P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Maharaja Pracinabarhisat appeared in the lineage of Prthu. While his sons, the Pracetas, were performing austerities in the water, he was busily engaged in mundane, material affairs. Narada Muni appeared on the scene and spiritually enlightened him through an allegory involving a character named Puranjana (the soul), who resides within the city of nine gates (the body). The powerful story instigated a profound existential awakening within the King, who realised how materially entrenched he had become.
Previous Strong Next Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita
Last updated 1 year ago
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Maharaja Pracinabarhisat appeared in the lineage of Prthu. While his sons, the Pracetas, were performing austerities in the water, he was busily engaged in mundane, material affairs. Narada Muni appeared on the scene and spiritually enlightened him through an allegory involving a character named Puranjana (the soul), who resides within the city of nine gates (the body). The powerful story instigated a profound existential awakening within the King, who realised how materially entrenched he had become.
Previous Strong Next Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita
Last updated 1 year ago
Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita
Chapter 24
Maitreya continued by discussing the descendants in the family of Prthu. When he came to Pracinabarhisat and his ten sons, the Pracetas, he paused to narrate more.
When requested by their father to procreate, the Pracetas first went to practise austerities for 10,000 years in the water. En route, they met Lord Siva who taught them a series of beautiful prayers known as the Rudra-gita. In these prayers, one first offers respects to the four expansions of Vishnu and the presiding deities of various elements, after which the Lord’s glorious form is described, along with the super-excellence of bhakti .
Siva was taught this prayer by Lord Brahma, and he encouraged the Pracetas to attentively recite it with great devotion.
Previous P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31) Next Puranjana Story
Last updated 1 year ago
Pracetas Rule
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Pracetas Rule
Chapter 30, 31
Maitreya next reverted back to the activities of the Pracetas after they had completed their 10,000 years of austerity. [ 14 ]
Satisfied by their cooperation, friendship and austerity, the Lord appeared before the Pracetas and glorified their activities. He instructed them to marry, procreate and become exemplars of bhakti in householder life. Having received this instruction, the Pracetas offered eloquent prayers to the Lord and begged to remain in the association of Vaisnavas so they could always hear about Krishna.
When the Pracetas emerged from the water, they saw that the earth was covered with overgrown trees, preventing progressive agriculture and farming of the land. In anger, they generated fire from their mouths and began burning everything up so that the earth would be cleared for cultivation. After Brahma pacified them, they married Marisa, the daughter of Pamaloca, who was left in the care of the trees. Daksa, who had offended Siva, was reborn from their union.
The Pracetas ruled for thousands of years, and then decided to renounce it all. They left Marisa in the care of Daksa and departed the kingdom for a life of spiritual absorption. After reaching their destination, they chanced upon Narada Muni, who instructed them to perform undiverted bhakti , which captures the Lord in the heart.
Previous Pracinabarhisat Attains Perfection Next Priyavrata – Elder Son of Manu
Last updated 1 year ago
Pracinabarhisat Attains Perfection
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Pracinabarhisat Attains Perfection
Chapter 29
Pracinabarhisat humbly admitted that he didn’t completely understand the deep purport of the story. Narada Muni thus elaborated on the allegory and comprehensively detailed how the conditioned soul becomes entangled in material life. Narada thus urged the King to renounce material activity and cultivate his spiritual life.
He then narrated the allegory of a deer to invoke a further sense of urgency within Pracinabarhisat – the deer is grazing and enjoying the charming atmosphere, completely oblivious to the fact that a tiger is about to devour it. Narada reminded him that death was fast approaching, and his consciousness at that crucial hour would determine his next life situation. He specifically explained how the subtle body carries the soul to its next destination.
When the King submitted that his illusion was over, Narada Muni happily left for Siddhaloka. Pracinabarhisat then handed over the kingdom to his sons and went to Kapilasrama to pursue spiritual perfection, which he eventually attained.
Previous Puranjana Story Next Pracetas Rule
Last updated 1 year ago
Priyavrata – Elder Son of Manu
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Priyavrata – Elder Son of Manu
Chapter 31
Having concluded the narration of Uttanapada (the younger son of Svayambhuva Manu) and his descendants, Sukadeva Goswami prepared himself to describe the activities of Priyavrata (the older son of Svayambhuva Manu) and his descendants.
Vidura and Maitreya’s conversation thus reached its conclusion. Feeling inspired and purified by the exchange, Vidura fell at Maitreya’s feet and offered all respect and thanks. He then left for the city of Hastinapura to see his relatives and deliver transcendental knowledge to his brother. [ 15 ]
Previous Pracetas Rule Next Root of Devotion
Last updated 1 year ago
Puranjana Story
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Puranjana Story
Chapter 25, 26, 27, 28
While performing their austerities, the Pracetas happily recited the prayers. Meanwhile, their father, King Pracinabarhisat, was engrossed in materialistic endeavours and oblivious to the spiritual dimension of life. The itinerant preacher, Narada Muni, arrived on the scene and resolved to philosophically enlighten the King through the allegorical story of Puranjana.
Long ago, a King named Puranjana was looking for a suitable place to fulfil his desires, when he chanced upon a beautiful city which had nine gates and all the necessary facilities. This, he thought, was the ideal place. Accompanied by his friend, Avijnata, he entered that city, and later became attracted by Puranjani, a woman who had ten servants. After marriage, she faithfully arranged varieties of material pleasures in the city for one hundred years, during which time the King became completely henpecked.
Explanation: Wandering in the material world, the spirit soul (Puranjana) accepts a material body (city of nine gates). Though accompanied by the Supersoul (Avijnata), his attention is attracted by mundane religiosity and sense gratification (Puranjani). He thus wastes his valuable years in temporary pleasures that amount to nothing.
Once, Puranjana abandoned his wife and went on a hunting excursion, indiscriminately killing many innocent animals on his journey. Hungry and thirsty, he eagerly returned to the palace, only to find the Queen lying on the ground looking depressed and emaciated. He regretted leaving her and sought forgiveness for his nefarious activities. Being pacified, the Queen regained her luster and enjoyed sexual union with him. The King begot 1,100 sons and 110 daughters, who were duly married and had their own children, and thus the city became populated. Puranjana became tormented by family demands and was plundered due to his attachments.
Explanation: Sometimes, one gives up his religiosity and intelligence (abandoning Puranjani), and hedonistically runs after the opposite sex (hunting animals). Frustrated by such whimsical attempts for pleasure, one returns, repents, and regains their good sense. They again adopt a pious life, but remain absorbed in material pursuits (sexual union with Puranjani). The activities of such bewildered souls produce a network of karmic reactions which bind them to the material world (expanding family of Puranjana).
Some years later, when King Chandavega and his soldiers attacked, a five- hooded snake attempted to defend the city. Puranjana, himself absorbed in sense gratification, paid little attention to the attack, while the serpent was becoming weaker and weaker. Kalakanya was Chandavega’s daughter, and she was renowned for discretely attacking people. She entered the city with her associates and embraced Puranjana, while her other associates wreaked havoc. When the situation deteriorated, the city was set ablaze and the King was forced to leave, embroiled in thoughts of his family and wife. After leaving the city, Puranjana was tormented by all the animals that he had mercilessly killed earlier in his life.
Explanation: The body is eventually attacked by time (Chandavega) and our life energy (five-hooded snake) is depleted. Being preoccupied with material endeavours, old age eventually arrives (Kalakanya), almost imperceptibly, along with diseases, fear and ill-fate. The body gradually dwindles and thus becomes uninhabitable (city is set ablaze), and the soul is forced to leave, absorbed in thoughts of various attachments and desires (worry for family and dependents). Moving to the next chapter of existence, the soul is subjected to a series of karmic reactions for his misdeeds (attack of animals).
Because he remembered his wife, Puranjana went on to become the daughter of King Vidarbha (Vaidarbhi), and was married to Malayadhvaja. After Vaidarbhi gave birth to children, Malayadhvaja retired from household life and dedicated himself to spiritual pursuits. Vaidarbhi followed him, and when he died, she arranged his funeral pyre and prepared to enter the fire. Just then, an old brahmana friend of Puranjana came and questioned her. He said that they were old friends, but she had forgotten him, having engaged in the illusory relationships and activities of this world.
Explanation: If one is fortunate, they receive the seed of bhakti from a spiritual master (Malayadhvaja) and this gives rise to the practice of devotional service (birth of children). Those practices of bhakti expand unlimitedly (further children), and when one is mature, the spiritual master retires (Malayadhvaja renounces). The disciple always follows in the footsteps of the spiritual master, and is constantly absorbed in the fire of following his instructions. The Lord (old brahmana friend) appears before such a dedicated devotee and enlightens him with the knowledge necessary to return to the spiritual world.
Narada thus concluded the allegorical story.
Previous Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita Next Pracinabarhisat Attains Perfection
Last updated 1 year ago
Root of Devotion
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Root of Devotion
“The topmost benediction for those who are living in this material world and are subjected to the repetition of birth and death (transmigration) is association with pure devotees. One should search out such pure devotees and remain with them. That will make one completely happy, even though living within the material world. This Krishna consciousness movement is started for that purpose. A person who is overly affected materially may take advantage of this movement and become intimately associated with it. In this way the confused and frustrated inhabitants of this material world may find the highest happiness in association with devotees.” ( SB 4.30.34 )
Maharaja Pracinabarhisat was rescued from the depths of material entanglement and transported to the summit of spiritual absorption. We see this incredible transformation in many of Srimad-Bhagavatam’s personalities, and may have even witnessed similar things in the lives of those around us. If we pause for thought, we can appreciate it even in our own lives.
What is the root cause which triggers a spiritual turnaround?
Previous Priyavrata – Elder Son of Manu Next The Beginning
Last updated 1 year ago
Proofreaders of Devotion
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Root of Devotion
Proofreaders of Devotion
“I don’t read the book, I read the author. I first check whether the author is authentic. Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura trained me in proofreading, so I always look for what is right or wrong. But I am not a proofreader of the press only; I am a proofreader of the world. I proofread men; I proofread religions. I dissect their faults and try to correct them.” (Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Thakura)
Devotees undoubtedly give us entrance into spiritual life, but they are also absolutely necessary if we want to progressively continue our journey. While writing the story of our life, we need proofreaders by our side.
Brevity – give any piece of writing to an editor and they’ll likely compress several long paragraphs into a few short lines. They reveal the substance, and leave the rest by the wayside. In the same way, saintly persons can reveal the true substance of our spirituality. We may overembellish and exaggerate the truth, but when we appear before a transcendental proofreader, the degree of genuine sincerity, quality and devotion in our spirituality becomes strikingly apparent.
Accuracy – when we pen down our thoughts, there may be mistakes in grammar, spelling and sentence formation. Proofreaders can detect, fix and ensure a smooth read. In the same way, our lives are riddled with mistakes – risky misconceptions, bad decisions, false assumptions and unhelpful attitudes. Saintly persons can detect these problems and fix them before they begin to impede our progressive journey in the story of life.
Clarity – writers know what they mean but people can easily misinterpret. Proofreaders ensure that the well-intentioned meaning of the author is not misconstrued by the reader. In the same way, we may adopt a sincere and noble approach in spiritual life, but be unaware of things that may be detrimental and counterproductive to what we are trying to achieve. Proofreaders stand external to the picture of our life and flag up potentially injurious behaviours that we are oblivious to.
Potency – even if a piece of writing is substantial, accurate and clear, a proofreader may well reword it to communicate the same, but with greater force and clarity. Saintly persons can, in the same way, show us a more efficient, effective and powerful way to lead our lives. We may not be doing anything wrong, but they can reveal a more effective way of reaching our goals and realising our dreams. It’s easy to get stuck into the standard ways of living and functioning, becoming averse to new approaches to life.
As years go by, we get tempted to start flying solo. We should, however, always stop and consider: who is proofreading my life?
Previous Why is this Important? Next R.E.A.P
Last updated 1 year ago
The Beginning
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Root of Devotion
The Beginning
In Madhurya Kadambini, Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura scientifically analyses the soul’s spiritual journey. He systematically delineates a sequence of eight stages that a sincere and serious practitioner will progress through before arriving at the ultimate goal, pure love of God ( prema ). Before describing the journey, Visvanatha Chakravarti spends considerable time discussing how one begins that spiritual journey.
Our attraction for devotional activities (which is carried from previous lives) impels us towards further execution of those devotional activities in this life. That subsequent execution further increases one’s attraction. But where does the initial attraction come from? During our material sojourn, what is the turning point at which one begins cultivating their relationship with God? How is that seed of bhakti implanted within the heart?
Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura explores a variety of options. Some may posit that the cause of bhakti is good fortune. Such an explanation is inconclusive, since the question remains as to how that good fortune arises. Others may propose that the cause of bhakti is good karma and pious activity. This is unacceptable since piety is still a material activity, and how could something material be the cause of something divinely spiritual? Some may posit that Krishna is the cause of bhakti . But then we face another problem since Krishna says “I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all.” ( BG 9.29 ). With that in mind, why would He bestow good fortune on some and not others?
In a deeply realised and illuminating fashion, Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura reveals that the journey to pure love ultimately begins when one contacts a devotee of Krishna: “ The root cause of devotional service to Lord Krishna is association with advanced devotees. Even when one’s dormant love for Krishna awakens, association with devotees is still most essential.” ( CC Madhya 22.83 )
Since Vaisnavas have bhakti implanted within their hearts, they are impelled and equipped to give it to others, and in this way instigate the spiritual journey of another. Thus, in the deepest sense, bhakti is the cause of bhakti . Although this analysis may seem deeply philosophical, it’s incredibly practical and simple. We have all experienced that even ordinary love can’t be bought, forced, or manufactured. It is the product of an individual’s free will and desire. Only love creates love, and only divine love creates divine love. So, if we want divine love, we must encounter someone who has it. If we are fortunate to meet such a person, and receptive enough to accept that divine gift, our spiritual journey begins.
Previous Root of Devotion Next Why is this Important?
Last updated 1 year ago
Why is this Important?
P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
Root of Devotion
Why is this Important?
Knowing that saintly association is the root cause of devotion is invaluable information. Firstly, it helps us develop a deep sense of gratitude and appreciation for Vaisnavas. Anyone who is on the spiritual journey, and has awakened bhakti in their heart is special indeed. They have the potential to transform people’s lives, and they should be honoured and valued with utmost appreciation. Secondly, it gives us a clue as to how we can instigate spiritual change in the world. As we find bigger and better ways to expose the masses of people to saintly association of Vaisnavas, we can rest assured that hearts will be touched and transformed. Thirdly, and a little closer to home, we can appreciate that if we fill our lives with the quality association of Vaisnavas, then advancement on the spiritual path is assured.
Previous The Beginning Next Proofreaders of Devotion
Last updated 1 year ago
नारदउवाच
सैनिका भयनाम्नो ये बर्हिष्मन् दिष्टकारिण: ।
प्रज्वारकालकन्याभ्यां
विचेरुरवनीमिमाम् ॥ १ ॥
nārada uvāca
[naarada uvaacha]
sainikā bhaya-nāmno ye
[sainikaa bhaya-naamno ye]
barhiṣman diṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ
[barhishman dishta-kaarinah]
prajvāra-kāla-kanyābhyāṁ
[prajvaara-kaala-kanyaabhyaam]
vicerur avanīm imām
[vicherur avaneem imaam]
Word-for-word
nāradaḥ uvāca—the great sage Nārada continued to speaksainikāḥ—the soldiersbhaya-nāmnaḥ—of Bhaya (Fear)ye—all of them whobarhiṣman—O King Prācīnabarhiṣatdiṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ—the order carriers of deathprajvāra—with Prajvārakāla-kanyābhyām—and with Kālakanyāviceruḥ—traveledavanīm—on earthimām—this.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
nārada uvāca
nāradaḥ uvāca
the great sage Nārada continued to speak
sainikā bhaya-nāmno ye
sainikāḥ
the soldiers
bhaya-nāmnaḥ
of Bhaya (Fear)
ye
all of them who
barhiṣman diṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ
barhiṣman
O King Prācīnabarhiṣat
diṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ
the order carriers of death
prajvāra-kāla-kanyābhyāṁ
prajvāra
with Prajvāra
kāla-kanyābhyām
and with Kālakanyā
vicerur avanīm imām
viceruḥ
traveled
avanīm
on earth
imām
this.
The great sage Nārada continued: My dear King Prācīnabarhiṣat, afterward the King of the Yavanas, whose name is fear itself, as well as Prajvāra, Kālakanyā, and his soldiers, began to travel all over the world.
Purport
The period of life just prior to death is certainly very dangerous because usually at this time people are attacked by the weakness of old age as well as many kinds of disease. The diseases that attack the body are compared here to soldiers. These soldiers are not ordinary soldiers, for they are guided by the King of the Yavanas, who acts as their commander-in-chief. The word diṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ indicates that he is their commander. When a man is young, he does not care for old age but enjoys sex to the best of his satisfaction, not knowing that at the end of life his sexual indulgence will bring on various diseases, which so much disturb the body that one will pray for immediate death. The more one enjoys sex during youth, the more he suffers in old age.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Nārada said: O King Prācīnabarhiṣat! The soldiers of Fear, the fulfillers of karma, along with Prajvāra and the old age, began to travel the earth.
The Twenty-eighth Chapter describes how, leaving the worn-out city with his wife, Purañjana attained bhakti by the influence of devotees.
Now the method of giving up the gross body is described until the twenty-fourth verse. The soldiers are various diseases. Diṣṭa-kāriṇaḥ means those who bestow the bad reactions of one’s deeds.
Fear-king, Prajvāra, Kālakanyā and the soldiers traveled the world. The trio of forces — fear, fever, old age — campaigns globally; no one is exempt from their reach.
Reflection Questions
Where do I imagine I'm immune from a campaign that's universal?
What does naming the trio's reach do to my planning?
त एकदा तु रभसा पुरञ्जनपुरीं नृप ।
रुरुधुर्भौमभोगाढ्यां
जरत्पन्नगपालिताम् ॥ २ ॥
ta ekadā tu rabhasā
[ta ekadaa tu rabhasaa]
purañjana-purīṁ nṛpa
[puranjana-pureem nripa]
rurudhur bhauma-bhogāḍhyāṁ
[rurudhur bhauma-bhogaadhyaam]
jarat-pannaga-pālitām
[jarat-pannaga-paalitaam]
Word-for-word
te—theyekadā—once upon a timetu—thenrabhasā—with great forcepurañjana-purīm—the city of Purañjananṛpa—O Kingrurudhuḥ—encircledbhauma-bhoga-āḍhyām—full of sense enjoymentsjarat—oldpannaga—by the serpentpālitām—protected.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ta ekadā tu rabhasā
te
they
ekadā
once upon a time
tu
then
rabhasā
with great force
purañjana-purīṁ nṛpa
purañjana-purīm
the city of Purañjana
nṛpa
O King
rurudhur bhauma-bhogāḍhyāṁ
rurudhuḥ
encircled
bhauma-bhoga-āḍhyām
full of sense enjoyments
jarat-pannaga-pālitām
jarat
old
pannaga
by the serpent
pālitām
protected.
Once the dangerous soldiers attacked the city of Purañjana with great force. Although the city was full of paraphernalia for sense gratification, it was being protected by the old serpent.
Purport
As one’s body engages in sense gratification, it becomes weaker and weaker daily. Finally the vital force becomes so weak that it is herein compared to a weak serpent. The life air has already been compared to the serpent. When the vital force within the body becomes weak, the body itself also becomes weak. At such a time the death symptoms — that is, the dangerous soldiers of death’s superintendent, Yamarāja — begin to attack very severely. According to the Vedic system, before coming to such a stage one should leave home and take sannyāsa to preach the message of God for the duration of life. However, if one sits at home and is served by his beloved wife and children, he certainly becomes weaker and weaker due to sense gratification. When death finally comes, one leaves the body devoid of spiritual assets. At the present time, even the oldest man in the family does not leave home, being attracted by wife, children, money, opulence, dwelling, etc. Thus at the end of life one worries about how his wife will be protected and how she will manage the great family responsibilities. In this way a man usually thinks of his wife before death. According to Bhagavad-gītā (8.6) :
yaṁ yaṁ vāpi smaran bhāvaṁ tyajaty ante kalevaram taṁ tam evaiti kaunteya sadā tad-bhāva-bhāvitaḥ
“Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail.”
At the end of life, a person thinks of what he has done throughout his whole life; thus he gets another body ( dehāntara ) according to his thoughts and desires at the end of life. One overly addicted to life at home naturally thinks of his beloved wife at the end of life. Consequently, in the next life he gets the body of a woman, and he also acquires the results of his pious or impious activities. In this chapter the acceptance of a woman’s body by King Purañjana will be thoroughly explained.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Once, they forcefully besieged the city of Purañjana, full of material enjoyment, which was protected by the old snake.
The city was protected by a worn-out life air.
His Holiness Kesava Bharati Das Goswami· 2013-02-11· English
Personal Guidance
The soldiers attacked the city with force; the old serpent (vital force) still protected it. The defenders hold the line longer than expected; thank them while they fight.
Reflection Questions
Whose protection of me am I taking for granted because it's quiet and constant?
kāla-kanyā—the daughter of Kālaapi—alsobubhuje—took possession ofpurañjana-puram—the city of Purañjanabalāt—by forceyayā—by whomabhibhūtaḥ—being overwhelmedpuruṣaḥ—a personsadyaḥ—immediatelyniḥsāratām—uselessnessiyāt—gets.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kāla-kanyāpi bubhuje
kāla-kanyā
the daughter of Kāla
api
also
bubhuje
took possession of
purañjana-puraṁ balāt
purañjana-puram
the city of Purañjana
balāt
by force
yayābhibhūtaḥ puruṣaḥ
yayā
by whom
abhibhūtaḥ
being overwhelmed
puruṣaḥ
a person
sadyo niḥsāratām iyāt
sadyaḥ
immediately
niḥsāratām
uselessness
iyāt
gets.
Gradually Kālakanyā, with the help of dangerous soldiers, attacked all the inhabitants of Purañjana’s city and thus rendered them useless for all purposes.
Purport
At the fag end of life, when the invalidity of old age attacks a man, his body becomes useless for all purposes. Therefore Vedic training dictates that when a man is in his boyhood he should be trained in the process of brahmacarya — that is, he should be completely engaged in the service of the Lord and should not in any way associate with women. When the boy becomes a young man, he marries between the ages of twenty and twenty-five. When he is married at the right age, he can immediately beget strong, healthy sons. Now female descendants are increasing because young men are very weak sexually. A male child will be born if the husband is sexually stronger than the wife, but if the female is stronger, a female child will be born. Thus it is essential to practice the system of brahmacarya if one wishes to beget a male child when one is married. When one reaches the age of fifty, he should give up family life. At that time one’s child should be grown up so that the father can leave the family responsibilities to him. The husband and wife may then go abroad to live a retired life and travel to different places of pilgrimage. When both the husband and wife lose their attachment for family and home, the wife returns home to live under the care of her grown-up children and to remain aloof from family affairs. The husband then takes sannyāsa to render some service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
This is the perfect system of civilization. The human form of life is especially meant for God realization. If one is unable to take to the process of Kṛṣṇa consciousness from the very beginning of life, he must be trained to accept these principles at the fag end of life. Unfortunately, there is no training even in childhood, nor can one give up his family life even at the end. This is the situation with the city of Purañjana, figuratively described in these verses.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The daughter of Time, old age, who overpowers a person and makes him immediately useless, took possession of that city by force
His Holiness Janananda Goswami· 2020-01-27· English
Personal Guidance
Kālakanyā with soldiers rendered the inhabitants useless. Old age progressively retires the body's working components; usefulness expires section by section.
Reflection Questions
Which part of my body has already retired that I'm pretending is still operational?
Where could I gracefully accept the retirement of one capacity and shift to another?
tayā—by Kālakanyāupabhujyamānām—being taken possession ofvai—certainlyyavanāḥ—the Yavanassarvataḥ-diśam—from all sidesdvārbhiḥ—through the gatespraviśya—having enteredsu-bhṛśam—greatlyprārdayan—giving troublesakalām—all overpurīm—the city.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tayopabhujyamānāṁ vai
tayā
by Kālakanyā
upabhujyamānām
being taken possession of
vai
certainly
yavanāḥ sarvato-diśam
yavanāḥ
the Yavanas
sarvataḥ-diśam
from all sides
dvārbhiḥ praviśya subhṛśaṁ
dvārbhiḥ
through the gates
praviśya
having entered
su-bhṛśam
greatly
prārdayan sakalāṁ purīm
prārdayan
giving trouble
sakalām
all over
purīm
the city.
When Kālakanyā, daughter of Time, attacked the body, the dangerous soldiers of the King of the Yavanas entered the city through different gates. They then began to give severe trouble to all the citizens.
Purport
The body has nine gates: the two eyes, two nostrils, two ears, mouth, rectum and genitals. When one is harassed by the invalidity of old age, various diseases manifest at the gates of the body. For example, the eyes become so dim that one requires spectacles, and the ears become too weak to hear directly, and therefore one requires hearing aids. The nostrils are blocked by mucus, and one has to always sniff a medicinal bottle containing ammonia. Similarly, the mouth, too weak to chew, requires false teeth. The rectum also gives one trouble, and the evacuation process becomes difficult. Sometimes one has to take enemas and sometimes use a surgical nozzle to accelerate the passing of urine. In this way the city of Purañjana was attacked at various gates by the soldiers. Thus in old age all the gates of the body are blocked by so many diseases, and one has to take help from so many medicines and surgical appliances.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When she took possession of that city, the Yavanas then entered the city through the gates on all sides and caused great affliction to the whole city.
