knowing it. The crowd he summons to witness murder will witness avatāra instead.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.25

↗
మహామాత్ర త్వయా భద్ర రఙ్గద్వార్యుపనీయతామ్ । ద్విప: కువలయాపీడో జహి తేన మమాహితౌ ॥ ౨౫ ॥
mahāmātra tvayā bhadra
[mahaamaatra tvayaa bhadra]
raṅga-dvāry upanīyatām
[ranga-dvaary upaneeyataam]
dvipaḥ kuvalayāpīḍo
[dvipah kuvalayaapeedo]
jahi tena mamāhitau
[jahi tena mamaahitau]
mahā - mātra — O elephant-keeper tvayā — by you bhadra — my good man raṅga — of the arena dvāri — to the doorway upanīyatām — should be brought dvipaḥ — the elephant kuvalayāpīḍaḥ — named Kuvalayāpīḍa jahi — destroy tena — with that (elephant) mama — my ahitau — enemies .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
mahāmātra tvayā bhadra
mahā - mātra
O elephant-keeper
tvayā
by you
bhadra
my good man
raṅga-dvāry upanīyatām
raṅga
of the arena
dvāri
to the doorway
upanīyatām
should be brought
dvipaḥ kuvalayāpīḍo
dvipaḥ
the elephant
kuvalayāpīḍaḥ
named Kuvalayāpīḍa
jahi tena mamāhitau
jahi
destroy
tena
with that (elephant)
mama
my
ahitau
enemies .
  • mahā - mātra — great elephant-keeper
    Mahā (great) + mātra (one who measures, drives). The driver of Kuvalayāpīḍa, named for his rank. He, his elephant, and the gate all enter the Bhāgavatam's permanent vocabulary of Kṛṣṇa's Mathurā entry.
  • kuvalayāpīḍaḥ — Kuvalayāpīḍa (the royal elephant)
    Kuvalaya (water-lily, or the whole world) + āpīḍa (crusher) — 'world-crusher.' He will be killed at the arena's gate; his tusk will become Kṛṣṇa's weapon for the wrestlers.
  • raṅga - dvāri — at the doorway of the arena
    Raṅga (arena) + dvāra (door). The threshold of the stadium is named — this exact threshold is where Kṛṣṇa will dismount the chariot and meet the elephant in 10.43.4.
  • ahitau — my two enemies (the dual)
    A (not) + hita (well-wisher) — the unfriendly. Kaṁsa names Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma as a-hita. From the Gauḍīya side, the most beneficial pair in the universe are labeled by him as the most harmful — perfect inversion.
You, elephant-keeper, my good man, should position the elephant Kuvalayāpīḍa at the entrance to the wrestling arena and have him kill my two enemies.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
You, elephant-keeper, my good man, should position the elephant Kuvalayāpīḍa at the entrance to the wrestling arena and have him kill my two enemies.
Commentary

O elephant keeper, place Kuvalayapida at the entrance of the arena in order that he kill my enemies, those who are not beneficial to me (ahitau).

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He thought that he would please his dear wrestlers by exhausting Kṛṣṇa through a fight with the mad elephant. Internally however he was frightened. O skillful one (bhadra)! By this he encourages the elephant keeper. He tells the keeper what he has personally heard from Nārada about his own birth to incite him. According to Hari-vaṁśa the demon Drumila, king of Saubha, disguised himself as Ugrasena and bore Kaṁsa through Ugrasena’s wife. Bring Kṛṣṇa near the gate. It was the custom to have the king’s riding elephants near the gate. Kaṁsa’s real intention was that because it was a narrow place it would be easy to kill Kṛṣṇa there. Jāhi also means “bring him there.”

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses

Park the elephant at the gate, the king instructs — as if the gate of Mathurā could ever again be merely a gate after Kṛṣṇa walks through it. Each step of his plan adds a prop to the very stage of the līlā.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.26

↗
ఆరభ్యతాం ధనుర్యాగశ్చతుర్దశ్యాం యథావిధి । విశసన్తు పశూన్మేధ్యాన్ భూతరాజాయ మీఢుషే ॥ ౨౬ ॥
ārabhyatāṁ dhanur-yāgaś
[aarabhyataam dhanur-yaagash]
caturdaśyāṁ yathā-vidhi
[chaturdashyaam yathaa-vidhi]
viśasantu paśūn medhyān
[vishasantu pashoon medhyaan]
bhūta-rājāya mīḍhuṣe
[bhoota-raajaaya meedhushe]
ārabhyatām — should be commenced dhanuḥ - yāgaḥ — the bow sacrifice caturdaśyām — on the fourteenth day of the month yathā - vidhi — in accordance with Vedic injunctions viśasantu — offer in sacrifice paśūn — animals medhyān — which are fit to be offered bhūta - rājāya — to Lord Śiva, the lord of ghostly spirits mīḍhuṣe — the giver of benedictions .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ārabhyatāṁ dhanur-yāgaś
ārabhyatām
should be commenced
dhanuḥ - yāgaḥ
the bow sacrifice
caturdaśyāṁ yathā-vidhi
caturdaśyām
on the fourteenth day of the month
yathā - vidhi
in accordance with Vedic injunctions
viśasantu
offer in sacrifice
viśasantu paśūn medhyān
paśūn
animals
medhyān
which are fit to be offered
bhūta-rājāya mīḍhuṣe
bhūta - rājāya
to Lord Śiva, the lord of ghostly spirits
mīḍhuṣe
the giver of benedictions .
  • dhanuḥ - yāgaḥ — the bow sacrifice
    Dhanus (bow) + yāga (sacrifice). A royal Śaiva rite involving the worship of a sacred bow. The huge bow at this sacrifice is the bow Kṛṣṇa will break with one foot in SB 10.42, signaling Mathurā's true ruler.
  • caturdaśyām — on the fourteenth lunar day
    Caturdaśī — the fourteenth tithi. The traditional day for Śaiva worship. Kaṁsa is fixing the date; the date itself becomes the trigger of the avatāra's Mathurā-entry.
  • bhūta - rājāya — to the Lord of beings (Śiva)
    Bhūta (beings, ghosts) + rāja (king). Lord Śiva. Kaṁsa worships Śiva for personal protection — Gauḍīyas note: worship of any deva turned away from Viṣṇu-bhakti collapses into self-interest.
  • paśūn — (sacrificial) animals
    Paśu — animal, also the unsurrendered jīva in tantric vocabulary. The ritual slaughter Kaṁsa orders is itself the marker of his demonic mode: yajña reduced to harm.
Commence the bow sacrifice on the Caturdaśī day in accordance with the relevant Vedic injunctions. In ritual slaughter offer the appropriate kinds of animals to the magnanimous Lord Śiva.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Commence the bow sacrifice on the Caturdaśī day in accordance with the relevant Vedic injunctions. In ritual slaughter offer the appropriate kinds of animals to the magnanimous Lord Śiva.
Commentary

For my prosperity, cut up some goats in order to please the lord of living entities.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

We should not only use material means. We should use supernatural means also to lure them. The two should be brought on the occasion of a spiritual festival, on the pretext of seeing wrestling matches. Śiva was the protector of Mathurā and the bow and very generous (mīḍhuṣe). Mīḍhuṣe means “unto Śiva who gives satisfaction by bestowing boons.” This is also a statement made out of fear.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

We should not only use material means. We should use supernatural means also to lure them. The two should be brought on the occasion of a spiritual festival, on the pretext of seeing a wrestling matches. Śiva was the protector of Mathurā and the bow and he was very generous (mīḍhuṣe). Mīḍhuṣe means “unto Śiva who gives satisfaction by bestowing boons.” This is also a statement made out of fear.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Dana (Charity / Generosity)Prema (Divine Love)Svadhyaya (Self-study & Scripture Study)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

The bow-sacrifice on the Caturdaśī, animals offered to Lord Śiva — Kaṁsa wraps his murder-plan in proper ritual etiquette, an asura's love for the form of yajña without its essence. The Bhāgavatam shows the trap: yajña without bhakti is just decorated cruelty.

Dakṣa's headless yajña

In SB 4.2–7 Dakṣa performed a magnificent Vedic sacrifice, perfectly correct in every external detail, yet refused to include Lord Śiva and Satī. The yajña was destroyed; Dakṣa lost his head and was restored only after surrendering to Śiva.

