FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.61.8-9

చారుదేష్ణ: సుదేష్ణశ్చ చారుదేహశ్చ వీర్యవాన్ । సుచారుశ్చారుగుప్తశ్చ భద్రచారుస్తథాపర: ॥ ౮ ॥ చారుచన్ద్రో విచారుశ్చ చారుశ్చ దశమో హరే: । ప్రద్యుమ్నప్రముఖా జాతా రుక్‍మిణ్యాం నావమా: పితు: ॥ ౯ ॥
cārudeṣṇaḥ sudeṣṇaś ca
[chaarudeshnah sudeshnash cha]
cārudehaś ca vīryavān
[chaarudehash cha veeryavaan]
sucāruś cāruguptaś ca
[suchaarush chaaruguptash cha]
bhadracārus tathāparaḥ
[bhadrachaarus tathaaparah]
cārucandro vicāruś ca
[chaaruchandro vichaarush cha]
cāruś ca daśamo hareḥ
[chaarush cha dashamo hareh]
pradyumna-pramukhā jātā
[pradyumna-pramukhaa jaataa]
rukmiṇyāṁ nāvamāḥ pituḥ
[rukminyaam naavamaah pituh]
cārudeṣṇaḥ sudeṣṇaḥ ca — Cārudeṣṇa and Sudeṣṇa cārudehaḥ — Cārudeha ca — and vīrya - vān — powerful sucāruḥ cāruguptaḥ ca — Sucāru and Cārugupta bhadracāruḥ — Bhadracāru tathā — also aparaḥ — another cārucandraḥ vicāraḥ ca — Cārucandra and Vicāru cāraḥ — Cāru ca — also daśamaḥ — the tenth hareḥ — by Lord Hari pradyumna - pramukhāḥ — headed by Pradyumna jātaḥ — begotten rukmiṇyām — in Rukmiṇī na — not avamāḥ — inferior pituḥ — to their father .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
cārudeṣṇaḥ sudeṣṇaś ca
cārudeṣṇaḥ sudeṣṇaḥ ca
Cārudeṣṇa and Sudeṣṇa
cārudehaḥ
Cārudeha
cārudehaś ca vīryavān
ca
and
vīrya - vān
powerful
sucāruś cāruguptaś ca
sucāruḥ cāruguptaḥ ca
Sucāru and Cārugupta
bhadracārus tathāparaḥ
bhadracāruḥ
Bhadracāru
tathā
also
aparaḥ
another
cārucandro vicāruś ca
cārucandraḥ vicāraḥ ca
Cārucandra and Vicāru
cāraḥ
Cāru
ca
also
cāruś ca daśamo hareḥ
daśamaḥ
the tenth
hareḥ
by Lord Hari
pradyumna-pramukhā jātā
pradyumna - pramukhāḥ
headed by Pradyumna
jātaḥ
begotten
rukmiṇyāṁ nāvamāḥ pituḥ
rukmiṇyām
in Rukmiṇī
na
not
avamāḥ
inferior
pituḥ
to their father .
  • rukmiṇyām — in Rukmiṇī
    Locative of Rukmiṇī, Kṛṣṇa's first and chief queen, recognised in Gauḍīya theology as Lakṣmī's direct expansion in Dvārakā-līlā. Her sons inherit her closeness.
  • pradyumna-pramukhāḥ — headed by Pradyumna
    pramukha, 'foremost' — literally 'front-mouthed.' Pradyumna leads the ten as Kṛṣṇa's direct vyūha-incarnation. In the Catur-vyūha doctrine he is the deity of the mind (manas), aptly first in a list of Kṛṣṇa's mental progeny.
  • hareḥ — by Lord Hari
    Genitive of Hari, 'He who takes away' — of sins, of bondage. A favorite Bhāgavata-name; using it here marks the sons as ultimately Hari's, not Rukmiṇī's alone.
  • avamāḥ — inferior
    With the preceding 'na', 'not inferior to their father.' The same idiom as verse 1 — each generation participates in Kṛṣṇa's opulence but does not displace Him. Acintya-bhedābheda in narrative form.
The first son of Queen Rukmiṇī was Pradyumna, and also born of her were Cārudeṣṇa, Sudeṣṇa and the powerful Cārudeha, along with Sucāru, Cārugupta, Bhadracāru, Cārucandra, Vicāru and Cāru, the tenth. None of these sons of Lord Hari was less than his father.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The first son of Queen Rukmiṇī was Pradyumna, and also born of her were Cārudeṣṇa, Sudeṣṇa and the powerful Cārudeha, along with Sucāru, Cārugupta, Bhadracāru, Cārucandra, Vicāru and Cāru, the tenth. None of these sons of Lord Hari was less than his father.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Each of them was strong (vīryavān). Bhadracāru was younger than Cārugupta. That is indicated by tathā paraḥ. The succession is from oldest to youngest. The tenth is stated as such to emphasize that there was not an eleventh son and that Pradyumna was the eldest. The Lord was all attractive (hariḥ) and thus his sons were similar according to the maxim “like the seed so the sprout.” None of them (indicated by the word ca repeated) were less than their father. This was stated before, but for emphasis it is repeated. The following lists are similar.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The sons were similar to their father, who was attractive (hariḥ). With this intention they were all named Cāru (attractive). They were not less (na avamaḥ) than their father. This was stated before, but for emphasis it is repeated. The following lists are similar.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Prema (Divine Love)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva

Like ten lamps lit from one wick, each son of Rukmiṇī carries some syllable of his father's beauty — cāru, cāru, cāru — sound-echoes that the mother's prema keeps repeating, as if she could not stop saying 'beautiful' once she had begun.

Pradyumna recovered from Śambara

In SB 10.55, Rukmiṇī's firstborn Pradyumna was abducted by the demon Śambara within ten days of birth and thrown into the sea. He grew up in Śambara's house, learned the truth from Māyāvatī (Ratī, his eternal consort), killed Śambara, and returned to Dvārakā so resembling Kṛṣṇa that even Rukmiṇī first mistook him for her husband.

So when Śuka now names Pradyumna as Rukmiṇī's first son, he is not naming a stranger but the long-lost son already restored — Cupid himself born of Kṛṣṇa, the seed of the Aniruddha-line that will marry into Bāṇāsura's house in the next chapter.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 61