The diseases entered through the eyes and other openings.
His Holiness Yadunanadana Swami· 2010-05-20· English
Personal Guidance
Soldiers entered through the nine gates and gave trouble to all citizens. The body's nine portals are the entry points for disease; what enters there enters everywhere.
Reflection Questions
Which gate of my body is currently the weakest entry point for trouble?
Where could I strengthen one gate this season as a discipline?
तस्यां प्रपीड्यमानायामभिमानी पुरञ्जन: ।
अवापोरुविधांस्तापान् कुटुम्बी ममताकुल: ॥ ५ ॥
tasyāṁ prapīḍyamānāyām
[tasyaam prapeedyamaanaayaam]
abhimānī purañjanaḥ
[abhimaanee puranjanah]
avāporu-vidhāṁs tāpān
[avaaporu-vidhaams taapaan]
kuṭumbī mamatākulaḥ
[kutumbee mamataakulah]
Word-for-word
tasyām—when the cityprapīḍyamānāyām—was put into different difficultiesabhimānī—too much absorbedpurañjanaḥ—King Purañjanaavāpa—achieveduru—manyvidhān—varietiestāpān—painskuṭumbī—family manmamatā-ākulaḥ—too much affected by attachment to family.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tasyāṁ prapīḍyamānāyām
tasyām
when the city
prapīḍyamānāyām
was put into different difficulties
abhimānī purañjanaḥ
abhimānī
too much absorbed
purañjanaḥ
King Purañjana
avāporu-vidhāṁs tāpān
avāpa
achieved
uru
many
vidhān
varieties
tāpān
pains
kuṭumbī mamatākulaḥ
kuṭumbī
family man
mamatā-ākulaḥ
too much affected by attachment to family.
When the city was thus endangered by the soldiers and Kālakanyā, King Purañjana, being overly absorbed in affection for his family, was placed in difficulty by the attack of Yavana-rāja and Kālakanyā.
Purport
When we refer to the body, we include the external gross body with its various limbs, as well as the mind, intelligence and ego. In old age these all become weak when they are attacked by different diseases. The proprietor of the body, the living soul, becomes very sad at not being able to use the field of activities properly. In Bhagavad-gītā it is clearly explained that the living entity is the proprietor of this body ( kṣetra-jña ) and that the body is the field of activities ( kṣetra ). When a field is overgrown with thorns and weeds, it becomes very difficult for the owner to work it. That is the position of the spirit soul when the body itself becomes a burden due to disease. Extra burdens are placed on the body in the form of anxiety and general deterioration of the bodily functions.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When the city was suffering, Purañjana, identifying with the city, overcome with possessiveness for family, underwent a great variety of pains.
Abhimānī means that he completely identified with the city.
His Holiness Mahavishnu Swami· 2020-01-29· English
Personal Guidance
Absorbed in family affection, Purañjana was placed in difficulty. The deepest absorptions hurt most when they're disrupted; family-attachment compounds the suffering.
Reflection Questions
Where would my attachment to family deepen my suffering if it were disrupted?
What level of dispassion would actually be a kindness to myself?
kanyā—by the daughter of Timeupagūḍhaḥ—being embracednaṣṭa-śrīḥ—bereft of all beautykṛpaṇaḥ—miserviṣaya-ātmakaḥ—addicted to sense gratificationnaṣṭa-prajñaḥ—bereft of intelligencehṛta-aiśvaryaḥ—bereft of opulencegandharva—by the Gandharvasyavanaiḥ—and by the Yavanasbalāt—by force.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kanyopagūḍho naṣṭa-śrīḥ
kanyā
by the daughter of Time
upagūḍhaḥ
being embraced
naṣṭa-śrīḥ
bereft of all beauty
kṛpaṇo viṣayātmakaḥ
kṛpaṇaḥ
miser
viṣaya-ātmakaḥ
addicted to sense gratification
naṣṭa-prajño hṛtaiśvaryo
naṣṭa-prajñaḥ
bereft of intelligence
hṛta-aiśvaryaḥ
bereft of opulence
gandharva-yavanair balāt
gandharva
by the Gandharvas
yavanaiḥ
and by the Yavanas
balāt
by force.
When King Purañjana was embraced by Kālakanyā, he gradually lost all his beauty. Having been too much addicted to sex, he became very poor in intelligence and lost all his opulence. Being bereft of all possessions, he was conquered forcibly by the Gandharvas and the Yavanas.
Purport
When a person is attacked by the invalidity of old age and is still addicted to sense gratification, he gradually loses all his personal beauty, intelligence and good possessions. He thus cannot resist the forceful attack of the daughter of Time.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Embraced by old age, bereft of beauty, miserable, thinking of enjoyment, his wisdom and wealth destroyed, he saw his city being violently smashed by the Gandharvas and Yavanas, and saw that his sons, grandsons, followers, ministers and wife had become indifferent, disrespectful and were acting adversely.
Viśīrṇām should be viśīryamānām (being destroyed.) Pratikūlān means they acted adversely, against their natures—they were subject to lamentation and other distresses. They did not respect him (anādṛtān). The sons are discernment and other such qualities. The grandsons are patience and other qualities. The followers are the senses and the ministers are the controlling deities of mind and senses. The word ca indicates that they could not at all perform their functions (gata-sauhṛdān) and as well, the wife, intelligence had no power of apprehension.
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2010-05-22· English
Personal Guidance
Embraced by Kālakanyā, his beauty faded, intelligence weakened, opulence vanished; he was conquered. Sex addiction past prime makes all losses simultaneous; the package deal is brutal.
Reflection Questions
Where is one habit currently producing simultaneous losses I haven't bundled in my analysis?
What single root would, if pulled, reduce many surface symptoms?
विशीर्णां स्वपुरीं वीक्ष्य प्रतिकूलाननादृतान् ।
पुत्रान् पौत्रानुगामात्याञ्जायां च गतसौहृदाम् ॥ ७ ॥
viśīrṇāṁ sva-purīṁ vīkṣya
[visheernaam sva-pureem veekshya]
pratikūlān anādṛtān
[pratikoolaan anaadritaan]
putrān pautrānugāmātyāṣ
[putraan pautraanugaamaatyaash]
jāyāṁ ca gata-sauhṛdām
[jaayaam cha gata-sauhridaam]
Word-for-word
viśīrṇām—scatteredsva-purīm—his own townvīkṣya—seeingpratikūlān—opposing elementsanādṛtān—being disrespectfulputrān—sonspautra—grandsonsanuga—servantsamātyān—ministersjāyām—wifeca—andgata-sauhṛdām—indifferent.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
viśīrṇāṁ sva-purīṁ vīkṣya
viśīrṇām
scattered
sva-purīm
his own town
vīkṣya
seeing
pratikūlān anādṛtān
pratikūlān
opposing elements
anādṛtān
being disrespectful
putrān pautrānugāmātyāṣ
putrān
sons
pautra
grandsons
anuga
servants
amātyān
ministers
jāyāṁ ca gata-sauhṛdām
jāyām
wife
ca
and
gata-sauhṛdām
indifferent.
King Purañjana then saw that everything in his town was scattered and that his sons, grandsons, servants and ministers were all gradually opposing him. He also noted that his wife was becoming cold and indifferent.
Purport
When one becomes an invalid, his senses and organs are weakened. In other words, they are no longer under one’s control. The senses and sense objects then begin to oppose him. When a person is in a distressed condition, even his family members — his sons, grandsons and wife — become disrespectful. They no longer are under the command of the master of the house. Just as we wish to use our senses for sense gratification, the senses also require strength from the body in reciprocation. A man keeps a family for enjoyment, and similarly family members demand enjoyment from the head of the family. When they do not receive sufficient money from him, they grow disinterested and ignore his commands or desires. This is all due to one’s being a kṛpaṇa (miser). This word kṛpaṇa, used in the sixth verse, is in opposition to the word brāhmaṇa. In the human form of life one should become a brāhmaṇa, which means that one should understand the constitutional position of the Absolute Truth, Brahman, and then engage in His service as a Vaiṣṇava. We get this facility in the human form of life, but if we do not properly utilize this opportunity, we become a kṛpaṇa, miser. A miser is one who gets money but does not spend it properly. This human form of life is especially meant for understanding Brahman, for becoming a brāhmaṇa, and if we do not utilize it properly, we remain a kṛpaṇa. We can actually see that when one has money but does not spend it, he remains a miser and is never happy. Similarly, when one’s intelligence is spoiled due to sense gratification, he remains a miser throughout his life.
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2010-05-24· English
Personal Guidance
Town scattered, sons and grandsons gradually opposing, wife cold and indifferent. Internal organs and faculties go from cooperative to oppositional; even your own body turns against you.
Reflection Questions
Whose 'opposition from within' — a body part, a faculty — am I currently negotiating with?
Where am I treating it as enemy when it's just exhausted?
आत्मानं कन्यया ग्रस्तं पञ्चालानरिदूषितान् ।
दुरन्तचिन्तामापन्नो न लेभे तत्प्रतिक्रियाम् ॥ ८ ॥
ātmānaṁ kanyayā grastaṁ
[aatmaanam kanyayaa grastam]
pañcālān ari-dūṣitān
[panchaalaan ari-dooshitaan]
duranta-cintām āpanno
[duranta-chintaam aapanno]
na lebhe tat-pratikriyām
[na lebhe tat-pratikriyaam]
Word-for-word
ātmānam—himselfkanyayā—by Kālakanyāgrastam—being embracedpañcālān—Pañcālaari-dūṣitān—infected by the enemiesduranta—insurmountablecintām—anxietyāpannaḥ—having obtainedna—notlebhe—achievedtat—of thatpratikriyām—counteraction.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ātmānaṁ kanyayā grastaṁ
ātmānam
himself
kanyayā
by Kālakanyā
grastam
being embraced
pañcālān ari-dūṣitān
pañcālān
Pañcāla
ari-dūṣitān
infected by the enemies
duranta
insurmountable
duranta-cintām āpanno
cintām
anxiety
āpannaḥ
having obtained
na lebhe tat-pratikriyām
na
not
lebhe
achieved
tat
of that
pratikriyām
counteraction.
When King Purañjana saw that all his family members, relatives, followers, servants, secretaries and everyone else had turned against him, he certainly became very anxious. But he could not counteract the situation because he was thoroughly overwhelmed by Kālakanyā.
Purport
When a person becomes weak from the attack of old age, the family members, servants and secretaries do not care for him. He is then unable to counteract this. Thus he becomes more and more anxious and laments his frightful condition.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Seeing himself attacked by old age and the districts plundered by the enemy, he became very worried, but could not find a remedy.
He was attacked by old age (kanyayā) and the five sense objects were spoiled by diseases. He could find no cures by mantras or medicines.
Everyone turned against him; he became anxious but couldn't counteract Kālakanyā. Some losses can't be reversed by anxiety; old age must be received, not resisted.
Reflection Questions
Where am I anxiously trying to reverse what should be received?
What's the difference between productive concern and useless anxiety in this season?
कामानभिलषन्दीनोयातयामांश्चकन्यया ।
विगतात्मगतिस्नेह:पुत्रदारांश्चलालयन् ॥ ९ ॥
kāmān abhilaṣan dīno
[kaamaan abhilashan deeno]
yāta-yāmāṁś ca kanyayā
[yaata-yaamaamsh cha kanyayaa]
vigatātma-gati-snehaḥ
[vigataatma-gati-snehah]
putra-dārāṁś ca lālayan
[putra-daaraamsh cha laalayan]
Word-for-word
kāmān—objects of enjoymentabhilaṣan—always lusting afterdīnaḥ—the poor manyāta-yāmān—staleca—alsokanyayā—by the influence of Kālakanyāvigata—lostātma-gati—real purpose of lifesnehaḥ—attachment toputra—sonsdārān—wifeca—andlālayan—affectionately maintaining.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kāmān abhilaṣan dīno
kāmān
objects of enjoyment
abhilaṣan
always lusting after
dīnaḥ
the poor man
yāta-yāmāṁś ca kanyayā
yāta-yāmān
stale
ca
also
kanyayā
by the influence of Kālakanyā
vigatātma-gati-snehaḥ
vigata
lost
ātma-gati
real purpose of life
snehaḥ
attachment to
putra-dārāṁś ca lālayan
putra
sons
dārān
wife
ca
and
lālayan
affectionately maintaining.
The objects of enjoyment became stale by the influence of Kālakanyā. Due to the continuance of his lusty desires, King Purañjana became very poor in everything. Thus he did not understand the aim of life. He was still very affectionate toward his wife and children, and he worried about maintaining them.
Purport
This is exactly the position of present civilization. Everyone is engaged in maintaining the body, home and family. Consequently everyone becomes confused at the end of life, not knowing what spiritual life and the goal of human life are. In a civilization of sense gratification there cannot be spiritual life, because a person thinks only of this life. Although the next life is a fact, no information is given about it.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Though he desired to eat, the foods were useless. By the influence of old age, he was miserable, having lost a higher status in next life and having lost the affection of his sons and others in this life. But he remained affectionate to sons and wife.
He desires sweets but they were useless, since he could not digest them. He lost the goal of a better next life, and lost the goal of this life, affection from sons and family. Another version has snehāt. He was miserable because of losing life’s goal and the affection of his sons.
His Holiness Jayadvaita Swami· 2010-10-03· English
Personal Guidance
Enjoyment-objects became stale; lust persisted; he still worried about family and didn't understand life's aim. Stale enjoyment with persistent craving is a hellish loop; aim has to be rediscovered.
Reflection Questions
Which enjoyment in my life has gone stale while the craving remains?
Where do I substitute family-worry for the deeper question of life's aim?
गन्धर्वयवनाक्रान्तां कालकन्योपमर्दिताम् ।
हातुं प्रचक्रमे राजा तां पुरीमनिकामत: ॥ १० ॥
gandharva-yavanākrāntāṁ
[gandharva-yavanaakraantaam]
kāla-kanyopamarditām
[kaala-kanyopamarditaam]
hātuṁ pracakrame rājā
[haatum prachakrame raajaa]
tāṁ purīm anikāmataḥ
[taam pureem anikaamatah]
Word-for-word
gandharva—by the Gandharva soldiersyavana—and by the Yavana soldiersākrāntām—overcomekāla-kanyā—by Kālakanyā (the daughter of Time)upamarditām—being smashedhātum—to give uppracakrame—proceededrājā—King Purañjanatām—thatpurīm—the cityanikāmataḥ—unwilling.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
gandharva-yavanākrāntāṁ
gandharva
by the Gandharva soldiers
yavana
and by the Yavana soldiers
ākrāntām
overcome
kāla-kanyopamarditām
kāla-kanyā
by Kālakanyā (the daughter of Time)
upamarditām
being smashed
hātuṁ pracakrame rājā
hātum
to give up
pracakrame
proceeded
rājā
King Purañjana
tāṁ purīm anikāmataḥ
tām
that
purīm
the city
anikāmataḥ
unwilling.
The city of King Purañjana was overcome by the Gandharva and Yavana soldiers, and although the King had no desire to leave the city, he was circumstantially forced to do so, for it was smashed by Kālakanyā.
Purport
The living entity, separated from the association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, tries to enjoy this material world. He is given a chance to enjoy it in a particular type of body, beginning with the body of a Brahmā down to that of the microbe. From the Vedic history of creation we can understand that the first living creature was Lord Brahmā, who created the seven great sages and other Prajāpatis to increase the universal population. Thus every living entity, according to karma, his past desires and activities, gets a particular type of body, from that of Brahmā to that of a microbe or germ in stool. Due to long association with a particular type of material body and also due to the grace of Kālakanyā and her māyā, one becomes overly attached to a material body, although it is the abode of pain. Even if one tries to separate a worm from stool, the worm will be unwilling to leave. It will return to the stool. Similarly, a hog generally lives in a very filthy state, eating stool, but if one tries to separate it from its condition and give it a nice place, the hog will be unwilling. In this way if we study each and every living entity, we will find that he will defy offers of a more comfortable position. Although King Purañjana was attacked from all sides, he was unwilling to leave the city. In other words, the living entity — whatever his condition — does not want to give up the body. But he will be forced to give it up because, after all, this material body cannot exist forever.
The living entity wishes to enjoy the material world in different ways, and therefore by nature’s law he is allowed to transmigrate from one body to another, exactly as a person transmigrates from the body of an infant to a child to a boy to a youth to a man. This process is constantly going on. At the last stage, when the gross body becomes old and invalid, the living entity is reluctant to give it up, despite the fact that it is no longer usable. Although material existence and the material body are not comfortable, why does the living entity not want to leave? As soon as one gets a material body, he has to work very hard to maintain it. He may engage in different fields of activity, but whatever the case, everyone has to work very hard to maintain the material body. Unfortunately, society has no information of the soul’s transmigration. Because the living entity does not hope to enter the spiritual kingdom of eternal life, bliss and knowledge, he wants to stick to his present body, even though it may be useless. Consequently, the greatest welfare activity in this material world is the furthering of the Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement.
This movement is giving human society information about the kingdom of God. There is God, there is Kṛṣṇa, and everyone can return to God and live eternally in bliss and knowledge. A Kṛṣṇa conscious person is not afraid of giving up the body because his position is always eternal. A Kṛṣṇa conscious person engages in the transcendental loving service of the Lord eternally; therefore as long as he lives within the body, he is happy to engage in the loving service of the Lord, and when he gives up the body, he is also permanently situated in the service of the Lord. The saintly devotees are always free and liberated, whereas the karmīs, who have no knowledge of spiritual life or the transcendental loving service of the Lord, are very much afraid of giving up the rotten material body.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Though he did not desire to do, the King began to abandon the city which was being crushed by old age and attacked by the Gandharvas and Yavanas.
Anikāmataḥ means “though not desiring to do so.”
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2013-03-01· English
Personal Guidance
The city was overcome; though he didn't want to leave, he was forced out by Kālakanyā. Departure isn't optional eventually; the question is whether you arrange or are dragged.
Reflection Questions
Where am I refusing to arrange what will be forced anyway?
bhaya-nāmnaḥ—of Bhaya (Fear)agra-jaḥ—elderbhrātā—brotherprajvāraḥ—named Prajvārapratyupasthitaḥ—being present theredadāha—set firetām—to thatpurīm—citykṛtsnām—wholesalebhrātuḥ—his brotherpriya-cikīrṣayā—in order to please.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
bhaya-nāmno ’grajo bhrātā
bhaya-nāmnaḥ
of Bhaya (Fear)
agra-jaḥ
elder
bhrātā
brother
prajvāraḥ pratyupasthitaḥ
prajvāraḥ
named Prajvāra
pratyupasthitaḥ
being present there
dadāha tāṁ purīṁ kṛtsnāṁ
dadāha
set fire
tām
to that
purīm
city
kṛtsnām
wholesale
bhrātuḥ priya-cikīrṣayā
bhrātuḥ
his brother
priya-cikīrṣayā
in order to please.
Under the circumstances, the elder brother of Yavana-rāja, known as Prajvāra, set fire to the city to please his younger brother, whose other name is fear itself.
Purport
According to the Vedic system, a dead body is set on fire, but before death there is another fire, or fever, which is called prajvāra, or viṣṇu-jvāra. Medical science verifies that when one’s temperature is raised to 107 degrees, a man immediately dies. This prajvāra , or high fever, at the last stage of life places the living entity in the midst of a blazing fire.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Fear’s elder brother Prajvāra arrived and burned the city completely, desiring to please his brother.
Pravāraḥ is Viṣṇuvjāra.
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2010-05-28· English
Personal Guidance
Prajvāra (final fever) set fire to the city to please his younger brother (fear). The final illness is itself an offering to fear; the deathbed-fire is a recognized stage.
Reflection Questions
Where do I imagine illness as random when scripture treats it as part of the structured ending?
What would prepared receiving of one's final illness look like?
tasyām—when that citysandahyamānāyām—was ablazesa-pauraḥ—along with all the citizenssa-paricchadaḥ—along with all servants and followerskauṭumbikaḥ—the King, having so many relativeskuṭumbinyā—along with his wifeupātapyata—began to suffer the heat of the firesa-anvayaḥ—along with descendants.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tasyāṁ sandahyamānāyāṁ
tasyām
when that city
sandahyamānāyām
was ablaze
sapauraḥ saparicchadaḥ
sa-pauraḥ
along with all the citizens
sa-paricchadaḥ
along with all servants and followers
kauṭumbikaḥ kuṭumbinyā
kauṭumbikaḥ
the King, having so many relatives
kuṭumbinyā
along with his wife
upātapyata sānvayaḥ
upātapyata
began to suffer the heat of the fire
sa-anvayaḥ
along with descendants.
When the city was set ablaze, all the citizens and servants of the King, as well as all family members, sons, grandsons, wives and other relatives, were within the fire. King Purañjana thus became very unhappy.
Purport
There are many parts of the body — the senses, the limbs, the skin, the muscles, blood, marrow, etc. — and all these are considered here figuratively as sons, grandsons, citizens and dependents. When the body is attacked by the viṣṇu-jvāra, the fiery condition becomes so acute that sometimes one remains in a coma. This means that the body is in such severe pain that one becomes unconscious and cannot feel the miseries taking place within the body. Indeed, the living entity becomes so helpless at the time of death that, although unwilling, he is forced to give up the body and enter another. In Bhagavad-gītā it is stated that man may, by scientific advancement, improve the temporary living conditions, but that he cannot avoid the pangs of birth, old age, disease and death. These are under the control of the Supreme Personality of Godhead through the agency of material nature. A foolish person cannot understand this simple fact. Now people are very busy trying to find petroleum in the midst of the ocean. They are very anxious to make provisions for the future petroleum supply, but they do not make any attempts to ameliorate the conditions of birth, old age, disease and death. Thus a person in ignorance, not knowing anything about his own future life, is certainly defeated in all his activities.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
As the city began burning, the King, along with the citizens, retinue, his wife, and extended family, began to feel the heat.
The citizens are the seven dhātus. The retinue or servants are the senses. Kauṭumbikaḥ means one who enjoys with the wife. He suffered along with his intelligence. The descendents are the sons and grandsons. The lack of sandhi is poetic license.
His Holiness Yadunanadana Swami· 2010-05-29· English
Personal Guidance
All citizens, servants, family members were in the fire; Purañjana was unhappy. Family being burned-with-you is the deepest grief; the totality of loss arrives at once.
Reflection Questions
Whose grief at the totality of loss have I underestimated?
Where would imagining the deathbed scene re-prioritize my present hours?
यवनोपरुद्धायतनो ग्रस्तायां कालकन्यया ।
पुर्यांप्रज्वारसंसृष्ट:
पुरपालोऽन्वतप्यत ॥ १३ ॥
yavanoparuddhāyatano
[yavanoparuddhaayatano]
grastāyāṁ kāla-kanyayā
[grastaayaam kaala-kanyayaa]
puryāṁ prajvāra-saṁsṛṣṭaḥ
[puryaam prajvaara-samsrishtah]
pura-pālo ’nvatapyata
[pura-paalo ’nvatapyata]
Word-for-word
yavana—by the Yavanasuparuddha—attackedāyatanaḥ—his abodegrastāyām—when seizedkāla-kanyayā—by the daughter of Timepuryām—the cityprajvāra-saṁsṛṣṭaḥ—being approached by Prajvārapura-pālaḥ—the city superintendentanvatapyata—became also very much aggrieved.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yavanoparuddhāyatano
yavana
by the Yavanas
uparuddha
attacked
āyatanaḥ
his abode
grastāyāṁ kāla-kanyayā
grastāyām
when seized
kāla-kanyayā
by the daughter of Time
puryāṁ prajvāra-saṁsṛṣṭaḥ
puryām
the city
prajvāra-saṁsṛṣṭaḥ
being approached by Prajvāra
pura-pālo ’nvatapyata
pura-pālaḥ
the city superintendent
anvatapyata
became also very much aggrieved.
The city’s superintendent of police, the serpent, saw that the citizens were being attacked by Kālakanyā, and he became very aggrieved to see his own residence set ablaze after being attacked by the Yavanas.
Purport
The living entity is covered by two different types of bodies — the gross body and the subtle body. At death we can see that the gross body is finished, but actually the living entity is carried by the subtle body to another gross body. The so-called scientists of the modern age cannot see how the subtle body is working in carrying the soul from one body to another. This subtle body has been figuratively described as a serpent, or the city’s police superintendent. When there is fire everywhere, the police superintendent cannot escape either. When there is security and an absence of fire in the city, the police superintendent can impose his authority upon the citizens, but when there is an all-out attack on the city, he is rendered useless. As the life air was ready to leave the gross body, the subtle body also began to experience pain.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When the city was being attacked by old age, the protector of the city, seeing his abode attacked by Yavanas, and himself touched by Prajvāra, became most distressed.
The protector of the city was the snake, the life air.
The serpent (vital force) saw the citizens attacked and his residence burning; he was aggrieved. Even the vital force grieves at its own dissolution; the principle of life is sentient.
Reflection Questions
Have I considered that my vital force itself feels what's happening?
Where could honoring the life-principle change how I treat my body?
