FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.38.41

పప్రచ్ఛ సత్కృతం నన్ద: కథం స్థ నిరనుగ్రహే । కంసే జీవతి దాశార్హ సౌనపాలా ఇవావయ: ॥ ౪౧ ॥
papraccha sat-kṛtaṁ nandaḥ
[paprachcha sat-kritam nandah]
kathaṁ stha niranugrahe
[katham stha niranugrahe]
kaṁse jīvati dāśārha
[kamse jeevati daashaarha]
sauna-pālā ivāvayaḥ
[sauna-paalaa ivaavayah]
papraccha — asked sat - kṛtam — who had been honored nandaḥ — Nanda Mahārāja katham — how stha — you are living niranugrahe — the merciless kaṁse — Kaṁsa jīvati — while he is alive dāśārha — O descendant of Daśārha sauna — an animal slaughterer pālāḥ — whose keeper iva — just like avayaḥ — sheep .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
papraccha sat-kṛtaṁ nandaḥ
papraccha
asked
sat - kṛtam
who had been honored
nandaḥ
Nanda Mahārāja
kathaṁ stha niranugrahe
katham
how
stha
you are living
niranugrahe
the merciless
kaṁse jīvati dāśārha
kaṁse
Kaṁsa
jīvati
while he is alive
dāśārha
O descendant of Daśārha
sauna-pālā ivāvayaḥ
sauna
an animal slaughterer
pālāḥ
whose keeper
iva
just like
avayaḥ
sheep .
  • nandaḥ — Nanda Mahārāja
    Nanda — Kṛṣṇa's foster-father in Vraja. Gauḍīyas hold Nanda as the personification of vātsalya-rasa in its paternal aspect (paired with Yaśodā). His first words to a Yadu-clan visitor are a father's worry about the wider family.
  • niranugrahe — the merciless
    Compound: nir (without) + anugraha (mercy, grace). The same anugraha Akrūra used of Kaṁsa in v.7 (as devotional irony) Nanda now negates plainly. Gauḍīyas read this as the unironic verdict on Kaṁsa — the political reality Akrūra had to dress in bhakti's clothing.
  • kaṁse — while Kaṁsa is alive
    Locative of Kaṁsa. The Mathurā tyrant. Nanda's word-order places kaṁse jīvati in a single phrase — "with Kaṁsa alive" — a quietly devastating compression. Survival under such a king is itself a calamity.
  • dāśārha — O descendant of Daśārha
    Vocative — Akrūra's clan-name as a descendant of Daśārha (a Yādava ancestor). Gauḍīyas note Nanda's careful address: he speaks to Akrūra as a kinsman of the imperiled Yadus, framing the conversation as family rather than emissary-business.
  • sauna — an animal slaughterer
    From sūnā — slaughterhouse. The butcher of animals. Gauḍīyas read this image as a deliberate inversion of dharma: the king ought to protect his subjects as a cowherd tends cows; Kaṁsa tends them as a butcher does sheep.
  • avayaḥ — sheep
    Domesticated, defenseless animals. The metaphor depicts the Yadus under Kaṁsa as victims-in-waiting. Gauḍīyas use this verse to teach about adharmic kingship: where the rāja is asura, the prajā are not citizens but cattle in line.
Nanda Mahārāja asked Akrūra: O descendant of Daśārha, how are all of you maintaining yourselves while that merciless Kaṁsa remains alive? You are just like sheep under the care of a butcher.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Nanda Mahārāja asked Akrūra: O descendant of Daśārha, how are all of you maintaining yourselves while that merciless Kaṁsa remains alive? You are just like sheep under the care of a butcher.
Commentary

"How are you living (katham stha), being protected by one who slaughters animals (sauna palah) like sheep? You do not know when you will be killed."

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

After Akrūra had been welcomed by Balarāma, Nanda inquired from him. O descendant of Daśārha! By this, Nanda hints that Akrūra must be fearful, since Kaṁsa had hatred for the Yadu dynasty. Śauna means a killer of animals, derived from śunā (killing). As long as he lives the sheep will be inevitably killed. Similarly as long as Kaṁsa lives your lives will not be safe. The example indicates that because the Yadus are not strong, Kaṁsa can easily kill them. Kaṁsa is without mercy. He is crueler than the killer of animals, since he will kill the Yadus. Therefore he should be killed.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses

A villager seeing a relative from the city does not ask after the weather first — he asks how the family is surviving the tyrant. Nanda Mahārāja's first question is not about Mathurā's politics or markets; it is about whether the Yadus are still alive at all. The sheep-and-butcher image places Kaṁsa exactly: not a king, an abattoir.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 38