FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.60.56

భ్రాతుర్విరూపకరణం యుధి నిర్జితస్య ప్రోద్వాహపర్వణి చ తద్వధమక్షగోష్ఠ్యామ్ । దు:ఖం సముత్థమసహోఽస్మదయోగభీత్యా నైవాబ్రవీ: కిమపి తేన వయం జితాస్తే ॥ ౫౬ ॥
bhrātur virūpa-karaṇaṁ yudhi nirjitasya
[bhraatur viroopa-karanam yudhi nirjitasya]
prodvāha-parvaṇi ca tad-vadham akṣa-goṣṭhyām
[prodvaaha-parvani cha tad-vadham aksha-goshthyaam]
duḥkhaṁ samuttham asaho ’smad-ayoga-bhītyā
[duhkham samuttham asaho ’smad-ayoga-bheetyaa]
naivābravīḥ kim api tena vayaṁ jitās te
[naivaabraveeh kim api tena vayam jitaas te]
bhrātuḥ — of your brother virūpa - karaṇam — the disfigurement yudhi — in battle nirjitasya — who was defeated prodvāha — of the marriage ceremony (of Rukmiṇī’s grandson, Aniruddha) parvaṇi — on the appointed day ca — and tat — his vadham — killing akṣa - goṣṭhyām — during a gambling match duḥkham — sorrow samuṭtham — fully experienced asahaḥ — intolerable asmat — from Us ayoga — of separation bhītyā — out of fear na — not eva — indeed abravīḥ — did you speak kim api — anything tena — by that vayam — We jitāḥ — conquered te — by you .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bhrātur virūpa-karaṇaṁ yudhi nirjitasya
bhrātuḥ
of your brother
virūpa - karaṇam
the disfigurement
yudhi
in battle
nirjitasya
who was defeated
prodvāha-parvaṇi ca tad-vadham akṣa-goṣṭhyām
prodvāha
of the marriage ceremony (of Rukmiṇī’s grandson, Aniruddha)
parvaṇi
on the appointed day
ca
and
tat
his
vadham
killing
akṣa - goṣṭhyām
during a gambling match
duḥkhaṁ samuttham asaho ’smad-ayoga-bhītyā
duḥkham
sorrow
samuṭtham
fully experienced
asahaḥ
intolerable
naivābravīḥ kim api tena vayaṁ jitās te
asmat
from Us
ayoga
of separation
bhītyā
out of fear
na
not
eva
indeed
abravīḥ
did you speak
kim api
anything
tena
by that
vayam
We
jitāḥ
conquered
te
by you .
  • asahaḥ — intolerable
    From a + √sah — un-endurable. The grief was intolerable, and she bore it. Gauḍīyas read this as the pinnacle of nāyikā-dhairya — endurance in mādhurya — comparable to Sītā's at Aśokavana.
  • asmat-ayoga-bhītyā — out of fear of separation from Us
    Compound: asmat (from Us) + ayoga (non-union, separation) + bhīti (fear). The one fear that overrode every other grief: losing Him. The verse names mādhurya's signature fear by the exact term.
  • na eva abravīḥ — you did not speak
    Strong negation: na (not) + eva (indeed) + abravīḥ (you spoke). Triple emphasis on her silence. The Bhāgavatam-poet measures conjugal-prema by speech withheld — māuna (silence) as the bhāva-language.
  • jitāḥ — conquered
    From √ji — to conquer. The verb 'conquered' applied to Bhagavān by His devotee. Cf. SB 10.9.18 (Yaśodā 'binding' Kṛṣṇa). Gauḍīyas treat this as the central paradox of mādhurya: the unconquerable is conquered by prema.
When your brother, who had been defeated in battle and then disfigured, was later killed during a gambling match on Aniruddha’s wedding day, you felt unbearable grief, yet out of fear of losing Me you spoke not a word. By this silence you have conquered Me.

Here Lord Kṛṣṇa refers to an event that will be described in the next chapter. Thus Kṛṣṇa’s talks with Rukmiṇī must have taken place after the marriage of Aniruddha.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
When your brother, who had been defeated in battle and then disfigured, was later killed during a gambling match on Aniruddha's wedding day, you felt unbearable grief, yet out of fear of losing Me you spoke not a word. By this silence you have conquered Me.
Commentary

"I killed your brother at the gambling match during the weeding of Aniruddha. Out of fear of separation from me you did not express your sorrow, or say "You should not have done that." It was weak sorrow, expressed only for the common opinion. That sorrow also gave rise to joy, because there was happiness at the violence against Rukmi who was hostile to me." For this verse it is understood that this event took place after the marriage of Aniruddha.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Because he was your brother you had affection for him. His disfigurement was thus intolerable for you. He was defeated in battle. Since he was your brother I should not have defeated him, even in battle. And having him killed on Aniruddha’s wedding day was not proper, since you felt the most intolerable grief. But you did not speak out of worry that your master (asmad) should never be inattentive to you. Asmad (we) is used in the plural to indicate his associates as well. Separation from him would be complete if all his associates also left. We, not just myself, but all my associates, have been controlled by you, what to speak of being conquered by you. We do not have such power.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
Concepts
YogaJiva

When your brother — defeated, disfigured at My hand, later killed by My elder brother during a gambling match at the wedding of our own grandson — when all of this fell on you, you carried it in silence, afraid only of losing Me. By that silence you have conquered Me. The verse is the Lord's open confession of being conquered.

Rukmī's disfigurement and death

In SB 10.54.40–51, after Rukmī attempts to recapture Rukmiṇī, Kṛṣṇa shaves his head and beard with arrows at her tearful plea — Balarāma stays His hand from killing. Rukmī, humiliated, founds the city of Bhojakaṭa and vows never to return to Kuṇḍina until he has slain Kṛṣṇa.

Later in SB 10.61, at the wedding of Aniruddha (Rukmiṇī's grandson by Pradyumna) and Rukmavatī (Rukmī's daughter), a dice-game breaks out; Rukmī insults Balarāma; Balarāma slays him with a board from the game. The present verse acknowledges that Rukmiṇī bore both of these blows in silence — and that her silence has conquered Bhagavān.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 60