नशेकेसोऽवितुंतत्रपुरुकृच्छ्रोरुवेपथु: ।
गन्तुमैच्छत्ततो वृक्षकोटरादिव सानलात् ॥ १४ ॥
na śeke so ’vituṁ tatra
[na sheke so ’vitum tatra]
puru-kṛcchroru-vepathuḥ
[puru-krichchroru-vepathuh]
gantum aicchat tato vṛkṣa-
[gantum aichchat tato vriksha-]
koṭarād iva sānalāt
[kotaraad iva saanalaat]
Word-for-word
na—notśeke—was ablesaḥ—heavitum—to protecttatra—therepuru—very muchkṛcchra—difficultyuru—greatvepathuḥ—sufferinggantum—to go outaicchat—desiredtataḥ—from therevṛkṣa—of a treekoṭarāt—from the hollowiva—likesa-analāt—on fire.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
na śeke so ’vituṁ tatra
na
not
śeke
was able
puru-kṛcchroru-vepathuḥ
gantum aicchat tato vṛkṣa-
saḥ
he
avitum
to protect
koṭarād iva sānalāt
tatra
there
puru
very much
kṛcchra
difficulty
uru
great
vepathuḥ
suffering
gantum
to go out
aicchat
desired
tataḥ
from there
vṛkṣa
of a tree
koṭarāt
from the hollow
iva
like
sa-analāt
on fire.
As a serpent living within the cavity of a tree wishes to leave when there is a forest fire, so the city’s police superintendent, the snake, wished to leave the city due to the fire’s severe heat.
Purport
It becomes very difficult for snakes to leave a forest when there is a fire. Other animals may flee due to their long legs, but serpents, only being able to crawl, are generally burnt in the fire. At the last stage, the limbs of the body are not as much affected as the life air.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
He could not protect the city. Undergoing great difficulty and quivering to the extreme, he desired to leave the city, just as a snake desires to leave hollow tree which is on fire.
He could not protect the city. He desired to leave just as a snake desire to leave a tree hole which is on fire.
His Holiness Janananda Goswami· 2013-03-06· English
Personal Guidance
Like a snake in a tree-hollow during a forest fire, the serpent wished to leave the burning city. The vital force naturally seeks to evacuate; you don't have to push it out, you just have to let it go.
Reflection Questions
Where am I forcing the vital force to stay where it's ready to leave?
What would 'allowing the snake to leave' look like in my dying-with-dignity preparation?
śithila—slackenedavayavaḥ—his limbsyarhi—whengandharvaiḥ—by the Gandharvashṛta—defeatedpauruṣaḥ—his bodily strengthyavanaiḥ—by the Yavanasaribhiḥ—by the enemiesrājan—O King Prācīnabarhiṣatuparuddhaḥ—being checkedruroda—cried loudlyha—indeed.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śithilāvayavo yarhi
śithila
slackened
avayavaḥ
his limbs
yarhi
when
gandharvair hṛta-pauruṣaḥ
gandharvaiḥ
by the Gandharvas
hṛta
defeated
pauruṣaḥ
his bodily strength
yavanair aribhī rājann
yavanaiḥ
by the Yavanas
aribhiḥ
by the enemies
rājan
O King Prācīnabarhiṣat
uparuddho ruroda ha
uparuddhaḥ
being checked
ruroda
cried loudly
ha
indeed.
The limbs of the serpent’s body were slackened by the Gandharvas and Yavana soldiers, who had thoroughly defeated his bodily strength. When he attempted to leave the body, he was checked by his enemies. Being thus baffled in his attempt, he began to cry loudly.
Purport
At the last stage of life, the different gates of the body are choked by the effects of disease, which are caused by an imbalance of bile, mucus and air. Thus the living entity cannot clearly express his difficulties, and surrounding relatives hear the sound “ghura ghura ” from a dying man. In his Mukunda-mālā-stotra, King Kulaśekhara states:
kṛṣṇa tvadīya-padapaṅkaja-pañjarāntam adyaiva me viśatu mānasa-rāja-haṁsaḥ prāṇa-prayāṇa-samaye kapha-vāta-pittaiḥ kaṇṭhāvarodhana-vidhau smaraṇaṁ kutas te
“My dear Kṛṣṇa, please help me die immediately so that the swan of my mind may be encircled by the stem of Your lotus feet. Otherwise at the time of my final breath, when my throat is choked up, how will it be possible for me to think of You?” The swan takes great pleasure in diving within water and being encircled by the stem of the lotus flower. This entanglement is sporting joy. If, in our healthy condition, we think of the lotus feet of the Lord and die, it is most fortunate. In old age, at the time of death, the throat sometimes becomes choked with mucus or blocked by air. At such a time the sound vibration of Hare Kṛṣṇa, the mahā-mantra, may not come out. Thus one may forget Kṛṣṇa. Of course, those who are strong in Kṛṣṇa consciousness cannot possibly forget Kṛṣṇa at any stage because they are accustomed to chanting the Hare Kṛṣṇa mantra, especially when there is a signal from death.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O King! When his limbs were weakened by the Gandharvas and his strength stolen by the Yavanas, his throat became choked up, and he began the death rattle.
As death approached, he made a rattling sound in his throat.
His Holiness Vedavyasa Priya Swami· 2016-10-29· Hindi
Personal Guidance
His limbs slackened by soldiers; he was checked from leaving and cried loudly. Diseases sometimes block even the soul's exit; the last stage can be technical, not just emotional.
Reflection Questions
Where am I unprepared for the technical aspects of dying that scripture details?
What practice would make exit cleaner if the technical obstacles arose?
दुहितृ:पुत्रपौत्रांश्चजामिजामातृपार्षदान् ।
स्वत्वावशिष्टं यत्किञ्चिद् गृहकोशपरिच्छदम् ॥ १६ ॥
duhitṝḥ putra-pautrāṁś ca
[duhitreeh putra-pautraamsh cha]
jāmi-jāmātṛ-pārṣadān
[jaami-jaamaatri-paarshadaan]
svatvāvaśiṣṭaṁ yat kiñcid
[svatvaavashishtam yat kinchid]
gṛha-kośa-paricchadam
[griha-kosha-parichchadam]
Word-for-word
duhitṝḥ—daughtersputra—sonspautrān—grandsonsca—andjāmi—daughters-in-lawjāmātṛ—sons-in-lawpārṣadān—associatessvatva—propertyavaśiṣṭam—remainingyat kiñcit—whatevergṛha—homekośa—accumulation of wealthparicchadam—household paraphernalia.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
duhitṝḥ putra-pautrāṁś ca
duhitṝḥ
daughters
putra
sons
pautrān
grandsons
ca
and
jāmi-jāmātṛ-pārṣadān
jāmi
daughters-in-law
jāmātṛ
sons-in-law
pārṣadān
associates
svatvāvaśiṣṭaṁ yat kiñcid
svatva
property
avaśiṣṭam
remaining
yat kiñcit
whatever
gṛha-kośa-paricchadam
gṛha
home
kośa
accumulation of wealth
paricchadam
household paraphernalia.
King Purañjana then began to think of his daughters, sons, grandsons, daughters-in-law, sons-in-law, servants and other associates, as well as his house, his household paraphernalia and his little accumulation of wealth.
Purport
It is not infrequent for a person overly attached to the material body to request a physician to prolong his life at least for some time. If the so-called scientific physician is able to prolong one’s life for a few minutes through the use of oxygen or other medicines, he thinks that he is very successful in his attempts, although ultimately the patient will die. This is called the struggle for existence. At the time of death both patient and physician still think of prolonging life, although all the constituents of the body are practically dead and gone.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Since he was a foolish householder, accepting me and mine concerning his household, he became miserable at impending separation from his wife. He began to think of his daughters, sons, grandsons, daughters-in-law, sons-in-law, followers, remaining property, house, treasury and furniture.
Yāmi means daughter-in-law. pramadayā viprayote upasthitaḥ means “when separated from a woman.” This does not refer to his intelligence since, when the gross body of the jīva is destroyed, there is no separation of the jīva from the intelligence. This refers to a conditioned jīva’s normal material wife, object of attachment, enjoyed by all the senses. The daughters and others mentioned in this verse also refer to conventional daughters and relatives, not the symbols in the spiritual metaphor. Some say that, at the time of death, the jīva thinks of his wife and sons, not of intelligence, discernment and other elements. Others say that dharmic intelligence was previously represented by his wife Purañjanī, but at the time of death, there is separation from dharmic intelligence, and joining with another intelligence. There are statements such as na mayy anāśite bhuṅkte: his wife would not take her dinner until he had finished his. (SB 4.28.19) This refers to a time before the separation from his dharmic intelligence. This will be explained later. The description in this verse presents the idea “I am not satisfied with my actions of dharma. What should I do? Death is now approaching.”
His Holiness Bir Krishna Goswami· 2011-12-20· English
Personal Guidance
He thought of daughters, sons, grandsons, in-laws, servants, house and little wealth. The dying mind reaches for the smallest details; nothing is too small to be clung to at the end.
Reflection Questions
What small details would my own dying mind reach for, and what does that reveal?
Where could I begin to loosen attachment to those small details now?
aham—Imama—mineiti—thussvī-kṛtya—acceptinggṛheṣu—in the homeku-matiḥ—whose mind is full of obnoxious thoughtsgṛhī—the householderdadhyau—turns his attention topramadayā—with his wifedīnaḥ—very poorviprayoge—when separationupasthite—occurred.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ahaṁ mameti svīkṛtya
aham
I
mama
mine
gṛheṣu kumatir gṛhī
dadhyau pramadayā dīno
viprayoga upasthite
iti
thus
svī-kṛtya
accepting
gṛheṣu
in the home
ku-matiḥ
whose mind is full of obnoxious thoughts
gṛhī
the householder
dadhyau
turns his attention to
pramadayā
with his wife
dīnaḥ
very poor
viprayoge
when separation
upasthite
occurred.
King Purañjana was overly attached to his family and conceptions of “I” and “mine.” Because he was overly attracted to his wife, he was already quite poverty-stricken. At the time of separation, he became very sorry.
Purport
It is clear in this verse that at the time of death thoughts of material enjoyment do not go away. This indicates that the living entity, the soul, is carried by the subtle body — mind, intelligence and ego. Due to false ego, the living entity still wants to enjoy the material world, and for want of material enjoyment he becomes sorry or sad. He still makes intellectual plans to further his existence, and therefore, although he gives up the gross body, he is carried by the subtle body to another gross body. The transmigration of the subtle body is never visible to material eyes; therefore when one gives up the gross body, we think that he is finished. Plans for material enjoyment are made by the subtle body, and the gross body is the instrument for enjoying these plans. Thus the gross body can be compared to the wife, for the wife is the agent for all kinds of sense gratification. Because of long association with the gross body, the living entity becomes very sad to be separated from it. The mental activity of the living entity obliges him to accept another gross body and continue his material existence.
The Sanskrit word strī means “expansion.” Through the wife one expands his various objects of attraction — sons, daughters, grandsons and so on. Attachment to family members becomes very prominent at the time of death. One often sees that just before leaving his body a man may call for his beloved son to give him charge of his wife and other paraphernalia. He may say, “My dear boy, I am being forced to leave. Please take charge of the family affairs.” He speaks in this way, not even knowing his destination.
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2010-06-08· English
Personal Guidance
Overly attached to 'I' and 'mine,' he was already poverty-stricken; separation hurt severely. Even before separation, attachment-as-poverty has set in; the suffering precedes the loss.
Reflection Questions
Where is my 'I-and-mine' attachment already making me poor before any actual loss?
What would relief look like if I held my belongings more lightly today?
लोकान्तरं गतवति मय्यनाथा कुटुम्बिनी ।
वर्तिष्यते कथं त्वेषा बालकाननुशोचती ॥ १८ ॥
lokāntaraṁ gatavati
[lokaantaram gatavati]
mayy anāthā kuṭumbinī
[mayy anaathaa kutumbinee]
vartiṣyate kathaṁ tv eṣā
[vartishyate katham tv eshaa]
bālakān anuśocatī
[baalakaan anushochatee]
Word-for-word
loka-antaram—into a different lifegatavati mayi—when I am goneanāthā—bereft of husbandkuṭumbinī—surrounded by all family membersvartiṣyate—will existkatham—howtu—theneṣā—this womanbālakān—childrenanuśocatī—lamenting about.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
lokāntaraṁ gatavati
loka-antaram
into a different life
gatavati mayi
when I am gone
mayy anāthā kuṭumbinī
anāthā
bereft of husband
kuṭumbinī
surrounded by all family members
vartiṣyate kathaṁ tv eṣā
vartiṣyate
will exist
katham
how
tu
then
eṣā
this woman
bālakān anuśocatī
bālakān
children
anuśocatī
lamenting about.
King Purañjana was anxiously thinking, “Alas, my wife is encumbered by so many children. When I pass from this body, how will she be able to maintain all these family members? Alas, she will be greatly harassed by thoughts of family maintenance.”
Purport
All these thoughts of one’s wife indicate that the King was overly engrossed with the thoughts of woman. Generally a chaste woman becomes a very obedient wife. This causes a husband to become attached to his wife, and consequently he thinks of his wife very much at the time of death. This is a very dangerous situation, as is evident from the life of King Purañjana. If one thinks of his wife instead of Kṛṣṇa at the time of death, he will certainly not return home, back to Godhead, but will be forced to accept the body of a woman and thus begin another chapter of material existence.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When I go to another world, how will my wife, without a husband, lamenting for her children, continue to exist?
His Holiness Vrindavan Chandra Das Goswami· 2019-07-17· Hindi
Personal Guidance
Alas, how will my wife maintain all these family members after I'm gone? Dying worry centers on survivors' welfare; it's noble in flavor and bondage-producing in effect.
Reflection Questions
Whose welfare worry consumes me, and is the worry producing actual provision?
Where could trust in higher arrangement replace worry?
न मय्यनाशिते भुङ्क्ते नास्नाते स्नाति मत्परा ।
मयि रुष्टे सुसन्त्रस्ता भर्त्सिते यतवाग्भयात् ॥ १९ ॥
na mayy anāśite bhuṅkte
[na mayy anaashite bhunkte]
nāsnāte snāti mat-parā
[naasnaate snaati mat-paraa]
mayi ruṣṭe susantrastā
[mayi rushte susantrastaa]
bhartsite yata-vāg bhayāt
[bhartsite yata-vaag bhayaat]
Word-for-word
na—nevermayi—when Ianāśite—had not eatenbhuṅkte—she would eatna—neverasnāte—had not taken bathsnāti—she would take her bathmat-parā—always devoted to memayi—when Iruṣṭe—was angrysu-santrastā—very much frightenedbhartsite—when I chastisedyata-vāk—fully controlled of wordsbhayāt—out of fear.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
na mayy anāśite bhuṅkte
na
never
mayi
when I
anāśite
had not eaten
bhuṅkte
she would eat
nāsnāte snāti mat-parā
na
never
asnāte
had not taken bath
snāti
she would take her bath
mat-parā
always devoted to me
mayi ruṣṭe susantrastā
mayi
when I
ruṣṭe
was angry
su-santrastā
very much frightened
bhartsite yata-vāg bhayāt
bhartsite
when I chastised
yata-vāk
fully controlled of words
bhayāt
out of fear.
King Purañjana then began to think of his past dealings with his wife. He recalled that his wife would not take her dinner until he had finished his, that she would not take her bath until he had finished his, and that she was always very much attached to him, so much so that if he would sometimes become angry and chastise her, she would simply remain silent and tolerate his misbehavior.
Purport
A wife is always supposed to be submissive to her husband. Submission, mild behavior and subservience are qualities in a wife which make a husband very thoughtful of her. For family life it is very good for a husband to be attached to his wife, but it is not very good for spiritual advancement. Thus Kṛṣṇa consciousness must be established in every home. If a husband and wife are very much attached to one another in Kṛṣṇa consciousness, they will both benefit because Kṛṣṇa is the center of their existence. Otherwise, if the husband is too much attached to his wife, he becomes a woman in his next life. The woman, being overly attached to her husband, becomes a man in her next life. Of course, it is an advantage for a woman to become a man, but it is not at all advantageous for the man to become a woman.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
If I did not eat, she would not eat. If I did not bathe, she would not bathe. She was devoted to me. When I became angry, she would become frightened. When I scolded her, she remained silent in fear.
When I did not eat (anāśite), she did not eat. When I scolded her (bhartsite) she remained silent.
He recalled she wouldn't dine or bathe until he had — utterly devoted. Memories of a beloved's devotion intensify the bond at the end; nothing accidental about how scripture details this.
Reflection Questions
Whose devotion to me am I recalling rather than reciprocating?
Where do these memories serve as bondage rather than as foundation for trust?
prabodhayati—gives good counselmā—unto meavijñam—foolishvyuṣite—at the time of my being awayśoka—by aggrievementkarśitā—being aggrieved and thus dried upvartma—pathetat—thisgṛha-medhīyam—of household responsibilitiesvīra-sūḥ—the mother of great heroesapi—althoughneṣyati—will she be able to execute.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
prabodhayati māvijñaṁ
prabodhayati
gives good counsel
mā
unto me
avijñam
foolish
vyuṣite śoka-karśitā
vyuṣite
at the time of my being away
śoka
by aggrievement
karśitā
being aggrieved and thus dried up
vartmaitad gṛha-medhīyaṁ
vartma
path
etat
this
gṛha-medhīyam
of household responsibilities
vīra-sūr api neṣyati
vīra-sūḥ
the mother of great heroes
api
although
neṣyati
will she be able to execute.
King Purañjana continued thinking how, when he was in a state of bewilderment, his wife would give him good counsel and how she would become aggrieved when he was away from home. Although she was the mother of so many sons and heroes, the King still feared that she would not be able to maintain the responsibility of household affairs.
Purport
At the time of death King Purañjana was thinking of his wife, and this is called polluted consciousness. As Lord Kṛṣṇa explains in Bhagavad-gītā (15.7) :
“The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal fragmental parts. Due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind.”
The living entity is, after all, part and parcel of the Supreme Spirit, Kṛṣṇa. In other words, Kṛṣṇa’s constitutional position and the living entity’s constitutional position are the same qualitatively. The only difference is that the living entity is eternally an atomic particle of the Supreme Spirit ( mamaivāṁśo jīva-loke jīva-bhūtaḥ sanātanaḥ ). In this material world of conditional life, the fragmental portion of the Supreme Lord, the individual soul, is struggling due to his contaminated mind and consciousness. As part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, a living entity is supposed to think of Kṛṣṇa, but here we see that King Purañjana (the living entity) is thinking of a woman. Such mental absorption with some sense object brings about the living entity’s struggle for existence in this material world. Since King Purañjana is thinking of his wife, his struggle for existence in the material world will not be ended by death. As revealed in the following verses, King Purañjana had to accept the body of a woman in his next life due to his being overly absorbed in thoughts of his wife. Thus mental absorption in social, political, pseudoreligious, national and communal consciousness is cause for bondage. During one’s lifetime one has to change his activities in order to attain release from bondage. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā (3.9) : yajñārthāt karmaṇo ’nyatra loko ’yaṁ karma-bandhanaḥ. If we do not change our consciousness in this life, whatever we do in the name of social, political, religious or communal and national welfare will be the cause of our bondage. This means we have to continue in material, conditional life. As explained in Bhagavad-gītā (15.7) , manaḥ-ṣaṣṭhānīndriyāṇi prakṛti-sthāni karṣati: when the mind and senses are engaged in material activities, one has to continue his material existence and struggle to attain happiness. In each and every life one is engaged in the struggle to become happy. Actually no one in this material world is happy, but the struggle gives a false sense of happiness. A person must work very hard, and when he attains the result of his hard work, he thinks himself happy. In the material world people do not know what real happiness is. Sukham ātyantikaṁ yat tad buddhi-grāhyam atīndriyam (Bg. 6.21): real happiness must be appreciated by one’s transcendental senses. Unless one is purified, the transcendental senses are not manifest; therefore to purify the senses one must take to Kṛṣṇa consciousness and engage the senses in the service of the Lord. Then there will be real happiness and liberation.
“The living entity in the material world carries his different conceptions of life from one body to another as the air carries aromas.” If the wind passes over a garden of roses, it will carry the aroma of roses, and if it passes over a filthy place, it will carry the stench of obnoxious things. Similarly, King Purañjana, the living entity, now passes the air of his life over his wife, a woman; therefore he has to accept the body of a woman in his next life.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
She would instruct me when I was foolish. When I was away, she became thin because of lamentation. Having many sons, how will she will be able to perform household duties?
She would enlighten me, a fool. When I was away (vyuṣite), she became thin. How will she undertake the tasks? Though she has sons to take care of, she will die, unable to bear separation from me.
His Holiness Nava Yogendra Swami· 2011-02-03· Hindi
Personal Guidance
She gave counsel; mourned absence; mother of many heroes — but he feared she wouldn't manage alone. Polluted consciousness at death takes the form of caring about exactly the wrong things.
Reflection Questions
Which 'caring' of mine is actually polluted because it's substituting for remembrance of the Lord?
What right caring would I aim for in my last moments?
कथं नु दारका दीना दारकीर्वापरायणा: ।
वर्तिष्यन्ते मयि गते भिन्ननाव इवोदधौ ॥ २१ ॥
kathaṁ nu dārakā dīnā
[katham nu daarakaa deenaa]
dārakīr vāparāyaṇāḥ
[daarakeer vaaparaayanaah]
vartiṣyante mayi gate
[vartishyante mayi gate]
bhinna-nāva ivodadhau
[bhinna-naava ivodadhau]
Word-for-word
katham—hownu—indeeddārakāḥ—sonsdīnāḥ—poordārakīḥ—daughtersvā—oraparāyaṇāḥ—having no one else to depend onvartiṣyante—will livemayi—when Igate—gone from this worldbhinna—brokennāvaḥ—boativa—likeudadhau—in the ocean.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kathaṁ nu dārakā dīnā
katham
how
nu
indeed
dārakāḥ
sons
dīnāḥ
poor
dārakīr vāparāyaṇāḥ
dārakīḥ
daughters
vā
or
aparāyaṇāḥ
having no one else to depend on
vartiṣyante mayi gate
vartiṣyante
will live
mayi
when I
gate
gone from this world
bhinna-nāva ivodadhau
bhinna
broken
nāvaḥ
boat
iva
like
udadhau
in the ocean.
King Purañjana continued worrying: “After I pass from this world, how will my sons and daughters, who are now fully dependent on me, live and continue their lives? Their position will be similar to that of passengers aboard a ship wrecked in the midst of the ocean.”
Purport
At the time of death every living entity worries about what will happen to his wife and children. Similarly, a politician also worries about what will happen to his country or his political party. Unless one is fully Kṛṣṇa conscious, he has to accept a body in the next life according to his particular state of consciousness. Since Purañjana is thinking of his wife and children and is overly engrossed in thoughts of his wife, he will accept the body of a woman. Similarly, a politician or so-called nationalist who is inordinately attached to the land of his birth will certainly be reborn in the same land after ending his political career. One’s next life will also be affected by the acts one performs during this life. Sometimes politicians act most sinfully for their own sense gratification. It is not unusual for a politician to kill the opposing party. Even though a politician may be allowed to take birth in his so-called homeland, he still has to undergo suffering due to his sinful activities in his previous life.
This science of transmigration is completely unknown to modern scientists. So-called scientists do not like to bother with these things because if they would at all consider this subtle subject matter and the problems of life, they would see that their future is very dark. Thus they try to avoid considering the future and continue committing all kinds of sinful activities in the name of social, political and national necessity.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
How will my poor sons and daughters who were dedicated to serving me, remain living, when I am gone? They will be like a shattered boat in the ocean.
Dārakīḥ means dārikāḥ (daughters). They were dedicated to serving me with affection in my old age (parāyanāḥ). How will they remain? They will die from continual crying. Bhinna means cracked.
His Holiness Yadunanadana Swami· 2010-06-14· English
Personal Guidance
How will my sons and daughters live? — Like passengers on a wrecked ship. The shipwreck metaphor is accurate; without proper preparation, dependents are exactly that vulnerable.
Reflection Questions
Where do I have dependents in 'shipwrecked' configurations?
What preparation could begin to give them a real boat?
एवं कृपणया बुद्ध्या शोचन्तमतदर्हणम् ।
ग्रहीतुं कृतधीरेनं भयनामाभ्यपद्यत ॥ २२ ॥
evaṁ kṛpaṇayā buddhyā
[evam kripanayaa buddhyaa]
śocantam atad-arhaṇam
[shochantam atad-arhanam]
grahītuṁ kṛta-dhīr enaṁ
[graheetum krita-dheer enam]
bhaya-nāmābhyapadyata
[bhaya-naamaabhyapadyata]
Word-for-word
evam—thuskṛpaṇayā—by miserlybuddhyā—intelligenceśocantam—lamentinga-tat-arhaṇam—on which he should not have lamentedgrahītum—in order to arrestkṛta-dhīḥ—the determined King of the Yavanasenam—himbhaya-nāmā—whose name was fearabhyapadyata—came there immediately.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
evaṁ kṛpaṇayā buddhyā
evam
thus
kṛpaṇayā
by miserly
buddhyā
intelligence
śocantam atad-arhaṇam
śocantam
lamenting
a-tat-arhaṇam
on which he should not have lamented
grahītuṁ kṛta-dhīr enaṁ
grahītum
in order to arrest
kṛta-dhīḥ
the determined King of the Yavanas
enam
him
bhaya-nāmābhyapadyata
bhaya-nāmā
whose name was fear
abhyapadyata
came there immediately.
Although King Purañjana should not have lamented over the fate of his wife and children, he nonetheless did so due to his miserly intelligence. In the meantime, Yavana-rāja, whose name was fear itself, immediately drew near to arrest him.