Kaṁsa now plans a śaiva-yāga to legitimate his killing of Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma. The pattern is the same — flawless ritual surface concealing offense against the Lord and His own. The Bhāgavatam knows this template by heart.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.27

↗
ఇత్యాజ్ఞాప్యార్థతన్త్రజ్ఞ ఆహూయ యదుపుఙ్గవమ్ । గృహీత్వా పాణినా పాణిం తతోఽక్రూరమువాచ హ ॥ ౨౭ ॥
ity ājñāpyārtha-tantra-jña
[ity aajnaapyaartha-tantra-jna]
āhūya yadu-puṅgavam
[aahooya yadu-pungavam]
gṛhītvā pāṇinā pāṇiṁ
[griheetvaa paaninaa paanim]
tato ’krūram uvāca ha
[tato ’krooram uvaacha ha]
iti — with these words ājñāpya — ordering artha — of personal interest and advantage tantra — of the doctrine jñaḥ — the knower āhūya — calling for yadu - puṅgavam — the most eminent of the Yadus gṛhītvā — taking pāṇinā — with his own hand pāṇim — his hand tataḥ — then akrūram — to Akrūra uvāca ha — he said .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ity ājñāpyārtha-tantra-jña
iti
with these words
ājñāpya
ordering
artha
of personal interest and advantage
tantra
of the doctrine
jñaḥ
the knower
āhūya yadu-puṅgavam
āhūya
calling for
yadu - puṅgavam
the most eminent of the Yadus
gṛhītvā pāṇinā pāṇiṁ
gṛhītvā
taking
pāṇinā
with his own hand
pāṇim
his hand
tato ’krūram uvāca ha
tataḥ
then
akrūram
to Akrūra
uvāca ha
he said .
  • artha - tantra - jñaḥ — knower of the science of self-interest
    Artha (purpose, gain) + tantra (system, science) + jñā (knower). Kaṁsa is named as a master of the artha-śāstra — political calculation. The Bhāgavatam quietly contrasts him with Akrūra, who is about to act outside this calculus.
  • akrūram — Akrūra
    A (not) + krūra (cruel) — 'the non-cruel one.' He is named for the opposite of Kaṁsa's whole disposition. Gauḍīya tradition reveres Akrūra as a great devotee and the chariot-driver who carried the Lord out of Vraja.
  • yadu - puṅgavam — best of the Yadus
    Yadu (the Yadu clan) + puṅgava (bull, foremost). Akrūra is the foremost Yadu, the same lineage from which Kṛṣṇa Himself takes birth. Kaṁsa is sending a Yadu to bring two more Yadus — his own kinsmen executing his fall.
  • pāṇim — (his) hand
    The hand-taking gesture (pāṇi-grahaṇa) is the language of intimate trust — used in marriage, in friendship-pacts. Kaṁsa imitates the form to extract Akrūra's cooperation; the Bhāgavatam wants the reader to feel the hollowness.
Having thus commanded his ministers, Kaṁsa next called for Akrūra, the most eminent of the Yadus. Kaṁsa knew the art of securing personal advantage, and thus he took Akrūra’s hand in his own and spoke to him as follows.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Having thus commanded his ministers, Kaṁsa next called for Akrūra, the most eminent of the Yadus. Kaṁsa knew the art of securing personal advantage, and thus he took Akrūra's hand in his own and spoke to him as follows.
Commentary

Kamsa was knowledgeable of artha sastra. That means he knew all about artha and kama, but not dharma and moksa.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kaṁsa knew the conclusions (tantra) about artha, material benefits, or the scriptures concerning them, but not the scriptures about dharma. Akūra was the most trustworthy of the Yadus (yadu-puṅgavam). Therefore he was suitable to go. He called him, not because he was Kaṁsa’s man, but because Akrūra could deliberate on matters skillfully. He held Akrūra’s hand to show affection and to make sure that he would not tell others what he would say. He spoke to him among his own people, not others (tataḥ or tatra). Ha means he spoke clearly.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Svadhyaya (Self-study & Scripture Study)Guru Bhakti (Reverence for Teacher)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Nishkama Karma (Selfless Action)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)
Related verses
Concepts
JivaDharma

Kaṁsa takes Akrūra's hand in his own — the very gesture of friendship, performed by a man whose every other gesture is murder. Bhakti's tragedy and comedy both: Akrūra, who lives inwardly already as Kṛṣṇa's devotee, is now to be sent on the perfect errand by the perfect enemy.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.28

↗
భో భో దానపతే మహ్యం క్రియతాం మైత్రమాద‍ృత: । నాన్యస్త్వత్తో హితతమో విద్యతే భోజవృష్ణిషు ॥ ౨౮ ॥
bho bho dāna-pate mahyaṁ
[bho bho daana-pate mahyam]
kriyatāṁ maitram ādṛtaḥ
[kriyataam maitram aadritah]
nānyas tvatto hitatamo
[naanyas tvatto hitatamo]
vidyate bhoja-vṛṣṇiṣu
[vidyate bhoja-vrishnishu]
bhoḥ bhoḥ — my dear dāna — of charity pate — master mahyam — for me kriyatām — please do maitram — a friendly favor ādṛtaḥ — out of respect na — none anyaḥ — other tvattaḥ — than yourself hita - tamaḥ — who acts most favorably vidyate — exists bhoja - vṛṣṇiṣu — among the Bhojas and Vṛṣṇis .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bho bho dāna-pate mahyaṁ
bhoḥ bhoḥ
my dear
dāna
of charity
pate
master
mahyam
for me
kriyatāṁ maitram ādṛtaḥ
kriyatām
please do
maitram
a friendly favor
ādṛtaḥ
out of respect
nānyas tvatto hitatamo
na
none
anyaḥ
other
tvattaḥ
than yourself
hita - tamaḥ
who acts most favorably
vidyate bhoja-vṛṣṇiṣu
vidyate
exists
bhoja - vṛṣṇiṣu
among the Bhojas and Vṛṣṇis .
  • dāna - pate — O master of charity
    Dāna (charity) + pati (master). Akrūra's lineage of giving — he is famed as a great dānī. Kaṁsa praises him for the very virtue Kaṁsa lacks, in order to use it.
  • maitram — a friendly favor
    From mitra (friend). The mitra-bhāva Kaṁsa asks for is, in the bhakti-rasa-śāstra, the foundation of sakhya-bhakti — but applied here in mockery, between conspirators. The word resonates against its rasa-meaning.
  • bhoja - vṛṣṇiṣu — among the Bhojas and Vṛṣṇis
    Bhoja (Kaṁsa's clan) + Vṛṣṇi (Vasudeva-Akrūra's clan). Both branches of the Yadus. Kaṁsa names the family-spectrum across which he is asking Akrūra to act.
  • hita - tamaḥ — the most well-wishing
    Hita (beneficial) + superlative -tama. The same root that gave a-hita in verse 25 (where Kaṁsa named Kṛṣṇa-Balarāma as his enemies). The word-pair brackets the chapter: Kaṁsa labels people who help him with hita and people who threaten him with ahita — a moral grammar built entirely around his own survival.
My dear Akrūra, most charitable one, please do me a friendly favor out of respect. Among the Bhojas and Vṛṣṇis, there is no one else as kind to us as you.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
My dear Akrūra, most charitable one, please do me a friendly favor out of respect. Among the Bhojas and Vṛṣṇis, there is no one else as kind to us as you.
Commentary

In order to please me, undertake this action easy for a friend to do.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kaṁsa repeats bho bho out of respect. O best of the generous (dāna-pate)! You must do something for my benefit! You should do what is worthy of a friend. “O king of the Bhojas! Why do you send me?” You are the order bearer among all the Yadus. I respect you.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

Kaṁsa flatters Akrūra as 'most charitable, most kind' — accurate adjectives, used cynically. The asura's mode is to manipulate the genuine virtues of devotees toward his ends; the līlā permits this because the manipulation will deliver Akrūra exactly where his heart already wants to go.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.29

