FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.89.6-7

నైచ్ఛత్త్వమస్యుత్పథగ ఇతి దేవశ్చుకోప హ । శూలముద్యమ్య తం హన్తుమారేభే తిగ్మలోచన: ॥ ౬ ॥ పతిత్వా పాదయోర్దేవీ సాన్‍త్‍వయామాస తం గిరా । అథో జగామ వైకుణ్ఠం యత్ర దేవో జనార్దన: ॥ ౭ ॥
naicchat tvam asy utpatha-ga
[naichchat tvam asy utpatha-ga]
iti devaś cukopa ha
[iti devash chukopa ha]
śūlam udyamya taṁ hantum
[shoolam udyamya tam hantum]
ārebhe tigma-locanaḥ
[aarebhe tigma-lochanah]
patitvā pādayor devī
[patitvaa paadayor devee]
sāntvayām āsa taṁ girā
[saantvayaam aasa tam giraa]
atho jagāma vaikuṇṭhaṁ
[atho jagaama vaikuntham]
yatra devo janārdanaḥ
[yatra devo janaardanah]
na aicchat — he did not desire this (embrace) tvam — you asi — are utpatha - gaḥ — a transgressor of the path (of religion) iti — so saying devaḥ — the lord (Śiva) cukopa ha — became angry śūlam — his trident udyamya — raising tam — him (Bhṛgu) hantum — to kill ārebhe — was about tigma — fierce locanaḥ — whose eyes patitvā — falling pādayoḥ — at (Lord Śiva’s) feet devī — Goddess Devī sāntvayām āsa — pacified tam — him girā — with words atha u — then jagāma — (Bhṛgu) went vaikuṇṭham — to the spiritual planet of Vaikuṇṭha yatra — where devaḥ janārdanaḥ — Lord Janārdana (Viṣṇu) .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
naicchat tvam asy utpatha-ga
na aicchat
he did not desire this (embrace)
tvam
you
asi
are
utpatha - gaḥ
a transgressor of the path (of religion)
iti devaś cukopa ha
iti
so saying
devaḥ
the lord (Śiva)
cukopa ha
became angry
śūlam udyamya taṁ hantum
śūlam
his trident
udyamya
raising
tam
him (Bhṛgu)
hantum
to kill
ārebhe tigma-locanaḥ
ārebhe
was about
tigma
fierce
locanaḥ
whose eyes
patitvā pādayor devī
patitvā
falling
pādayoḥ
at (Lord Śiva’s) feet
devī
Goddess Devī
sāntvayām āsa taṁ girā
sāntvayām āsa
pacified
tam
him
girā
with words
atho jagāma vaikuṇṭhaṁ
atha u
then
jagāma
(Bhṛgu) went
vaikuṇṭham
to the spiritual planet of Vaikuṇṭha
yatra devo janārdanaḥ
yatra
where
devaḥ janārdanaḥ
Lord Janārdana (Viṣṇu) .
  • utpatha-gaḥ — transgressor of the path of religion
    Compound: ut-patha (off-path) + ga (goer). Bhṛgu's calculated insult to Śiva — strategically chosen for maximum provocation. The Bhāgavatam shows that even this slur ought not to ignite a true adhīśa; that it does ignite Śiva here is the point being made.
  • vaikuṇṭham — Vaikuṇṭha, the realm without anxiety
    From vi (without) + kuṇṭha (dullness, hindrance). The realm whose very name announces it is free of the heat that just flared on Kailāsa. Gauḍīyas read the etymology as a thesis statement for the chapter.
  • janārdanaḥ — Janārdana, the Lord
    From jana (people) + ardana (one who agitates / one who is asked). The name applies to Kṛṣṇa as both the destroyer of the wicked and the One whom all approach with requests. Bhṛgu is about to ask the most provocative question of all.
But Bhṛgu refused his embrace, telling him, “You are a deviant heretic.” At this Lord Śiva became angry, and his eyes burned ferociously. He raised his trident and was about to kill Bhṛgu when Goddess Devī fell at his feet and spoke some words to pacify him. Bhṛgu then left that place and went to Vaikuṇṭha, where Lord Janārdana resides.

In Kṛṣṇa, Śrīla Prabhupāda writes: “It is said that an offense can be committed either with the body, with the mind or by speech. Bhṛgu Muni’s first offense, committed toward Lord Brahmā, was an offense with the mind. His second offense, committed toward Lord Śiva by insulting him, criticizing him for unclean habits, was an offense by speech. Because the quality of ignorance is prominent in Lord Śiva, when he heard Bhṛgu’s insult his eyes immediately became red with anger. With uncontrollable rage, he took up his trident and prepared to kill Bhṛgu Muni. At that time Lord Śiva’s wife, Pārvatī, was present. Her personality, like Lord Siva’s, is a mixture of the three qualities, and therefore she is called Triguṇa-mayī. In this case, she saved the situation by evoking Lord Śiva’s quality of goodness.” Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī remarks that the Vaikuṇṭha planet referred to here is Śvetadvīpa.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
But Bhṛgu refused his embrace, telling him, "You are a deviant heretic." At this Lord Śiva became angry, and his eyes burned ferociously. He raised his trident and was about to kill Bhṛgu when Goddess Devī fell at his feet and spoke some words to pacify him. Bhṛgu then left that place and went to Vaikuṇṭha, where Lord Janārdana resides.
Commentary

Seeing the mode of ignorance in Siva, and the mode of goodness in his expansion Parvati, having thus tested him, he understood that Siva could not overcome this ignorance. Therefore he went to the best person, Visnu and committed more than verbal offense, a bodily offense.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Bhṛgu did not desire to embrace him because he followed an unauthorized path, smearing ashes from the graveyard on his body. Śiva became angry. His eyes became hot to spread fire. His wife pacified him with logical words. He then went to Vaikuṇṭha in the material world, made by the son of Vikuṇṭha (Vaikuṇṭha). This was a special Viṣṇu-loka. Verse 12 mentions that Vaikuṇṭha resided there. patnī vikuṇṭhā śubhrasya vaikuṇṭhaiḥ sura-sattamaiḥ tayoḥ sva-kalayā jajṣe vaikuṇṭho bhagavān svayam vaikuṇṭhaḥ kalpito yena loko loka-namaskṛtaḥ ramayā prārthyamānena devyā tat-priya-kāmyayā From the combination of Śubhra and his wife, Vikuṇṭhā, there appeared the Supreme Lord, Vaikuṇṭha, along with demigods who were his personal plenary expansions. Just to please the goddess of fortune, the Supreme Lord, Vaikuṇṭha, at her request, created another Vaikuṇṭha planet, which is worshiped by everyone. SB 8.5.4

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomAbhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Daksya (Resourcefulness / Skill)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses

Śiva's eyes ignite; the trident lifts. Devī falls at his feet and the storm passes. Bhṛgu, his test of tamas complete, turns toward Vaikuṇṭha. The Bhāgavatam draws a clean line: even the most exalted demigod is still moved by insult; only Vaikuṇṭha-īśvara is not.

Citraketu and Pārvatī's curse

In SB 6.17, Citraketu — a perfected Vaiṣṇava — laughed at Śiva sitting in Pārvatī's lap. Pārvatī cursed him, and Citraketu, unruffled, accepted the curse without retaliation, even thanking her.

Gauḍīyas pair this with the present episode: Śiva's consort here pacifies, there curses; in both cases the Vaiṣṇava receives the response without losing composure. The chapter's measure of greatness — equanimity under insult — Citraketu meets in a related register.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 89