FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.51.53

భవాపవర్గో భ్రమతో యదా భవే- జ్జనస్య తర్హ్యచ్యుత సత్సమాగమ: । సత్సఙ్గమో యర్హి తదైవ సద్గతౌ పరావరేశే త్వయి జాయతే మతి: ॥ ౫౩ ॥
bhavāpavargo bhramato yadā bhavej
[bhavaapavargo bhramato yadaa bhavej]
janasya tarhy acyuta sat-samāgamaḥ
[janasya tarhy achyuta sat-samaagamah]
sat-saṅgamo yarhi tadaiva sad-gatau
[sat-sangamo yarhi tadaiva sad-gatau]
parāvareśe tvayi jāyate matiḥ
[paraavareshe tvayi jaayate matih]
bhava — of material existence apavargaḥ — the cessation bhramataḥ — who has been wandering yadā — when bhavet — occurs janasya — for a person tarhi — at that time acyuta — O infallible Lord sat — of saintly devotees samāgamaḥ — the association sat - saṇgamaḥ — saintly association yarhi — when tadā — then eva — only sat — of the saintly gatau — who is the goal para — of superior (the causes of material creation) avara — and inferior (their products) īśe — for the Supreme Lord tvayi — Yourself jāyate — is born matiḥ — devotion .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bhavāpavargo bhramato yadā bhavej
bhava
of material existence
apavargaḥ
the cessation
bhramataḥ
who has been wandering
yadā
when
bhavet
occurs
janasya tarhy acyuta sat-samāgamaḥ
janasya
for a person
tarhi
at that time
acyuta
O infallible Lord
sat
of saintly devotees
samāgamaḥ
the association
sat-saṅgamo yarhi tadaiva sad-gatau
sat - saṇgamaḥ
saintly association
yarhi
when
tadā
then
eva
only
sat
of the saintly
gatau
who is the goal
parāvareśe tvayi jāyate matiḥ
para
of superior (the causes of material creation)
avara
and inferior (their products)
īśe
for the Supreme Lord
tvayi
Yourself
jāyate
is born
matiḥ
devotion .
  • bhava-apavargaḥ — the cessation of material existence
    Compound: bhava (becoming, samsāra) + apavargaḥ (cessation). The end of wandering. Gauḍīyas note: apavarga here does not mean Advaitin merging; it means saṁsāra ending so that bhakti can begin. Liberation in the Gauḍīya frame is service, not absorption.
  • sat-samāgamaḥ — the association of saintly devotees
    Compound: sat (saintly, real) + samāgamaḥ (meeting). The Vaiṣṇava's catalyst — sādhu-saṅga, sat-saṅga. Caitanya-caritāmṛta repeatedly cites this verse; Rūpa Gosvāmī ranks sādhu-saṅga first among bhakti's nourishments.
  • acyuta — O infallible Lord
    Vocative of Acyuta — He who does not fall. One of Bhagavān's primary names. Mucukunda addresses Kṛṣṇa as Acyuta precisely at the verse about falling — saṁsāric falling, devotee non-falling. The vocative is doctrinal.
  • sat-gatau — the goal of the saintly
    Compound: sat + gatau (goal, destination). Bhagavān as the bhakta's destination. Gauḍīyas read this against impersonalist destinations — sat-gati is a Person, not a state.
  • matiḥ — devotion, fixed intelligence
    From √man — to think. Here, the buddhi turned toward Bhagavān. Same matiḥ that was 'asat-mati' in verse 46 is now bhakti-mati. The chapter rotates the same word.
When the material life of a wandering soul has ceased, O Acyuta, he may attain the association of Your devotees. And when he associates with them, there awakens in him devotion unto You, who are the goal of the devotees and the Lord of all causes and their effects.

Ācāryas Jīva Gosvāmī and Viśvanātha Cakravartī agree on the following point: Although it is stated here that when material life ceases one attains the association of devotees, in fact it is the association of the Lord’s devotees that enables one to transcend material existence. Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī explains this apparent inversion of sequence by quoting the Kāvya-prakāśa (10.153) as follows: kārya-kāraṇayoś ca paurvāparya-viparyayo vijñeyātiśayoktiḥ syāt sa. “A statement in which the logical order of a cause and its effect is reversed should be understood as atiśayokti, emphasis by extreme assertion.” Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī cites the following commentary on this statement: kāraṇasya śīghra-kārītāṁ vaktuṁ kāryasya pūrvam uktau. “To express the swift action of a cause, one may assert the result before the cause.” In this connection Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī points out that the merciful association of the Lord’s devotees makes possible our determination to become Kṛṣṇa conscious. And the ācārya agrees with Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī that this verse is an instance of atiśayokti.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
When the material life of a wandering soul has ceased, O Acyuta, he may attain the association of Your devotees. And when he associates with them, there awakens in him devotion unto You, who are the goal of the devotees and the Lord of all causes and their effects.
Commentary