↗
అతస్త్వామాశ్రిత: సౌమ్య కార్యగౌరవసాధనమ్ । యథేన్ద్రో విష్ణుమాశ్రిత్య స్వార్థమధ్యగమద్ విభు: ॥ ౨౯ ॥
atas tvām āśritaḥ saumya
[atas tvaam aashritah saumya]
kārya-gaurava-sādhanam
[kaarya-gaurava-saadhanam]
yathendro viṣṇum āśritya
[yathendro vishnum aashritya]
svārtham adhyagamad vibhuḥ
[svaartham adhyagamad vibhuh]
ataḥ — therefore tvām — on you āśritaḥ — (I am) depending saumya — O gentle one kārya — prescribed duties gaurava — soberly sādhanam — who executes yathā — as similarly indraḥ — Indra viṣṇum — Lord Viṣṇu āśritya — taking shelter of sva - artham — his goals adhyagamat — achieved vibhuḥ — the powerful King of heaven .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
atas tvām āśritaḥ saumya
ataḥ
therefore
tvām
on you
āśritaḥ
(I am) depending
saumya
O gentle one
kārya-gaurava-sādhanam
kārya
prescribed duties
gaurava
soberly
sādhanam
who executes
yathendro viṣṇum āśritya
yathā
as similarly
indraḥ
Indra
viṣṇum
Lord Viṣṇu
āśritya
taking shelter of
svārtham adhyagamad vibhuḥ
sva - artham
his goals
adhyagamat
achieved
vibhuḥ
the powerful King of heaven .
  • āśritaḥ — having taken shelter, depending
    Past participle of ā + √śri — to take shelter. Kaṁsa uses śaraṇāgati's vocabulary instrumentally; for Gauḍīyas the word is sacred — it is what Bhagavad-gītā 18.66 asks for.
  • saumya — O gentle one
    Soma-like — cool, mild. The address fits Akrūra exactly. Kaṁsa unintentionally names Akrūra's true mood — the one that will, on the road to Mathurā, dissolve into Kṛṣṇa-prema.
  • viṣṇum — Lord Viṣṇu
    Viṣṇu — the all-pervading Lord. Kaṁsa names Viṣṇu out loud in his own throne-room. Gauḍīya theology: the very name on demonic lips carries protective force; Kaṁsa is killed by Kṛṣṇa partly because he could not stop saying His names.
  • sva - artham — his own purpose
    Sva (own) + artha (interest, purpose). Indra's purpose was kingdom; Kaṁsa's, the same. The Bhāgavatam notes the parity of motives — and the radical difference of outcomes when one motive (Indra's) is finally placed before Viṣṇu and the other (Kaṁsa's) is held against Him.
Gentle Akrūra, you always carry out your duties soberly, and therefore I am depending on you, just as powerful Indra took shelter of Lord Viṣṇu to achieve his goals.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Gentle Akrūra, you always carry out your duties soberly, and therefore I am depending on you, just as powerful Indra took shelter of Lord Viṣṇu to achieve his goals.
Commentary

I have come to you because you can execute the task most perfectly.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

O peaceful Akrūra! He addresses him to give to encourage him. I take shelter of you since you are my friend and you are peaceful. “For what purpose do you take shelter of me?” I take shelter to accomplish an important task. “You are capable of doing everything yourself. Why do you need me?” That is true, but even if I am capable, the work will succeed with assistance. He gives an example. Though Indra was capable (vibhuḥ), he took shelter of Viṣṇu to achieve his goals. He indicates that Viṣṇu is inferior to Indra, since he hated Viṣṇu.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Dhriti (Resilience / Steadfastness / Fortitude)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Mardava (Gentleness)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Achapalya (Steadiness / Non-fickleness)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)Atma Nigraha (Self-control)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Kaṁsa names a precedent for his request: Indra took shelter of Viṣṇu to win his ends. The example is exact — and entirely against him. The same Viṣṇu whose shelter Indra took is now embodied in the boy Kaṁsa is sending Akrūra to fetch. He cites the very Lord he means to kill.

Indra at Viṣṇu's feet

Throughout the Purāṇas — including the churning of the milk ocean in SB 8.5–9 — Indra repeatedly loses his kingdom and recovers it only by surrendering at Viṣṇu's lotus feet. Kaṁsa selects this very pattern as his rhetorical model.

Gauḍīya commentators relish the irony: Kaṁsa unconsciously names the doctrine of śaraṇāgati to the one devotee in the room who will, three chapters from now (SB 10.38–40), actually perform it — Akrūra's vision of Kṛṣṇa in the Yamunā is the chapter's true destination.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.30

↗
గచ్ఛ నన్దవ్రజం తత్ర సుతావానకదున్దుభే: । ఆసాతే తావిహానేన రథేనానయ మా చిరమ్ ॥ ౩౦ ॥
gaccha nanda-vrajaṁ tatra
[gachcha nanda-vrajam tatra]
sutāv ānakadundubheḥ
[sutaav aanakadundubheh]
āsāte tāv ihānena
[aasaate taav ihaanena]
rathenānaya mā ciram
[rathenaanaya maa chiram]
gaccha — go nanda - vrajam — to the cowherd village of Nanda tatra — there sutau — the two sons ānakadundubheḥ — of Vasudeva āsāte — are living tau — Them iha — here anena — by this rathena — chariot ānaya — bring mā ciram — without delay .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
gaccha nanda-vrajaṁ tatra
gaccha
go
nanda - vrajam
to the cowherd village of Nanda
tatra
there
sutāv ānakadundubheḥ
sutau
the two sons
ānakadundubheḥ
of Vasudeva
āsāte tāv ihānena
āsāte
are living
tau
Them
iha
here
anena
by this
rathenānaya mā ciram
rathena
chariot
ānaya
bring
mā ciram
without delay .
  • nanda - vrajam — to Nanda's cowherd village
    Nanda + vraja. The same compound used in verse 22; the Bhāgavatam keeps naming the destination as belonging to Nanda — a quiet sovereignty-claim by vātsalya-rasa. Even Kaṁsa cannot speak of Vraja without naming Nanda.
  • sutau — the two sons
    Dual of suta — the two boys. Always the dual: Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma. The pair is so welded in narrative that Kaṁsa's order necessarily covers both.
  • rathena — by chariot
    Ratha — chariot. Gauḍīya tradition reads the ratha here as the vehicle of bhakti itself — Akrūra's chariot will carry the Lord, but only because the driver's mind already does.
  • mā ciram — without delay
    Mā (do not) + ciram (long time). 'Hurry.' Kaṁsa's anxiety in two syllables. He cannot bear the prophecy unresolved one more day; his own hurry delivers Bhagavān to his arena.
Please go to Nanda’s village, where the two sons of Ānakadundubhi are living, and without delay bring Them here on this chariot.

Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī gives the following interesting note: “When King Kaṁsa said ‘with this chariot,’ he pointed with his index finger to a brand-new, attractive chariot. Kaṁsa thought that since Akrūra was innocent by nature, when he saw this fine, new vehicle he would naturally want to drive it and quickly bring the two boys back. But the actual reason Akrūra went on a new chariot was that it would have been clearly inappropriate for the Supreme Personality of Godhead to mount a chariot that had already been enjoyed by the wicked Kaṁsa.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Please go to Nanda's village, where the two sons of Ānakadundubhi are living, and without delay bring Them here on this chariot.
Commentary

Pointing with his finger at the new chariot, Kamsa said, "Seeing the new astonishing chariot the young boys will readily sit in it." Akrura took the new chariot, thinking that it would be unsuitable to bring the Lord in something used previously by Kamsa.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Having encouraged Akrūra, Kaṁsa states the mission. They are in Vraja and have not fled elsewhere. Bring them in this chariot (anena), newly constructed and profusely ornamented. Kaṁsa gave his own chariot to show special favor to him. Seeing the new, beautiful chariot, the two children will happy mount it by their own without delay. Actually it was by the will of the Lord that nice arrangements were made for his welcome to Mathurā.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Dhriti (Resilience / Steadfastness / Fortitude)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Mardava (Gentleness)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Achapalya (Steadiness / Non-fickleness)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

'Go fetch the two boys on this chariot.' Said as a simple errand. But the chariot to Vraja is, in Gauḍīya memory, the chariot of separation — the one on which Kṛṣṇa will leave Vṛndāvana, the wheels of which still mark Akrūra's tīrtha on the bank of the Yamunā.

The chariot at Akrūra-ghāṭa

In SB 10.39, Akrūra drives this very chariot to Nanda's village, takes Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma on board, and on the road bathes in the Yamunā — where he beholds the Lord both on the chariot and within the water, his lifelong meditation fulfilled.

The Six Gosvāmīs identified Akrūra-ghāṭa on the Yamunā near Vṛndāvana; pilgrims still visit. The chariot Kaṁsa is dispatching here is the same wood that carries the Bhāgavatam's quiet center.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.31