Purport
Foolish people do not know that every individual soul is responsible for his own actions and reactions in life. As long as a living entity in the form of a child or boy is innocent, it is the duty of the father and mother to lead him into a proper understanding of the values of life. When a child is grown, it should be left up to him to execute the duties of life properly. The parent, after his death, cannot help his child. A father may leave some estate for his children’s immediate help, but he should not be overly absorbed in thoughts of how his family will survive after his death. This is the disease of the conditioned soul. Not only does he commit sinful activities for his own sense gratification, but he accumulates great wealth to leave behind so that his children may also gorgeously arrange for sense gratification.
In any case, everyone is afraid of death, and therefore death is called bhaya, or fear. Although King Purañjana was engaged in thinking of his wife and children, death did not wait for him. Death does not wait for any man; it will immediately carry out its duty. Since death must take away the living entity without hesitation, it is the ultimate God realization of the atheists, who spoil their lives thinking of country, society and relatives, to the neglect of God consciousness. In this verse the word atad-arhaṇam is very significant, for it means that one should not be overly engaged in welfare activities for one’s family members, countrymen, society and community. None of these will help a person to advance spiritually. Unfortunately, in present-day society so-called educated men have no idea what spiritual progress is. Although they have the opportunity in the human form of life to make spiritual progress, they remain misers. They use their lives improperly and simply waste them thinking about the material welfare of their relatives, countrymen, society and so on. One’s actual duty is to learn how to conquer death. Lord Kṛṣṇa states the process of conquering death in Bhagavad-gītā (4.9) :
janma karma ca me divyam evaṁ yo vetti tattvataḥ tyaktvā dehaṁ punar janma naiti mām eti so ’rjuna
“One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna.”
After giving up this body, one who is fully Kṛṣṇa conscious does not accept another material body but returns home, back to Godhead. Everyone should try to attain this perfection. Unfortunately, instead of doing so, people are absorbed in thoughts of society, friendship, love and relatives. This Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement, however, is educating people throughout the world and informing them how to conquer death. Hariṁ vinā na mṛtiṁ taranti: one cannot conquer death without taking shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
At that time, Fear approached to take the King, who was lamenting in this way, though it was not befitting, along with his wretched intelligence.
He should not have lamented since his he was actually a spiritual particle (atad-arhaṇam). Atad-arhaṇam can also mean “he did not deserve to be taken by fear, since he practiced dharma.”
His Holiness Prabodhananda Sarasvati Swami· 2016-11-10· Hindi
Personal Guidance
He shouldn't have lamented but did from miserly intelligence; Yavana-rāja approached to arrest. Lament beyond what's productive becomes the doorway through which Fear arrests you.
Reflection Questions
Where is my lament producing nothing but a wider opening for Fear?
पशुवद्यवनैरेष नीयमान: स्वकं क्षयम् ।
अन्वद्रवन्ननुपथा:शोचन्तोभृशमातुरा: ॥ २३ ॥
paśuvad yavanair eṣa
[pashuvad yavanair esha]
nīyamānaḥ svakaṁ kṣayam
[neeyamaanah svakam kshayam]
anvadravann anupathāḥ
[anvadravann anupathaah]
śocanto bhṛśam āturāḥ
[shochanto bhrisham aaturaah]
Word-for-word
paśu-vat—like an animalyavanaiḥ—by the Yavanaseṣaḥ—Purañjananīyamānaḥ—being arrested and taken awaysvakam—to their ownkṣayam—abodeanvadravan—followedanupathāḥ—his attendantsśocantaḥ—lamentingbhṛśam—greatlyāturāḥ—being distressed.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
paśuvad yavanair eṣa
paśu-vat
like an animal
yavanaiḥ
by the Yavanas
eṣaḥ
Purañjana
nīyamānaḥ svakaṁ kṣayam
nīyamānaḥ
being arrested and taken away
svakam
to their own
kṣayam
abode
anvadravann anupathāḥ
anvadravan
followed
anupathāḥ
his attendants
śocanto bhṛśam āturāḥ
śocantaḥ
lamenting
bhṛśam
greatly
āturāḥ
being distressed.
When the Yavanas were taking King Purañjana away to their place, binding him like an animal, the King’s followers became greatly aggrieved. While they lamented, they were forced to go along with him.
Purport
When Yamarāja and his assistants take a living entity away to the place of judgment, the life, life air and desires, being followers of the living entity, also go with him. This is confirmed in the Vedas. When the living entity is taken away or arrested by Yamarāja ( tam utkrāmantam ), the life air also goes with him ( prāṇo ’nūtkrāmati ), and when the life air is gone ( prāṇam anūtkrāmantam ), all the senses ( sarve prāṇāḥ ) also go along ( anūtkrāmanti ). When the living entity and the life air are gone, the lump of matter produced of five elements — earth, water, air, fire and ether — is rejected and left behind. The living entity then goes to the court of judgment, and Yamarāja decides what kind of body he is going to get next. This process is unknown to modern scientists. Every living entity is responsible for his activities in this life, and after death he is taken to the court of Yamarāja, where it is decided what kind of body he will take next. Although the gross material body is left, the living entity and his desires, as well as the resultant reactions of his past activities, go on. It is Yamarāja who decides what kind of body one gets next in accordance with one’s past actions.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Like an animal, he was led by the Yavanas to their abode. His retinue followed, lamenting and greatly distressed.
He was lead away like an animal by the Yamadūtas (yavanaiḥ). His life air and followers (anupathāḥ) ran after him. Śruti says tam anukrāmantaṁ prāṇo ’nukrāmati prāṇam anukrāmantaṁ sarve prāṇā anukrāmanti: the life air follows the jīva when it leaves the body and the other life airs follow the main life air.
His Holiness Bir Krishna Goswami· 2011-12-29· English
Personal Guidance
They took him away bound like an animal; his followers lamented as they were forced along. At death, the senses and life-airs go along with the soul; the procession is not solitary.
Reflection Questions
Whose 'following' might be more aware than I credit at the moment of departure?
Where does seeing the procession at death reorder my current relationships with my faculties?
purīm—the cityvihāya—having given upupagataḥ—gone outuparuddhaḥ—arrestedbhujaṅgamaḥ—the serpentyadā—whentam—himeva—certainlyanu—afterpurī—the cityviśīrṇā—scatteredprakṛtim—mattergatā—turned into.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
purīṁ vihāyopagata
purīm
the city
vihāya
having given up
uparuddho bhujaṅgamaḥ
upagataḥ
gone out
yadā tam evānu purī
uparuddhaḥ
arrested
bhujaṅgamaḥ
the serpent
yadā
when
viśīrṇā prakṛtiṁ gatā
tam
him
eva
certainly
anu
after
purī
the city
viśīrṇā
scattered
prakṛtim
matter
gatā
turned into.
The serpent, who had already been arrested by the soldiers of Yavana-rāja and was out of the city, began to follow his master along with the others. As soon as they all left the city, it was immediately dismantled and smashed to dust.
Purport
When the living entity is arrested, all his followers — namely the life air, the senses and sense objects — immediately leave the lump of matter, the body. When the living entity and his companions leave, the body no longer works but turns into basic material elements — earth, water, fire, air and ether. When a city attacked by enemies is vacated by its inhabitants, the enemy immediately takes advantage of that city and bombards it to smash the whole thing to dust. When we say, “Dust thou art, and unto dust thou shall return,” we refer to the body. When a city is attacked and bombarded by enemies, the citizens generally leave, and the city ceases to exist.
It is a foolish person who engages in improving the condition of a city without caring for the citizens or inhabitants. Similarly, a living entity who is not properly enlightened in spiritual knowledge simply takes care of the external body, not knowing that the spirit soul is the principal factor within the body. When one is advanced in spiritual knowledge, the spirit soul is saved from eternal transmigration. The Bhāgavatam considers those who are attached to their bodies to be like cows and asses ( sa eva go-kharaḥ ). The cow is a very innocent animal, and the ass is a beast of burden. One who labors under the bodily conception simply works like an ass and does not know his self-interest. It is therefore said:
yasyātma-buddhiḥ kuṇape tri-dhātuke sva-dhīḥ kalatrādiṣu bhauma ijya-dhīḥ yat-tīrtha-buddhiḥ salile na karhicij janeṣv abhijñeṣu sa eva go-kharaḥ
“A human being who identifies this body made of three elements with his self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of birth worshipable, and who goes to a place of pilgrimage simply to take a bath rather than meet men of transcendental knowledge there, is to be considered like an ass or a cow.” ( Bhāg. 10.84.13 )
Human civilization devoid of Kṛṣṇa consciousness is simply a civilization of lower animals. Sometimes such a civilization may study the dead body and consider the brain or the heart. However, no part of the body is important unless the spirit soul is present. In a modern civilization of cows and asses, scientists try to search out some value in the brain or heart of a dead man.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When the snake, captured by the Yavanas, left the city, the city was broken down and returned to the five elements.
The snake was captured by the Yavanas. The city returned to the elements (prakṛtim gatā).
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2010-06-17· English
Personal Guidance
The serpent followed; the city was immediately dismantled and smashed to dust. Once the king and his faculties leave, the city collapses immediately; the body is held up only by the resident.
Reflection Questions
Where am I treating my body as if it were the cause of itself rather than held by an inner resident?
What changes when I see the body as borrowed scaffolding?
vikṛṣyamāṇaḥ—being draggedprasabham—forciblyyavanena—by the Yavanabalīyasā—who was very powerfulna avindat—could not remembertamasā—by darkness of ignoranceāviṣṭaḥ—being coveredsakhāyam—his friendsuhṛdam—always a well-wisherpuraḥ—from the very beginning.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
vikṛṣyamāṇaḥ prasabhaṁ
vikṛṣyamāṇaḥ
being dragged
prasabham
forcibly
yavanena balīyasā
yavanena
by the Yavana
balīyasā
who was very powerful
nāvindat tamasāviṣṭaḥ
na avindat
could not remember
tamasā
by darkness of ignorance
āviṣṭaḥ
being covered
sakhāyaṁ suhṛdaṁ puraḥ
sakhāyam
his friend
suhṛdam
always a well-wisher
puraḥ
from the very beginning.
When King Purañjana was being dragged with great force by the powerful Yavana, out of his gross ignorance he still could not remember his friend and well-wisher, the Supersoul.
A person can be in full Kṛṣṇa consciousness and become happy and satisfied if he knows but three things — namely, that the Supreme Lord Kṛṣṇa is the enjoyer of all benefits, that He is the proprietor of everything, and that He is the supreme friend of all living entities. If one does not know this and functions instead under the bodily conception, he is always harassed by the tribulations offered by material nature. In actuality, the Supreme Lord is sitting by the side of everyone: īśvaraḥ sarva-bhūtānāṁ hṛd-deśe ’rjuna tiṣṭhati ( Bg. 18.61 ). The living entity and the Supersoul are sitting side by side in the same tree, but despite being harassed by the laws of material nature, the foolish living entity does not turn toward the Supreme Personality of Godhead for protection. However, he thinks that he is able to protect himself from the stringent laws of material nature. This, however, is not possible. The living entity must turn toward the Supreme Personality of Godhead and surrender unto Him. Only then will he be saved from the onslaught of the powerful Yavana, or Yamarāja.
The word sakhāyam, “friend,” is very significant in this verse because God is eternally present beside the living entity. The Supreme Lord is also described as suḥrdam, “ever well-wisher.” The Supreme Lord is always a well-wisher, just like a father or mother. Despite all the offenses of a son, the father and mother are always the son’s well-wisher. Similarly, despite all our offenses and defiance of the desires of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Lord will give us immediate relief from all the hardships offered by material nature if we simply surrender unto Him, as confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā ( mām eva ye prapadyante māyām etāṁ taranti te ). Unfortunately, due to our bad association and great attachment for sense gratification, we do not remember our best friend, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
As he was being dragged forcibly by the strong Yavanas, since he was covered by ignorance, he did not recognize the Supreme Lord his friend and his well-wisher from previous time.
By ignorance he did not know the Supreme Lord who was his friend previously.
Out of gross ignorance, he still couldn't remember his friend Supersoul. The biggest loss at the deathbed is failing to remember the Lord; the rest is replaceable.
Reflection Questions
What practice could ensure I would remember the Lord even under maximum stress?
Where am I betting on memory under conditions I haven't tested?
tam—himyajña-paśavaḥ—the sacrificial animalsanena—by himsaṁjñaptāḥ—killedye—all of them whoadayālunā—by the most unkindkuṭhāraiḥ—by axescicchiduḥ—pierced to pieceskruddhāḥ—being very angrysmarantaḥ—rememberingamīvam—sinful activityasya—of himtat—that.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
taṁ yajña-paśavo ’nena
tam
him
yajña-paśavaḥ
the sacrificial animals
saṁjñaptā ye ’dayālunā
kuṭhāraiś cicchiduḥ kruddhāḥ
smaranto ’mīvam asya tat
anena
by him
saṁjñaptāḥ
killed
ye
all of them who
adayālunā
by the most unkind
kuṭhāraiḥ
by axes
cicchiduḥ
pierced to pieces
kruddhāḥ
being very angry
smarantaḥ
remembering
amīvam
sinful activity
asya
of him
tat
that.
That most unkind king, Purañjana, had killed many animals in various sacrifices. Now, taking advantage of this opportunity, all these animals began to pierce him with their horns. It was as though he were being cut to pieces by axes.
Purport
Those who are very enthusiastic about killing animals in the name of religion or for food must await similar punishment after death. The word māṁsa, “meat,” indicates that those animals whom we kill will be given an opportunity to kill us. Although in actuality no living entity is killed, the pains of being pierced by the horns of animals will be experienced after death. Not knowing this, rascals unhesitatingly go on killing poor animals. So-called human civilization has opened many slaughterhouses for animals in the name of religion or food. Those who are a little religious kill animals in temples, mosques or synagogues, and those who are more fallen maintain various slaughterhouses. Just as in civilized human society the law is a life for a life, no living entity can encroach upon another living entity as far as the Supreme Lord is concerned. Everyone should be given freedom to live at the cost of the supreme father, and animal-killing — either for religion or for food — is always condemned by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In Bhagavad-gītā (16.19) Lord Kṛṣṇa says:
“Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, are cast by Me into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life.” The animal-killers ( dviṣataḥ ), envying other living entities and the Supreme Personality of Godhead, are placed in darkness and cannot understand the theme and objective of life. This is further explained in the following verses.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The sacrificial animals that he had killed, remembering his sins, angrily chopped him with axes without mercy.
The animals cut by his knife during material sacrifices began to cut him with axes. Amīvam means offense.
The animals he had killed in sacrifices pierced him with horns; he was cut to pieces. Karma keeps its appointments at death; nothing 'in the name of religion' actually escapes accounting.
Reflection Questions
Where do I justify present harm under cover of religious frame?
What appointment have I made for myself that scripture warns me of?
ananta-pāre—unlimitedly expandedtamasi—in the material existence of darknessmagnaḥ—being mergednaṣṭa-smṛtiḥ—bereft of all intelligencesamāḥ—for many yearsśāśvatīḥ—practically eternallyanubhūya—experiencingārtim—the threefold miseriespramadā—of womensaṅga—by associationdūṣitaḥ—being contaminated.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ananta-pāre tamasi
ananta-pāre
unlimitedly expanded
tamasi
in the material existence of darkness
magno naṣṭa-smṛtiḥ samāḥ
magnaḥ
being merged
naṣṭa-smṛtiḥ
bereft of all intelligence
samāḥ
for many years
śāśvatīr anubhūyārtiṁ
śāśvatīḥ
practically eternally
anubhūya
experiencing
ārtim
the threefold miseries
pramadā-saṅga-dūṣitaḥ
pramadā
of women
saṅga
by association
dūṣitaḥ
being contaminated.
Due to his contaminated association with women, a living entity like King Purañjana eternally suffers all the pangs of material existence and remains in the dark region of material life, bereft of all remembrance for many, many years.
Purport
This is a description of material existence. Material existence is experienced when one becomes attached to a woman and forgets his real identity as the eternal servant of Kṛṣṇa ( naṣṭa-smṛtiḥ ). In this way, in one body after another, the living entity perpetually suffers the threefold miseries of material existence. To save human civilization from the darkness of ignorance, this movement was started. The main purpose of the Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement is to enlighten the forgetful living entity and remind him of his original Kṛṣṇa consciousness. In this way the living entity can be saved from the catastrophe of ignorance as well as bodily transmigration. As Śrīla Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura has sung:
anādi karama-phale, paḍi’ bhavārṇava-jale, taribāre nā dekhi upāya e viṣaya-halāhale, divā-niśi hiyā jvale, mana kabhu sukha nāhi pāya
“Because of my past fruitive activities, I have now fallen into an ocean of nescience. I cannot find any means to get out of this great ocean, which is indeed like an ocean of poison. We are trying to be happy through sense enjoyment, but actually that so-called enjoyment is like food that is too hot and causes burning in the heart. I feel a burning sensation constantly, day and night, and thus my mind cannot find satisfaction.”
Material existence is always full of anxiety. People are always trying to find many ways to mitigate anxiety, but because they are not guided by a real leader, they try to forget material anxiety through drink and sex indulgence. Foolish people do not know that by attempting to escape anxiety by drink and sex, they simply increase their duration of material life. It is not possible to escape material anxiety in this way.
The word pramadā-saṅga-dūṣitaḥ indicates that apart from all other contamination, if one simply remains attached to a woman, that single contamination will be sufficient to prolong one’s miserable material existence. Consequently, in Vedic civilization one is trained from the beginning to give up attachment for women. The first stage of life is brahmacārī, the second stage gṛhastha, the third stage vānaprastha, and the fourth stage sannyāsa. All these stages are devised to enable one to detach himself from the association of women.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Merged in unending darkness, devoid of memory, experiencing pain for infinite years, and, contaminated by association with a woman, he remembered in his mind that woman, and finally was born in the house of a great king of Vidarbha as the best of women.
He was merged in darkness devoid of end, in suffering. Since he worshipped through many sacrifices, it should be understood that he also enjoyed happiness in Svarga for many years. This is not mentioned in order to create a sense of renunciation in Prācīnabarhi. Because of remembering a woman he became a woman. The spiritual perspective is this. It was said that, because one faints from the extreme pain at the time of death, the loss of dharmic intelligence is temporary. After enjoying in Svarga with the exhaustion of pious deed, he regains his dharmic intelligence and is born in the house of a person following dharma. That is the intention of the verse. However, attaining a body of a man or woman was not mentioned. The various options of birth however, such as man or woman, are not mentioned here. This is explained later:
kvacit pumān kvacic ca strī kvacin nobhayam andha-dhīḥ
devo manuṣyas tiryag vā yathā-karma-guṇaṁ bhavaḥ
This foolish jīva is sometimes a man and sometimes he is a woman. Sometimes he is eunuch. Sometimes he is a devatā, a human or an animal. His birth takes place according to the guṇas and his actions. SB 4.29.29
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2013-03-20· English
Personal Guidance
Contaminated by association with women, he suffers many years in the dark region of material life. The penalty is multi-life and dark; sense-attachment isn't a single-life mistake.
Reflection Questions
Which contamination am I treating as a current-life issue when its consequences are multi-life?
What would extending my time-horizon change about today's choices?
tām—hereva—certainlymanasā—by the mindgṛhṇan—acceptingbabhūva—becamepramadā—womanuttamā—highly situatedanantaram—after deathvidarbhasya—of Vidarbharāja-siṁhasya—of the most powerful kingveśmani—at the house.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tām eva manasā gṛhṇan
tām
her
eva
certainly
manasā
by the mind
gṛhṇan
accepting
babhūva pramadottamā
babhūva
became
pramadā
woman
uttamā
highly situated
anantaraṁ vidarbhasya
anantaram
after death
vidarbhasya
of Vidarbha
rāja-siṁhasya veśmani
rāja-siṁhasya
of the most powerful king
veśmani
at the house.
King Purañjana gave up his body while remembering his wife, and consequently in his next life he became a very beautiful and well-situated woman. He took his next birth as the daughter of King Vidarbha in the very house of the King.
Purport
Since King Purañjana thought of his wife at the time of death, he attained the body of a woman in his next birth. This verifies the following verse in Bhagavad-gītā (8.6) :
yaṁ yaṁ vāpi smaran bhāvaṁ tyajaty ante kalevaram taṁ tam evaiti kaunteya sadā tad-bhāva-bhāvitaḥ
“Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail.”
When a living entity is accustomed to think of a particular subject matter or become absorbed in a certain type of thought, he will think of that subject at the time of death. At the time of death, one will think of the subject that has occupied his life while he was awake, lightly sleeping or dreaming, or while he was deeply sleeping. After falling from the association of the Supreme Lord, the living entity thus transmigrates from one bodily form to another according to nature’s course, until he finally attains the human form. If he is absorbed in material thoughts and ignorant of spiritual life, and if he does not take shelter under the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda, who solves all questions of birth and death, he will become a woman in the next life, especially if he thinks of his wife. As stated in Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (3.31.1) , karmaṇā daiva-netreṇa. A living entity acts piously and impiously, and sometimes in both ways. All actions are taken into account, and the living entity is offered a new body by his superiors. Although King Purañjana was overly attached to his wife, he nonetheless performed many pious fruitive activities. Consequently, although he took the form of a woman, he was given a chance to be the daughter of a powerful king. As confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā (6.41) :
“The unsuccessful yogī, after many, many years of enjoyment on the planets of the pious living entities, is born into a family of righteous people or into a family of rich aristocracy.”
If a person falls from the path of bhakti-yoga, God realization, due to attachment to fruitive activity, philosophical speculation or mystic yoga, he is given a chance to take birth in a high and rich family. The higher authorities appointed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead thus render justice to the living entity according to the living entity’s desires. Although King Purañjana was overly absorbed in thoughts of his wife and thus became a woman, he took birth in the family of a king due to his previous pious activities. The conclusion is that all our activities are taken into consideration before we are awarded another body. Nārada Muni therefore advised Vyāsadeva that one should take to Kṛṣṇa consciousness, devotional service, and abandon all ordinary occupational duties. This advice was also given by Lord Kṛṣṇa Himself. Although a devotee may fall from the path of spiritual consciousness, he will nonetheless attain a human body in the home of a devotee or a rich man. In this way one can resume his devotional service.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Merged in unending darkness, devoid of memory, experiencing pain for infinite years, and, contaminated by association with a woman, he remembered in his mind that woman, and finally was born in the house of a great king of Vidarbha as the best of women.
He was merged in darkness devoid of end, in suffering. Since he worshipped through many sacrifices, it should be understood that he also enjoyed happiness in Svarga for many years. This is not mentioned in order to create a sense of renunciation in Prācīnabarhi. Because of remembering a woman he became a woman. The spiritual perspective is this. It was said that, because one faints from the extreme pain at the time of death, the loss of dharmic intelligence is temporary. After enjoying in Svarga with the exhaustion of pious deed, he regains his dharmic intelligence and is born in the house of a person following dharma. That is the intention of the verse. However, attaining a body of a man or woman was not mentioned. The various options of birth however, such as man or woman, are not mentioned here. This is explained later:
kvacit pumān kvacic ca strī kvacin nobhayam andha-dhīḥ
devo manuṣyas tiryag vā yathā-karma-guṇaṁ bhavaḥ
This foolish jīva is sometimes a man and sometimes he is a woman. Sometimes he is eunuch. Sometimes he is a devatā, a human or an animal. His birth takes place according to the guṇas and his actions. SB 4.29.29
His Holiness Smita Krishna Swami· 2013-03-21· English
Personal Guidance
Remembering his wife at death, he became a beautiful woman — daughter of King Vidarbha. What you think of at death determines your next body literally; scripture is technical, not metaphorical.
Reflection Questions
What if my last thought were known to determine my next form — would I rearrange anything?
What rehearsal would make the right last-thought more likely?
upayeme—marriedvīrya—of valor or prowesspaṇām—the prizevaidarbhīm—daughter of Vidarbhamalaya-dhvajaḥ—Malayadhvajayudhi—in the fightnirjitya—after conqueringrājanyān—other princespāṇḍyaḥ—best of the learned, or born in the country known as Pāṇḍupara—transcendentalpuram—cityjayaḥ—conqueror.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
upayeme vīrya-paṇāṁ
upayeme
married
vīrya
of valor or prowess
paṇām
the prize
vaidarbhīṁ malayadhvajaḥ
vaidarbhīm
daughter of Vidarbha
malaya-dhvajaḥ
Malayadhvaja
yudhi nirjitya rājanyān
yudhi
in the fight
nirjitya
after conquering
rājanyān
other princes
pāṇḍyaḥ para-purañjayaḥ
pāṇḍyaḥ
best of the learned, or born in the country known as Pāṇḍu
para
transcendental
puram
city
jayaḥ
conqueror.
It was fixed that Vaidarbhī, daughter of King Vidarbha, was to be married to a very powerful man, Malayadhvaja, an inhabitant of the Pāṇḍu country. After conquering other princes, he married the daughter of King Vidarbha.
Purport
It is customary among kṣatriyas for a princess to be offered under certain conditions. For instance, Draupadī was offered in marriage to one who could pierce a fish with an arrow simply by seeing the reflection of that fish. Kṛṣṇa married one of His queens after conquering seven strong bulls. The Vedic system is for a daughter of a king to be offered under certain conditions. Vaidarbhī, the daughter of Vidarbha, was offered to a great devotee and powerful king. Since King Malayadhvaja was both a powerful king and great devotee, he fulfilled all the requirements. The name Malayadhvaja signifies a great devotee who stands as firm as Malaya Hill and, through his propaganda, makes other devotees similarly as firm. Such a mahā-bhāgavata can prevail over the opinions of all others. A strong devotee makes propaganda against all other spiritual conceptions, namely jñāna, karma and yoga. With his devotional flag unfurled, he always stands fast to conquer other conceptions of transcendental realization. Whenever there is an argument between a devotee and a nondevotee, the pure, strong devotee comes out victorious.
