FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.45.30-31

ప్రభవౌ సర్వవిద్యానాం సర్వజ్ఞౌ జగదీశ్వరౌ । నాన్యసిద్ధామలం జ్ఞానం గూహమానౌ నరేహితై: ॥ ౩౦ ॥ అథో గురుకులే వాసమిచ్ఛన్తావుపజగ్మతు: । కాశ్యం సాన్దీపనిం నామ హ్యవన్తిపురవాసినమ్ ॥ ౩౧ ॥
prabhavau sarva-vidyānāṁ
[prabhavau sarva-vidyaanaam]
sarva-jñau jagad-īśvarau
[sarva-jnau jagad-eeshvarau]
nānya-siddhāmalaṁ jñānaṁ
[naanya-siddhaamalam jnaanam]
gūhamānau narehitaiḥ
[goohamaanau narehitaih]
atho gurukule vāsam
[atho gurukule vaasam]
icchantāv upajagmatuḥ
[ichchantaav upajagmatuh]
kāśyaṁ sāndīpaniṁ nāma
[kaashyam saandeepanim naama]
hy avanti-pura-vāsinam
[hy avanti-pura-vaasinam]
prabhavau — They who were the origin sarva — of all varieties vidyānām — of knowledge sarva - jñau — omniscient jagat - īśvarau — the Lords of the universe na — not anya — from any other source siddha — achieved amalam — impeccable jñānam — knowledge gūhamānau — hiding nara — humanlike īhitaiḥ — by Their activities atha u — then guru — of the spiritual master kule — in the school vāsam — residence icchantau — desiring upajagatuḥ — They approached kāśyam — the native of Kāśī (Benares) sāndīpanim nāma — named Sāndīpani hi — indeed avanti - pura — in the city of Avantī (modern Ujjain) vāsinam — living .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
prabhavau sarva-vidyānāṁ
prabhavau
They who were the origin
sarva
of all varieties
vidyānām
of knowledge
sarva-jñau jagad-īśvarau
sarva - jñau
omniscient
jagat - īśvarau
the Lords of the universe
nānya-siddhāmalaṁ jñānaṁ
na
not
anya
from any other source
siddha
achieved
amalam
impeccable
jñānam
knowledge
gūhamānau narehitaiḥ
gūhamānau
hiding
nara
humanlike
īhitaiḥ
by Their activities
atho gurukule vāsam
atha u
then
guru
of the spiritual master
kule
in the school
vāsam
residence
icchantāv upajagmatuḥ
icchantau
desiring
upajagatuḥ
They approached
kāśyaṁ sāndīpaniṁ nāma
kāśyam
the native of Kāśī (Benares)
sāndīpanim nāma
named Sāndīpani
hi
indeed
hy avanti-pura-vāsinam
avanti - pura
in the city of Avantī (modern Ujjain)
vāsinam
living .
  • sarva - vidyānām — of all branches of knowledge
    Sarva-vidyā = every vidyā. The verse names Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma as the prabhavau (origin) of every vidyā (cf. BG 7.10, bījaṁ māṁ sarva-bhūtānām). Yet They pretend to study them — the paradox stated openly.
  • gūhamānau — hiding
    Present participle of √gūh — to conceal. Bhagavān deliberately covers His omniscience. Gauḍīyas note: His āvaraṇa-śakti and His vilāsa-śakti work together — He hides what He is so He can play what He plays.
  • nara - īhitaiḥ — by humanlike activities
    Nara-īhita = human-action. Compound: human (nara) + endeavors (īhita). His behavior, not His being, is human. The phrase carries the whole Gauḍīya bhagavat-tattva: form supremely real, conduct supremely intimate.
  • guru - kule — in the school of the spiritual master
    Guru-kula = guru's household. The classical Vedic learning institution where students lived with the teacher. Bhagavān endorses guru-kula-vāsa by personally undertaking it.
  • sāndīpanim — (named) Sāndīpani
    Proper name. Sāndīpani is preserved by tradition as the priestly teacher at Avantī. Gauḍīyas honor him as the one teacher in human history before whom Bhagavān visibly knelt — the supreme honor any guru can receive.
Concealing Their innately perfect knowledge by Their humanlike activities, those two omniscient Lords of the universe, Themselves the origin of all branches of knowledge, next desired to reside at the school of a spiritual master. Thus They approached Sāndīpani Muni, a native of Kāsī living in the city of Avantī.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Concealing Their innately perfect knowledge by Their humanlike activities, those two omniscient Lords of the universe, Themselves the origin of all branches of knowledge, next desired to reside at the school of a spiritual master. Thus They approached Sāndīpani Muni, a native of Kāsī living in the city of Avantī.
Commentary

Krsna had knowledge not given by or dependent on others (na anya siddha). This however he covered up while he was acting as a normal human being. Therefore he went to the gurukula to acquire knowledge.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Though they were the origin of all knowledge, they desired to live in a gurukula. Mounting a chariot they went to Sāndīpani who was born in Kāśī.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Though they were masters of all knowledge they went to the gurukula to teach others. After that, or for that reason (atha), they desired to go the gurukula. At the time of the upanāyanam they did not have this desire since it would cause pain from separation and was of no particular use. They went to the guru’s āśrama by chariot. That is mentioned later. He was born in Kāśī. Thus he studied all scriptures there. Sandīpani means the son of he who reveals all knowledge. Avantīpura was situated between Mathurā and Dvārakā. Thus he chose that place.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Brahmacharya (Self-discipline / Restraint)Atma Nigraha (Self-control)
Related verses

The two omniscient Lords, sources of every vidyā, approach Sāndīpani Muni's gurukula as students the way the sun would knock on a lamp's door and ask to be lit. They hide their pre-existing knowledge under humanlike behavior so the world can see what student-bhāva looks like.

Bhagavān's pretended ignorance as ācārya-vrata

Across the Bhāgavatam, Bhagavān repeatedly conceals His full knowledge to teach by example. In SB 11.6-29 (the Uddhava-gītā), Kṛṣṇa speaks at length though He has nothing to learn. In SB 1.9, He stands silently before Bhīṣma to receive dharmic instruction. In the Bhagavad-gītā He frames Himself as a friend learning from a friend.

The deepest example, Gauḍīyas hold, is Caitanya Mahāprabhu Himself — Bhagavān taking the role of His own greatest devotee, learning Kṛṣṇa-tattva from Rāmānanda Rāya. Here at Sāndīpani's gurukula the principle is announced: pre-existing knowledge is concealed so the form of receiving knowledge can be honored.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 45