↗
నిసృష్ట: కిల మే మృత్యుర్దేవైర్వైకుణ్ఠసంశ్రయై: । తావానయ సమం గోపైర్నన్దాద్యై: సాభ్యుపాయనై: ॥ ౩౧ ॥
nisṛṣṭaḥ kila me mṛtyur
[nisrishtah kila me mrityur]
devair vaikuṇṭha-saṁśrayaiḥ
[devair vaikuntha-samshrayaih]
tāv ānaya samaṁ gopair
[taav aanaya samam gopair]
nandādyaiḥ sābhyupāyanaiḥ
[nandaadyaih saabhyupaayanaih]
nisṛṣṭaḥ — sent kila — indeed me — my mṛtyuḥ — death devaiḥ — by the demigods vaikuṇṭha — of Lord Viṣṇu saṁśrayaiḥ — who take shelter tau — the two of Them ānaya — bring samam — together with gopaiḥ — the cowherd men nanda - ādyaiḥ — headed by Nanda sa — with abhyupāyanaiḥ — gifts .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
nisṛṣṭaḥ kila me mṛtyur
nisṛṣṭaḥ
sent
kila
indeed
me
my
mṛtyuḥ
death
devair vaikuṇṭha-saṁśrayaiḥ
devaiḥ
by the demigods
vaikuṇṭha
of Lord Viṣṇu
saṁśrayaiḥ
who take shelter
tāv ānaya samaṁ gopair
tau
the two of Them
ānaya
bring
samam
together with
gopaiḥ
the cowherd men
nandādyaiḥ sābhyupāyanaiḥ
nanda - ādyaiḥ
headed by Nanda
sa
with
abhyupāyanaiḥ
gifts .
  • mṛtyuḥ — (my) death
    Mṛtyu — death. Kaṁsa accepts the prophecy verbatim. He will not deny it; he will only try to outmaneuver it. The Bhāgavatam's diagnosis: false confidence in one's own will against destined Bhagavān.
  • devaiḥ — by the demigods
    The same devas whom Kaṁsa displaced from svarga. The Bhāgavatam frames the avatāra-purpose throughout this canto as paritrāṇa of these devas — a relief that arrives through the children of Vasudeva.
  • vaikuṇṭha - saṁśrayaiḥ — by those sheltered by Vaikuṇṭha (Viṣṇu)
    Vaikuṇṭha (the place of no anxiety) + saṁśraya (taking refuge). Kaṁsa names the devotional doctrine — refuge in Vaikuṇṭha — as the operating principle behind the demigods' attack on him.
  • abhyupāyanaiḥ — with gifts of tribute
    Abhi + upāyana (a gift offered with approach). The cowherds are to bring gifts — Kaṁsa wants the appearance of vassalage. The Bhāgavatam notes how a demon stages dharma's outer form to mask adharma's act.
The demigods, who are under the protection of Viṣṇu, have sent these two boys as my death. Bring Them here, and also have Nanda and the other cowherd men come with gifts of tribute.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The demigods, who are under the protection of Viṣṇu, have sent these two boys as my death. Bring Them here, and also have Nanda and the other cowherd men come with gifts of tribute.
Commentary

My death ( the two boys) has been created inescapably by the devatas who take shelter of Visnu.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He states the purpose in two verses. Of the two one will kill me. What can I do, since death (one of them) has been sent by the devatās protected by Viṣṇu. Bring both of them, since the effort is the same. In order to make Akrūra go, Kaṁsa hides the fact that the two are actually non-different from Viṣṇu. Also bring Nanda and others. Kaṁsa feared that they would not come unprotected. His hidden, evil intention was also to cause problems for Nanda and the rest. They should also bring ghee and yogurt. In this way they would believe that the sacrifice for the bow would actually take place.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)
Related verses

He admits aloud that the demigods, sheltered by Viṣṇu, have sent these boys as his death. Kaṁsa's intelligence is unimpaired; only his will is. He sees the whole picture and walks straight into it — vidveṣa-bhakti's dark mirror.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.32

↗
ఘాతయిష్య ఇహానీతౌ కాలకల్పేన హస్తినా । యది ముక్తౌ తతో మల్లైర్ఘాతయే వైద్యుతోపమై: ॥ ౩౨ ॥
ghātayiṣya ihānītau
[ghaatayishya ihaaneetau]
kāla-kalpena hastinā
[kaala-kalpena hastinaa]
yadi muktau tato mallair
[yadi muktau tato mallair]
ghātaye vaidyutopamaiḥ
[ghaataye vaidyutopamaih]
ghātayiṣye — I shall have Them killed iha — here ānītau — brought kāla - kalpena — like death itself hastinā — by the elephant yadi — if muktau — They go free tataḥ — then mallaiḥ — by wrestlers ghātaye — I will have killed vaidyuta — lightning upamaiḥ — just like .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ghātayiṣya ihānītau
ghātayiṣye
I shall have Them killed
iha
here
ānītau
brought
kāla-kalpena hastinā
kāla - kalpena
like death itself
hastinā
by the elephant
yadi muktau tato mallair
yadi
if
muktau
They go free
tataḥ
then
mallaiḥ
by wrestlers
ghātaye vaidyutopamaiḥ
ghātaye
I will have killed
vaidyuta
lightning
upamaiḥ
just like .
  • ghātayiṣye — I shall have (Them) killed
    Causative future of √han (to kill). Kaṁsa makes himself a remote cause — he will have it done, not do it. Even his violence is delegated; the only thing in his palace that is direct is the truth Nārada brought.
  • kāla - kalpena — like time itself, like death itself
    Kāla (time) + kalpa (resembling). The elephant compared to Kāla, devourer. Yet in five chapters Kṛṣṇa kills Kāla-like Kuvalayāpīḍa with a single twist of the tusk — Kṛṣṇa is the kāla of Kāla (kāla-kālaḥ).
  • hastinā — by the elephant
    Hastin — elephant. The kingly weapon. Mathurā's signature instrument of state-power, deployed at the arena-gate.
  • vaidyuta - upamaiḥ — comparable to lightning
    Vaidyuta (lightning) + upamā (likeness). The wrestlers' strength is named with Indra's weapon-image again — same image as verse 10's thunderbolt. The Bhāgavatam keeps recycling Indra-similes for Kṛṣṇa's opponents, since Indra Himself was already conquered at Govardhana.
After you bring Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma, I will have Them killed by my elephant, who is as powerful as death itself. And if by chance They escape from him, I will have Them killed by my wrestlers, who are as strong as lightning.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
After you bring Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma, I will have Them killed by my elephant, who is as powerful as death itself. And if by chance They escape from him, I will have Them killed by my wrestlers, who are as strong as lightning.
Commentary

They will be killed by these wrestlers who are like thunderbolts.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

What is the purpose in bringing them? I will have them killed. If they escape the elephant, then I will have them killed by the wrestlers. There is another meaning. If you bring them to Mathurā, I will have them enter by the gate which will increase their enthusiasm for defeating me and will have them enter into the arena, with the elephant which is death for my wrestlers and me. For my liberation (muktau) I will have them approach me (ghataye) with the wrestlers at the gate, who are like the devatās who accompany one during the gradual stages of liberation.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

What is the purpose in bringing them? I will have them killed by my elephant, powerful as death. Death cannot be avoided for them. They will not escape, but if they do, then I will have my wrestlers kill them. The comparison with lightning indicates that their death could not be avoided.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

If the elephant fails, the wrestlers; if the wrestlers fail, the next plan. Kaṁsa lists backups for Bhagavān's murder. Every plan is correct in form and impossible in fact. The Bhāgavatam smiles at the cumulative redundancy of an asura against the Lord.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.33

↗
తయోర్నిహతయోస్తప్తాన్ వసుదేవపురోగమాన్ । తద్బన్ధూన్ నిహనిష్యామి వృష్ణిభోజదశార్హకాన్ ॥ ౩౩ ॥
tayor nihatayos taptān
[tayor nihatayos taptaan]
vasudeva-purogamān
[vasudeva-purogamaan]
tad-bandhūn nihaniṣyāmi
[tad-bandhoon nihanishyaami]
vṛṣṇi-bhoja-daśārhakān
[vrishni-bhoja-dashaarhakaan]
tayoḥ — the two of Them nihatayoḥ — when They are killed taptān — tormented vasudeva - purogamān — led by Vasudeva tad - bandhūn — Their relatives nihaniṣyāmi — I will kill vṛṣṇi - bhoja - daśārhakān — the Vṛṣṇis, Bhojas and Daśārhas .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tayor nihatayos taptān
tayoḥ
the two of Them
nihatayoḥ
when They are killed
taptān
tormented
vasudeva-purogamān
vasudeva - purogamān
led by Vasudeva
tad-bandhūn nihaniṣyāmi
tad - bandhūn
Their relatives
nihaniṣyāmi
I will kill
vṛṣṇi-bhoja-daśārhakān
vṛṣṇi - bhoja - daśārhakān
the Vṛṣṇis, Bhojas and Daśārhas .
  • taptān — (those) afflicted, lamenting
    Past participle of √tap — to be heated, pained. Kaṁsa anticipates the family's grief and treats it as cause for further killing. Asura-logic: their pain proves they love what I want destroyed; therefore destroy them too.
  • vasudeva - purogamān — headed by Vasudeva
    Vasudeva + puroga (going in front, foremost). Vasudeva is named the leader of the relatives — the same Vasudeva Nārada has just exposed as Bhagavān's father. Kaṁsa's full extermination-target.
  • vṛṣṇi - bhoja - daśārhakān — the Vṛṣṇis, Bhojas, and Daśārhas
    Three Yadu sub-clans. The Bhāgavatam names them because the Yadu-vaṁśa is the Lord's own appearance-lineage; Kaṁsa's plan is to annihilate it entirely, which makes it the chapter's most pointed adharma.
  • nihaniṣyāmi — I shall kill
    Future of ni + √han. The first-person killing-verb in Kaṁsa's mouth is in the future tense — a future Bhagavān has already cancelled.
When these two have been killed, I will kill Vasudeva and all Their lamenting relatives — the Vṛṣṇis, Bhojas and Daśārhas.

