FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.5.24

దిష్టయ‍ా సంసారచక్రేఽస్మిన్ వర్తమాన: పునర్భవ: । ఉపలబ్ధో భవానద్య దుర్లభం ప్రియదర్శనమ్ ॥ ౨౪ ॥
diṣṭyā saṁsāra-cakre ’smin
[dishtyaa samsaara-chakre ’smin]
vartamānaḥ punar-bhavaḥ
[vartamaanah punar-bhavah]
upalabdho bhavān adya
[upalabdho bhavaan adya]
durlabhaṁ priya-darśanam
[durlabham priya-darshanam]
diṣṭyā — it is also by great fortune saṁsāra - cakre asmin — in this world of birth and death vartamānaḥ — although I was existing punaḥ - bhavaḥ — my meeting with you is just like another birth upalabdhaḥ — being obtained by me bhavān — you adya — today durlabham — although it was never to happen priya - darśanam — to see you again, my very dear friend and brother .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
diṣṭyā saṁsāra-cakre ’smin
diṣṭyā
it is also by great fortune
saṁsāra - cakre asmin
in this world of birth and death
vartamānaḥ punar-bhavaḥ
vartamānaḥ
although I was existing
punaḥ - bhavaḥ
my meeting with you is just like another birth
upalabdho bhavān adya
upalabdhaḥ
being obtained by me
bhavān
you
adya
today
durlabhaṁ priya-darśanam
durlabham
although it was never to happen
priya - darśanam
to see you again, my very dear friend and brother .
  • diṣṭyā — by great fortune
    Repeated from verse 23. Vasudeva uses the same word for his own fortune (in seeing Nanda) as he used for Nanda's (in receiving a son) — Vaiṣṇava humility reads both as gifts of the Lord, not personal achievements.
  • saṁsāra-cakre asmin — in this wheel of birth and death
    Saṁsāra + cakra + asmin ('in this'). The technical term for the round of birth and death. Locative case — 'within this wheel.' Vasudeva names their situation honestly: even great souls are within saṁsāra-cakra, and Vaiṣṇava-saṅga inside the wheel is the rare gift.
  • punaḥ-bhavaḥ — another birth
    Punaḥ ('again') + bhava ('becoming, birth'). Vasudeva names the reunion as a 'new birth' — a beautiful Vaiṣṇava reframing of meeting after long separation. Each true darśana of a devotee is a rebirth into bhakti's atmosphere.
  • durlabham — very rare, hard to obtain
    Dur + labha ('hard to attain'). The same word the Gītā uses for self-realization (BG 7.3, BG 7.19). Vaiṣṇava-saṅga in saṁsāra is named with the language usually reserved for liberation.
  • priya-darśanam — the sight of one dear
    Priya + darśana. Darśana is again technical — the meeting of devotees and of devotee with deity. The whole phrase glosses what makes the reunion 'another birth': it is darśana of priya, the form of sight that constitutes Vaiṣṇava relationship.
It is also by good fortune that I am seeing you. Having obtained this opportunity, I feel as if I have taken birth again. Even though one is present in this world, to meet with intimate friends and dear relatives in this material world is extremely difficult.

Vasudeva had been imprisoned by Kaṁsa, and therefore, although present in Mathurā, he was unable to see Nanda Mahārāja for many years. Therefore when they met again, Vasudeva considered this meeting to be another birth.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
It is also by good fortune that I am seeing you. Having obtained this opportunity, I feel as if I have taken birth again. Even though one is present in this world, to meet with intimate friends and dear relatives in this material world is extremely difficult.
Commentary

"Because I have today met you, by good fortunate, I have again taken birth in this world . Before this time, not meeting you, my life is like death."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

By good fortune I can meet you today, because to see dear friends is very rare. “It is not rare to see me, since I am under your control.” You seem to have been born again. “How is this?” You are existing in the wheel of saṁsāra, where death is always possible. The sentiment here is aniṣṭhāśaṅkīnīva bandhu-hṛdayāni: a relative or intimate friend is always fearful of some injury to his beloved. (Abhijṣāna-śakuntalā-nāṭaka) Or, existing in the wheel of saṁsāra, it is as if you are reborn in the form of your son, caused by his birth. That is your good fortune. It is rare to see dear friends, what to speak of seeing you filled with such bliss. Or it is fortune somehow in this wheel of saṁsāra, for I have taken birth again because of seeing you today, which is rare.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

You are existing in the wheel of saṁsāra, where death is always possible. The sentiment here is aniṣṭhāśaṅkīnīva bandhu-hṛdayāni: a relative or intimate friend is always fearful of some injury to his beloved. (Abhijṣāna-śakuntalā-nāṭaka) Or though you exist in this wheel of saṁsāra, suddenly filled with sorrow for children or wife, it is good fortune to meet you today, when you have been born again as your son, for it is rare to see dear ones. Or It is good fortunate that, though in the wheel of saṁsāra, you are as if reborn because you have attained seeing a dear son which is rare in old age. Or though I exist in the wheel of saṁsāra, by good fortunate I am as if reborn because you, my dear friend, have attained sight of a dear son, which is rare.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomSatya (Truthfulness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Ahimsa (Non-violence / Compassion)Raksha (Protective Responsibility)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Atma Nigraha (Self-control)Nyaya (Justice / Righteous Judgment)
Related verses
Concepts
Darshana
Meeting a dear devotee after long separation is no accident — it is Kṛṣṇa's mercy granting you a fresh birth into association.
Practical Applications
  • Reach out today to one devotee or sādhu-saṅga friend you have lost touch with, and treat the meeting as a second birth.
  • Refuse to take the presence of intimate, Kṛṣṇa-conscious relationships for granted — name three by name and thank Kṛṣṇa for each.
  • Notice when saṁsāra's wheel has kept you 'imprisoned' from association, and carve out one concrete hour this week for darśana or satsaṅga.

Two ships meet on a stormy sea after years of separate journeys — the meeting is itself a kind of rebirth, a port snatched from the wind. Vasudeva calling this meeting punaḥ-bhava ('another birth') names the rare value of Vaiṣṇava-saṅga in this world: where it happens, it is a new birth.

Vidura and Maitreya at the Yamunā

In Bhāgavatam 3.5, Vidura — returning from his long pilgrimage after the family quarrel — meets the sage Maitreya at the banks of the Yamunā. Vidura's first words name the meeting as a great fortune in the cycle of saṁsāra, almost the same language Vasudeva uses to Nanda here.

The Gauḍīya teaching draws on both passages: in saṁsāra-cakra, the meeting of devotees is more rare than birth in a good family, more rare than wealth, more rare than knowledge. When it happens, it is to be honored as the punaḥ-bhava of the soul into devotional company.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 5