FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.14.51

తద్ రాజేన్ద్ర యథా స్నేహ: స్వస్వకాత్మని దేహినామ్ । న తథా మమతాలమ్బిపుత్రవిత్తగృహాదిషు ॥ ౫౧ ॥
tad rājendra yathā snehaḥ
[tad raajendra yathaa snehah]
sva-svakātmani dehinām
[sva-svakaatmani dehinaam]
na tathā mamatālambi-
[na tathaa mamataalambi-]
putra-vitta-gṛhādiṣu
[putra-vitta-grihaadishu]
tat — therefore rāja - indra — O best of kings yathā — as snehaḥ — the affection sva - svaka — of each individual ātmani — for the self dehinām — of the embodied beings na — not tathā — thus mamatā - ālambi — for that which one identifies with as his possessions putra — sons vitta — wealth gṛha — homes ādiṣu — and so on .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tad rājendra yathā snehaḥ
tat
therefore
rāja - indra
O best of kings
yathā
as
snehaḥ
the affection
sva-svakātmani dehinām
sva - svaka
of each individual
ātmani
for the self
dehinām
of the embodied beings
na tathā mamatālambi-
na
not
tathā
thus
mamatā - ālambi
for that which one identifies with as his possessions
putra-vitta-gṛhādiṣu
putra
sons
vitta
wealth
gṛha
homes
ādiṣu
and so on .
  • snehaḥ — affection
    From √snih — to be sticky, to adhere. Affection that 'sticks'. The Gauḍīya bhakti-hierarchy uses sneha as one of the higher stages (sneha → māna → praṇaya...). Here used in its prior, general-emotional sense to be sublated.
  • sva-svaka-ātmani — in one's very own self
    Compound: sva (own) + svaka (one's very own, intensified) + ātman (self). The doubled possessive intensifies — 'one's very own ātmā'. The ātmā that is most one's own — which Śukadeva will identify as Kṛṣṇa.
  • dehinām — of embodied beings
    Genitive plural of dehin — embodied one. The condition of being embodied is the condition of mistaking the body for the self. Sets up verse 52's even harsher diagnosis.
  • mamatā-ālambi — dependent on the sense of 'mine'
    Compound: mamatā (mine-ness) + ālambi (depending on). Possessions are loved through mamatā. Bhakti is the reorientation of mamatā — Kṛṣṇa is 'mine' in the fullest sense, replacing the lower mamatā.
  • rāja-indra — O best of kings
    Compound: rāja (king) + indra (chief). Vocative — 'king of kings, O Parīkṣit'. The technical address to the dying king. The teaching is being delivered at the highest possible address — the chapter's audience-frame matters.
For this reason, O best of kings, the embodied soul is self-centered: he is more attached to his own body and self than to his so-called possessions like children, wealth and home.

It is now common practice all over the world for a mother to kill her own child within the womb if the birth of that child represents any inconvenience for her. Similarly, grown children eagerly place their elderly parents in lonely institutions rather than be inconvenienced by their presence at home. These and innumerable other examples prove that people in general are more attached to their own body and self, which represent “I-ness,” than to their family and other possessions, which represent “my-ness.” Although conditioned souls are very proud of their so-called love for society, family and so forth, in reality every conditioned soul is acting on the platform of gross or subtle selfishness.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
For this reason, O best of kings, the embodied soul is self-centered: he is more attached to his own body and self than to his so-called possessions like children, wealth and home.
Commentary

The preference for ones own self over attachment to sons, wealth or house is natural.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The negative aspect is shown. Śrīdhara Svāmī explains this in terms of ahaṅkāra. The next verse however indicates this with the words dehātma-vādinām (those who think the self is the body). Other versions of the words are not approved because of the intended statement and the mention of the body in the next verse. Mamatāvalambī can have a locative meaning since it is separated from the final clause. The objects of possessiveness have less attraction than the self. O king, you know well that even the king does not have as much affection for the kingdom as does for himself!

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

One has affection for one’s own ātmā in the body (sva-svaka ātmani). Śrīdhara Svāmī explains this in terms of ahaṅkāra because of the identification with the body. However it is not proper to say that ātmani means “for the body”since thinking that one is the body is explained in the next verse. For those who understand that they are ātmā, not the body (dehinān) there is affection for the ātmā. The affection for objects of possession like children is less than the affection for the self with the identity of “I.” O great king! One does not have as much affection for the kingdom as for the self. You know that.

Related values
Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Kartavya (Duty / Responsibility)Satya (Truthfulness)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)Dana (Charity / Generosity)Yajña (Sacrifice / Spirit of Offering)
Related verses
Concepts
Atma

A miser loves his treasure box more than his coat; a parent loves his child more than his treasure box; but neither loves either more than his own body. Snehas radiate in concentric circles; the innermost ring is the body's selfhood. Hold this for now; the chapter will redirect the entire concentric structure to point at Kṛṣṇa.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 14