Even today there are wicked political leaders throughout the world who make such plans and even carry them out.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
When these two have been killed, I will kill Vasudeva and all Their lamenting relatives—the Vṛṣṇis, Bhojas and Daśārhas.
Commentary

When these two boys are killed, Vasudeva, the Vrsnis and their friends of the Bhoja and Dasarha dynsasties will become weak.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

“You will get trouble from his friends.” Kaṁsa responds in two verses. I will kill his friends such as Vasudeva. “Why do you not kill them before killing the two boys?” They will be in a state of lamentation after the two are killed. This shows Kaṁsa’s great anger. The other meaning is “Having approached the two for my liberation, I will also approach his friends since they are faithful to him.”

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

“You will get trouble from his friends.” Kaṁsa responds in two verses. I will kill his friends such as Vasudeva. “Why do you not kill them before killing the two boys?” They will be in a state of lamentation after the two are killed. It will be easy to kill them. “They are your relatives.” They are friends of the two boys. I will destroy them completely--along with their wealth (ni-haniṣyāmi).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Shraddha (Faith / Reverence)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Kaṁsa's list is generational: kill the boys, then the parents, then every relative who mourns them. Hatred without an off-switch is its own form of theology — a perfect inverse of bhakti's all-inclusive love. The Bhāgavatam puts the speech in his mouth so we can hear the contour exactly.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.34

↗
ఉగ్రసేనం చ పితరం స్థవిరం రాజ్యకాముకం । తద్భ్రాతరం దేవకం చ యే చాన్యే విద్విషో మమ ॥ ౩౪ ॥
ugrasenaṁ ca pitaraṁ
[ugrasenam cha pitaram]
sthaviraṁ rājya-kāmukaṁ
[sthaviram raajya-kaamukam]
tad-bhrātaraṁ devakaṁ ca
[tad-bhraataram devakam cha]
ye cānye vidviṣo mama
[ye chaanye vidvisho mama]
ugrasenam — King Ugrasena ca — and pitaram — my father sthaviram — old rājya — for the kingdom kāmukam — greedy tat - bhrātaram — his brother devakam — Devaka ca — also ye — who ca — and anye — others vidviṣaḥ — enemies mama — my .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ugrasenaṁ ca pitaraṁ
ugrasenam
King Ugrasena
ca
and
pitaram
my father
sthaviraṁ rājya-kāmukaṁ
sthaviram
old
rājya
for the kingdom
kāmukam
greedy
tad-bhrātaraṁ devakaṁ ca
tat - bhrātaram
his brother
devakam
Devaka
ca
also
ye cānye vidviṣo mama
ye
who
ca
and
anye
others
vidviṣaḥ
enemies
mama
my .
  • ugrasenam — Ugrasena (his father)
    Ugra (fierce) + sena (army) — 'fierce-army.' Yet the man is mild. Kaṁsa had already imprisoned him and seized the throne (SB 10.1.69); now he proposes to finish him. Gauḍīyas note: Kṛṣṇa will free Ugrasena and restore him as Mathurā's king in SB 10.45.
  • pitaram — (my) father
    Pitṛ — father. Kaṁsa names him as 'father' even while planning to kill him — the Bhāgavatam preserves the word to mark the depth of the offense, by Vedic standards the gravest of crimes.
  • kāmukam — greedy, lustful (for the kingdom)
    From √kam — to desire. Kaṁsa projects his own greed onto Ugrasena. The Bhāgavatam often catches asuras in this exact projection: the very vice they live by is named in others as the pretext for harm.
  • vidviṣaḥ — (my) enemies
    Vi + √dviṣ — to hate. The same root as dveṣa, one of the kleśas. Kaṁsa lives inside the kleśa of dveṣa and names the world from inside it; everyone becomes vidviṣa.
I will also kill my old father, Ugrasena, who is greedy for my kingdom, and I will kill his brother Devaka and all my other enemies as well.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
I will also kill my old father, Ugrasena, who is greedy for my kingdom, and I will kill his brother Devaka and all my other enemies as well.
Commentary

I will also kill all my other enemies.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

I will also kill all others who side with them.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

I will also kill my old father, greedy for the kingdom, and all others who side with them.

Related values
Prema (Divine Love)Bhakti (Devotion)
Concepts
RasaJiva

He turns finally on his own father. The arc of Kaṁsa's plan, traced verse by verse, terminates at parricide. The Bhāgavatam quietly shows how demonic ambition exhausts its outward targets and finally consumes its own kin — a reverse-Vraja, where family is destroyed instead of treasured.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.35

↗
తతశ్చైషా మహీ మిత్ర భవిత్రీ నష్టకణ్టకా ॥ ౩౫ ॥
tataś caiṣā mahī mitra
[tatash chaishaa mahee mitra]
bhavitrī naṣṭa-kaṇṭakā
[bhavitree nashta-kantakaa]
tataḥ — then ca — and eṣā — this mahī — earth mitra — O friend bhavitrī — will be naṣṭa — destroyed kaṇṭakā — her thorns .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tataś caiṣā mahī mitra
tataḥ
then
ca
and
eṣā
this
mahī
earth
mitra
O friend
bhavitrī naṣṭa-kaṇṭakā
bhavitrī
will be
naṣṭa
destroyed
kaṇṭakā
her thorns .
  • mahī — the earth
    Mahī — the earth, also bhū-devī. The same earth-goddess prayed to Brahmā in SB 10.1 for relief from demonic kings; Kaṁsa unknowingly names the very being whose petition started the whole avatāra-mission.
  • mitra — O friend
    Address to Akrūra. Kaṁsa uses friendship-vocabulary; for Gauḍīyas the irony lands hard — true friendship is Kṛṣṇa-sakhya, which Akrūra is about to enter; Kaṁsa's mitra-bhāva is the simulacrum.
  • naṣṭa - kaṇṭakā — free of thorns
    Naṣṭa (destroyed) + kaṇṭaka (thorn). Bhāgavatam's stock idiom for a peaceful realm. Kaṁsa imagines the thorns are Kṛṣṇa-Balarāma-Ugrasena-Vasudeva — exactly inverted from reality, where the thorn is himself.
Then, my friend, this earth will be free of thorns.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Then, my friend, this earth will be free of thorns.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

“But I am a Bhoja. Am I not their friends?” No, you are my friend. You are my benefactor. I will give part of my kingdom to you.

Concepts
Jiva

'Then the earth will be free of thorns.' One half-line — the asura's vision of utopia. The Bhāgavatam pairs his line with its silent rebuttal: the earth is freed of thorns precisely when Bhagavān removes Kaṁsa Himself, six chapters from now.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.36

