FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.16.56

కాలియ ఉవాచ వయం ఖలా: సహోత్పత్త్యా తామసా దీర్ఘమన్యవ: । స్వభావో దుస్త్యజో నాథ లోకానాం యదసద్గ్రహ: ॥ ౫౬ ॥
kāliya uvāca
[kaaliya uvaacha]
vayaṁ khalāḥ sahotpattyā
[vayam khalaah sahotpattyaa]
tamasā dīrgha-manyavaḥ
[tamasaa deergha-manyavah]
svabhāvo dustyajo nātha
[svabhaavo dustyajo naatha]
lokānāṁ yad asad-grahaḥ
[lokaanaam yad asad-grahah]
kāliyaḥ uvāca — Kāliya said vayam — we khalāḥ — envious saha utpattyā — by our very birth tāmasāḥ — of ignorant nature dīrgha - manyavaḥ — constantly angry svabhāvaḥ — one’s material nature dustyajaḥ — is very difficult to give up nātha — O Lord lokānām — for ordinary persons yat — because of which asat — of the unreal and impure grahaḥ — the acceptance .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kāliya uvāca
kāliyaḥ uvāca
Kāliya said
vayam
we
vayaṁ khalāḥ sahotpattyā
khalāḥ
envious
saha utpattyā
by our very birth
tamasā dīrgha-manyavaḥ
tāmasāḥ
of ignorant nature
dīrgha - manyavaḥ
constantly angry
svabhāvo dustyajo nātha
svabhāvaḥ
one’s material nature
dustyajaḥ
is very difficult to give up
nātha
O Lord
lokānāṁ yad asad-grahaḥ
lokānām
for ordinary persons
yat
because of which
asat
of the unreal and impure
grahaḥ
the acceptance .
  • khalāḥ — envious / wicked
    Same word the chapter used for Bhagavān's targets (verse 6, khala-saṁyamana). Kāliya names himself by the very category Bhagavān's avatāra exists to address. He places himself in the demoniac's row, accurately.
  • tāmasāḥ — in the mode of ignorance
    From tamas. Kāliya confesses his guṇa. Bhāgavata: confession of one's mode is the first step out of it. Identification with the body-and-guṇa is itself the bondage; naming it loosens it.
  • svabhāvaḥ - dustyajaḥ — (this) nature is hard to give up
    Compound: sva-bhāva (own nature) + dustyaja (hard to abandon). The asura's honest admission: 'I cannot fix this myself.' Gauḍīya: bandhu-nāśa — destruction of bondage — comes only by His grace, not by self-effort.
  • asat - grahaḥ — clinging to the unreal
    Compound: asat (unreal, perishable) + graha (grasping, holding). The Bhāgavata diagnosis of bondage. Mistaking the temporary body for the self. Recognized — even by a snake.
The serpent Kāliya said: Our very birth as a snake has made us envious, ignorant and constantly angry. O my Lord, it is so difficult for people to give up their conditioned nature, by which they identify with that which is unreal.

Śrīla Sanātana Gosvāmī points out that because of his wretched condition, Kāliya was unable to compose original prayers to the Lord, and thus he paraphrased some of the prayers offered by his wives. The word asad-graha indicates that a conditioned soul seizes upon impermanent and impure things such as his own body, the bodies of others, and other countless varieties of material sense objects. The ultimate result of such material attachment is frustration, disappointment and anguish — a fact that has now become crystal clear to the poor serpent Kāliya.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The serpent Kāliya said: Our very birth as a snake has made us envious, ignorant and constantly angry. O my Lord, it is so difficult for people to give up their conditioned nature, by which they identify with that which is unreal.
Commentary

"When even the learned men become influenced by attraction and repulsion, knowing it is wrong, what fault do I have?"

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Kāliya speaks four verses. By nature of the species (saha utpattyā) I am evil. O lord (nātha)! You have the ability to crush that evil nature!

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Not able to speak anything else because of his suffering condition, he spoke what he heard his wives say. Thinking the Lord would be pleased, he spoke words similar to theirs. Kāliya speaks four verses. By nature of the species (saha utpattyā) I am evil. O Lord (nātha)! You have the ability to crush that evil nature!

Related values
Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Kartavya (Duty / Responsibility)Hrih (Modesty / Sense of Shame)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)Dana (Charity / Generosity)Yajña (Sacrifice / Spirit of Offering)
Related verses
Concepts
Bhava

By birth we are envious, ignorant, full of long-standing anger. Our nature is hard to give up; living beings hold to the unreal. Kāliya's first speech is not a defense; it is a diagnosis. He has been crushed into honesty. The serpent's first prayer is the prayer of jīva-tattva: I am bound; I cannot free myself.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 16