FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.60.35

సత్యం భయాదివ గుణేభ్య ఉరుక్రమాన్త: శేతే సముద్ర ఉపలమ్భనమాత్ర ఆత్మా । నిత్యం కదిన్ద్రియగణై: కృతవిగ్రహస్త్వం త్వత్సేవకైర్నృపపదం విధుతం తమోఽన్ధమ్ ॥ ౩౫ ॥
satyaṁ bhayād iva guṇebhya urukramāntaḥ
[satyam bhayaad iva gunebhya urukramaantah]
śete samudra upalambhana-mātra ātmā
[shete samudra upalambhana-maatra aatmaa]
nityaṁ kad-indriya-gaṇaiḥ kṛta-vigrahas tvaṁ
[nityam kad-indriya-ganaih krita-vigrahas tvam]
tvat-sevakair nṛpa-padaṁ vidhutaṁ tamo ’ndham
[tvat-sevakair nripa-padam vidhutam tamo ’ndham]
satyam — true bhayāt — out of fear iva — as if guṇebhyaḥ — of the material modes urukrama — O You who perform transcendental feats antaḥ — within śete — You have lain down samudre — in the ocean upalambhana - mātraḥ — pure awareness ātma — the Supreme Soul nityam — always kat — bad indriya - gaṇaiḥ — against all the material senses kṛta - vigrahaḥ — battling tvam — You tvat — Your sevakaiḥ — by the servants nṛpa — of a king padam — the position vidhutam — rejected tamaḥ — darkness andham — blind .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
satyaṁ bhayād iva guṇebhya urukramāntaḥ
satyam
true
bhayāt
out of fear
iva
as if
guṇebhyaḥ
of the material modes
urukrama
O You who perform transcendental feats
antaḥ
within
śete samudra upalambhana-mātra ātmā
śete
You have lain down
samudre
in the ocean
upalambhana - mātraḥ
pure awareness
ātma
the Supreme Soul
nityaṁ kad-indriya-gaṇaiḥ kṛta-vigrahas tvaṁ
nityam
always
kat
bad
indriya - gaṇaiḥ
against all the material senses
kṛta - vigrahaḥ
battling
tvam
You
tvat-sevakair nṛpa-padaṁ vidhutaṁ tamo ’ndham
tvat
Your
sevakaiḥ
by the servants
nṛpa
of a king
padam
the position
vidhutam
rejected
tamaḥ
darkness
andham
blind .
  • urukrama — O You who perform transcendental feats
    Compound vocative: uru (great) + krama (step, deed). The Vāmana-Trivikrama epithet — He who took three vast strides. She calls Him by the name of cosmic conquest while pretending to accept His self-portrait as a refugee.
  • samudre — You have lain down within the ocean
    Phrase: samudra (ocean) + antaḥ (within) + śete (lies). The yoga-śayana of Kṣīrodakaśāyī. She turns His 'I fled to the ocean' (v. 12) into 'You recline within the ocean' — the same words become praise.
  • ātma — the Supreme Soul
    Capitalized in translation — Paramātmā, not jīvātmā. Gauḍīyas hold the strict distinction: jīva-ātmā ≠ Paramātmā ≠ Brahman, in acintya-bhedābheda relation. Rukmiṇī names Him Paramātmā here, the Lord who reclines as the in-dweller.
  • tvat-sevakaiḥ — by Your servants
    Compound: tvat (Your) + sevaka (servant). Even Your servants reject royal dominion (nṛpa-pada) — let alone You. The Gauḍīya inversion of worldly value is exactly Rukmiṇī's own logic for choosing Him over the kings.
Yes, my Lord Urukrama, You lay down within the ocean as if afraid of the material modes, and thus in pure consciousness You appear within the heart as the Supersoul. You are always battling against the foolish material senses, and indeed even Your servants reject the privilege of royal dominion, which leads to the blindness of ignorance.