The word pāṇḍya comes from the word paṇḍā, meaning “knowledge.” Unless one is highly learned, he cannot conquer nondevotional conceptions. The word para means “transcendental,” and pura means “city.” The para-pura is Vaikuṇṭha, the kingdom of God, and the word jaya refers to one who can conquer. This means that a pure devotee, who is strong in devotional service and who has conquered all nondevotional conceptions, can also conquer the kingdom of God. In other words, one can conquer the kingdom of God, Vaikuṇṭha, only by rendering devotional service. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is called ajita, meaning that no one can conquer Him, but a devotee, by strong devotional service and sincere attachment to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, can easily conquer Him. Lord Kṛṣṇa is fear personified for everyone, but He voluntarily agreed to fear the stick of mother Yaśodā. Kṛṣṇa, God, cannot be conquered by anyone but His devotee. Such a devotee kindly married the daughter of King Vidarbha.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Intelligent Malayadhvaja, the conqueror of enemy cities, after defeating other kings in battle, married the daughter of the King of Vidarbha, as prize for his chivalry.
As long as the jīva does not have bhakti, he cannot get deliverance from saṁsāra. Bhakti is spontaneous. It arises from association with devotees, by spontaneous mercy of devotees. That is shown in Purañjana’s next life as Vaidarbhī, where he attained association with a devotee through marriage. Malayadhvaja means the best (dhvaja) among the devotees, who are equal to Malaya mountain range, since they are worthy of the same worship. Upayeme (married) can mean “accepting to be a student.” Vīrya-paṇām (prize for valor) can also mean no one else could be accepted as teacher because he had great mercy as his power (vīrya).
asmiḹ loke vartamānaḥ sva-dharma-stho 'naghaḥ śuciḥ
jñānaṁ viśuddham āpnoti mad-bhaktiṁ vā yadṛcchayā
One who is situated in his prescribed duty, free from sinful activities and cleansed of material contamination, in this very life obtains transcendental knowledge or, by fortune, devotional service unto me. SB 11.20.11
bhavāpavargo bhramato yadā bhavej
janasya tarhy acyuta sat-samāgamaḥ
sat-saṅgamo yarhi tadaiva sad-gatau
parāvareśe tvayi jāyate matiḥ
When the material life of a wandering soul has ceased, O Acyuta, he may attain the association of your devotees. And when he associates with them, there awakens in him devotion unto you, who are the goal of the devotees and the Lord of all causes and their effects. SB 10.51.53
These verses show that bhakti arises in the jīva in some birth, from sudden association with a devotee. He had defeated other kings. This means that he had uprooted all sins, offenses, time and karma. Pāṇḍyaḥ means he was from Paṇḍya province, or “he who could discriminate between matter and spirit.” Para-purañjayaḥ means “he who conquered the cities of enemies” or “he who cut the doubts arising from other philosophies.”
Vaidarbhī was fixed to be married to Malayadhvaja of the Pāṇḍu country, who conquered other princes and married her. Fate sometimes provides a better match in the next life; not all karmic returns are punitive.
Reflection Questions
Where do I assume karma is only punishment and miss the matchmaker aspect?
What better match might be on its way that I haven't expected?
तस्यां स जनयां चक्र आत्मजामसितेक्षणाम् ।
यवीयस: सप्त सुतान् सप्त द्रविडभूभृत: ॥ ३० ॥
tasyāṁ sa janayāṁ cakra
[tasyaam sa janayaam chakra]
ātmajām asitekṣaṇām
[aatmajaam asitekshanaam]
yavīyasaḥ sapta sutān
[yaveeyasah sapta sutaan]
sapta draviḍa-bhūbhṛtaḥ
[sapta dravida-bhoobhritah]
Word-for-word
tasyām—through hersaḥ—the Kingjanayām cakre—begotātmajām—daughterasita—blue or blackīkṣaṇām—whose eyesyavīyasaḥ—younger, very powerfulsapta—sevensutān—sonssapta—sevendraviḍa—province of Draviḍa, or South Indiabhū—of the landbhṛtaḥ—kings.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tasyāṁ sa janayāṁ cakra
tasyām
through her
saḥ
the King
janayām cakre
begot
ātmajām asitekṣaṇām
ātmajām
daughter
asita
blue or black
īkṣaṇām
whose eyes
yavīyasaḥ sapta sutān
yavīyasaḥ
younger, very powerful
sapta
seven
sutān
sons
sapta draviḍa-bhūbhṛtaḥ
sapta
seven
draviḍa
province of Draviḍa, or South India
bhū
of the land
bhṛtaḥ
kings.
King Malayadhvaja fathered one daughter, who had very black eyes. He also had seven sons, who later became rulers of that tract of land known as Draviḍa. Thus there were seven kings in that land.
Purport
King Malayadhvaja was a great devotee, and after he married the daughter of King Vidarbha, he gave her one nice daughter, whose eyes were black. Figuratively this means that the daughter of King Malayadhvaja was also bestowed with devotional service, for her eyes were always fixed on Kṛṣṇa. A devotee has no vision in his life other than Kṛṣṇa. The seven sons are the seven processes of devotional service — hearing, chanting, remembering, offering worship, offering prayers, rendering transcendental loving service and serving the lotus feet of the Lord. Of the nine types of devotional service, only seven were immediately given. The balance — friendship and surrendering everything — were to be developed later. In other words, devotional service is divided into two categories, namely vidhi-mārga and rāga-mārga. The process of becoming friends with the Lord and sacrificing everything for Him belongs to the category of rāga-mārga, the stage of developed devotional service. For the neophyte, the important processes are those of hearing and chanting ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanam ), remembering Kṛṣṇa, worshiping the Deity in the temple, offering prayers, always engaging in the service of the Lord, and worshiping the lotus feet of the Lord.
The word yavīyasaḥ indicates that these processes are very powerful. After a devotee engages in the processes of śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ smaraṇaṁ pāda-sevanam/ arcanaṁ vandanaṁ dāsyam, and is able to secure these processes, he can later become a devotee capable of rendering spontaneous devotional service, namely sakhyam and ātma-nivedanam. Generally the great ācāryas who preach devotional service all over the world belong to the category of sakhyam ātma-nivedanam. A neophyte devotee cannot actually become a preacher. The neophyte is advised to execute devotional service in the seven other fields ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanam, etc.). If one can successfully execute the preliminary seven items, he can in the future be situated on the platform of sakhyam ātma-nivedanam.
The specific mention of Draviḍa-deśa refers to the five Draviḍa-deśas in South India. All are very strong in rendering the preliminary devotional processes ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanam ). Some great ācāryas, like Rāmānujācārya and Madhvācārya, also came from Draviḍa-deśa and became great preachers. They were all situated on the platform of sakhyam ātma-nivedanam.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
In her, he begot a daughter named Asiteksaṇā and seven younger sons who became kings of seven southern provinces.
Asitekṣaṇā was the daughter’s name. It can also mean she who received the glance of Kṛṣṇa (asita). Thus it means one who has a taste for serving Kṛṣṇa. By the mercy of guru, the jīva develops a taste for serving Kṛṣṇa. The seven sons were born later. They are hearing, remembering, chanting, serving the lotus feet, deity worship, bowing down and servitude. Because friendship and full surrender are difficult in the beginning, and will appear spontaneously later, they are not mentioned. The sons were kings of the southern provinces. The southern provinces are renowned for prominence of bhakti, hearing and chanting. The seven processes ruled like kings, having subdued karma, jñāna and other processes.
Malayadhvaja had a black-eyed daughter and seven sons who became rulers of Draviḍa. The line produces leaders; one good marriage seeds an entire region's stewardship.
Reflection Questions
Which 'marriage' of mine could seed multiple lines of stewardship?
Where am I undervaluing the generational effect of present unions?
एकैकस्याभवत्तेषांराजन्नर्बुदमर्बुदम् ।
भोक्ष्यते यद्वंशधरैर्मही मन्वन्तरं परम् ॥ ३१ ॥
ekaikasyābhavat teṣāṁ
[ekaikasyaabhavat teshaam]
rājann arbudam arbudam
[raajann arbudam arbudam]
bhokṣyate yad-vaṁśa-dharair
[bhokshyate yad-vamsha-dharair]
mahī manvantaraṁ param
[mahee manvantaram param]
Word-for-word
eka-ekasya—of each oneabhavat—there becameteṣām—of themrājan—O Kingarbudam—ten millionarbudam—ten millionbhokṣyate—is ruledyat—whosevaṁśa-dharaiḥ—by descendantsmahī—the whole worldmanu-antaram—up to the end of one Manuparam—and afterward.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ekaikasyābhavat teṣāṁ
eka-ekasya
of each one
abhavat
there became
teṣām
of them
rājann arbudam arbudam
rājan
O King
arbudam
ten million
arbudam
ten million
bhokṣyate yad-vaṁśa-dharair
bhokṣyate
is ruled
yat
whose
vaṁśa-dharaiḥ
by descendants
mahī manvantaraṁ param
mahī
the whole world
manu-antaram
up to the end of one Manu
param
and afterward.
My dear King Prācīnabarhiṣat, the sons of Malayadhvaja gave birth to many thousands and thousands of sons, and all of these have been protecting the entire world up to the end of one Manu’s life span and even afterward.
Purport
There are fourteen Manus in one day of Brahmā. A manvantara, the life span of one Manu, is given as 71 multiplied by 4,320,000 years. After one such Manu passes on, another Manu begins his life span. In this way the life cycle of the universe is going on. As one Manu follows another, the cult of Kṛṣṇa consciousness is being imparted, as confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā (4.1) :
“The Blessed Lord said: I instructed this imperishable science of yoga to the sun-god, Vivasvān, and Vivasvān instructed it to Manu, the father of mankind, and Manu in turn instructed it to Ikṣvāku.” Vivasvān, the sun-god, imparted Bhagavad-gītā to one Manu, and this Manu imparted it to his son, who imparted it to yet another Manu. In this way the propagation of Kṛṣṇa consciousness is never stopped. No one should think that this Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement is a new movement. As confirmed by Bhagavad-gītā and Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, it is a very, very old movement, for it has been passing down from one Manu to another.
Among Vaiṣṇavas there may be some difference of opinion due to everyone’s personal identity, but despite all personal differences, the cult of Kṛṣṇa consciousness must go on. We can see that under the instructions of Śrīla Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura, Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Gosvāmī Mahārāja began preaching the Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement in an organized way within the past hundred years. The disciples of Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Gosvāmī Mahārāja are all godbrothers, and although there are some differences of opinion, and although we are not acting conjointly, every one of us is spreading this Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement according to his own capacity and producing many disciples to spread it all over the world. As far as we are concerned, we have already started the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, and many thousands of Europeans and Americans have joined this movement. Indeed, it is spreading like wildfire. The cult of Kṛṣṇa consciousness, based on the nine principles of devotional service ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ smaraṇaṁ pāda-sevanam/ arcanaṁ vandanaṁ dāsyaṁ sakhyam ātma-nivedanam ), will never be stopped. It will go on without distinction of caste, creed, color or country. No one can check it.
The word bhokṣyate is very important in this verse. Just as a king gives protection to his citizens, these devotees, following the principles of devotional service, will give protection to all the people of the world. The people of the world are very much harassed by so-called religious-principled svāmīs, yogīs, karmīs and jñānīs, but none of these can show the right way to become elevated to the spiritual platform. There are primarily four parties spreading devotional service all over the universe. These are the Rāmānuja sampradāya, the Madhva sampradāya, the Viṣṇusvāmi sampradāya and the Nimbārka sampradāya. The Madhva-Gauḍīya sampradāya in particular comes from Lord Caitanya Mahāprabhu. All these devotees are spreading this Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement very widely and giving protection to innocent people who are being so much embarrassed by pseudo- avatāras,-svāmīs, -yogīs and others.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Each of them had tens of millions of children, the descendents of whom ruled the earth during Manu’s period and after.
The seven sons had many sons and grandsons. This also means that the processes like hearing can each be subdivided into hearing the name, the pastimes, or the qualities. Or they can be divided according to worship of different avatāras. Or they can be divided according to different rasas. Thus there are innumerable subdivisions of each process.
bhakti-yogo bahu-vidho mārgair bhāvini bhāvyate
svabhāva-guṇa-mārgeṇa puṁsāṁ bhāvo vibhidyate
Bhakti appears in many forms by particular actions in a person according to his intentions. The intentions of men are classed by the actions of the guṇas arising from one’s nature. SB 3.29.7
The descendants are the different sampradāyas. They ruled the whole earth. This means that the earth was protected from ignorance and materialistic karma-yoga.
His grandsons protected the world up to and after one Manu's span. The line keeps protecting through cosmic ages; dharmic lineages outlast individuals.
Reflection Questions
Whose long-line protection am I receiving without knowing it?
What contribution of mine could outlast me by ages if rightly seeded?
अगस्त्य:प्राग्दुहितरमुपयेमेधृतव्रताम् ।
यस्यां दृढच्युतो जात इध्मवाहात्मजो मुनि: ॥ ३२ ॥
agastyaḥ prāg duhitaram
[agastyah praag duhitaram]
upayeme dhṛta-vratām
[upayeme dhrita-vrataam]
yasyāṁ dṛḍhacyuto jāta
[yasyaam dridhachyuto jaata]
idhmavāhātmajo muniḥ
[idhmavaahaatmajo munih]
Word-for-word
agastyaḥ—the great sage Agastyaprāk—firstduhitaram—daughterupayeme—marrieddhṛta-vratām—taken to vowsyasyām—through whomdṛḍhacyutaḥ—named Dṛḍhacyutajātaḥ—was bornidhmavāha—named Idhmavāhaātma-jaḥ—sonmuniḥ—the great sage.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
agastyaḥ prāg duhitaram
agastyaḥ
the great sage Agastya
prāk
first
duhitaram
daughter
upayeme dhṛta-vratām
upayeme
married
dhṛta-vratām
taken to vows
yasyāṁ dṛḍhacyuto jāta
yasyām
through whom
dṛḍhacyutaḥ
named Dṛḍhacyuta
jātaḥ
was born
idhmavāhātmajo muniḥ
idhmavāha
named Idhmavāha
ātma-jaḥ
son
muniḥ
the great sage.
The great sage named Agastya married the first-born daughter of Malayadhvaja, the avowed devotee of Lord Kṛṣṇa. From her one son was born, whose name was Dṛḍhacyuta, and from him another son was born, whose name was Idhmavāha.
Purport
The name Agastya Muni is very significant. Agastya Muni represents the mind. The word agastya indicates that the senses do not act independently, and the word muni means “mind.” The mind is the center of all the senses, and thus the senses cannot work independent of the mind. When the mind takes to the cult of bhakti, it engages in devotional service. The cult of bhakti ( bhakti-latā ) is the first daughter of Malayadhvaja, and as previously described, her eyes are always upon Kṛṣṇa ( asitekṣaṇām ). One cannot render bhakti to any demigod. Bhakti can be rendered only to Viṣṇu ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ ). Thinking the Absolute Truth to be without form, the Māyāvādīs say that the word bhakti can apply to any form of worship. If this were the case, a devotee could imagine any demigod or any godly form and worship it. This, however, is not the real fact. The real fact is that bhakti can be applied only to Lord Viṣṇu and His expansions. Therefore bhakti-latā is dṛḍha-vrata, the great vow, for when the mind is completely engaged in devotional service, the mind does not fall down. If one tries to advance by other means — by karma-yoga or jñāna-yoga — one will fall down, but if one is fixed in bhakti, he never falls down.
Thus from bhakti-latā the son Dṛḍhacyuta is born, and from Dṛḍhacyuta the next son, Idhmavāha, is born. The word idhma-vāha refers to one who carries wood for burning in a sacrifice when approaching a spiritual master. The point is that bhakti-latā, the cult of devotion, fixes one in his spiritual position. One so fixed never comes down, and he begets children who are strict followers of the śāstric injunctions. As said in the Vedas:
tad-vijñānārthaṁ sa gurum evābhigacchet samit-pāṇiḥ śrotriyaṁ brahma-niṣṭham
In the line of devotional service, those who are initiated are strict followers of the Vedic scriptural injunctions.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The sage Agastya married the first-born daughter of Malayadhvaja, who had firm vows, in whom one son named Dṛḍhacyuta was born. Dṛḍhacyuta had Idhmavāha as his son.
Agastya married the first daughter. Agastya means “one who brings together (stya) all the senses which cannot act (aga) on their own.” This means the mind, which accepted a taste (ruci) for Kṛṣṇa (the first daughter). That taste produced firm vows of mercy, tolerance and other good qualities (dṛdha-vratām). This means that from taste (ruci), by great mercy, the mind of the jīva then developed āsakti for serving Kṛṣṇa. That āsakti was devoid of (cyutaḥ) attachment (dṛdha) to Satyaloka and other places. This means it had distaste for enjoyments of this world and higher worlds. Or there developed distaste for other practices like jñāna and for liberation. That means the mind was completely devoid of desire for other practices or goals because of the exclusive taste for serving Kṛṣṇa. How did all this arise? He had a son Idhmavāha (one who carries firewood for sacrifice). This is famous in the śruti passage tad-vijñānārthaṁ sa gurum evābhigacchet samit-pāṇiḥ śrotriyaṁ brahma-niṣṭham: with fuel in hand, one should approach a guru learned in the Vedas and fixed in the Lord for knowledge of the Lord. (Muṇḍaka Upaniṣad 1.2.12) It means surrender to guru. According to the story line, Agastya had a son named Dṛdhacyuta who had a son named Idhmavāha. This is a description of the descendents of Malaydhvaja’s daughter.
Agastya married the eldest daughter; from her came Dṛḍhacyuta, then Idhmavāha. The mind (Agastya) married to discriminating intellect produces firm-resolve and offering-bearer; faculties have offspring.
Reflection Questions
What 'offspring' do my own faculties produce when properly married?
Where could I encourage the right inner marriages?
vibhajya—having dividedtanayebhyaḥ—among his sonskṣmām—the whole worldrāja-ṛṣiḥ—the great saintly kingmalayadhvajaḥ—named Malayadhvajaārirādhayiṣuḥ—desiring to worshipkṛṣṇam—Lord Kṛṣṇasaḥ—hejagāma—wentkulācalam—unto Kulācala.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
vibhajya tanayebhyaḥ kṣmāṁ
vibhajya
having divided
tanayebhyaḥ
among his sons
kṣmām
the whole world
rājarṣir malayadhvajaḥ
rāja-ṛṣiḥ
the great saintly king
malayadhvajaḥ
named Malayadhvaja
ārirādhayiṣuḥ kṛṣṇaṁ
ārirādhayiṣuḥ
desiring to worship
kṛṣṇam
Lord Kṛṣṇa
sa jagāma kulācalam
saḥ
he
jagāma
went
kulācalam
unto Kulācala.
After this, the great saintly King Malayadhvaja divided his entire kingdom among his sons. Then, in order to worship Lord Kṛṣṇa with full attention, he went to a solitary place known as Kulācala.
Purport
Malayadhvaja, the great king, was certainly a mahā-bhāgavata, topmost devotee. By executing devotional service, he begot many sons and disciples for propagating the bhakti cult ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ ). Actually, the entire world should be divided among such disciples; everyone should be engaged in preaching the cult of Kṛṣṇa consciousness. In other words, when disciples are grown up and are able to preach, the spiritual master should retire and sit down in a solitary place to write and execute nirjana-bhajana. This means sitting silently in a solitary place and executing devotional service. This nirjana-bhajana, which is the silent worship of the Supreme Lord, is not possible for a neophyte devotee. Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura never advised a neophyte devotee to go to a solitary place to engage in devotional service. Indeed, he has written a song in this connection:
“My dear mind, what kind of devotee are you? Simply for cheap adoration you sit in a solitary place and pretend to chant the Hare Kṛṣṇa mahā-mantra, but this is all cheating.” Thus Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura advocated that every devotee, under the guidance of an expert spiritual master, preach the bhakti cult, Kṛṣṇa consciousness, all over the world. Only when one is mature can he sit in a solitary place and retire from preaching all over the world. Following this example, the devotees of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness now render service as preachers in various parts of the world. Now they can allow the spiritual master to retire from active preaching work. In the last stage of the spiritual master’s life, the devotees of the spiritual master should take preaching activities into their own hands. In this way the spiritual master can sit down in a solitary place and render nirjana-bhajana.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The saintly king Malayadhvaja, desiring to worship Kṛṣṇa after dividing the earth among his sons, departed to Kulācala.
Dividing the earth means after dividing up the types of bhakti. Kulācalam means a place for concentration, a place giving bhakti or Veṅkaṭa hill.
His Holiness Vedavyasa Priya Swami· 2016-11-22· Hindi
Personal Guidance
Malayadhvaja divided his kingdom among his sons and went alone to Kulācala to worship Kṛṣṇa. The mature exit involves dividing what you've built and going to a quiet place; both halves are necessary.
hitvā—giving upgṛhān—homesutān—childrenbhogān—material happinessvaidarbhī—the daughter of King Vidarbhamadira-īkṣaṇā—with enchanting eyesanvadhāvata—followedpāṇḍya-īśam—King Malayadhvajajyotsnā iva—like the moonshinerajanī-karam—the moon.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
hitvā gṛhān sutān bhogān
hitvā
giving up
gṛhān
home
sutān
children
bhogān
material happiness
vaidarbhī madirekṣaṇā
vaidarbhī
the daughter of King Vidarbha
madira-īkṣaṇā
with enchanting eyes
anvadhāvata
followed
anvadhāvata pāṇḍyeśaṁ
pāṇḍya-īśam
King Malayadhvaja
jyotsneva rajanī-karam
jyotsnā iva
like the moonshine
rajanī-karam
the moon.
Just as the moonshine follows the moon at night, immediately after King Malayadhvaja departed for Kulācala, his devoted wife, whose eyes were very enchanting, followed him, giving up all homely happiness, despite family and children.
Purport
Just as in the vānaprastha stage the wife follows the husband, similarly when the spiritual master retires for nirjana-bhajana, some of his advanced devotees follow him and engage in his personal service. In other words, those who are very fond of family life should come forward in the service of the spiritual master and abandon so-called happiness afforded by society, friendship and love. A verse by Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura in his Gurv-aṣṭaka is significant in this regard: yasya prasādād bhagavat-prasādaḥ. A disciple should always remember that by serving the spiritual master he can easily advance in Kṛṣṇa consciousness. All the scriptures recommend that it is by pleasing the spiritual master and serving him directly that one can attain the highest perfectional stage of devotional service.
The word madirekṣaṇā is also significant in this verse. Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī has explained in his Sandarbha that the word madira means “intoxicating.” If one’s eyes become intoxicated upon seeing the Deity, he may be called madirekṣaṇa. Queen Vaidarbhī’s eyes were very enchanting, just as one’s eyes are madirekṣaṇa when engaged in seeing the temple Deity. Unless one is an advanced devotee, he cannot fix his eyes on the Deity in the temple.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Giving up he house, sons and enjoyments, the daughter of King Vidarbha with attractive eyes followed her husband, just as moon light follows the moon.
Just as the wife serves the husband by rejecting enjoyment, the disciple engages in service to guru by hearing and chanting, giving no regard even to solitary places (grhān) which could give rise to the bliss of prema (bhogān), in order to attain with ease the perfection of all goals by serving guru. This is the teaching in this verse. Mad means exciting. Irā means message or the Vedas. Her glance was always in the Veda, which gave joy, since the Vedas say that service to guru is the highest. Jīva Gosvāmī says that madira means the Lord who gives joy. She had a glance always in the form of the Lord who gives joy. The meaning according to the story is that she had ever-youthful glances in her eyes.
His Holiness Sacinandana Swami· 1992-11-23· English
Personal Guidance
Like moonshine follows the moon, his devoted wife followed despite home and children. The right spouse follows even into vānaprastha; some bonds belong on the next mountain.
Reflection Questions
Whose 'moonshine following' have I underestimated as just attachment when it's actual devotion?
Where am I a moon whose shine would, in turn, find a planet to light?
tatra—therecandravasā—the Candravasā Rivernāma—namedtāmraparṇī—the Tāmraparṇī Rivervaṭodakā—the Vaṭodakā Rivertat—of those riverspuṇya—pioussalilaiḥ—with the watersnityam—dailyubhayatra—in both waysātmanaḥ—of himselfmṛjan—washingkanda—bulbsaṣṭibhiḥ—and by seedsmūla—rootsphalaiḥ—and by fruitspuṣpa—flowersparṇaiḥ—and by leavestṛṇā—grassudakaiḥ—and by watervartamānaḥ—subsistingśanaiḥ—graduallygātra—his bodykarśanam—rendering thintapaḥ—austerityāsthitaḥ—he underwent.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tatra candravasā nāma
tatra
there
candravasā
the Candravasā River
nāma
named
tāmraparṇī vaṭodakā
tāmraparṇī
the Tāmraparṇī River
vaṭodakā
the Vaṭodakā River
tat-puṇya-salilair nityam
tat
of those rivers
puṇya
pious
salilaiḥ
with the waters
nityam
daily
ubhayatrātmano mṛjan
ubhayatra
in both ways
ātmanaḥ
of himself
mṛjan
washing
kandāṣṭibhir mūla-phalaiḥ
kanda
bulbs
aṣṭibhiḥ
and by seeds
mūla
roots
phalaiḥ
and by fruits
puṣpa-parṇais tṛṇodakaiḥ
puṣpa
flowers
parṇaiḥ
and by leaves
tṛṇā
grass
udakaiḥ
and by water
vartamānaḥ śanair gātra-
vartamānaḥ
subsisting
śanaiḥ
gradually
gātra
his body
karśanaṁ tapa āsthitaḥ
karśanam
rendering thin
tapaḥ
austerity
āsthitaḥ
he underwent.