↗
జరాసన్ధో మమ గురుర్ద్వివిదో దయిత: సఖా । శమ్బరో నరకో బాణో మయ్యేవ కృతసౌహృదా: । తైరహం సురపక్షీయాన్ హత్వా భోక్ష్యే మహీం నృపాన్ ॥ ౩౬ ॥
jarāsandho mama gurur
[jaraasandho mama gurur]
dvivido dayitaḥ sakhā
[dvivido dayitah sakhaa]
śambaro narako bāṇo
[shambaro narako baano]
mayy eva kṛta-sauhṛdāḥ
[mayy eva krita-sauhridaah]
tair ahaṁ sura-pakṣīyān
[tair aham sura-paksheeyaan]
hatvā bhokṣye mahīṁ nṛpān
[hatvaa bhokshye maheem nripaan]
jarāsandhaḥ — Jarāsandha mama — my guruḥ — elder (father-in-law) dvividaḥ — Dvivida dayitaḥ — my dear sakhā — friend śambaraḥ — Śambara narakaḥ — Naraka bāṇaḥ — Bāṇa mayi — for me eva — indeed kṛta - sauhṛdāḥ — who have strong friendship taiḥ — with them aham — 1 sura — of the demigods pakṣīyān — those who are allies hatvā — killing bhokṣye — will enjoy mahīm — the earth nṛpān — the kings .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
jarāsandho mama gurur
jarāsandhaḥ
Jarāsandha
mama
my
guruḥ
elder (father-in-law)
dvivido dayitaḥ sakhā
dvividaḥ
Dvivida
dayitaḥ
my dear
sakhā
friend
śambaro narako bāṇo
śambaraḥ
Śambara
narakaḥ
Naraka
bāṇaḥ
Bāṇa
mayy eva kṛta-sauhṛdāḥ
mayi
for me
eva
indeed
kṛta - sauhṛdāḥ
who have strong friendship
tair ahaṁ sura-pakṣīyān
taiḥ
with them
aham
1
sura
of the demigods
pakṣīyān
those who are allies
hatvā bhokṣye mahīṁ nṛpān
hatvā
killing
bhokṣye
will enjoy
mahīm
the earth
nṛpān
the kings .
  • jarāsandhaḥ — Jarāsandha
    Jarā (the old woman) + sandha (joined). Born in two halves and joined by the demoness Jarā. King of Magadha, Kaṁsa's father-in-law. He invades Mathurā seventeen times in SB 10.50–52 and is finally killed by Bhīma.
  • dvividaḥ — Dvivida
    The monkey-demon, brother of Mainda. He befriended Naraka and ravaged the earth. Balarāma kills him in SB 10.67 — Gauḍīyas note this as a Balarāma-only victory, a quiet sphere of His independent action.
  • śambaraḥ — Śambara
    The demon who, alarmed by a prophecy of his own, stole infant Pradyumna and was eventually killed by him in SB 10.55. The same prophecy-fear that drives Kaṁsa drives Śambara — the asura type is repeatable.
  • narakaḥ — Naraka
    Narakāsura, the son of Bhū-devī, who tormented the demigods until Kṛṣṇa killed him at Prāgjyotiṣapura (SB 10.59), liberating the sixteen thousand princesses.
  • bāṇaḥ — Bāṇa
    Bāṇāsura, devotee of Lord Śiva, possessor of a thousand arms. Defeated by Kṛṣṇa in SB 10.62–63 in the war over his daughter Uṣā and Aniruddha.
  • kṛta - sauhṛdāḥ — having made friendship (with me)
    Kṛta (made) + sauhṛda (friendship, lit. 'good-heartedness'). The friendship is named precisely so that the Bhāgavatam can later show its instability: each of these 'friends' falls separately, none rescues Kaṁsa, and even Jarāsandha cannot save his son-in-law.
My elder relative Jarāsandha and my dear friend Dvivida are solid well-wishers of mine, as are Śambara, Naraka and Bāṇa. I will use them all to kill off those kings who are allied with the demigods, and then I will rule the earth.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
My elder relative Jarāsandha and my dear friend Dvivida are solid well-wishers of mine, as are Śambara, Naraka and Bāṇa. I will use them all to kill off those kings who are allied with the demigods, and then I will rule the earth.
Commentary

How will the world be without thorns, if Jarasandha and others are present? Jarasandha is my elder, or guru (svasura)

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

I will kill all those who side with the devatās such as the Kauravas. Then I will rule the earth. There is another meaning however. I will enjoy the earth in my state of liberation, since liberation includes all enjoyment (figuratively).

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Dvivida is my dear friend. He is particularly mentioned because of his great courage. The kings he will kill are the Pāṇḍavas, and the kings of Matsya and Pāṣcāla.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses

Kaṁsa lists his allies: Jarāsandha, Dvivida, Śambara, Naraka, Bāṇa. The Bhāgavatam files them for later use — every one of these names will appear in a later chapter of Canto 10 or 11 as a demon Kṛṣṇa kills, displaces, or domesticates. Kaṁsa's friend-list is the Lord's to-do list.

The roster that becomes a casualty-list

Jarāsandha will be killed by Bhīma at Kṛṣṇa's direction (Mahābhārata, Sabhā-parva). Dvivida, the monkey-demon, will be killed by Balarāma in SB 10.67. Śambara was already killed by Pradyumna in SB 10.55. Naraka will be killed by Kṛṣṇa Himself in SB 10.59. Bāṇa will be defeated and his thousand arms cut down in SB 10.62–63.

Kaṁsa's coalition speech names, in one verse, five future Kṛṣṇa-victories. Gauḍīya tradition takes pleasure in pointing out: every demon's roll-call is also Bhagavān's syllabus.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.37

↗
ఏతజ్జ్ఞాత్వానయ క్షిప్రం రామకృష్ణావిహార్భకౌ । ధనుర్మఖనిరీక్షార్థం ద్రష్టుం యదుపురశ్రియమ్ ॥ ౩౭ ॥
etaj jñātvānaya kṣipraṁ
[etaj jnaatvaanaya kshipram]
rāma-kṛṣṇāv ihārbhakau
[raama-krishnaav ihaarbhakau]
dhanur-makha-nirīkṣārthaṁ
[dhanur-makha-nireekshaartham]
draṣṭuṁ yadu-pura-śriyam
[drashtum yadu-pura-shriyam]
etat — this jñātvā — knowing ānaya — bring kṣipram — quickly rāma - kṛṣṇau — Rāma and Kṛṣṇa iha — here arbhakau — the young boys dhanuḥ - makha — the bow sacrifice nirīkṣā - artham — in order to witness draṣṭum — to see yadu - pura — of the capital city of the Yadu dynasty śriyam — the opulence .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
etaj jñātvānaya kṣipraṁ
etat
this
jñātvā
knowing
ānaya
bring
kṣipram
quickly
rāma-kṛṣṇāv ihārbhakau
rāma - kṛṣṇau
Rāma and Kṛṣṇa
iha
here
arbhakau
the young boys
dhanur-makha-nirīkṣārthaṁ
dhanuḥ - makha
the bow sacrifice
nirīkṣā - artham
in order to witness
draṣṭuṁ yadu-pura-śriyam
draṣṭum
to see
yadu - pura
of the capital city of the Yadu dynasty
śriyam
the opulence .
  • rāma - kṛṣṇau — Rāma and Kṛṣṇa
    Repeated yet again as the dual unit. Each repetition seats the pair more firmly in the chapter's structural center; Kaṁsa cannot finish a sentence without naming them.
  • arbhakau — the two boys, the two children
    Arbhaka — a small child, a boy. Kaṁsa uses the diminutive, perhaps to belittle. Vraja uses the same word constantly out of vātsalya. The same syllables, opposite bhāvas — characteristic of the Bhāgavatam's economy.
  • dhanuḥ - makha — the bow sacrifice
    Dhanus (bow) + makha (sacrifice). Same yāga as verse 26. The bait. Kṛṣṇa's response in SB 10.42 will be to lift the great bow and break it in two — a coronation-act without a coronation.
  • yadu - pura - śriyam — the splendor of the Yadu capital
    Yadu + pura (city) + śrī (splendor). Mathurā. The Bhāgavatam names the city with full reverence; Kaṁsa rules it but does not own it — Kṛṣṇa is its true Lord, returning to claim what was always His.
Now that you understand my intentions, please go at once and bring Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma to watch the bow sacrifice and see the opulence of the Yadus’ capital.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Now that you understand my intentions, please go at once and bring Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma to watch the bow sacrifice and see the opulence of the Yadus' capital.
Commentary

You should not tell this secret plot to others, but you should speak as follows, inviting the boys to the dhanur yajna.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Fooling them by the attractions, you can bring these two foolish children (arbhakau). The bow sacrifice and the splendor of the city will be attractive to boys coming from the forest. Hari-vaṁśa says: vācyaś ca nandagopo vai karam ādāya vārṣikam śīghram āgaccha nagaraṁ gopaiḥ sarvaiḥ samanvitaḥ kṛsṇa-saṅkarṣaṇau caiva vasudeva-sutāv ubhau draṣṭum icchati vai kaṁsaḥ sabhṛtyaḥ sapurohitaḥ etau yuddha-vidau raṅge kāla-nirmāna-yodhinau dṛḍha-pratikṛtī caiva śṛṇomi vyāyatodyamau asmākam api mallau dvau sajjau yuddha-kṛtotsavau tābhyām saha nihyotsyete tau yuddha-kuśalāva ubhau drāṣṭavyau ca mayāvaśyaṁ bālau tāv amaropamau pita-svasuḥ sutau mukhyau vrajavāsau vane carau vaktavyaṁ ca vraje tasmin samīpe vraja-vāsinām raja dhanur makham nāma kāriṣyati vai sukhī sannikṛṣte prajās tatra nivasantu yathā sukham janasyāmantritasyārthe yathā syāt sarvam avyayam payasaḥ sarpiṣaś caiva dadhno dadhyuttarasya ca yathā kāma pradānāya bhojyādhiśrayanāya ca You should speak to Nanda as follows. “Go quickly to Mathurā, bringing your yearly tax with all the cowherds. Kaṁsa, his servants and priests desire to see the sons of Vasudeva, Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma. I have heard that the two boys are expert at fighting, fighters who bring death in the arena, determined and most perseverant. Our two wrestlers are prepared for this festive combat. Your two boys, expert at fighting should compete with them.” I must see these two boys living in Vraja, who wander in the forest, the sons of my father’s sister, who are like devatās. You should tell the people of Vraja that the rejoicing king will perform a sacrifice for the bow. The citizens should stay nearby comfortably. For the invited guests there will be unlimited milk, ghee, yogurt, and buttermilk to be given freely and for cooking.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