When will bhakti which destroys all suffering and bestows all bliss appear? That is stated in this verse. When the wandering jiva destroys his bondage of material existence, then he will get association of merciful devotees (sat sangamah). When that happens, then certainly attachment to you will take place. When that association occurs, and nothing else, then attachment to you will take place. In this verse the words "when" and "then" is used with a broad conception of time. In the concept of more accurate time, however, association of devotees and destruction of material existence are related as cause and effect and should be mentioned in that way, using yarhi and tarhi; that is, when there is association of devotees, then there is destruction of bondage. However, because the effect happens so quickly, the effect is mentioned before the cause, to emphasize the quickness. This is an example of the fourth type of atisaya ukti or extreme statement. Vaisnava tosani explains the word sad gatau. Unto you the shelter of the devotees. "Without my mercy association does not take place. Therefore my mercy should be the first cause. " "When there is devotional association, then attachment to you whose shelter is the devotee (who is dependent on the devotee, gives mercy to the devotee) arises. As you yourself say, I am dependent on the devotee, whatever you do is also by the desire of the devotee, it Is not independent. Your mercy is after the mercy of the devotee. You are dependent on the devotee, and not dependent on the non devotee. The later state your mercy arises from the previous state, devotee’s mercy. Therefore your mercy does not arise first. Such mercy of the devotees is shown in the statement 10.23.31. svayam samuttirya...The great devotees who take shelter of your feet cross over the ocean of material existence, and leave here through the line of guru succession the boat of your lotus feet, because they are most affectionate to all living entities."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

When will that person attain auspiciousness? When those with knowledge attain liberation, then the discerning persons attain association. Or it can be the fourth type of literary ornament called atiśayokti. Caturthī sā kāraṇasya gaditam śīghra-kārītāṁ vaktuṁ kāryasya pūrvam uktau: the fourth type is that in order to express the swift action of a cause, one may assert the result before the cause.” Thus the real meaning is “Where there is association with devotees, there is quick release from saṁsāra, because, where there is association, one is able to fix one’s mind on you.” Where one concentrates the mind on you, there will be certain release from samṣāra, at that time only (eva) and no other time. O Lord, you never fail to do this (acyuta)! “Without my mercy there can be no association with devotees. Let my mercy be the first cause.” The Lord takes shelter (gatau) of the devotees (sat). Though he is independent, his mercy occurs by the will of the devotees, not independently. Aham bhakta-parādhinaḥ: I am dependent on my devotees. (SB 9.4. 63) The mercy follows the devotee. You are dependent on the devotees, not on the non-devotees. Only when there is prior association of devotees does mercy occur, and not before that. svayaṁ samuttīrya sudustaraṁ dyuman bhavārṇavaṁ bhīmam adabhra-sauhṛdāḥ bhavat-padāmbhoruha-nāvam atra te nidhāya yātāḥ sad-anugraho bhavān O Lord, shining brilliantly! The merciful devotees, easily crossing the insurmountable and terrifying ocean of material life, attain their goal using the boat of your lotus feet. You are merciful to your devotees. SB 10.2.31 Thus by association of devotees alone, the mind concentrates on you. This is because you are not dependent on what higher or lower beings (parāvareśe) know. By association with Garga, I have been able to fix my mind on you. You have said, “Since in the past you repeatedly prayed to me, I have personally come to this cave to show you mercy.” (verse 42) Because of that, I have now attained you, the giver of freedom from saṁsāra. Instead of mati sometimes ratiḥ is seen. The bud of rati, concentration on the Lord, arises by association alone.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

When or if saṁsāra is destroyed, association with your devotees occurs. The potential form (bhavet) expresses possibility. You are unfailing in your persistence. Or when there is rejection of family life association arises. Or when there is liberation in Vaikuṇṭha there is association with the devotees (sat) of you (acyuta) or with devotees who never fall (acyuta). Or there is steady association with devotees. At that time alone, or exactly at that moment, one develops devotion to you. This is because the Lord is attained through the devotees (sad-gatau). Thus the Lord says na rodhayati māṁ yogaḥ: yoga does not attract me. (SB 11.12.1) Why is this? You are the attained by bhakti which derides (avara) liberation (para). Or though you are the lord of all higher and lower beings (parāvareśe), you take shelter of devotees (sad-gatau). Sometimes rati is seen instead of bhakti. There will occur rati for you by steady association with devotees after destruction of saṁsāra.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses

When the long wandering ends, the soul meets devotees — and from that meeting, bhakti to Bhagavān is born. The verse names the exact mechanism: sādhu-saṅga is the catalyst. Mucukunda gives a chapter-long stuti in the form of a theology of how Vaiṣṇavas come into being.

Nārada's previous birth (SB 1.5-6)

Nārada, in his earlier birth as the son of a maidservant, served the caraṇas (wandering sages) during a single rainy season. The remnants of their food, their company, and their songs created the seed of his bhakti. He says in SB 1.5.25-26 that all the saṁskāras of his next life — his Nārada-vapu, his vīṇā, his perpetual kṛṣṇa-kīrtana — flowed from that one rainy-season sādhu-saṅga.

Gauḍīyas read Nārada's story as the exact illustration of Mucukunda's verse 53. The wandering ends, sādhu-saṅga begins, bhakti is born. The chapter pivots on this verse — every reader of Bhāgavatam at this moment is invited to recognize themselves as the bhramat-jana (wandering soul) the verse names.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 51