In the province of Kulācala, there were rivers named Candravasā, Tāmraparṇī and Vaṭodakā. King Malayadhvaja used to go to those pious rivers regularly and take his bath there. Thus he purified himself externally and internally. He took his bath and ate bulbs, seeds, leaves, flowers, roots, fruits and grasses and drank water. In this way he underwent severe austerities. Eventually he became very skinny.
Purport
We can definitely see that to advance in Kṛṣṇa consciousness one must control his bodily weight. If one becomes too fat, it is to be assumed that he is not advancing spiritually. Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura severely criticized his fat disciples. The idea is that one who intends to advance in Kṛṣṇa consciousness must not eat very much. Devotees used to go to forests, high hills or mountains on pilgrimages, but such severe austerities are not possible in these days. One should instead eat only prasāda and no more than required. According to the Vaiṣṇava calendar, there are many fasts, such as Ekādaśī and the appearance and disappearance days of God and His devotees. All of these are meant to decrease the fat within the body so that one will not sleep more than desired and will not become inactive and lazy. Overindulgence in food will cause a man to sleep more than required. This human form of life is meant for austerity, and austerity means controlling sex, food intake, etc. In this way time can be saved for spiritual activity, and one can purify himself both externally and internally. Thus both body and mind can be cleansed.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
At Kulācala the King bathed daily internally and externally in the Candravaṣa, Tāmraparṇī and Vaṭodakā Rivers. Undergoing austerities, subsisting on roots, seeds, bulbs, fruits, flowers, leaves, grass and water, his body eventually became thin.
Internally and externally (ubhayatra) he washed away impurities. As in the case of Pṛthu, his intense austerity arose from his great eagerness for the Lord.
His Holiness Prabodhananda Sarasvati Swami· 2013-04-04· English
Personal Guidance
He bathed in Candravasā, Tāmraparṇī, Vaṭodakā; ate bulbs, seeds, leaves; gradually his body grew thin. Forest-life is sequenced; bathing-eating-thinning, in that order, transforms the body for the soul.
Reflection Questions
Which simple sequence (bathing, eating, thinning) could I begin to honor seriously?
Where do I imagine asceticism as random when scripture sequences it?
Through austerity, King Malayadhvaja in body and mind gradually became equal to the dualities of cold and heat, happiness and distress, wind and rain, hunger and thirst, the pleasant and the unpleasant. In this way he conquered all relativities.
Purport
Liberation means becoming free from the relativities of the world. Unless one is self-realized, he has to undergo the dual struggle of the relative world. In Bhagavad-gītā Lord Kṛṣṇa advises Arjuna to conquer all relativities through tolerance. Lord Kṛṣṇa points out that it is the relativities like winter and summer that give us trouble in the material world. In the winter we do not like taking a bath, but in the summer we wish to take a bath twice, thrice or more a day. Thus Kṛṣṇa advises us not to be disturbed by such relativities and dualities when they come and go.
The common man has to undergo much austerity to become equipoised before dualities. One who becomes agitated by the relativities of life has accepted a relative position and must therefore undergo the austerities prescribed in the śāstras to transcend the material body and put an end to material existence. King Malayadhvaja underwent severe austerities by leaving his home, going to Kulācala, taking his bath in the sacred rivers and eating only vegetables like stems, roots, seeds, flowers and leaves, avoiding any cooked food or grains. These are very, very austere practices. In this age it is very difficult to leave home and go to the forest or the Himālayas to adopt the processes of austerity. Indeed, it is almost impossible. If one is even advised to give up meat-eating, drinking, gambling and illicit sex, one will fail to do so. What, then, would a person do if he went to the Himālayas or Kulācala? Such acts of renunciation are not possible in this age; therefore Lord Kṛṣṇa has advised us to accept the bhakti-yoga process. Bhakti-yoga will automatically liberate a person from the dualities of life. In bhakti-yoga, Kṛṣṇa is the center, and Kṛṣṇa is always transcendental. Thus in order to transcend dualities, one must always engage in the service of the Lord, as confirmed by Bhagavad-gītā (14.26) :
māṁ ca yo ’vyabhicāreṇa bhakti-yogena sevate sa guṇān samatītyaitān brahma-bhūyāya kalpate
“One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman.”
If one is factually engaged in the service of the Lord, bhakti-yoga, he will automatically control his senses, his tongue and so many other things. Once engaged in the bhakti-yoga process with all sincerity, one will have no chance of falling down. Even if one falls down, there is no loss. One’s devotional activities may be stunned or choked for the time being, but as soon as there is another chance, the practitioner begins from the point where he left off.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Seeing all things equally, he conquered the dualities of cold and heat, wind and rain, hunger, thirst, favorable and unfavorable conditions, happiness and distress.
His Holiness Bhakti Dhira Damodar Swami· 2019-08-13· English
Personal Guidance
By austerity he became equal to cold/heat, happiness/distress, hunger/thirst — conquering relativity. The duals collapse under sustained practice; you don't need new circumstances, you need transformed relativity.
Reflection Questions
Which dual is currently agitating me most, and what discipline would collapse it?
Where do I keep waiting for circumstances to change instead of practicing equanimity?
By worshiping, executing austerities and following the regulative principles, King Malayadhvaja conquered his senses, his life and his consciousness. Thus he fixed everything on the central point of the Supreme Brahman [Kṛṣṇa].
Purport
Whenever the word brahman appears, the impersonalists take this to mean the impersonal effulgence, the brahmajyoti. Actually, however, Parabrahman, the Supreme Brahman, is Kṛṣṇa, Vāsudeva. As stated in Bhagavad-gītā (7.19) , vāsudevaḥ sarvam iti: Vāsudeva extends everywhere as the impersonal Brahman. One cannot fix one’s mind upon an impersonal “something.” Bhagavad-gītā (12.5) therefore says, kleśo ’dhikataras teṣām avyaktāsakta-cetasām: “For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome.” Consequently, when it is said herein that King Malayadhvaja fixed his mind on Brahman, “Brahman” means the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Vāsudeva.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Burning all impurities by austerity, knowledge, niyama and yama, and conquering his senses, life air and mind, he fixed his mind on Vāsudeva.
Brahmaṇi means Vāsudeva by the context of the following verses. Ātmanam is the mind.
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2014-05-22· Czech
Personal Guidance
By worship, austerity and rules, he conquered senses, life, consciousness; fixed everything on Kṛṣṇa. Many practices converging on one focal point; that's the design of a successful spiritual life.
Reflection Questions
What is the focal point of my many practices, and is it sharp enough?
Where do my practices scatter rather than converge?
āste—remainssthāṇuḥ—immovableiva—likeekatra—in one placedivyam—of the demigodsvarṣa—yearsśatam—one hundredsthiraḥ—steadyvāsudeve—unto Lord Kṛṣṇabhagavati—the Supreme Personality of Godheadna—notanyat—anything elseveda—did knowudvahan—possessingratim—attraction.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
āste sthāṇur ivaikatra
āste
remains
sthāṇuḥ
immovable
iva
like
ekatra
in one place
divyaṁ varṣa-śataṁ sthiraḥ
divyam
of the demigods
varṣa
years
śatam
one hundred
sthiraḥ
steady
vāsudeve bhagavati
vāsudeve
unto Lord Kṛṣṇa
bhagavati
the Supreme Personality of Godhead
nānyad vedodvahan ratim
na
not
anyat
anything else
veda
did know
udvahan
possessing
ratim
attraction.
In this way he stayed immovable in one place for one hundred years by the calculation of the demigods. After this time, he developed pure devotional attraction for Kṛṣṇa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and remained fixed in that position.
Purport
bahūnāṁ janmanām ante jñānavān māṁ prapadyate vāsudevaḥ sarvam iti sa mahātmā sudurlabhaḥ
“After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare.” ( Bg. 7.19 ) Vāsudeva, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kṛṣṇa, is everything, and one who knows this is the greatest of all transcendentalists. It is stated in Bhagavad-gītā that one realizes this after many, many births. This is also confirmed in this verse with the words divyaṁ varṣa-śatam, “one hundred years according to the calculation of the demigods.” According to the calculations of the demigods, one day (twelve hours) is equal to six months on earth. A hundred years of the demigods would equal thirty-six thousand earth years. Thus King Malayadhvaja executed austerities and penances for thirty-six thousand years. After this time, he became fixed in the devotional service of the Lord. To live on earth for so many years, one has to take birth many times. This confirms the conclusion of Kṛṣṇa. To come to the conclusion of Kṛṣṇa consciousness and remain fixed in the realization that Kṛṣṇa is everything, as well as render service unto Kṛṣṇa, are characteristics of the perfectional stage. As said in Caitanya-caritāmṛta ( Madhya 22.62) , kṛṣṇe bhakti kaile sarva-karma kṛta haya: when one comes to the conclusion that Kṛṣṇa is everything by worshiping or by rendering devotional service unto Kṛṣṇa, one actually becomes perfect in all respects. Not only must one come to the conclusion that Kṛṣṇa is everything, but he must remain fixed in this realization. This is the highest perfection of life, and it is this perfection that King Malayadhvaja attained at the end.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
For a hundred years of the devatās he remained fixed in one place. Possessing rati for the Supreme Lord Vāsudeva, he was not aware of anything else.
By such remembrance in bhakti, continuous rati for the Lord appeared.
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2014-05-23· Czech
Personal Guidance
He stayed immovable for 100 demigod-years and developed pure devotional attraction for Kṛṣṇa. Pure devotion can take a very long time; not all aspirants get there fast.
Reflection Questions
Where am I impatient with my own pace when the texts treat it as expected to be slow?
What would 100-demigod-year patience look like in my own practice?
स व्यापकतयात्मानं व्यतिरिक्ततयात्मनि ।
विद्वान् स्वप्न इवामर्शसाक्षिणं विरराम ह ॥ ४० ॥
sa vyāpakatayātmānaṁ
[sa vyaapakatayaatmaanam]
vyatiriktatayātmani
[vyatiriktatayaatmani]
vidvān svapna ivāmarśa-
[vidvaan svapna ivaamarsha-]
sākṣiṇaṁ virarāma ha
[saakshinam viraraama ha]
Word-for-word
saḥ—King Malayadhvajavyāpakatayā—by all-pervasivenessātmānam—the Supersoulvyatiriktatayā—by differentiationātmani—in his own selfvidvān—perfectly educatedsvapne—in a dreamiva—likeamarśa—of deliberationsākṣiṇam—the witnessvirarāma—became indifferentha—certainly.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
sa vyāpakatayātmānaṁ
saḥ
King Malayadhvaja
vyāpakatayā
by all-pervasiveness
ātmānam
the Supersoul
vyatiriktatayātmani
vyatiriktatayā
by differentiation
ātmani
in his own self
vidvān svapna ivāmarśa-
vidvān
perfectly educated
svapne
in a dream
iva
like
amarśa
of deliberation
sākṣiṇaṁ virarāma ha
sākṣiṇam
the witness
virarāma
became indifferent
ha
certainly.
King Malayadhvaja attained perfect knowledge by being able to distinguish the Supersoul from the individual soul. The individual soul is localized, whereas the Supersoul is all-pervasive. He became perfect in knowledge that the material body is not the soul but that the soul is the witness of the material body.
Purport
The conditioned soul is often frustrated in trying to understand the distinctions between the material body, the Supersoul and the individual soul. There are two types of Māyāvādī philosophers: the followers of the Buddhist philosophy and the followers of the Śaṅkara philosophy. The followers of Buddha do not recognize that there is anything beyond the body. The followers of Śaṅkara conclude that there is no separate existence of the Paramātmā, the Supersoul; they believe that the individual soul is identical with the Paramātmā in the ultimate analysis. But the Vaiṣṇava philosopher, who is perfect in knowledge, knows that the body is made of the external energy and that the Supersoul, the Paramātmā, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is sitting with the individual soul and is distinct from him. As Lord Kṛṣṇa states in Bhagavad-gītā (13.3) :
kṣetrajñaṁ cāpi māṁ viddhi sarva-kṣetreṣu bhārata kṣetra-kṣetrajñayor jñānaṁ yat taj jñānaṁ mataṁ mama
“O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies, and to understand this body and its owner is called knowledge. That is My opinion.”
The body is taken to be the field, and the individual soul is taken to be the worker in that field. Yet there is another, who is known as the Supersoul, who, along with the individual soul, simply witnesses. The individual soul works and enjoys the fruits of the body, whereas the Supersoul simply witnesses the activities of the individual soul but does not enjoy the fruits of those activities. The Supersoul is present in every field of activity, whereas the individual soul is present in his one localized body. King Malayadhvaja attained this perfection of knowledge and was able to distinguish between the soul and the Supersoul and the soul and the material body.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Momentarily realizing the Lord externally in all things and internally as well, he then fainted. It was like seeing a dream, whose witness is internal reflection.
By that rati, the Lord appeared everywhere. He realized (vidvān) the Lord as a form suddenly appearing in all directions (vyāpakatayā) because of the appearance of rati, and he realized the Lord within himself separately (vyatiriktatayā). By the fire of eagerness for prema he fainted (virarāma). The separation was not fully relieved by this sudden appearance of the Lord arising from intense separation. An example is given. It was just like knowing something in a dream. The hunger of a person is not relieved by eating food in a dream. What is the proof for such appearances of the Lord? The function of the antaḥkaraṇa called reflection is the witness, not a person with an eye. Because the pain of separation does not disappear by the functioning of the antaḥkaraṇa with his internal vision, he also realized the Lord who had appeared in his vision directly with his eyes. .
His Holiness Jayapataka Swami· 1989-04-11· English
Personal Guidance
He attained perfect knowledge by distinguishing Supersoul from individual soul. Distinction-keeping is the breakthrough; conflation looks easy but blocks the realization.
Reflection Questions
Where do I conflate ātmā and Paramātmā in a way that flattens both?
What sharper distinction would actually deepen my relationship with both?
sākṣāt—directlybhagavatā—by the Supreme Personality of Godheaduktena—instructedguruṇā—the spiritual masterhariṇā—by Lord Harinṛpa—O Kingviśuddha—purejñāna—knowledgedīpena—by the light ofsphuratā—enlighteningviśvataḥ-mukham—all angles of vision.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
sākṣād bhagavatoktena
sākṣāt
directly
bhagavatā
by the Supreme Personality of Godhead
guruṇā hariṇā nṛpa
viśuddha-jñāna-dīpena
sphuratā viśvato-mukham
uktena
instructed
guruṇā
the spiritual master
hariṇā
by Lord Hari
nṛpa
O King
viśuddha
pure
jñāna
knowledge
dīpena
by the light of
sphuratā
enlightening
viśvataḥ-mukham
all angles of vision.
In this way King Malayadhvaja attained perfect knowledge because in his pure state he was directly instructed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By means of such enlightening transcendental knowledge, he could understand everything from all angles of vision.
Purport
In this verse the words sākṣād bhagavatoktena guruṇā hariṇā are very significant. The Supreme Personality of Godhead speaks directly to the individual soul when the devotee has completely purified himself by rendering devotional service to the Lord. Lord Kṛṣṇa confirms this also in Bhagavad-gītā (10.10) :
“To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me.”
The Lord is the Supersoul seated in everyone’s heart, and He acts as the caitya-guru, the spiritual master within. However, He gives direct instructions only to the advanced, pure devotees. In the beginning, when a devotee is serious and sincere, the Lord gives him directions from within to approach a bona fide spiritual master. When one is trained by the spiritual master according to the regulative principles of devotional service and is situated on the platform of spontaneous attachment for the Lord ( rāga-bhakti ), the Lord also gives instructions from within ( teṣāṁ satata-yuktānāṁ bhajatāṁ prīti-pūrvakam/ dadāmi buddhi-yogaṁ tam ). This distinct advantage is obtained by a liberated soul. Having attained this stage, King Malayadhvaja was directly in touch with the Supreme Lord and was receiving instructions from Him directly.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O King! By direct vision of the Lord who takes away all suffering, shining brightly everywhere, by the lamp of pure knowledge taught by guru concerning the Lord’s sweetness, he saw himself possessing love for the Lord and saw the Lord possessing love for him, and after losing that vision because of fainting, he gave up all connection with the gross and subtle bodies.
Then, when prema arose, he saw the Lord directly. By the Supreme Lord who takes away all suffering (hariṇā), with bright effulgence spreading everywhere (viśvataḥmukham sphuratā), and by the lamp of knowledge, the means of realizing the Lord’s sweetness, what is taught by the guru, one sees himself as the possessor of rati for the supreme Brahman (ātmānam pare brahmaṇi), because it has already been said vāsudeve bhagavati nānyad vedodvahan ratim: he saw only that he had rati for Vāsudeva. The Lord also says ye yathā māṁ prapadyante tāṁstathaiva bhajāmyaham: according to how they surrender to me, I reward them. (BG 4.11) Thus he saw the Lord to be full of attraction for him (ātmani parabrahman). At that moment, giving up that vision because of fainting in bliss, he lost interest in gross and subtle coverings completely.
But those who favor the regal aspect of the Lord explain the three verses in the following way. The King, knowing the Supreme Lord (ātmānam) as all-pervading and also situated within the jīva, gave up saṁsāra. Examples are given of each vision. All pervasiveness of the Lord is similar to the witness of reflection, the mind, which spreads through the body of the jīva. The Lord within is similar to realizing in deep sleep that there is only the ātmā, for one says “I slept soundly.” In the deep sleep state, there is realization of only the ātmā, separate from body. How does this knowledge arise? It arises from the Lord who is the witness. Dadāmi buddhiyogaṁ taṁ yena māmupayānti: I give intelligence by which one attains me. (BG10.10) By the lamp of that knowledge, one sees in the Supreme Lord, who is the āśraya-tattva, the pure jīva, who takes shelter of the Lord. And he sees in the pure jīva, you, the Supreme Lord, presiding over the jīva. After attaining prema, one gives up the process of reflection (vihāya īkṣām). Because the Bhāgavatam is like Mohinī avatāra, giving nectar to the devotees and cheating the demons, others interpret these verses differently. The devotees do not accept those interpretations.
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2014-05-25· Czech
Personal Guidance
He attained knowledge directly instructed by the Lord; from that he could understand everything. Direct divine instruction beats all study; once it begins, comprehension generalizes.
Reflection Questions
Have I ever received direct divine instruction and recognized it as such?
What practice might open the channel for direct instruction in my life?
pare—transcendentalbrahmaṇi—in the Absoluteca—andātmānam—the selfparam—the supremebrahma—Absolutetathā—alsoātmani—in himselfvīkṣamāṇaḥ—thus observingvihāya—giving upīkṣām—reservationasmāt—from this processupararāma—retiredha—certainly.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
pare brahmaṇi cātmānaṁ
pare
transcendental
brahmaṇi
in the Absolute
ca
and
ātmānam
the self
paraṁ brahma tathātmani
param
the supreme
brahma
Absolute
tathā
also
ātmani
in himself
vīkṣamāṇo vihāyekṣām
vīkṣamāṇaḥ
thus observing
vihāya
giving up
īkṣām
reservation
asmād upararāma ha
asmāt
from this process
upararāma
retired
ha
certainly.
King Malayadhvaja could thus observe that the Supersoul was sitting by his side, and that he, as the individual soul, was sitting by the side of the Supersoul. Since both were together, there was no need for separate interests; thus he ceased from such activities.
Purport
In the advanced stage of devotional service, the devotee does not see anything separate between his own interests and those of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Both interests become one, for the devotee does not act for a separate interest. Whatever he does, he does in the interest of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. At that time he sees everything in the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supreme Personality of Godhead in everything. Having attained this stage of understanding, he sees no distinction between the spiritual and material worlds. In perfect vision, the material world becomes the spiritual world due to its being the external energy of the Supreme Lord. For the perfect devotee, the energy and the energetic are nondifferent. Thus the so-called material world becomes spiritual ( sarvaṁ khalv idaṁ brahma ). Everything is intended for the service of the Supreme Lord, and the expert devotee can utilize any so-called material thing for the Lord’s service. One cannot serve the Lord without being situated on the spiritual platform; thus if a so-called material thing is dovetailed in the service of the Lord, it is no longer to be considered material. This is how the pure devotee, in his perfect vision, sees from all angles.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O King! By direct vision of the Lord who takes away all suffering, shining brightly everywhere, by the lamp of pure knowledge taught by guru concerning the Lord’s sweetness, he saw himself possessing love for the Lord and saw the Lord possessing love for him, and after losing that vision because of fainting, he gave up all connection with the gross and subtle bodies.
Then, when prema arose, he saw the Lord directly. By the Supreme Lord who takes away all suffering (hariṇā), with bright effulgence spreading everywhere (viśvataḥmukham sphuratā), and by the lamp of knowledge, the means of realizing the Lord’s sweetness, what is taught by the guru, one sees himself as the possessor of rati for the supreme Brahman (ātmānam pare brahmaṇi), because it has already been said vāsudeve bhagavati nānyad vedodvahan ratim: he saw only that he had rati for Vāsudeva. The Lord also says ye yathā māṁ prapadyante tāṁstathaiva bhajāmyaham: according to how they surrender to me, I reward them. (BG 4.11) Thus he saw the Lord to be full of attraction for him (ātmani parabrahman). At that moment, giving up that vision because of fainting in bliss, he lost interest in gross and subtle coverings completely.
But those who favor the regal aspect of the Lord explain the three verses in the following way. The King, knowing the Supreme Lord (ātmānam) as all-pervading and also situated within the jīva, gave up saṁsāra. Examples are given of each vision. All pervasiveness of the Lord is similar to the witness of reflection, the mind, which spreads through the body of the jīva. The Lord within is similar to realizing in deep sleep that there is only the ātmā, for one says “I slept soundly.” In the deep sleep state, there is realization of only the ātmā, separate from body. How does this knowledge arise? It arises from the Lord who is the witness. Dadāmi buddhiyogaṁ taṁ yena māmupayānti: I give intelligence by which one attains me. (BG10.10) By the lamp of that knowledge, one sees in the Supreme Lord, who is the āśraya-tattva, the pure jīva, who takes shelter of the Lord. And he sees in the pure jīva, you, the Supreme Lord, presiding over the jīva. After attaining prema, one gives up the process of reflection (vihāya īkṣām). Because the Bhāgavatam is like Mohinī avatāra, giving nectar to the devotees and cheating the demons, others interpret these verses differently. The devotees do not accept those interpretations.
He saw Supersoul sitting by his side; no separate interests; he ceased separate activities. When two interests are seen as one, separate striving dissolves; no need to manage two agendas.
Reflection Questions
Which of my activities continues from a sense of separate interest from the Lord's?
Where would unity of interest end the striving altogether?
patim—her husbandparama—supremedharma-jñam—knower of religious principlesvaidarbhī—the daughter of Vidarbhamalaya-dhvajam—named Malayadhvajapremṇā—with love and affectionparyacarat—served in devotionhitvā—giving upbhogān—sense enjoymentssā—shepati-devatā—accepting her husband as the Supreme Lord.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
patiṁ parama-dharma-jñaṁ
patim
her husband
parama
supreme
dharma-jñam
knower of religious principles
vaidarbhī malayadhvajam
vaidarbhī
the daughter of Vidarbha
malaya-dhvajam
named Malayadhvaja
premṇā paryacarad dhitvā
premṇā
with love and affection
paryacarat
served in devotion
hitvā
giving up
bhogān sā pati-devatā
bhogān
sense enjoyments
sā
she
pati-devatā
accepting her husband as the Supreme Lord.
The daughter of King Vidarbha accepted her husband all in all as the Supreme. She gave up all sensual enjoyment and in complete renunciation followed the principles of her husband, who was so advanced. Thus she remained engaged in his service.
Purport
Figuratively, King Malayadhvaja is the spiritual master, and his wife, Vaidarbhī, is the disciple. The disciple accepts the spiritual master as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As stated by Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura in Gurv-aṣṭaka, sākṣād-dharitvena: “One directly accepts the guru, the spiritual master, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.” One should accept the spiritual master not in the sense that the Māyāvādī philosophers do, but in the way recommended here. Since the spiritual master is the most confidential servant of the Lord, he should be treated exactly like the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The spiritual master should never be neglected or disobeyed, like an ordinary person.
If a woman is fortunate enough to be the wife of a pure devotee, she can serve her husband without any desire for sense gratification. If she remains engaged in the service of her exalted husband, she will automatically attain the spiritual perfections of her husband. If a disciple gets a bona fide spiritual master, simply by satisfying him, he can attain a similar opportunity to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Vaidarbhī, seeing her husband as the Lord, served her husband, the highest knower of dharma, with devotion, giving up all enjoyment.
The disciple remains serving the guru until attaining perfection. That is shown in four verses.
Vaidarbhī accepted her husband as Supreme, gave up sense-enjoyment, followed him in renunciation. The disciple accepts the master as ultimate; that acceptance enables renunciation, not the other way around.
Reflection Questions
Whose acceptance-as-Supreme would unlock my own renunciation?
