FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.89.23

బ్రహ్మద్విష: శఠధియో లుబ్ధస్య విషయాత్మన: । క్షత్రబన్ధో: కర్మదోషాత్ పఞ్చత్వం మే గతోఽర్భక: ॥ ౨౩ ॥
brahma-dviṣaḥ śaṭha-dhiyo
[brahma-dvishah shatha-dhiyo]
lubdhasya viṣayātmanaḥ
[lubdhasya vishayaatmanah]
kṣatra-bandhoḥ karma-doṣāt
[kshatra-bandhoh karma-doshaat]
pañcatvaṁ me gato ’rbhakaḥ
[panchatvam me gato ’rbhakah]
brahma — against brāhmaṇas dviṣaḥ — hateful śaṭha — duplicitous dhiyaḥ — whose mentality lubdhasya — avaricious viṣaya - ātmanaḥ — addicted to sense gratification kṣatra - bandhoḥ — of an unqualified kṣatriya karma — in the performance of duties doṣāt — because of discrepancies pañcatvam — death me — my gataḥ — met arbhakaḥ — son .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
brahma-dviṣaḥ śaṭha-dhiyo
brahma
against brāhmaṇas
dviṣaḥ
hateful
śaṭha
duplicitous
dhiyaḥ
whose mentality
lubdhasya viṣayātmanaḥ
lubdhasya
avaricious
viṣaya - ātmanaḥ
addicted to sense gratification
kṣatra-bandhoḥ karma-doṣāt
kṣatra - bandhoḥ
of an unqualified kṣatriya
karma
in the performance of duties
doṣāt
because of discrepancies
pañcatvaṁ me gato ’rbhakaḥ
pañcatvam
death
me
my
gataḥ
met
arbhakaḥ
son .
  • brahma-dviṣaḥ — of one who hates brāhmaṇas
    Compound: brahma (brāhmaṇa) + dviṣ (hater). The harshest possible label for a kṣatriya. The brāhmaṇa's grief licenses overstatement — and the Bhāgavatam preserves the overstatement because it amplifies the resolution.
  • viṣaya-ātmanaḥ — of one whose self is sense-objects
    Compound: viṣaya (sense-object) + ātman (self). The diagnosis of conditioned existence — taking oneself to be one's sense-pleasures. Gauḍīyas use this compound widely to name what bhakti reverses.
  • kṣatra-bandhoḥ — of a so-called kṣatriya
    Compound: kṣatra (warrior class) + bandhu (mere relative). A standard Sanskrit pejorative — 'kṣatriya by birth only, not by quality.' The brāhmaṇa's accusation is therefore double: not just bad king, but fallen kṣatriya.
  • pañcatvam — death (lit. the state of five-ness)
    From pañca (five). The body returns to its five elements. The Sanskrit idiom for death itself names the dispersal — a reminder that even at the most grievous moment, the analysis remains tattva-clear.
[The brāhmaṇa said:] This duplicitous, greedy enemy of brāhmaṇas, this unqualified ruler addicted to sense pleasure, has caused my son’s death by some discrepancies in the execution of his duties.

Presuming that he himself had done nothing to cause his son’s death, the brāhmaṇa thought it reasonable to blame King Ugrasena. In the Vedic social system, the monarch is considered responsible for everything occurring in his kingdom, good or bad. Even in a democracy, a manager who takes charge of some group or project should accept personal responsibility for any failure rather than, as is so common today, trying to place the blame on his subordinates or superiors.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[The brāhmaṇa said:] This duplicitous, greedy enemy of brāhmaṇas, this unqualified ruler addicted to sense pleasure, has caused my son's death by some discrepancies in the execution of his duties.
Commentary

I have no fault. It is the king’s fault that my sons have died.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

You hate the Vedas or brāhmaṇas since you are indifferent to the death of a brāhmaṇa. The reason is that you have distorted judgment, because your mind is attracted to material pleasures. The reason for this is that you are the lowest of kṣatriyas.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomShanti (Peace / Tranquility)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Saurya (Heroism / Bravery)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)
Related verses
Concepts
Karma

The brāhmaṇa names the king as the cause — a duplicitous, greedy ruler addicted to sense pleasure. The chapter is preparing a paradox: this 'king' is Ugrasena, who reigns by Kṛṣṇa's grace in Dvārakā. The accusation cannot literally be true; the device sets up the puzzle that only Kṛṣṇa Himself will solve in verse 58.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 89