'Bring the two boys — let them see the bow sacrifice and the splendor of Mathurā.' Cover-story over a death-plot, sightseeing as bait. The Bhāgavatam smiles: yes, the boys will see Mathurā — and Mathurā will see them, and the city's gaze will never recover.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.38

↗
శ్రీఅక్రూర ఉవాచ రాజన్ మనీషితం సధ్ర్యక్ తవ స్వావద్యమార్జనమ్ । సిద్ధ్యసిద్ధ్యో: సమం కుర్యాద్దైవం హి ఫలసాధనమ్ ॥ ౩౮ ॥
śrī-akrūra uvāca
[shree-akroora uvaacha]
rājan manīṣitaṁ sadhryak
[raajan maneeshitam sadhryak]
tava svāvadya-mārjanam
[tava svaavadya-maarjanam]
siddhy-asiddhyoḥ samaṁ kuryād
[siddhy-asiddhyoh samam kuryaad]
daivaṁ hi phala-sādhanam
[daivam hi phala-saadhanam]
śrī - akrūraḥ uvāca — Śrī Akrūra said rājan — O King manīṣitam — the thinking sadhryak — perfect tava — your sva — your own avadya — misfortune mārjanam — which will wash away siddhi - asiddhyoḥ — in both success and failure samam — equal kuryāt — one should act daivam — destiny hi — after all phala — the fruit, result sādhanam — the cause of achieving .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śrī-akrūra uvāca
śrī - akrūraḥ uvāca
Śrī Akrūra said
rājan
O King
rājan manīṣitaṁ sadhryak
manīṣitam
the thinking
sadhryak
perfect
tava svāvadya-mārjanam
tava
your
sva
your own
avadya
misfortune
mārjanam
which will wash away
siddhy-asiddhyoḥ samaṁ kuryād
siddhi - asiddhyoḥ
in both success and failure
samam
equal
kuryāt
one should act
daivaṁ hi phala-sādhanam
daivam
destiny
hi
after all
phala
the fruit, result
sādhanam
the cause of achieving .
  • manīṣitam — (your) thinking, considered plan
    Past participle of √man — thought-through, considered. Akrūra grants Kaṁsa intellectual respect even while declining his moral frame. Devotee speech is precisely this two-layered.
  • siddhi - asiddhyoḥ — in success and failure
    Siddhi (success) + asiddhi (failure) in dual genitive. The exact Gītā 2.48 phrase. The Bhāgavatam is in deliberate intertext with the Gītā here.
  • samam — equally, with equanimity
    Sama — even, equal. Samatva — the equanimity that is the gateway to yoga (Gītā 2.48). Akrūra speaks the technical term inside a political conversation.
  • daivam — fate, divine providence
    Daiva — what comes from the devas, from Bhagavān. Akrūra names daiva as the actual cause of fruits. For Gauḍīyas, daiva is finally Kṛṣṇa's will — the answer Akrūra gives is theologically denser than Kaṁsa can hear.
  • phala - sādhanam — the producer of results
    Phala (fruit) + sādhana (means, producer). Daiva produces phala — the agent of results is not the schemer. The whole of Kaṁsa's chapter-long speech is gently dismantled by these two words.
Śrī Akrūra said: O King, you have expertly devised a process to free yourself of misfortune. Still, one should be equal in success and failure, since it is certainly destiny that produces the results of one’s work.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Śrī Akrūra said: O King, you have expertly devised a process to free yourself of misfortune. Still, one should be equal in success and failure, since it is certainly destiny that produces the results of one's work.
Commentary

You have thoroughly considered how to avoid your death. But now hear the words of niti sastra. In regards to success or failure, one should perform the action with cool head, since fate alone will determine the result.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

After hearing this, with a desire to accomplish seeing the Lord and as a result, to bring about the death of Kaṁsa which he long desired, he desired to announce his friendship with Kaṁsa by praising him. That is expressed in two verses. You have considered correctly because you are the king. It is permitted in the scriptures for the king to use force. “Why did Akrūra, follower of dharma, permit punishment?” Hearing all of Kaṁsa’s false words he hid his true intentions and simply repeated Kaṁsa’s views in praise. One should endeavor (kuryāt) for solutions to such problems by taking the advice of scriptures. If one ignores this, one becomes sinful. Without joy or sorrow (samaḥ), one should do this. Another version has samam instead of samaḥ. Then it is an adverb (do this with composure).

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

I am satisfied with this result, after acting favorably to this wicked person for so long. Actually it is done for my benefit. Therefor I should act for his benefit. In not saying it is benefical, he will worry that I am indifferent. If, not trusting me, he does not send me, my long-held desire will not be fulfilled. I will thus speak some encouraging words to him. This he does with two verses. O king, you should protect your body and your kingdom (rājan)! Or this act should follow nīti-śāstra for kings, not karma scriptures. One should perform actions whether successful or a failure. One should not rejoice on success and one should not feel pain on failure. Why? Your fate produces the result. What will effort accomplish? Samam acts as an adverb, or the word bhāvam should be added after samam. The meaning is the same.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses
Concepts
Dharma

Akrūra answers gently — yes, your plan is well-crafted, but a wise man treats success and failure as equal because daiva produces the fruit. He sounds like a courtier and reads like a sage. He is already inside niṣkāma-karma, sitting in front of the very man who has never known it.

Bhagavad-gītā 2.47 in Akrūra's mouth

Kṛṣṇa's instruction to Arjuna — perform your duty, abandon attachment to results, be equipoised in success and failure (Gītā 2.47–48) — is anticipated, almost word-for-word, by Akrūra here: siddhy-asiddhyoḥ samaṁ kuryāt.

Gauḍīya commentators note that the doctrine of niṣkāma-karma was alive in great devotees long before it was formally spoken at Kurukṣetra. Akrūra speaks it to the man least able to hear it — which is perhaps why Kṛṣṇa later speaks it to the man most able to.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.39

↗
మనోరథాన్ కరోత్యుచ్చైర్జనో దైవహతానపి । యుజ్యతే హర్షశోకాభ్యాం తథాప్యాజ్ఞాం కరోమి తే ॥ ౩౯ ॥
manorathān karoty uccair
[manorathaan karoty uchchair]
jano daiva-hatān api
[jano daiva-hataan api]
yujyate harṣa-śokābhyāṁ
[yujyate harsha-shokaabhyaam]
tathāpy ājñāṁ karomi te
[tathaapy aajnaam karomi te]
manaḥ - rathān — his desires karoti — carries out uccaiḥ — fervently janaḥ — the average person daiva — by Providence hatān — thwarted api — even though yujyate — he is confronted harṣa - śokābhyām — by happiness and distress tathā api — nonetheless ājñām — order karomi — I will do te — your .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
manorathān karoty uccair
manaḥ - rathān
his desires
karoti
carries out
uccaiḥ
fervently
jano daiva-hatān api
janaḥ
the average person
daiva
by Providence
hatān
thwarted
api
even though
yujyate harṣa-śokābhyāṁ
yujyate
he is confronted
harṣa - śokābhyām
by happiness and distress
tathāpy ājñāṁ karomi te
tathā api
nonetheless
ājñām
order
karomi
I will do
te
your .
  • manaḥ - rathān — (his) desires, chariots of the mind
    Manas (mind) + ratha (chariot) — a beautiful compound: 'chariots of the mind,' i.e., daydreams, projects, ambitions. Akrūra uses ratha as a metaphor for desire — and is about to be sent on a literal ratha. The Bhāgavatam loves these doublings.
  • daiva - hatān — thwarted by Providence
    Daiva (fate) + hata (struck down). Even when Providence has already struck the desire dead, the ordinary person keeps pursuing it. The diagnosis applies to Kaṁsa exactly.
  • harṣa - śokābhyām — by joy and grief
    Harṣa (joy) + śoka (grief) — the dvandva-pair the yogī must cross. Akrūra describes the dvandva-affliction in the language of yoga-śāstra.
  • ājñām karomi te — I shall carry out your order
    Ājñā (order) + karomi (I do) + te (your). Akrūra's quiet 'yes.' His obedience is real but multivalent — Kaṁsa hears subservience; Bhagavān hears bhakti's eagerness to be in the vicinity of His līlā at any cost.
An ordinary person is determined to act on his desires even when fate prevents their fulfillment. Therefore he encounters both happiness and distress. Yet even though such is the case, I will execute your order.

Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī explains that although what Akrūra said was courteous and encouraging, his hidden meaning was far different. What he really meant was this: “Your plan is not fit to execute, yet I will carry it out since you are the King and I am your subject, and in any case, you are about to die.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
An ordinary person is determined to act on his desires even when fate prevents their fulfillment. Therefore he encounters both happiness and distress. Yet even though such is the case, I will execute your order.
Commentary

Living entities (low forms, not you) perform activities with expectations that are sometimes fulfilled and sometimes unfulfilled, leading to happiness and distress. But I will carry out my orders so that you will be happy. This is the external meaning. Another meaning is: "Though it is not proper to carry out an order of you who desire to die, I will do so, because you are the king and I am a citizen." Another meaning is: "Though your desires will not be fulfilled, mine will be fulfilled, so I will carry out your order".

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

A person like me dedicated to dharma without attachment should not do this. But I will follow your order since you are the king, the embodiment of all devatās. He shows devotion to Kaṁsa in order to hide his true intentions. Being defeated by fate, or even being successful (api), one endeavors for fulfilling desires and must experience joy and sorrow. He is not like a detached person who is happy. Though this is the case, I will follow your order. He indicates the future. You will rid yourself of misfortune since you will be liberated, for (hi from the previous verse) Kṛṣṇa (daivam) is the giver of all results. You cannot do anything independently. People like you struggle against fate. If the lord is the doer, then I am insignificant. Thus I will do what is favorable for him as a devotee. After the killing Ariṣṭa, Kaṁsa spoke to the Yadus in an enflamed manner and criticized Vasudeva. They also condemned Kaṁsa. Kaṁsa spoke like a blind person. This is the opinion of Hari-vaṁśa.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He illustrates this. On attaining one’s desires one rejoices and on not attaining one’s desires, one laments. Thus nothing is certain since the force of karma is dominant. Therefore one should not be attached to the result. Fate overrides human effort. Thus nīti-śāstra is rejected. In his statement he places lamentation after rejoicing (harṣa-śokābhyām). This indicates that Kaṁsa will not attain his desire and will ultimately lament. Thus though it is not proper for me to act at this time, because I am under your control, I will follow your order. According to your order I will go to Vraja, not by my choice. He hides his true feelings.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)
Related verses
Concepts
Dharma

Akrūra finishes: ordinary people pursue desires destiny has already cancelled, oscillating between joy and grief. He sounds detached — but his obedience to Kaṁsa's order is not detachment. It is the devotee's quiet eagerness: yes, I will go, because the road leads to Kṛṣṇa.

📝 My note

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.36.40

↗
శ్రీశుక ఉవాచ ఏవమాదిశ్య చాక్రూరం మన్త్రిణశ్చ విసృజ్య స: । ప్రవివేశ గృహం కంసస్తథాక్రూర: స్వమాలయమ్ ॥ ౪౦ ॥
śrī-śuka uvāca
[shree-shuka uvaacha]
evam ādiśya cākrūraṁ
[evam aadishya chaakrooram]
mantriṇaś ca viṣṛjya saḥ
[mantrinash cha vishrijya sah]
praviveśa gṛhaṁ kaṁsas
[pravivesha griham kamsas]
tathākrūraḥ svam ālayam
[tathaakroorah svam aalayam]
śrī - śukaḥ uvāca — Śukadeva Gosvāmī said evam — thus ādiśya — instructing ca — and akrūram — Akrūra mantriṇaḥ — his ministers ca — and visṛjya — dismissing saḥ — he praviveśa — entered gṛham — his quarters kaṁsaḥ — Kaṁsa tathā — also akrūraḥ — Akrūra svam — his own ālayam — residence .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śrī-śuka uvāca
śrī - śukaḥ uvāca
Śukadeva Gosvāmī said
evam ādiśya cākrūraṁ
evam
thus
ādiśya
instructing
ca
and
akrūram
Akrūra
mantriṇaś ca viṣṛjya saḥ
mantriṇaḥ
his ministers
ca
and
visṛjya
dismissing
saḥ
he
praviveśa gṛhaṁ kaṁsas
praviveśa
entered
gṛham
his quarters
kaṁsaḥ
Kaṁsa
tathākrūraḥ svam ālayam
tathā
also
akrūraḥ
Akrūra
svam
his own
ālayam
residence .
  • ādiśya — having instructed
    Absolutive of ā + √diś — to indicate, command. Kaṁsa's whole speech is summarized in one absolutive. The chapter compresses his apparatus and lets the line move toward the next morning.
  • visṛjya — dismissing
    Vi + √sṛj — to release, send away. Kaṁsa sends his ministers off; Bhagavān will soon send Kaṁsa off in the same verbal sense — visarjana is the word for the dismissal of a deity at the end of pūjā; Kaṁsa's pūjā of his own ego is about to be dismissed.
  • gṛham — home, palace quarters
    Gṛha — house. Kaṁsa's gṛha and Akrūra's gṛha close the chapter as a contrast — same word, opposite contents. The Bhāgavatam ends on the home-quiet that precedes the journey.
  • akrūraḥ — Akrūra
    Named one last time at the chapter's close. The Bhāgavatam loves to seat the next chapter's protagonist in the final word of the present one. Akrūra walks home and into chapter 37.
Śukadeva Gosvāmī said: Having thus instructed Akrūra, King Kaṁsa dismissed his ministers and retired to his quarters, and Akrūra returned home.

Thus end the purports of the humble servants of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda to the Tenth Canto, Thirty-sixth Chapter, of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, entitled “The Slaying of Ariṣṭā, the Bull Demon.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Śukadeva Gosvāmī said: Having thus instructed Akrūra, King Kaṁsa dismissed his ministers and retired to his quarters, and Akrūra returned home.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kaṁsa went into the inner chambers (gṛham) and Akrūra went to his house.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The use of the word ca twice indicates that both parties were equally important. Equally instigating his ministers and Akrura, being skillful at bad advice, he was inviting death. Kaṁsa went to his house (gṛham) and (tathā) Akrūra went to his house. Thus end the purports of the humble servants of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda to the Tenth Canto, Thirty-sixth Chapter, of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, entitled "The Slaying of Ariṣṭā, the Bull Demon." 10.37: The Killing of the Demons Keśi and Vyoma verses: Summary, 1-2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10-11, 12, 13, 14, 15-20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33 Chapter Summary This chapter describes the killing of the horse demon, Keśī; Nārada's glorification of Lord Kṛṣṇa's future pastimes; and Kṛṣṇa's killing of Vyomāsura. On Kaṁsa's order the Keśi demon assumed the form of a huge horse and went to Vraja. As he approached, his loud neighing terrified all the inhabitants, and they began looking for Śrī Kṛṣṇa. When He saw the demon, Kṛṣṇa came forward and challenged him to come near. Keśī charged Kṛṣṇa and tried to strike Him with his front legs, but the Lord seized them, whirled the demon around several times, and then threw him a distance of one hundred bow-lengths. Keśī remained unconscious for some time. When the demon regained consciousness, he furiously charged Kṛṣṇa again, his mouth agape. The Lord then thrust His left arm into the horse demon's mouth, and as Keśī tried to bite the arm, it felt like a red-hot iron rod. Kṛṣṇa's arm expanded more and more, finally choking the demon, and in extreme agony Keśī gave up his life. Lord Kṛṣṇa then removed His arm. He stood calmly, showing no pride at having killed the demon, as the demigods showered down flowers from the sky and glorified the Lord with prayers. Soon thereafter Nārada Muni, the great sage among the demigods, approached Kṛṣṇa and prayed to Him in various ways, glorifying the Lord's future pastimes. Then Nārada paid his obeisances and departed. One day, while tending the cows, Kṛṣṇa, Balarāma and the cowherd boys became engrossed in playing hide-and-go-seek. Some of the boys took the role of sheep, some the role of thieves, and others shepherds. The shepherds would search for the sheep when the thieves stole them. Taking advantage of this game, a demon named Vyoma, sent by Kaṁsa, dressed himself like a cowherd boy and joined the band of "thieves." He abducted a few cowherd boys at a time and threw them into a mountain cave, keeping them there by blocking the entrance with a boulder. Gradually Vyomāsura abducted all but four or five cowherd boys. When Kṛṣṇa saw what the demon was doing, He ran after him, grabbed him and killed him just as one would kill a sacrificial animal.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Atma Nigraha (Self-control)
Related verses

The session ends. Kaṁsa retires to his quarters; Akrūra goes home. Two doors close on the same hallway; behind one, sleeplessness and dread; behind the other, the trembling expectation of a man who knows that tomorrow he will see Kṛṣṇa's face.

Akrūra's all-night anticipation

The very next chapter (SB 10.38) opens with Akrūra unable to sleep, mounting his chariot before dawn, meditating on Kṛṣṇa's lotus feet, his hairs standing on end at the thought of meeting the Lord he has worshiped from a distance all his life.

This closing verse of chapter 36 — Akrūra returning home — is the last quiet moment before that rapture. The Bhāgavatam lets the curtain fall between two doors so the next chapter can rise on the devotee already weeping in his chariot.

📝 My note