Where am I trying to renounce without first surrendering the master-question?
cīra-vāsā—wearing old garmentsvrata-kṣāmā—lean and thin on account of austeritiesveṇī-bhūta—entangledśiroruhā—her hairbabhau—she shoneupa patim—near the husbandśāntā—peacefulśikhā—flamesśāntam—without being agitatediva—likeanalam—fire.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
cīra-vāsā vrata-kṣāmā
cīra-vāsā
wearing old garments
vrata-kṣāmā
lean and thin on account of austerities
veṇī-bhūta-śiroruhā
veṇī-bhūta
entangled
śiroruhā
her hair
babhāv upa patiṁ śāntā
babhau
she shone
upa patim
near the husband
śāntā
peaceful
śikhā śāntam ivānalam
śikhā
flames
śāntam
without being agitated
iva
like
analam
fire.
The daughter of King Vidarbha wore old garments, and she was lean and thin because of her vows of austerity. Since she did not arrange her hair, it became entangled and twisted in locks. Although she remained always near her husband, she was as silent and unagitated as the flame of an undisturbed fire.
Purport
When one begins to burn firewood, there is smoke and agitation in the beginning. Although there are so many disturbances in the beginning, once the fire is completely set, the firewood burns steadily. Similarly, when both husband and wife follow the regulative principles of austerity, they remain silent and are not agitated by sex impulses. At such a time both husband and wife are benefited spiritually. One can attain this stage of life by completely giving up a luxurious mode of life.
In this verse the word cīra-vāsā refers to very old torn garments. The wife especially should remain austere, not desiring luxurious dresses and living standards. She should accept only the bare necessities of life and minimize her eating and sleeping. There should be no question of mating. Simply by engaging in the service of her exalted husband, who must be a pure devotee, the wife will never be agitated by sex impulses. The vānaprastha stage is exactly like this. Although the wife remains with the husband, she undergoes severe austerities and penances so that although both husband and wife live together, there is no question of sex. In this way both husband and wife can live together perpetually. Since the wife is weaker than the husband, this weakness is expressed in this verse with the words upa patim. Upa means “near to,” or “almost equal to.” Being a man, the husband is generally more advanced than his wife. Nonetheless, the wife is expected to give up all luxurious habits. She should not even dress nicely or comb her hair. Hair-combing is one of the main businesses of women. In the vānaprastha stage the wife should not take care of her hair. Thus her hair will become tangled in knots. Consequently, the wife will no longer be attractive to the husband, and she herself will no longer be agitated by sex impulses. In this way both husband and wife can advance in spiritual consciousness. This advanced stage is called the paramahaṁsa stage, and once it is obtained, both husband and wife can be actually liberated from bodily consciousness. If the disciple remains steady in the service of the spiritual master, he need no longer fear falling down into the clutches of māyā.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Wearing old clothing, thin because of austerity, with hair tangled, peaceful like the coals of a fire without flame, she remained by the side of her husband.
Upa is a preposition governing a noun in the accusative. It means “near the husband slightly lower in position.” She was peaceful like the coals of a fire, just shining, but without smoke.
His Holiness Bhakti Bhusana Swami· 1993-06-16· English
Personal Guidance
Old garments, lean body, matted hair — silent, unagitated as a flameless fire. The fully transformed disciple ceases external symptoms of struggle; the fire just glows.
Reflection Questions
Where do I still produce smoke when steady glow would suffice?
What would a flameless-fire posture look like in my own service?
ajānatī—without any knowledgepriya-tamam—her dearmost husbandyadā—whenuparatam—passed awayaṅganā—the womansusthira—fixed upāsanam—on the seatāsādya—going up toyathā—aspūrvam—beforeupācarat—went on serving him.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ajānatī priyatamaṁ
ajānatī
without any knowledge
priya-tamam
her dearmost husband
yadoparatam aṅganā
yadā
when
susthirāsanam āsādya
yathā-pūrvam upācarat
uparatam
passed away
aṅganā
the woman
susthira
fixed up
āsanam
on the seat
āsādya
going up to
yathā
as
pūrvam
before
upācarat
went on serving him.
The daughter of King Vidarbha continued as usual to serve her husband, who was seated in a steady posture, until she could ascertain that he had passed away from the body.
Purport
It appears that the Queen did not even talk to her husband while serving. She would simply perform her prescribed duties without talk. Thus she did not stop rendering service until she could ascertain that her husband had passed from the body.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When he passed away, she approached her dear husband sitting in a fixed position and served him as before, unaware of his passing.
His Holiness Bhakti Padma Saurabh Pracharak Swami· 2019-09-03· Hindi
Personal Guidance
She continued serving until she could ascertain her husband had passed. Service continues through the master's transition; you don't quit at the visible end.
Reflection Questions
Whose service in my life have I quit too soon after the obvious end?
Where could 'serving past the visible' deepen everything?
yadā—whenna—notupalabheta—could feelaṅghrau—in the feetūṣmāṇam—heatpatyuḥ—of her husbandarcatī—while servingāsīt—she becamesaṁvigna—anxioushṛdayā—at heartyūtha-bhraṣṭā—bereft of her husbandmṛgī—the she-deeryathā—as.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yadā nopalabhetāṅghrāv
yadā
when
ūṣmāṇaṁ patyur arcatī
na
not
upalabheta
could feel
aṅghrau
in the feet
ūṣmāṇam
heat
patyuḥ
of her husband
arcatī
while serving
āsīt saṁvigna-hṛdayā
āsīt
she became
saṁvigna
anxious
hṛdayā
at heart
yūtha-bhraṣṭā mṛgī yathā
yūtha-bhraṣṭā
bereft of her husband
mṛgī
the she-deer
yathā
as.
While she was serving her husband by massaging his legs, she could feel that his feet were no longer warm and could thus understand that he had already passed from the body. She felt great anxiety upon being left alone. Bereft of her husband’s company, she felt exactly as the deer feels upon being separated from its mate.
Purport
As soon as the circulation of blood and air within the body stops, it is to be understood that the soul within the body has left. The stoppage of the blood’s circulation is perceived when the hands and feet lose heat. One tests whether a body is alive or not by feeling the heart’s palpitations and the coldness of the feet and hands.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
When she could not feet warmth in her husband’s feet as she served him, she became disturbed in heart like a doe bereft of her partner.
Serving him (arcatī), she could not feet warmth. The verb should be nopālabheta.
Massaging his legs, she felt his feet cold; recognized he was gone; felt like a deer separated from its mate. The detection point is bodily; the lament that follows is appropriate; both are part of the practice.
Reflection Questions
Whose passing did I detect through a small bodily signal, and how did I honor that moment?
Where do I avoid the bodily reality of loss, missing the doorway it opens?
ātmānam—about herselfśocatī—lamentingdīnam—wretchedabandhum—without a friendviklava—brokenheartedaśrubhiḥ—by tearsstanau—her breastsāsicya—wettingvipine—in the forestsusvaram—loudlypraruroda—began to crysā—she.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ātmānaṁ śocatī dīnam
ātmānam
about herself
śocatī
lamenting
dīnam
wretched
abandhuṁ viklavāśrubhiḥ
abandhum
without a friend
viklava
brokenhearted
aśrubhiḥ
by tears
stanāv āsicya vipine
stanau
her breasts
āsicya
wetting
vipine
in the forest
susvaraṁ praruroda sā
susvaram
loudly
praruroda
began to cry
sā
she.
Being now alone and a widow in that forest, the daughter of Vidarbha began to lament, incessantly shedding tears, which soaked her breasts, and crying very loudly.
Purport
Figuratively the queen is supposed to be the disciple of the king; thus when the mortal body of the spiritual master expires, his disciples should cry exactly as the queen cries when the king leaves his body. However, the disciple and spiritual master are never separated because the spiritual master always keeps company with the disciple as long as the disciple follows strictly the instructions of the spiritual master. This is called the association of vāṇī (words). Physical presence is called vapuḥ. As long as the spiritual master is physically present, the disciple should serve the physical body of the spiritual master, and when the spiritual master is no longer physically existing, the disciple should serve the instructions of the spiritual master.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Lamenting her pitiable condition without a husband, wetting her breasts with her tears, she cried loudly in the forest.
When the guru leaves his mortal body, the disciple becomes overcome with lamentation with pain of separation, like a wife for her departed husband. That is described here. She lamented her condition. Who will protect me from now on? Thus she became grief stricken.
His Holiness Bir Krishna Goswami· 2020-07-05· English
Personal Guidance
Alone and widowed, she lamented loudly, tears soaking her breasts. Loud grief is appropriate when the master passes; restrained mourning is not the higher form.
Reflection Questions
Where have I suppressed grief that scripture would have me express loudly?
uttiṣṭha—please get uputtiṣṭha—please get uprāja-ṛṣe—O saintly kingimām—this earthudadhi—by the oceanmekhalām—surroundeddasyubhyaḥ—from the rogueskṣatra-bandhubhyaḥ—from the unclean kingsbibhyatīm—very much afraidpātum—to protectarhasi—you ought.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
uttiṣṭhottiṣṭha rājarṣe
uttiṣṭha
please get up
uttiṣṭha
please get up
rāja-ṛṣe
O saintly king
imām udadhi-mekhalām
imām
this earth
udadhi
by the ocean
mekhalām
surrounded
dasyubhyaḥ kṣatra-bandhubhyo
dasyubhyaḥ
from the rogues
kṣatra-bandhubhyaḥ
from the unclean kings
bibhyatīṁ pātum arhasi
bibhyatīm
very much afraid
pātum
to protect
arhasi
you ought.
O best of kings, please get up! Get up! Just see this world surrounded by water and infested with rogues and so-called kings. This world is very much afraid, and it is your duty to protect her.
Purport
Whenever an ācārya comes, following the superior orders of the Supreme Personality of Godhead or His representative, he establishes the principles of religion, as enunciated in Bhagavad-gītā. Religion means abiding by the orders of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Religious principles begin from the time one surrenders to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is the ācārya’s duty to spread a bona fide religious system and induce everyone to bow down before the Supreme Lord. One executes the religious principles by rendering devotional service, specifically the nine items like hearing, chanting and remembering. Unfortunately, when the ācārya disappears, rogues and nondevotees take advantage and immediately begin to introduce unauthorized principles in the name of so-called svāmīs, yogīs, philanthropists, welfare workers and so on. Actually, human life is meant for executing the orders of the Supreme Lord, and this is stated in Bhagavad-gītā (9.34) :
“Engage your mind always in thinking of Me and become My devotee. Offer obeisances and worship Me. Being completely absorbed in Me, surely you will come to Me.”
The main business of human society is to think of the Supreme Personality of Godhead at all times, to become His devotees, to worship the Supreme Lord and to bow down before Him. The ācārya, the authorized representative of the Supreme Lord, establishes these principles, but when he disappears, things once again become disordered. The perfect disciples of the ācārya try to relieve the situation by sincerely following the instructions of the spiritual master. At the present moment practically the entire world is afraid of rogues and nondevotees; therefore this Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement is started to save the world from irreligious principles. Everyone should cooperate with this movement in order to bring about actual peace and happiness in the world.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Get up! Get up, O saintly King! You must protect this frightened earth surrounded by the seas from thieves and false kings.
O guru! Protect this earth in which you established bhakti, which is now frightened by those opposing bhakti.
Get up! Get up! The world is surrounded by water and rogues; it's your duty to protect her. Even in mourning, the disciple invokes the master's role as protector; the call to duty doesn't go silent.
Reflection Questions
Whose 'get up!' do I owe someone whose role is unfinished?
Where am I asleep when the disciples' lament should rouse me?
एवं विलपन्ती बाला विपिनेऽनुगता पतिम् ।
पतितापादयोर्भर्तूरुदत्यश्रूण्यवर्तयत् ॥ ४९ ॥
evaṁ vilapantī bālā
[evam vilapantee baalaa]
vipine ’nugatā patim
[vipine ’nugataa patim]
patitā pādayor bhartū
[patitaa paadayor bhartoo]
rudaty aśrūṇy avartayat
[rudaty ashroony avartayat]
Word-for-word
evam—thusvilapantī—lamentingbālā—the innocent womanvipine—in the solitary forestanugatā—strictly adherentpatim—unto her husbandpatitā—fallen downpādayoḥ—at the feetbhartuḥ—of her husbandrudatī—while cryingaśrūṇi—tearsavartayat—she shed.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
evaṁ vilapantī bālā
evam
thus
vilapantī
lamenting
bālā
the innocent woman
vipine ’nugatā patim
vipine
in the solitary forest
anugatā
strictly adherent
patim
unto her husband
patitā pādayor bhartū
patitā
fallen down
pādayoḥ
at the feet
bhartuḥ
of her husband
rudaty aśrūṇy avartayat
rudatī
while crying
aśrūṇi
tears
avartayat
she shed.
That most obedient wife thus fell down at the feet of her dead husband and began to cry pitifully in that solitary forest. Thus the tears rolled down from her eyes.
Purport
Just as a devoted wife becomes afflicted at the passing away of her husband, when a spiritual master passes away, the disciple becomes similarly bereaved.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Lamenting in the forest, the women, obedient to her husband, falling at the feet of her husband, wailed and began to shed tears.
Avartayat means released.
His Holiness Prabodhananda Sarasvati Swami· 2013-04-23· English
Personal Guidance
The obedient wife fell at her dead husband's feet, weeping pitifully. Falling-at-feet remains the right posture even after death; reverence outlasts breath.
Reflection Questions
Whose feet in my life still deserve obeisance even after they no longer move?
Where do I withhold reverence past someone's departure when they would still receive it?
citim—funeral pyredāru-mayīm—made with woodcitvā—having piled uptasyām—on thatpatyuḥ—of the husbandkalevaram—bodyādīpya—after ignitingca—alsoanumaraṇe—to die along with himvilapantī—lamentingmanaḥ—her minddadhe—fixed.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
citiṁ dārumayīṁ citvā
citim
funeral pyre
dāru-mayīm
made with wood
citvā
having piled up
tasyāṁ patyuḥ kalevaram
tasyām
on that
patyuḥ
of the husband
kalevaram
body
ādīpya cānumaraṇe
ādīpya
after igniting
ca
also
anumaraṇe
to die along with him
vilapantī mano dadhe
vilapantī
lamenting
manaḥ
her mind
dadhe
fixed.
She then prepared a blazing fire with firewood and placed the dead body of her husband upon it. When this was finished, she lamented severely and prepared herself to perish in the fire with her husband.
Purport
It is the long-standing tradition of the Vedic system that a faithful wife dies along with her husband. This is called saha-maraṇa. In India this system was prevalent even to the date of British occupation. At that time, however, a wife who did not wish to die with her husband was sometimes forced to do so by her relatives. Formerly that was not the case — the wife used to enter the fire voluntarily. The British government stopped this practice, considering it inhuman. However, from the early history of India we find that when Mahārāja Pāṇḍu died, he was survived by two wives — Mādrī and Kuntī. The question was whether both should die or one should die. After the death of Mahārāja Pāṇḍu, his wives settled that one should remain and the other should go. Mādrī would perish with her husband in the fire, and Kuntī would remain to take charge of the five Pāṇḍava children. Even as late as 1936 we saw a devoted wife voluntarily enter the fire of her husband.
This indicates that a devotee’s wife must be prepared to act in such a way. Similarly, a devoted disciple of the spiritual master would rather die with the spiritual master than fail to execute the spiritual master’s mission. As the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes down upon this earth to reestablish the principles of religion, so His representative, the spiritual master, also comes to reestablish religious principles. It is the duty of the disciples to take charge of the mission of the spiritual master and execute it properly. Otherwise the disciple should decide to die along with the spiritual master. In other words, to execute the will of the spiritual master, the disciple should be prepared to lay down his life and abandon all personal considerations.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
After piling up wood and lighting fire on the body of her husband on the pyre, in a state of lamentation, she decided to die with her husband.
She placed the body on the pyre and lit ablaze with fire. Having performed the last rites for his guru, the disciple then decides in his mind, “Separated from the feet of my guru, I cannot maintain my life. My body is burning in the fire of lamentation on remembering his qualities. I cannot put my energy in the bhakti of hearing and chanting that he taught. Therefore I will die today.” That is shown here.
She built a blazing pyre, placed the body, and prepared to perish with him. Saha-maraṇa was a real spiritual practice; the disciple's willingness to enter the same fire is the highest fidelity.
Reflection Questions
Where would I refuse to enter the same fire as my teacher even metaphorically?
What does 'same fire' mean in modern spiritual terms?
tatra—in that placepūrvataraḥ—previouskaścit—someonesakhā—friendbrāhmaṇaḥ—a brāhmaṇaātmavān—very learned scholarsāntvayan—pacifyingvalgunā—by very nicesāmnā—mitigating wordstām—unto herāha—he saidrudatīm—while she was cryingprabho—my dear King.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tatra pūrvataraḥ kaścit
tatra
in that place
pūrvataraḥ
previous
kaścit
someone
sakhā brāhmaṇa ātmavān
sakhā
friend
brāhmaṇaḥ
a brāhmaṇa
ātmavān
very learned scholar
sāntvayan valgunā sāmnā
sāntvayan
pacifying
valgunā
by very nice
sāmnā
mitigating words
tām āha rudatīṁ prabho
tām
unto her
āha
he said
rudatīm
while she was crying
prabho
my dear King.
My dear King, one brāhmaṇa, who was an old friend of King Purañjana, came to that place and began to pacify the Queen with sweet words.
Purport
The appearance of an old friend in the form of a brāhmaṇa is very significant. In His Paramātmā feature, Kṛṣṇa is the old friend of everyone. According to Vedic injunction, Kṛṣṇa is sitting with the living entity side by side. According to the śruti-mantra ( dvā suparṇā sayujā sakhāyāḥ ), the Lord is sitting within the heart of every living entity as suhṛt, the best friend. The Lord is always eager to have the living entity come home, back to Godhead. Sitting with the living entity as witness, the Lord gives him all chances to enjoy himself materially, but whenever there is an opportunity, the Lord gives good counsel and advises the living entity to abandon trying to become happy through material adjustment and instead turn his face toward the Supreme Personality of Godhead and surrender unto Him. When one becomes serious to follow the mission of the spiritual master, his resolution is tantamount to seeing the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As explained before, this means meeting the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the instruction of the spiritual master. This is technically called vāṇī-sevā. Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura states in his Bhagavad-gītā commentary on the verse vyavasāyātmikā buddhir ekeha kuru-nandana ( Bg. 2.41 ) that one should serve the words of the spiritual master. The disciple must stick to whatever the spiritual master orders. Simply by following on that line, one sees the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Paramātmā, appeared before the Queen as a brāhmaṇa, but why didn’t He appear in His original form as Śrī Kṛṣṇa? Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura remarks that unless one is very highly elevated in loving the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot see Him as He is. Nonetheless, if one sticks to the principles enunciated by the spiritual master, somehow or other he is in association with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Since the Lord is in the heart, He can advise a sincere disciple from within. This is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā (10.10) :
“To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me.”
In conclusion, if a disciple is very serious to execute the mission of the spiritual master, he immediately associates with the Supreme Personality of Godhead by vāṇī or vapuḥ. This is the only secret of success in seeing the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Instead of being eager to see the Lord in some bush of Vṛndāvana while at the same time engaging in sense gratification, if one instead sticks to the principle of following the words of the spiritual master, he will see the Supreme Lord without difficulty. Śrīla Bilvamaṅgala Ṭhākura has therefore said:
“If I am engaged in devotional service unto You, my dear Lord, then very easily can I perceive Your presence everywhere. And as far as liberation is concerned, I think that liberation stands at my door with folded hands, waiting to serve me — and all material conveniences of dharma [religiosity], artha [economic development] and kāma [sense gratification] stand with her.” ( Kṛṣṇa-karṇāmṛta 107) If one is very highly advanced in devotional service, he will have no difficulty in seeing the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If one engages in the service of the spiritual master, he not only sees the Supreme Personality of Godhead but attains liberation. As far as material conveniences are concerned, they automatically come, just as the maidservants of a queen follow the queen wherever she goes. Liberation is no problem for the pure devotee, and all material conveniences are simply awaiting him at all stages of life.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
In that place, as she wailed, “O master!” a previous brāhmaṇa friend, with composed nature, pacifying her with sweet words, spoke.
In a state similar to separation from guru, if one has pain in separation from the Lord, the Lord will appear. That is indicated here. The friend from previous time is the Lord with no beginning. The śruti says dvā suparṇā: the Lord is situated with the jīva in the body, like two birds in a tree. (Śvetāśvatara Upaniṣad 4.6) He had the dress of a brāhmaṇa: if a person does not have prema the Lord does not reveal himself directly to that person. Ātmavān means the Lord was situated in his svarūpa but that was covered over.
His Holiness Bir Krishna Goswami· 2012-01-23· English
Personal Guidance
An old brāhmaṇa friend of Purañjana came and pacified the queen with sweet words. The Supersoul (Kṛṣṇa) appears as old brāhmaṇa friend at the most desperate moments; the heart's intimate friend is always nearby.
Reflection Questions
Whose 'old friend' appearance in my hardest moment was actually the Supersoul reaching out?
Where am I missing such appearances by not recognizing them?
ब्राह्मणउवाच
का त्वं कस्यासि को वायं शयानो यस्य शोचसि ।
जानासि किं सखायं मां येनाग्रे विचचर्थ ह ॥ ५२ ॥
brāhmaṇa uvāca
[braahmana uvaacha]
kā tvaṁ kasyāsi ko vāyaṁ
[kaa tvam kasyaasi ko vaayam]
śayāno yasya śocasi
[shayaano yasya shochasi]
jānāsi kiṁ sakhāyaṁ māṁ
[jaanaasi kim sakhaayam maam]
yenāgre vicacartha ha
[yenaagre vichachartha ha]
Word-for-word
brāhmaṇaḥ uvāca—the learned brāhmaṇa saidkā—whotvam—youkasya—whoseasi—are youkaḥ—whovā—orayam—this manśayānaḥ—lying downyasya—for whomśocasi—you are lamentingjānāsi kim—do you knowsakhāyam—friendmām—Meyena—with whomagre—formerlyvicacartha—you consultedha—certainly.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
brāhmaṇa uvāca
brāhmaṇaḥ uvāca
the learned brāhmaṇa said
kā tvaṁ kasyāsi ko vāyaṁ
kā
who
tvam
you
kasya
whose
asi
are you
kaḥ
who
vā
or
ayam
this man
śayāno yasya śocasi
śayānaḥ
lying down
yasya
for whom
śocasi
you are lamenting
jānāsi kiṁ sakhāyaṁ māṁ
jānāsi kim
do you know
sakhāyam
friend
mām
Me
yenāgre vicacartha ha
yena
with whom
agre
formerly
vicacartha
you consulted
ha
certainly.
The brāhmaṇa inquired as follows: Who are you? Whose wife or daughter are you? Who is the man lying here? It appears you are lamenting for this dead body. Don’t you recognize Me? I am your eternal friend. You may remember that many times in the past you have consulted Me.
Purport
When a person’s relative dies, renunciation is automatically visible. Consultation with the Supersoul seated within everyone’s heart is possible only when one is completely free from the contamination of material attachment. One who is sincere and pure gets an opportunity to consult with the Supreme Personality of Godhead in His Paramātmā feature sitting within everyone’s heart. The Paramātmā is always the caitya-guru, the spiritual master within, and He comes before one externally as the instructor and initiator spiritual master. The Lord can reside within the heart, and He can also come out before a person and give him instructions. Thus the spiritual master is not different from the Supersoul sitting within the heart. An uncontaminated soul or living entity can get a chance to meet the Paramātmā face to face. Just as one gets a chance to consult with the Paramātmā within his heart, one also gets a chance to see Him actually situated before him. Then one can take instructions from the Supersoul directly. This is the duty of the pure devotee: to see the bona fide spiritual master and consult with the Supersoul within the heart.
When the brāhmaṇa asked the woman who the man lying on the floor was, she answered that he was her spiritual master and that she was perplexed about what to do in his absence. At such a time the Supersoul immediately appears, provided the devotee is purified in heart by following the directions of the spiritual master. A sincere devotee who follows the instructions of the spiritual master certainly gets direct instructions from his heart from the Supersoul. Thus a sincere devotee is always helped directly or indirectly by the spiritual master and the Supersoul. This is confirmed in Caitanya-caritāmṛta: guru-kṛṣṇa-prasāde pāya bhakti-latā-bīja. If the devotee serves his spiritual master sincerely, Kṛṣṇa automatically becomes pleased. Yasya prasādād bhagavad-prasādaḥ: by satisfying the spiritual master, one automatically satisfies Kṛṣṇa. Thus the devotee becomes enriched by both the spiritual master and Kṛṣṇa. The Supersoul is eternally the friend of the living entity and always remains with him. The Supersoul has always been ready to help the living entity, even before the creation of this material world. It is therefore stated here, yenāgre vicacartha. The word agre means “before the creation.” Thus the Supersoul has been accompanying the living entity since before the creation.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The brāhmaṇa said: Who are you? Who do you belong to? Who is this man lying here, for whom you lament? Do you know me, your friend, with whom you moved about previously?
“Who is this lying here?” He is my guru. According to the story the answer is “He is my husband.” On answering that, the next question is “Do you know me?” You are a brāhmaṇa. “Who am I?” You are my friend. “How did I become your friend?” You wandered with me before the creation (agre). This means “Along with me you remained experienced happiness in my association.”
His Holiness Bir Krishna Goswami· 2020-07-07· English
Personal Guidance
Who are you, whose wife? Don't you recognize Me, your eternal friend you've consulted many times? The Supersoul names His prior visibility; we've consulted Him before and forgotten.
Reflection Questions
When did I last 'consult' the Supersoul and not credit the consultation?
