FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.51.38

కాలత్రయోపపన్నాని జన్మకర్మాణి మే నృప । అనుక్రమన్తో నైవాన్తం గచ్ఛన్తి పరమర్షయ: ॥ ౩౮ ॥
kāla-trayopapannāni
[kaala-trayopapannaani]
janma-karmāṇi me nṛpa
[janma-karmaani me nripa]
anukramanto naivāntaṁ
[anukramanto naivaantam]
gacchanti paramarṣayaḥ
[gachchanti paramarshayah]
kāla — of time traya — in three phases (past, present and future) upapannāni — occurring janma — births karmāṇi — and activities me — My nṛpa — O King (Mucukunda) anukramantaḥ — enumerating na — not eva — at all antam — the end gacchanti — reach parama — the greatest ṛṣayaḥ — sages .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kāla-trayopapannāni
kāla
of time
traya
in three phases (past, present and future)
upapannāni
occurring
janma-karmāṇi me nṛpa
janma
births
karmāṇi
and activities
me
My
nṛpa
O King (Mucukunda)
anukramanto naivāntaṁ
anukramantaḥ
enumerating
na
not
eva
at all
antam
the end
gacchanti paramarṣayaḥ
gacchanti
reach
parama
the greatest
ṛṣayaḥ
sages .
  • kāla-traya — the three phases of time
    Compound: kāla + traya (triplet). Past, present, future. Bhagavān's janma-karma is co-extensive with all of time, because (verse 19) He is Time. Vaiṣṇava metaphysics: the avatāra's life happens in time, but His person stands outside it.
  • upapannāni — occurring
    Past participle of upa-√pad — to fall to, occur. Bhagavān's deeds 'fall to' all three times — they have happened, are happening, will happen. The avatāras are not single-event; they are cyclic and continual.
  • parama-ṛṣayaḥ — the greatest sages
    Compound: parama (greatest) + ṛṣayaḥ (sages). Vyāsa, Nārada, Vasiṣṭha, Śuka. Even these cannot reach the end. Gauḍīyas read this as the structural reason for the Bhāgavata being twelve cantos rather than complete — paramparā never finishes.
  • anukramantaḥ — enumerating
    Present participle of anu-√kram — to step after, enumerate one-by-one. The same root as Anu-kramaṇī (the indices that summarize Vedic texts). Even the great enumerators are inadequate to Bhagavān.
  • antam — the end
    From anta. There is no antam. The bhakti-attitude embraces this; the speculator wearies of it. Gauḍīyas read endlessness not as frustration but as the structural ground of perpetual rasa.
O King, the greatest sages enumerate My births and activities, which take place throughout the three phases of time, but never do they reach the end of them.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
O King, the greatest sages enumerate My births and activities, which take place throughout the three phases of time, but never do they reach the end of them.
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The greatest sages, even knowers of Vedānta, successively cannot count my births and activities, birth, names and qualities which appear in past, present and future. Yato vāco nivartante: the Lord cannot be fully described by words. (Taittirīya Upaniṣad)

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The sages count my birth and activities taking place in past, present and future and cannot reach an end. The qualities are even more. Guṇātmanas te’ pi guṇān vimātum: it is impossible to count the qualities of you who are composed of all qualities. (SB 10.14.7) Since the names arise from the qualities and activities they are also unlimited. The births are unlimited because the Lord appears many times over time and there are various forms which are many. The extent of time is unlimited. Counting in order, the great sages like Bhṛgu find that there is no end. O king! You can understand this since many great sages have gathered here because of your being a great king.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
Concepts
JivaKarma

The greatest sages enumerate Bhagavān's birth and deeds across past, present and future — and still do not reach the end. The Bhāgavata is itself an instance of this enumeration; it confesses, mid-recital, its own incompletability. A holy text that knows it cannot end is a Vaiṣṇava text.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 51