In text 12 Lord Kṛṣṇa said, rājabhyo bibhyataḥ su-bhru samudram śaraṇaṁ gatān: “Out of fear of the kings, We took shelter in the ocean.” Here Śrīmatī Rukmiṇī-devī points out that the actual rulers of this world are the guṇas, the material modes of nature, which impel all living beings to act. Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī points out that because Lord Kṛṣṇa fears that His devotee will come under the influence of the modes of nature and become entangled in sense gratification, He enters the internal ocean of their hearts, where He remains as the omniscient Supersoul ( upalambhana-mātra ātmā ). Thus He protects His devotees. The word upalambhana-mātraḥ also indicates that the Lord is the object of meditation for His devotees. In text 12 Lord Kṛṣṇa also said, balavadbhiḥ kṛta-dveṣān: “We created enmity with the powerful.” Here Śrīmatī Rukmiṇī-devī points out that it is the material senses which are actually powerful in this world. The Supreme Lord has taken up the battle against sense gratification on the part of His devotees, and thus He is constantly trying to help them in their struggle for spiritual purity. When the devotees become free of unwanted material habits, the Lord reveals Himself to them, and then the eternal loving relationship between the Lord and His devotees becomes an irrevocable fact. In the same verse Kṛṣṇa stated, tyakta-nṛpāsanān: “We renounced the royal throne.” But here Śrīmatī Rukmiṇī-devī points out that the position of political supremacy in this world usually implicates so-called powerful leaders in darkness and blindness. As the saying goes, “Power corrupts.” Thus even the Lord’s loving servants tend to shy away from political intrigue and power politics. The Lord Himself, being completely satisfied in His own spiritual bliss, would hardly be interested in occupying mundane political positions. Thus Śrīmatī Rukmiṇī-devī correctly interprets the Lord’s actions as evidence of His supreme transcendental nature.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Yes, my Lord Urukrama, You lay down within the ocean as if afraid of the material modes, and thus in pure consciousness You appear within the heart as the Supersoul. You are always battling against the foolish material senses, and indeed even Your servants reject the privilege of royal dominion, which leads to the blindness of ignorance.
Commentary

Krsna said, "Out of fear of the kings I took shelter in the ocean, building a house (saranam) there." "That is true, o most powerful one (urukrama). You actually have no fear. You seem to have fear of the sense objects such as sound (gunebhyah), which are kings because they control, since the devotees have fear of these sense objects, and you are dependent on your devotee. Out of that fear, you reside within the devotee hearts which are deep like the sea." "What is the proof that I reside there?" "You, paramatma (atma) are perceived there through your form, taste, fragrance, sound and touch (upalambhana matra). Your beauty, and other qualities are perceived by your devotees through meditation." This is understood from statements of Brahma and the Navayogendras. "O my Lord, persons who smell the aroma of Your lotus feet, carried by the air of Vedic sound through the holes of the ears, accept Your devotional service. For them You are never separated from the lotus of their hearts." (napaisi natha...) "The devotees bind your lotus feet in their hearts with ropes of love." (pranayarasanaya dhrta) (11.2.5). Krsna said, "I made enemies of many strong warriors." Rukmini replies, "You battle with the senses of your devotees, which are longing for material enjoyment, in order to deliver them from the sorrow of material life. In the beginning the sadhaka realizes a little of your sweetness through meditation, but does not see you directly. It appears that you enter their hearts and go to sleep as if out of fear of the sense objects. When the devotee’s devotion increases, and he conquers the enemy senses, he loses his attachment for the sense objects. Then it appears that you wake up and rise, make yourself visible to the devotee and give him your full sweetness." "I have given up the throne." "Yes, that is quite proper. Your servants also give up royal positions because it gives rise to complete loss of discrimination.. If they do so, what to speak of you?" By the reference to the servants here, it can be understood that the previous statements of this verse are in relation to the Lord’s devotees, not the Lord (the lord does not fear, or battle with the senses but does so in relation to the devotee.)

