FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.48.8

సైవం కైవల్యనాథం తం ప్రాప్య దుష్ప్రాప్యమీశ్వరమ్ । అఙ్గరాగార్పణేనాహో దుర్భగేదమయాచత ॥ ౮ ॥
saivaṁ kaivalya-nāthaṁ taṁ
[saivam kaivalya-naatham tam]
prāpya duṣprāpyam īśvaram
[praapya dushpraapyam eeshvaram]
aṅga-rāgārpaṇenāho
[anga-raagaarpanenaaho]
durbhagedam ayācata
[durbhagedam ayaachata]
sa — she evam — thus kaivalya — of liberation nātham — the controller tam — Him prāpya — obtaining duṣprāpyam — unobtainable īśvaram — the Supreme Lord aṅga - rāga — body ointment arpaṇena — by offering aho — oh durbhagā — unfortunate idam — this ayācata — she begged .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
saivaṁ kaivalya-nāthaṁ taṁ
sa
she
evam
thus
kaivalya
of liberation
nātham
the controller
tam
Him
prāpya duṣprāpyam īśvaram
prāpya
obtaining
duṣprāpyam
unobtainable
īśvaram
the Supreme Lord
aṅga-rāgārpaṇenāho
aṅga - rāga
body ointment
arpaṇena
by offering
aho
oh
durbhagedam ayācata
durbhagā
unfortunate
idam
this
ayācata
she begged .
  • kaivalya-nātham — the controller of liberation
    Compound: kaivalya (liberation, the state of being only-Self) + nātha (Lord, master). The very Lord who dispenses mokṣa stands within reach of her arm — and she asks for nights. Gauḍīyas read aho as Śukadeva's wonder at how kāma narrows even the largest opening.
  • duṣprāpyam — very hard to obtain
    Compound: duḥ (difficult) + prāpya (obtainable). Yogīs strain lifetimes for what Trivakrā received by one smear of sandalwood. The contrast is the verse's whole rhetorical force.
  • aṅga-rāga-arpaṇena — by offering body ointment
    Compound: aṅga (body) + rāga (colored paste, ointment) + arpaṇa (offering). One offering = the Lord at her door. Gauḍīya teachers cite this whenever a sādhaka despairs about the smallness of his service: Bhagavān is bhāva-grāhī, not measure-grāhī.
  • durbhagā — unfortunate one
    From duḥ (bad) + bhaga (fortune). The narrator's verdict, not Trivakrā's self-assessment. She thinks she has just won the lottery; Śukadeva, looking on, calls her unfortunate — because what she could have asked for, she did not ask for.
Having thus gotten the hard-to-get Supreme Lord by the simple act of offering Him body ointment, unfortunate Trivakrā submitted to that Lord of freedom the following request.

According to Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī, Śrīmatī Trivakrā prayed to the Lord, “Please enjoy only with me, and not with any other woman.” Because Kṛṣṇa was not prepared to grant such a benediction, Trivakrā is described here as unfortunate. Śrīdhara Svāmī adds that although to ordinary eyes she seemed to beg for material sex pleasure, in fact she was a liberated soul at this point.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Having thus gotten the hard-to-get Supreme Lord by the simple act of offering Him body ointment, unfortunate Trivakrā submitted to that Lord of freedom the following request.
Commentary

She requested that he enjoy only with her (kaivalya natham), not with anyone else at all. She is called unfortunate because Krsna would not fulfill that request.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

She had attained the Lord who was supremely independent and most difficult to attain just by offering ointment to him. Kaivalya means one-pointed devotion, or pure bhakti, as in the following. kaivalya-sammata-pathas tv atha bhakti-yogaḥ: bhakti yoga is the path approved as kaivalya. (SB 2.3.12) That is the explanation of Śrīdhara Svāmī. It is also said apavargaś cāpi bhavati: one achieves liberation in the form of bhakti. (SB 5.19.18) Thus kaivalyla-natham means the person capable of bestowing bhakti. She had attained in a remarkable manner (prāpya) the person who could bestow bhakti. She is called durbhāgā because she had been a hunchback and a servant, rather than a gopī endowed with the qualities of Lakṣmī by nature. It is amazing (aho) that she made a request for a most rare position to be mentioned in the next verse. Her misfortune however was in the past as in the case of the brāhmaṇa: kim anena kṛtaṁ puṇyam avadhūtena bhikṣuṇā śriyā hīnena loke ’smin garhitenādhamena ca What pious acts has this unkempt, impoverished brāhmaṇa performed? People regard him as lowly and contemptible, yet the spiritual master of the three worlds, the abode of Goddess Śrī, is serving him reverently. SB 10.80.25

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses

A poor villager wins audience with the emperor on a market day, and instead of asking for land or freedom, asks for one more market day. Trivakrā has the kaivalya-nātha in her room and uses Him to request more nights of the same kāma. The Bhāgavatam's aho durbhagā is the narrator's groan.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 48