FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.69.20-22

దీవ్యన్తమక్షైస్తత్రాపి ప్రియయా చోద్ధవేన చ । పూజిత: పరయా భక్త్యా ప్రత్యుత్థానాసనాదిభి: ॥ ౨౦ ॥ పృష్టశ్చావిదుషేవాసౌ కదాయాతో భవానితి । క్రియతే కిం ను పూర్ణానామపూర్ణైరస్మదాదిభి: ॥ ౨౧ ॥ అథాపి బ్రూహి నో బ్రహ్మన్ జన్మైతచ్ఛోభనం కురు । స తు విస్మిత ఉత్థాయ తూష్ణీమన్యదగాద్ గృహమ్ ॥ ౨౨ ॥
dīvyantam akṣais tatrāpi
[deevyantam akshais tatraapi]
priyayā coddhavena ca
[priyayaa choddhavena cha]
pūjitaḥ parayā bhaktyā
[poojitah parayaa bhaktyaa]
pratyutthānāsanādibhiḥ
[pratyutthaanaasanaadibhih]
pṛṣṭaś cāviduṣevāsau
[prishtash chaavidushevaasau]
kadāyāto bhavān iti
[kadaayaato bhavaan iti]
kriyate kiṁ nu pūrṇānām
[kriyate kim nu poornaanaam]
apūrṇair asmad-ādibhiḥ
[apoornair asmad-aadibhih]
athāpi brūhi no brahman
[athaapi broohi no brahman]
janmaitac chobhanaṁ kuru
[janmaitach chobhanam kuru]
sa tu vismita utthāya
[sa tu vismita utthaaya]
tūṣṇīm anyad agād gṛham
[tooshneem anyad agaad griham]
dīvyantam — playing akṣaiḥ — with dice tatra — there api — indeed priyayā — with His beloved ca — and uddhavena — with Uddhava ca — also pūjitaḥ — he was worshiped parayā — with transcendental bhaktyā — devotion pratyutthāna — by His standing up from His sitting place āsana — by His offering him a seat ādibhiḥ — and so on pṛṣṭaḥ — questioned ca — and aviduṣā — by one who was in ignorance iva — as if asau — he, Nārada kadā — when āyātaḥ — arrived bhavān — your good self iti — thus kriyate — is intended to be done kim — what nu — indeed pūrṇānām — by those who are full apūrṇaiḥ — with those who are not full asmat - ādibhiḥ — such as Ourself atha api — nonetheless brūhi — please tell naḥ — Us brahman — O brāhmaṇa janma — Our birth etat — this śobhanam — auspicious kuru — please make saḥ — he, Nārada tu — but vismitaḥ — astonished utthāya — standing up tūṣṇīm — silently anyat — to another agāt — went gṛham — palace .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
dīvyantam akṣais tatrāpi
dīvyantam
playing
akṣaiḥ
with dice
tatra
there
api
indeed
priyayā coddhavena ca
priyayā
with His beloved
ca
and
uddhavena
with Uddhava
pūjitaḥ parayā bhaktyā
pratyutthānāsanādibhiḥ
pṛṣṭaś cāviduṣevāsau
ca
also
kadāyāto bhavān iti
kriyate kiṁ nu pūrṇānām
pūjitaḥ
he was worshiped
parayā
with transcendental
apūrṇair asmad-ādibhiḥ
bhaktyā
devotion
pratyutthāna
by His standing up from His sitting place
āsana
by His offering him a seat
athāpi brūhi no brahman
janmaitac chobhanaṁ kuru
sa tu vismita utthāya
tūṣṇīm anyad agād gṛham
ādibhiḥ
and so on
pṛṣṭaḥ
questioned
ca
and
aviduṣā
by one who was in ignorance
iva
as if
asau
he, Nārada
kadā
when
āyātaḥ
arrived
bhavān
your good self
iti
thus
kriyate
is intended to be done
kim
what
nu
indeed
pūrṇānām
by those who are full
apūrṇaiḥ
with those who are not full
asmat - ādibhiḥ
such as Ourself
atha api
nonetheless
brūhi
please tell
naḥ
Us
brahman
O brāhmaṇa
janma
Our birth
etat
this
śobhanam
auspicious
kuru
please make
saḥ
he, Nārada
tu
but
vismitaḥ
astonished
utthāya
standing up
tūṣṇīm
silently
anyat
to another
agāt
went
gṛham
palace .
  • aviduṣā iva — as if by one in ignorance
    aviduṣā = by one who does not know; iva = as if. Bhagavān is sarva-jña; the chapter says iva — the ignorance is performed. Gauḍīyas treat this iva as one of the central markers of mānuṣīṁ tanum āśritam: the Lord adopts human limitations as a līlā-veil, not as a real limitation.
  • pūrṇānām apūrṇaiḥ — for the full by the not-full
    Genitive plural + instrumental plural pair. The full ones (pūrṇa) are devotees like Nārada; the not-full ones (apūrṇa) is Kṛṣṇa's playful self-description. The inversion is the chapter's signature: Bhagavān positions Himself as needy before the one He sustains.
  • uddhavena — with Uddhava
    Uddhava — Kṛṣṇa's cousin, minister, and intimate friend. He is the receiver of the Uddhava-gītā (SB 11.6-29). His presence at the dice game places this scene firmly in sakhya-territory even inside the aiśvarya-bound Dvārakā setting.
  • vismitaḥ — astonished
    Past participle of vi + √smi (to wonder, smile). Nārada — who has seen Bhagavān across yugas — is still vismita. Gauḍīyas hold this as proof that wonder is not the disposition of beginners but the permanent texture of darśana; the deeper the bhakta, the more easily astonished.
There he saw the Lord playing at dice with His beloved consort and His friend Uddhava. Lord Kṛṣṇa worshiped Nārada by standing up, offering him a seat, and so on, and then, as if He did not know, asked him, “When did you arrive? What can needy persons like Us do for those who are full in themselves? In any case, My dear brāhmaṇa, please make My life auspicious.” Thus addressed, Nārada was astonished. He simply stood up silently and went to another palace.

