FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.72.20

యోఽనిత్యేన శరీరేణ సతాం గేయం యశో ధ్రువమ్ । నాచినోతి స్వయం కల్ప: స వాచ్య: శోచ్య ఏవ స: ॥ ౨౦ ॥
yo ’nityena śarīreṇa
[yo ’nityena shareerena]
satāṁ geyaṁ yaśo dhruvam
[sataam geyam yasho dhruvam]
nācinoti svayaṁ kalpaḥ
[naachinoti svayam kalpah]
sa vācyaḥ śocya eva saḥ
[sa vaachyah shochya eva sah]
yaḥ — who anityena — temporary śarīreṇa — with the material body satām — by saints geyam — to be glorified yaśaḥ — fame dhruvam — permanent na ācinoti — does not acquire svayam — himself kalpaḥ — capable saḥ — he vācyaḥ — contemptible śocyaḥ — pitiable eva — indeed saḥ — he .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yo ’nityena śarīreṇa
satāṁ geyaṁ yaśo dhruvam
yaḥ
who
anityena
temporary
nācinoti svayaṁ kalpaḥ
sa vācyaḥ śocya eva saḥ
śarīreṇa
with the material body
satām
by saints
geyam
to be glorified
yaśaḥ
fame
dhruvam
permanent
na ācinoti
does not acquire
svayam
himself
kalpaḥ
capable
saḥ
he
vācyaḥ
contemptible
śocyaḥ
pitiable
eva
indeed
saḥ
he .
  • anityena — by the temporary
    Instrumental neuter. Sharp Vedānta vocabulary — the body is anitya, the fame to be earned by it is dhruva. Use the perishable as currency for the permanent.
  • satām — by the saints
    Genitive plural of sat. Only sādhu-glorified fame counts as dhruva. Worldly fame, however loud, is itself anitya — Gauḍīya reading: kīrti that pulls toward Bhagavān is the only real kīrti.
  • kalpaḥ — capable
    Nominative. Failure to earn fame is contemptible only when one was capable. The verse is not addressed to the weak; it is addressed to the strong who hesitate.
  • vācyaḥ-śocyaḥ — contemptible and pitiable
    Two adjectives in apposition. The Vedic society had two reactions to the wasted capable man — censure and pity. Kṛṣṇa names both, so Jarāsandha must answer both.
He indeed is to be censured and pitied who, though able to do so, fails to achieve with his temporary body the lasting fame glorified by great saints.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
He indeed is to be censured and pitied who, though able to do so, fails to achieve with his temporary body the lasting fame glorified by great saints.
Commentary

If he does not gain (na acinoti) fame with this temporary body, he is despicable.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

They then criticize. He who fails to achieve lasting fame sung by the saintly, because it is auspicious in this life and the next, is to be pitied. Though he is capable, and can attain fame without other’s help, he does not. He is like a stingy merchant. Or, by himself, without inspiration from others, he does not attain fame. He is to be criticized by those who see faults and pitied by those who do not see faults. The word saḥ is repeated to emphasize his pitiful condition.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomAbhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Daksya (Resourcefulness / Skill)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses

A torch is lit only to be carried somewhere; if held still until it burns down, both torch and bearer are wasted. The body is anitya — its only proper use is to win dhruva yaśas glorified by saints. The verse names the alternative: vācya and śocya, contemptible and pitiful.

Daśaratha refusing to break his word

Old, in pain, dying — Daśaratha could have repudiated Kaikeyī's boons and kept Rāma at home. He did not. He used the perishable body to keep an unbreakable word, even though it killed him. The yaśas of that refusal is sung in every Rāma-kathā: this is the dhruva fame of the verse.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 72