FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.44.7

మహానయం బతాధర్మ ఏషాం రాజసభాసదామ్ । యే బలాబలవద్యుద్ధం రాజ్ఞోఽన్విచ్ఛన్తి పశ్యత: ॥ ౭ ॥
mahān ayaṁ batādharma
[mahaan ayam bataadharma]
eṣāṁ rāja-sabhā-sadām
[eshaam raaja-sabhaa-sadaam]
ye balābalavad yuddhaṁ
[ye balaabalavad yuddham]
rājño ’nvicchanti paśyataḥ
[raajno ’nvichchanti pashyatah]
mahān — great ayam — this bata — alas adharmaḥ — act of irreligion eṣām — on the part of these rāja - sabhā — in the King’s assembly sadām — persons present ye — who bala - abala - vat — between strong and weak yuddham — a fight rājñaḥ — while the King anvicchanti — they also desire paśyataḥ — is watching .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
mahān ayaṁ batādharma
mahān
great
ayam
this
bata
alas
adharmaḥ
act of irreligion
eṣāṁ rāja-sabhā-sadām
eṣām
on the part of these
rāja - sabhā
in the King’s assembly
sadām
persons present
ye balābalavad yuddhaṁ
ye
who
bala - abala - vat
between strong and weak
yuddham
a fight
rājño ’nvicchanti paśyataḥ
rājñaḥ
while the King
anvicchanti
they also desire
paśyataḥ
is watching .
  • adharmaḥ — irreligion, breach of dharma
    From a- (non) + dharma. The structural opposite of the principle that holds the world. The women diagnose the assembly with one word — and in the Bhāgavatam, naming adharma is itself an act of dharma.
  • rāja - sabhā — royal assembly
    Compound: rāja (king) + sabhā (court). The same institution that failed Draupadī. The Bhāgavatam keeps pointing at the rāja-sabhā as a site of moral cowardice — and the king's gaze as its central rot.
  • anvicchanti — they also desire (to see it)
    Plural present of anu + √iṣ. The verb 'to follow-after-desire' — the courtiers' eyes mirror the king's. Adharma travels along anvicchā, the contagious wanting that takes the shape of the strongest man in the room.
  • bata — alas
    An exclamation of lament. The women's grammar carries the rasa: not analysis, not protest — lament. Gauḍīyas note that śoka (lament) in the mouth of bhaktas is itself a form of prayer.
[The women said:] Alas, what a greatly irreligious act the members of this royal assembly are committing! As the King watches this fight between the strong and the weak, they also want to see it.

The idea the ladies are expressing is that even if the King somehow wanted to see such an unfair match, why should the respectable members of the assembly also desire to see it? These feelings are natural. Even nowadays, if in a public place we find a violent fight going on between a very strong, large person and a weaker, smaller person, we are aroused to indignation. Compassionate women are especially offended and enraged by such unfair violence.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[The women said:] Alas, what a greatly irreligious act the members of this royal assembly are committing! As the King watches this fight between the strong and the weak, they also want to see it.
Commentary

The discussion of the women is described in ten verses. If the king sees a fight between young boys and strong adults he should stop it. When the spectators see that the king is watching they follow suit and simply watch. The king desires to watch and they imitate him.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Ten verses describe what they said. Since it was the king’s assembly, it should have been able to discern dharma. The others desire to see this since the king watches. Bata indicates lamentation.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Shanti (Peace / Tranquility)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Vinaya (Humility / Modesty)
Related verses
Concepts
Dharma

The king watches; the assembly watches because the king watches. Adharma propagates like a yawn through a tired court — one face permits it, then the next, then the next. The women of Mathurā refuse to yawn.

Vidura at the dice game

When Yudhiṣṭhira was being stripped at the dice match in the Kuru sabhā, every elder — Bhīṣma, Droṇa, Kṛpa — looked away. Only Vidura stood up and named the adharma aloud, and was driven from the hall for it.

The Mathurā women do what Vidura did: they refuse the sabhā's silence. Gauḍīyas read both episodes as proving the same point — when a king watches adharma without correcting it, the dharma of the realm passes to whichever lone voice will speak.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 44