In Kṛṣṇa, Śrīla Prabhupāda explains that when Nārada arrived at the second palace, “Lord Kṛṣṇa acted as if He did not know what had happened in the palace of Rukmiṇī.” Nārada understood that Lord Kṛṣṇa was simultaneously present in both palaces, performing different activities, so “he simply left the palace silently, in great astonishment over the Lord’s activities.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
There he saw the Lord playing at dice with His beloved consort and His friend Uddhava. Lord Kṛṣṇa worshiped Nārada by standing up, offering him a seat, and so on, and then, as if He did not know, asked him, "When did you arrive? What can needy persons like Us do for those who are full in themselves? In any case, My dear brāhmaṇa, please make My life auspicious." Thus addressed, Nārada was astonished. He simply stood up silently and went to another palace.
Commentary

At the palace of Satyabhama (tatra), he saw the Lord playing dice. He spoke to Narada who was standing silently in great astonishment.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

In this house he saw Kṛṣṇa also. This phrase from verse 13 should be supplied to verse 20. Or the sentence can be connected with the verb acaṣṭa in verse 23. Uddhava acted as the witness to the game of dice. The two words ca indicate that both Uddhava and Satyabhāmā were both principal persons in the game since the witness acts as an assistant. He was worshiped by the Lord. In one and a half verses, Kṛṣṇa asks questions. He asked as if he did not know that Nārada had come (though just previously Kṛṣṇa had welcomed Nārada in Rukmiṇī’s palace). It should be placed after kuru in verse 22. When did you come? What can we do for you? He uses the plural to include Balarāma. Give us an order.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

But (api) there he saw the Lord playing dice. Or even there he saw Kṛṣṇa. This sentence should be supplied. Or this verse can be connected with the phrase he saw Govinda in verse 23. The two words ca indicate that both Uddhava and Satyabhāmā were both principal persons in the game. And both Satyabhāmā and Kṛṣṇa had affection equal affection for Uddhava. He was worshipped by the Lord and offered foot water etc. He acted as if he did not know that he had previously spoken similar words. What can we humans or Yādavas, or us Lords (Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma, in plural out of respect for Balarāma), do for perfect persons? Or he uses the plural (asmat) to indicate respect since he was full of all powers. Please order me (brūhi). Make our birth auspicious. O personification of the Vedas (brahman)! It is quite suitable that you can do this.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Apaishunam (Non-slander)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Brahmacharya (Self-discipline / Restraint)
Related verses

A teacher who has been seated all day suddenly stands when a student enters the room and asks, 'When did you arrive?' as if the meeting were the student's gift to him. The reversal is the teaching. Kṛṣṇa playing dice with His beloved and Uddhava rises for Nārada and speaks as if He, the full one, were the one in need.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 69