FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.25.4

యథాద‍ృఢై: కర్మమయై: క్రతుభిర్నామనౌనిభై: । విద్యామాన్వీక్షికీం హిత్వా తితీర్షన్తి భవార్ణవమ్ ॥ ౪ ॥
yathādṛḍhaiḥ karma-mayaiḥ
[yathaadridhaih karma-mayaih]
kratubhir nāma-nau-nibhaiḥ
[kratubhir naama-nau-nibhaih]
vidyām ānvīkṣikīṁ hitvā
[vidyaam aanveekshikeem hitvaa]
titīrṣanti bhavārṇavam
[titeershanti bhavaarnavam]
yathā — as adṛḍhaiḥ — which are inadequate karma - mayaiḥ — based on fruitive activity kratubhiḥ — by ritual sacrifices nāma — in name only nau - nibhaiḥ — which serve as boats vidyām — knowledge ānvīkṣikīm — spiritual hitvā — abandoning titīrṣanti — they try to cross beyond bhava - arṇavam — the ocean of material existence .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yathādṛḍhaiḥ karma-mayaiḥ
yathā
as
adṛḍhaiḥ
which are inadequate
karma - mayaiḥ
based on fruitive activity
kratubhir nāma-nau-nibhaiḥ
kratubhiḥ
by ritual sacrifices
nāma
in name only
nau - nibhaiḥ
which serve as boats
vidyām ānvīkṣikīṁ hitvā
vidyām
knowledge
ānvīkṣikīm
spiritual
hitvā
abandoning
titīrṣanti bhavārṇavam
titīrṣanti
they try to cross beyond
bhava - arṇavam
the ocean of material existence .
  • bhava - arṇavam — the ocean of material existence
    bhava (becoming, saṁsāra) + arṇava (ocean). A standard Vaiṣṇava metaphor — the bhava-sindhu is crossed only by Kṛṣṇa's mercy (mām eva ye prapadyante, Bg 7.14). Indra mocks the only working raft.
  • nau - nibhaiḥ — which serve as boats (in name only)
    nau (boat) + nibha (resembling). Indra accuses Vraja of using a 'so-called boat'; the irony is that ritual sacrifice without recognition of Kṛṣṇa is itself the boat in name only. Gauḍīyas read this inversion as Indra's own diagnosis turning on him.
  • karma - mayaiḥ — based on fruitive activity
    karma + mayaḥ (consisting of). Indra defends ritualism — exactly the path Kṛṣṇa supplants when He instructs Nanda in the previous chapter to worship Govardhana instead. The verse exposes Indra's investment in karma-kāṇḍa.
  • ānvīkṣikīm — spiritual (knowledge)
    Traditionally 'logical science of the self.' Indra claims Vraja has abandoned ātma-vidyā for blind faith. The chapter inverts this: Vraja's direct surrender is the highest ātma-jñāna, and Indra's 'knowledge' is the abandonment.
Their taking shelter of Kṛṣṇa is just like the foolish attempt of men who abandon transcendental knowledge of the self and instead try to cross over the great ocean of material existence in the false boats of fruitive, ritual sacrifices.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Their taking shelter of Kṛṣṇa is just like the foolish attempt of men who abandon transcendental knowledge of the self and instead try to cross over the great ocean of material existence in the false boats of fruitive, ritual sacrifices.
Commentary

As vaisnavas desire to cross the ocean of material existence and thus take shelter of Krsna, rejecting the quest for knowledge of Brahman, these cowherd men have become absorbed in a sacrifice as a boat to cross the ocean, which cannot do so (adrdhaih). One should not attempt to cross the ocean by taking shelter of Krsna, hoping to reduce the size of the ocean to size of a calf’s hoofprint. But they desire to do so.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Just as foolish people try to cross material existence by sacrifices which give temporary results (adṛḍhaih), the cowherds took shelter of Kṛṣṇa and offended me. This example shows that they acted unsuitably because of lack of discrimination. Or, just as the foolish give up knowledge and try to cross existence by temporary sacrifices, the cowherds gave up Indra’s worship and took shelter of Kṛṣṇa and are trying to cross material existence. Because of his great anger, he does not complete the sentence. The real meaning however is this. Just as the devotees give up impersonal knowledge along with sacrifices, and desire to cross existence simply by taking shelter of Kṛṣṇa, the cowherds gave up my worship and tried to cross material existence by taking shelter of him.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)
Related verses
Concepts
Bhava

Indra ridicules the cowherds for crossing saṁsāra in a 'boat' named Kṛṣṇa instead of one named yajña. He has inverted the truth exactly — the very Person on whose behalf yajña is performed (Bg 5.29, yajña-bhoktāram) is now being called the inferior boat.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 25