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

She cannot avoid replying to the Lord’s statements. He said that out of fear he took shelter of the ocean. She replies “That is true.” But this must be taken in a secondary sense. It is not actually true. You manifest yourself, merged (śete) in the fort of Dvārakā within (aṇtaḥ) the ocean as if afraid of the kings (guṇebhyaḥ), but not actually afraid of them, just as you rest as antaryāmī in the ocean of the antaḥkaraṇa as if afraid of the guṇas but you are not afraid of the guṇas. This fear is only an appearance. You have made enemies with the strong (verse 12). That is directly true. You are continually opposed to the jīvas endowed inferior material senses. Now, it is suitable to oppose the kings with their material senses. As a pun there is another meaning. Though you are the antaryāmī you have taken a form (kṛta-vigrahaḥ) as the inferior senses. Since your spiritual forms do not manifest to the fallen jīvas and their senses, it is suitable for you to be engaged in pleasures contrary to those of the materialists. Since there is no word iva in this statement there is no comparison made. O Urukrama! Just as the pure jīva (ātmā) lives absorbed in the space within the heart which is like an unfathomable ocean, as if in fear of the material senses made of the guṇas, you live eternally (śete) in your abode of Dvārakā in the ocean, similar to Śvetadvīpa, as if in fear of the kings who are always dominated by the guṇas. yam antas samudre kavayo vayanti yad akṣare pare prajāḥ yataḥ prasūtā jagataḥ prasūtī toyena jīvan vyasasarja bhūmyām The wise know the Lord residing in the ocean. He resides in his supreme indestructible abode. From him arise the universe and the jīvas along with water. He created beings of the earth. Mahā-nārayaṇa Upaniṣad tad eva brahma paramaṁ kavīnām He alone is the supreme Brahman for the wise. Mahā-nārayaṇa Upaniṣad Māhalakṣmī says: yaṁ kāmaye tam ugraṁ kṛṇomi taṁ brahmāṇaṁ tam ṛṣim taṁ sumedhām samayo niścalarantaḥ I make the man whom I love exceeding mighty; I make him a wise man, a sage, a Brahmā. Time does not pass there. Ṛg Veda 10.125.5 nityaṁ sannihitas tatra bhagavān madhusūdanaḥ smṛtyāśeṣāśubha-haraṁ sarva-maṅgala-maṅgalam Kṛṣṇa is eternally present in Dvārakā. It is the most auspicious of all auspicious places, and merely remembering it destroys all contamination. SB 11.31.24 The two levels of meaning of the verse are ultimately the same. This can only happen in the Lord, because the Lord has a form of eternity, knowledge and bliss.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

It is true. You rest internally. Why? Because of fear of the guṇas. Why? You fear being touched by the faults of matter, situated outside. But this is only apparent (iva). Actually you are not afraid of being touched by the guṇas. You have great prowess (urukrama). Guṇebhyaḥ also refers to kings, since the kings use six guṇas or strategies in ruling. You oppose the material senses which are strong. Thus you (ātmā) situate yourself internally as the perceiver only, the form of pure knowledge (upalambhana-mātrah). Ātmā is used to show respect. Or bhavān can be implied from the previous verse. In this case ātmā means yourself or the antaryāmī. The word satyam (it is true) is understood the later statements as well. You oppose with the material senses or persons like Narakāsura, absorbed in sense enjoyments since they cause suffering. Or they oppose you, since they do not respect you. In verse 12 Kṛṣṇa mentioned that he made enemies with the strong. Kingdoms are rejected by your servants, those engaged in serving you with devotion, since they also are situated internally and oppose the material senses, because great evil arises by lack of internal vision, with focus on external enjoyment. They reject kingdoms because the kingdoms create enjoyment for the senses.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Apaishunam (Non-slander)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
Concepts
Satya

He who reclines on the milk-ocean is named 'afraid of the kings'? Even the joke is glorious. Rukmiṇī picks up His own irony and returns it: yes, You hide in the ocean — out of fear of the guṇas, not the kings. Your reclining is yoga-nidrā, not flight.

Kṣīrodakaśāyī Viṣṇu

The Bhāgavatam's standard cosmology (SB 2.5, 3.8, 10.13) describes Mahā-Viṣṇu reclining on Śeṣa in the causal ocean, from whose navel-lotus Brahmā arises and from whose pores the universes emerge.

Rukmiṇī invokes that cosmic posture as the true sense of 'taking shelter in the ocean.' His withdrawal there is yoga-māyā, not bhaya — and even the bhaya-language she lovingly turns: He fears the guṇas, that is, He refuses to be touched by material modes.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 60