Where would re-recognition of the eternal friend transform a current loss?
api smarasi—do you rememberca—alsoātmānam—the Supersoulavijñāta—unknownsakham—friendsakhe—O friendhitvā—giving upmām—Mepadam—positionanvicchan—desiringbhauma—materialbhoga—enjoymentrataḥ—attached togataḥ—you became.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
api smarasi cātmānam
api smarasi
do you remember
ca
also
ātmānam
the Supersoul
avijñāta-sakhaṁ sakhe
avijñāta
unknown
sakham
friend
sakhe
O friend
hitvā māṁ padam anvicchan
hitvā
giving up
mām
Me
padam
position
anvicchan
desiring
bhauma-bhoga-rato gataḥ
bhauma
material
bhoga
enjoyment
rataḥ
attached to
gataḥ
you became.
The brāhmaṇa continued: My dear friend, even though you cannot immediately recognize Me, can’t you remember that in the past you had a very intimate friend? Unfortunately, you gave up My company and accepted a position as enjoyer of this material world.
“O scion of Bharata [Arjuna], O conqueror of the foe, all living entities are born into delusion, overcome by the dualities of desire and hate.” This is an explanation of how the living entity falls down into this material world. In the spiritual world there is no duality, nor is there hate. The Supreme Personality of Godhead expands Himself into many. In order to enjoy bliss more and more, the Supreme Lord expands Himself in different categories. As mentioned in the Varāha Purāṇa, He expands Himself in viṣṇu-tattva (the svāṁśa expansion) and in His marginal potency (the vibhinnāṁśa, or the living entity). These expanded living entities are innumerable, just as the minute molecules of sunshine are innumerable expansions of the sun. The vibhinnāṁśa expansions, the marginal potencies of the Lord, are the living entities. When the living entities desire to enjoy themselves, they develop a consciousness of duality and come to hate the service of the Lord. In this way the living entities fall into the material world. In the Prema-vivarta it is said:
kṛṣṇa-bahirmukha haṣā bhoga-vāñchā kare nikaṭa-stha māyā tāre jāpaṭiyā dhare
The natural position of the living entity is to serve the Lord in a transcendental loving attitude. When the living entity wants to become Kṛṣṇa Himself or imitate Kṛṣṇa, he falls down into the material world. Since Kṛṣṇa is the supreme father, His affection for the living entity is eternal. When the living entity falls down into the material world, the Supreme Lord, through His svāṁśa expansion (Paramātmā), keeps company with the living entity. In this way the living entity may some day return home, back to Godhead.
By misusing his independence, the living entity falls down from the service of the Lord and takes a position in this material world as an enjoyer — that is to say, the living entity takes his position within a material body. Wanting to take a very exalted position, the living entity instead becomes entangled in a repetition of birth and death. He selects his position as a human being, a demigod, a cat, a dog, a tree, etc. In this way the living entity selects a body out of the 8,400,000 forms and tries to satisfy himself by a variety of material enjoyment. The Supersoul, however, does not like him to do this. Consequently, the Supersoul instructs him to surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Lord then takes charge of the living entity. But unless the living entity is uncontaminated by material desires, he cannot surrender to the Supreme Lord. In Bhagavad-gītā (5.29) the Lord says:
“The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries.”
The Supreme Lord is the supreme friend of everyone; however, no one can take advantage of the supreme friend’s instructions while making his own plans to become happy and entangling himself in the modes of material nature. When there is creation, the living entities take on different forms according to past desires. This means that all the species or forms of life are simultaneously created. Darwin’s theory stating that no human being existed from the beginning but that humans evolved after many, many years is simply a nonsensical theory. From Vedic literature we find that the first creature within the universe is Lord Brahmā. Being the most intelligent personality, Lord Brahmā could take charge of creating all the variety found within this material world.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Do you remember yourself, who had an unknown friend? O friend! Giving me up, desiring a place, you became engaged in material enjoyment.
“I do not know anything.” Though you do not recognize me, do you remember yourself, who had a friend you did not recognize (avijyāta-sakham), someone who was your friend, but unrecognized by you?” The bahuvrīhi compound avijñāta-sakham is poetic license. Or it can mean the friend of someone unknown. The form sakhe is the masculine form of address, though at present she was a woman. This indicates that the Lord wants to make her remember her previous life as a man. “You please remember. I cannot.” Giving me up, you became attached to enjoying. This means that the jīva gave up the Lord at the beginning of creation of the universe, because of previous karmas. Padam means place.
You had a very intimate friend, but you gave up My company to enjoy the material world. The fall begins with abandonment of an existing relationship; you were never alone, you just left.
Reflection Questions
Whose company did I once have and gave up in pursuit of something material?
Where could simply turning back resume the relationship?
haṁsau—two swansaham—Ica—andtvam—youca—alsoārya—O great soulsakhāyau—friendsmānasa-ayanau—together in the Mānasa Lakeabhūtām—becameantarā—separatedvā—indeedokaḥ—from the original homesahasra—thousandspari—successivelyvatsarān—years.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
haṁsāv ahaṁ ca tvaṁ cārya
haṁsau
two swans
aham
I
ca
and
tvam
you
ca
also
ārya
O great soul
sakhāyau mānasāyanau
sakhāyau
friends
mānasa-ayanau
together in the Mānasa Lake
abhūtām antarā vaukaḥ
abhūtām
became
antarā
separated
vā
indeed
okaḥ
from the original home
sahasra-parivatsarān
sahasra
thousands
pari
successively
vatsarān
years.
My dear gentle friend, both you and I are exactly like two swans. We live together in the same heart, which is just like the Mānasa Lake. Although we have been living together for many thousands of years, we are still far away from our original home.
Purport
The original home of the living entity and the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the spiritual world. In the spiritual world both the Lord and the living entities live together very peacefully. Since the living entity remains engaged in the service of the Lord, they both share a blissful life in the spiritual world. However, when the living entity wants to enjoy himself, he falls down into the material world. Even while he is in that position, the Lord remains with him as the Supersoul, his intimate friend. Because of his forgetfulness, the living entity does not know that the Supreme Lord is accompanying him as the Supersoul. In this way the living entity remains conditioned in each and every millennium. Although the Lord follows him as a friend, the living entity, because of forgetful material existence, does not recognize Him.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O noble one! I and you were two swans, friends in Mānasa Lake. Previously, for a thousand years, we were without a house.
We were two pure ātmās. Mānasa ayanam is the shelter of the heart. We were two pure ātmās, friends, whose dwelling place is the heart. In the story, the meaning is “We were born as two birds in Mānasa Lake.” We were without a house (okaḥ antarā). The word vā is for emphasis like eva. (Previously to dwelling together in the heart), during the great devastation or mahā-pralaya (sahasras-parivatsarān), [Note: During mahā-pralaya no material bodies or hearts exist. ]we remained without a house.
You and I are like two swans in the same heart-lake; we've lived together for thousands of years but are far from our original home. Cohabitation is real; relocation is the work — same lake, wrong continent.
Reflection Questions
Where do I sit in the same lake as the Supersoul but feel a continent away?
What would 'returning to original home' actually require this lifetime?
saḥ—that swantvam—yourselfvihāya—leavingmām—Mebandho—O friendgataḥ—wentgrāmya—materialmatiḥ—whose consciousnessmahīm—to earthvicaran—travelingpadam—positionadrākṣīḥ—you sawkayācit—by someonenirmitam—manufacturedstriyā—by a woman.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
sa tvaṁ vihāya māṁ bandho
saḥ
that swan
tvam
yourself
vihāya
leaving
mām
Me
bandho
O friend
gato grāmya-matir mahīm
gataḥ
went
grāmya
material
matiḥ
whose consciousness
mahīm
to earth
vicaran padam adrākṣīḥ
vicaran
traveling
padam
position
adrākṣīḥ
you saw
kayācin nirmitaṁ striyā
kayācit
by someone
nirmitam
manufactured
striyā
by a woman.
My dear friend, you are now My very same friend. Since you left Me, you have become more and more materialistic, and not seeing Me, you have been traveling in different forms throughout this material world, which was created by some woman.
Purport
When the living entity falls down, he goes into the material world, which was created by the external energy of the Lord. This external energy is described herein as “some woman,” or prakṛti. This material world is composed of material elements, ingredients supplied by the mahat-tattva, the total material energy. The material world, created by this external energy, becomes the so-called home of the conditioned soul. Within this material world the conditioned soul accepts different apartments, or different bodily forms, and then travels about. Sometimes he travels in the higher planetary systems and sometimes in the lower systems. Sometimes he travels in higher species of life and sometimes in lower species. He has been wandering within this material universe since time immemorial. As explained by Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu:
brahmāṇḍa bhramite kona bhāgyavān jīva guru-kṛṣṇa-prasāde pāya bhakti-latā-bīja
The living entity wanders into many species of life, but he is fortunate when he once again meets his friend, either in person or through His representative.
Actually, it is Kṛṣṇa who personally advises all living entities to return home, back to Godhead. Sometimes Kṛṣṇa sends His representative, who, delivering Kṛṣṇa’s very message, canvasses all living entities to return home, back to Godhead. Unfortunately the living entity is so greatly attached to material enjoyment that he does not take the instructions of Kṛṣṇa or His representative very seriously. This material tendency is mentioned in this verse as grāmya-matiḥ, sense gratification. The word mahīm means “within this material world.” All living entities within this material world are sensually inclined. Consequently they become entangled in different types of bodies and suffer the pangs of material existence.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O friend! Leaving me, with material consciousness you went to the earth. Wandering about, you saw a place made by some woman, by māyā.
Striyā means “by māyā.”
Since leaving Me you've been traveling in different forms in this world, made by some woman (māyā). The material world is itself maternal — māyā's product — not random and not yours.
Reflection Questions
Where do I treat the material world as if it were mine, missing its maternal authorship?
What changes when I see this whole place as made by māyā for my education?
In that city [the material body] there are five gardens, nine gates, one protector, three apartments, six families, five stores, five material elements, and one woman who is lord of the house.
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
It had five gardens, nine doors, one protector, three storehouses, six communities, five markets, five causes, a mistress and a master.
It had five gardens or sense objects, nine openings of the body for the prāṇa. One prāṇa was the guard. The three treasuries are earth, water and fire. The six mercantile communities are the five knowledge senses and mind. The five markets are t he five action senses. The five powers of state are the five gross elements, the material substance. The mistress is intelligence. The master is husband of the intelligence.
His Holiness Prahladananada Swami· 2010-07-24· English
Personal Guidance
Five gardens, nine gates, one protector, three apartments, six families, five stores, five elements, one woman lord. The body's anatomy as a city: enumerate its inhabitants to understand who you are.
Reflection Questions
Have I ever taken inventory of my body in scripture's terms?
Where would that inventory reorganize my self-understanding?
pañca—fiveindriya-arthāḥ—sense objectsārāmāḥ—the gardensdvāraḥ—gatesprāṇāḥ—apertures of the sensesnava—nineprabho—O Kingtejaḥ-ap—fire, waterannāni—food grains or earthkoṣṭhāni—apartmentskulam—familiesindriya-saṅgrahaḥ—five senses and the mind.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
pañcendriyārthā ārāmā
pañca
five
dvāraḥ prāṇā nava prabho
tejo-’b-annāni koṣṭhāni
kulam indriya-saṅgrahaḥ
indriya-arthāḥ
sense objects
ārāmāḥ
the gardens
dvāraḥ
gates
prāṇāḥ
apertures of the senses
nava
nine
prabho
O King
tejaḥ-ap
fire, water
annāni
food grains or earth
koṣṭhāni
apartments
kulam
families
indriya-saṅgrahaḥ
five senses and the mind.
My dear friend, the five gardens are the five objects of sense enjoyment, and the protector is the life air, which passes through the nine gates. The three apartments are the chief ingredients — fire, water and earth. The six families are the aggregate total of the mind and five senses.
Purport
The five senses that acquire knowledge are sight, taste, smell, sound and touch, and these act through the nine gates — the two eyes, two ears, one mouth, two nostrils, the genitals and one rectum. These holes are compared to gates in the walls of the city. The principal ingredients are earth, water and fire, and the principal actor is the mind, which is controlled by the intelligence ( buddhi ).
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The five sense objects are the gardens. The gates are nine openings of the body. The storerooms are fire, water and earth. The communities are the senses and mind combined.
Two verses explain the previous verse. There are nine openings for prāṇa. The families or communities are merchants.
Personal Guidance
Five gardens are sense-objects; protector is life-air; three apartments are fire-water-earth; six families are mind plus five senses. Each element of the parable has a body-system referent; the figure is precise.
Reflection Questions
Which body-system do I most ignore even though it shapes everything?
What practice would honor a body-system I've been negligent about?
vipaṇaḥ—storestu—thenkriyā-śaktiḥ—the energy for activities, or the working sensesbhūta—the five gross elementsprakṛtiḥ—the material elementsavyayā—eternalśakti—the energyadhīśaḥ—controllerpumān—mantu—thenatra—herepraviṣṭaḥ—enteredna—does notavabudhyate—become subjected to knowledge.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
vipaṇas tu kriyā-śaktir
vipaṇaḥ
stores
tu
then
kriyā-śaktiḥ
the energy for activities, or the working senses
bhūta-prakṛtir avyayā
bhūta
the five gross elements
prakṛtiḥ
the material elements
avyayā
eternal
śakty-adhīśaḥ pumāṁs tv atra
śakti
the energy
adhīśaḥ
controller
pumān
man
tu
then
atra
here
praviṣṭo nāvabudhyate
praviṣṭaḥ
entered
na
does not
avabudhyate
become subjected to knowledge.
The five stores are the five working sensory organs. They transact their business through the combined forces of the five elements, which are eternal. Behind all this activity is the soul. The soul is a person and an enjoyer in reality. However, because he is now hidden within the city of the body, he is devoid of knowledge.
Purport
The living entity enters the material creation with the aid of the five elements — earth, water, fire, air and ether — and thus his body is formed. Although the living entity is working from within, he is nonetheless unknown. The living entity enters the material creation, but because he is bewildered by the material energy, he appears to be hidden. The bodily conception of life is prominent because of ignorance ( nāvabudhyate ). Intelligence is described in the feminine gender, but owing to her prominence in all activities, she is described in this verse as adhīśaḥ, the controller. The living entity lives by means of fire, water and food grains. It is through the combination of these three that the body is maintained. Consequently the body is called prakṛti, material creation. All the elements gradually combine to form flesh, bone, blood and so on. All these appear as various apartments. It is said in the Vedas that the digested foods are ultimately divided into three. The solid portion becomes stool, and the semiliquid portion turns into flesh. The liquid portion turns yellow and is again divided into three. One of these liquid portions is called urine. Similarly, the fiery portion is divided into three, and one is called bone. Out of the five elements, fire, water and food grains are very important. These three are mentioned in the previous verse, whereas sky (ether) and air are not mentioned. This is all explained in Bhagavad-gītā (13.20) :
prakṛtiṁ puruṣaṁ caiva viddhy anādī ubhāv api vikārāṁś ca guṇāṁś caiva viddhi prakṛti-sambhavān
“Material nature and the living entities should be understood to be beginningless. Their transformations and the modes of matter are products of material nature.” Prakṛti, material nature, and puruṣa, the living entity, are eternal. When they both come in contact, there are different reactions and manifestations. All of them should be considered the results of the interaction of the three modes of material nature.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
The markets are the action senses, and the five gross elements are the causes. The controller of energy, the man, entering there, does not gain knowledge.
The five gross elements are the cause (prakṛtiḥ). Entering that place, a man becomes bewildered. What is the energy or śakti? It is intelligence. He is the controller of the intelligence. This is the explanation of the man and wife (strī-dhavakam). But the word also means he who is controlled by the wife. What can be said? Entering the body, the jīva, though master, becomes controlled by the intelligence. This is indicated by the masculine gender.
His Holiness Kadamba Kanana Swami· 2010-07-27· English
Personal Guidance
Five stores are working organs; the soul is the actual enjoyer but hidden in the body. The enjoyer is hidden; misidentification with stores and gardens is the standard confusion.
Reflection Questions
Where am I identified with the stores when I should know myself as the hidden enjoyer?
What single act of inward attention would reveal the enjoyer?
tasmin—in that situationtvam—yourāmayā—with the womanspṛṣṭaḥ—being in contactramamāṇaḥ—enjoyingaśruta-smṛtiḥ—without remembrance of spiritual existencetat—with hersaṅgāt—by associationīdṛśīm—like thisprāptaḥ—you have attaineddaśām—a statepāpīyasīm—full of sinful activitiesprabho—My dear friend.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tasmiṁs tvaṁ rāmayā spṛṣṭo
tasmin
in that situation
tvam
you
rāmayā
with the woman
spṛṣṭaḥ
being in contact
ramamāṇo ’śruta-smṛtiḥ
ramamāṇaḥ
enjoying
aśruta-smṛtiḥ
without remembrance of spiritual existence
tat-saṅgād īdṛśīṁ prāpto
tat
with her
saṅgāt
by association
īdṛśīm
like this
prāptaḥ
you have attained
daśāṁ pāpīyasīṁ prabho
daśām
a state
pāpīyasīm
full of sinful activities
prabho
My dear friend.
My dear friend, when you enter such a body along with the woman of material desires, you become overly absorbed in sense enjoyment. Because of this, you have forgotten your spiritual life. Due to your material conceptions, you are placed in various miserable conditions.
Purport
When a person becomes materially engrossed, he has no capacity to hear about spiritual existence. Forgetfulness of spiritual existence entangles a man more and more in material existence. Such is the result of sinful life. Various bodies are developed with the material ingredients because of different types of sinful activities. King Purañjana assumed the body of a woman, Vaidarbhī, as a result of his sinful activities. Bhagavad-gītā clearly says ( striyo vaiśyās tathā śūdrāḥ ) that such a body is lowborn. If one takes shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, however, he can be elevated to the highest perfection, even though he be lowborn. One acquires lower births when one’s spiritual intelligence is reduced.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O friend! Having entered that place with the woman, enjoying, without hearing about knowledge of the self, you have attained this sinful condition by association with her.
Aśruta-smṛtiḥ means “who had heard nothing by which to gain knowledge of the self.”
His Holiness Vedavyasa Priya Swami· 2016-12-19· Hindi
Personal Guidance
You entered with the woman of material desires and got absorbed in sense-enjoyment, forgetting spiritual life. The entry-with-desires is the moment of forgetting; remember who you arrived as.
Reflection Questions
Whose desire did I enter this scene with, and have I distinguished it from my own?
Where could returning to the entry-point clarify my present?
न त्वं विदर्भदुहिता नायं वीर: सुहृत्तव ।
न पतिस्त्वं पुरञ्जन्या रुद्धो नवमुखे यया ॥ ६० ॥
na tvaṁ vidarbha-duhitā
[na tvam vidarbha-duhitaa]
nāyaṁ vīraḥ suhṛt tava
[naayam veerah suhrit tava]
na patis tvaṁ purañjanyā
[na patis tvam puranjanyaa]
ruddho nava-mukhe yayā
[ruddho nava-mukhe yayaa]
Word-for-word
na—nottvam—youvidarbha-duhitā—daughter of Vidarbhana—notayam—thisvīraḥ—herosu-hṛt—well-wishing husbandtava—yourna—notpatiḥ—husbandtvam—youpurañjanyāḥ—of Purañjanīruddhaḥ—capturednava-mukhe—in the body having nine gatesyayā—by the material energy.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
na tvaṁ vidarbha-duhitā
na
not
tvam
you
vidarbha-duhitā
daughter of Vidarbha
nāyaṁ vīraḥ suhṛt tava
na
not
ayam
this
vīraḥ
hero
su-hṛt
well-wishing husband
tava
your
na patis tvaṁ purañjanyā
na
not
patiḥ
husband
tvam
you
purañjanyāḥ
of Purañjanī
ruddho nava-mukhe yayā
ruddhaḥ
captured
nava-mukhe
in the body having nine gates
yayā
by the material energy.
Actually, you are not the daughter of Vidarbha, nor is this man, Malayadhvaja, your well-wishing husband. Nor were you the actual husband of Purañjanī. You were simply captivated in this body of nine gates.
Purport
In the material world many living entities come into contact with one another and, increasing their attachment to a particular type of body, become related as father, husband, mother, wife, etc. Actually every living entity is a separate individual being, and it is because of his contact with matter that he comes together with other bodies and becomes falsely related. False bodies create various associations in the name of family, community, society and nationality. Actually every living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but the living entities are overly engrossed in the material body. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kṛṣṇa, appears and gives instructions in the form of Bhagavad-gītā and Vedic literatures. The Supreme Lord gives these instructions because He is the eternal friend of the living entities. His instructions are important because by them the living entity can obtain liberation from bodily engagement. As water passes down a river, many straws and grasses are carried from the shore. These straws and grasses come together in the river’s current, but when the waves toss this way and that, they are separated and carried somewhere else. Similarly, the innumerable living entities within this material world are being carried by the waves of material nature. Sometimes the waves bring them together, and they form friendships and relate to one another on a bodily basis of family, community or nationality. Eventually they are thrown out of association by the waves of material nature. This process has been going on since the creation of material nature. In this regard, Śrīla Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura sings:
miche māyāra vaśe, yāccha bhese’, khāccha hābuḍubu, bhāi jīva kṛṣṇa-dāsa, e viśvāsa, karle ta’ āra duḥkha nāi
“My dear living entities, you are being carried away by the waves of material nature. Sometimes you are on the surface, sometimes you are being drowned. In this way your eternal life is being spoiled. If you simply catch hold of Kṛṣṇa and take shelter of His lotus feet, you will once again get free from all the miserable material conditions.”
In this verse the words suhṛt, “well-wisher,” and tava, “your,” are very significant. One’s so-called husband, relative, son, father or whatever cannot actually be a well-wisher. The only actual well-wisher is Kṛṣṇa Himself, as Kṛṣṇa confirms in Bhagavad-gītā (5.29) : suhṛdaṁ sarva-bhūtānām. Society, friendship, love and well-wishers are all simply results of being packed in different bodies. One should know this well and try to get out of this bodily encagement into which one is thrown birth after birth. One should take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kṛṣṇa, and return home, back to Godhead.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
You are not the daughter of King Vidarbha. This hero is not your friend or husband. You are not the husband of Puraṣajanī, who kept you in the city with nine gates.
“If I have never heard any knowledge about the self, then you should tell me what I should know.” This verse informs her. You are not the daughter of any common person. You are cit-śakti jīva belonging to me. This hero is not your friend, giving benefit, but I am the friend. In this form, I have become your guru and have taught you devotion to me. In this way I have acted as your friend. You were blockaded in the city with nine gates. You are not the husband of Purañjanī, but the conscious particle covered with ignorance. In this way two meanings have been explained in the story. The meaning of the story line is clear.
Personal Guidance
You are not actually Vidarbha's daughter; Malayadhvaja isn't your husband; you weren't Purañjanī's husband either. The identities you held were captivations of a nine-gated body; none of them were ultimate.
Reflection Questions
Which identity am I most tightly holding that the Lord would name as not-ultimate?
What survives the dropping of all such identities?
māyā—illusory energyhi—certainlyeṣā—thismayā—by Mesṛṣṭā—createdyat—from whichpumāṁsam—a malestriyam—a femalesatīm—chastemanyase—you thinkna—notubhayam—bothyat—becausevai—certainlyhaṁsau—freed from material contaminationpaśya—just seeāvayoḥ—ourgatim—factual position.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
māyā hy eṣā mayā sṛṣṭā
māyā
illusory energy
hi
certainly
eṣā
this
mayā
by Me
sṛṣṭā
created
yat pumāṁsaṁ striyaṁ satīm
yat
from which
pumāṁsam
a male
striyam
a female
satīm
chaste
manyase nobhayaṁ yad vai
manyase
you think
na
not
ubhayam
both
yat
because
vai
certainly
haṁsau paśyāvayor gatim
haṁsau
freed from material contamination
paśya
just see
āvayoḥ
our
gatim
factual position.
Sometimes you think yourself a man, sometimes a chaste woman and sometimes a neutral eunuch. This is all because of the body, which is created by the illusory energy. This illusory energy is My potency, and actually both of us — you and I — are pure spiritual identities. Now just try to understand this. I am trying to explain our factual position.
Purport
The factual position of both the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entity is qualitatively one. The Supreme Lord is the Supreme Spirit, the Supersoul, and the living entity is the individual spiritual soul. Even though both of them are original spiritual identities, the living entity forgets his identity when he comes in contact with material nature and becomes conditioned. At such a time he identifies himself as a product of the material nature. Because of the material body, he forgets that he is the eternal ( sanātana ) part and parcel of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is confirmed in this way: mamaivāṁśo jīva-loke jīva-bhūtaḥ sanātanaḥ. The word sanātana is found in several places in Bhagavad-gītā. Both the Lord and the living entity are sanātana (eternal), and there is also a place known as sanātana, beyond this material nature. The real residence of both the living entity and God is the domain of sanātana, not this material world. The material world is the temporary, external energy of the Lord, and the living entity is placed in this material world because he wanted to imitate the position of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In this material world he tries to enjoy his senses to his best capacity. All the activities of the conditioned soul within this material world are perpetually taking place in different types of bodies, but when the living entity acquires developed consciousness, he should try to rectify his situation and again become a member of the spiritual world. The process by which one can return home, back to Godhead, is bhakti-yoga, sometimes called sanātana-dharma. Instead of accepting a temporary occupational duty based on the material body, one should take to the process of sanātana-dharma, or bhakti-yoga, so that he can put an end to this perpetual bondage in material bodies and return home, back to Godhead. As long as human society works on the basis of false material identification, all the so-called advancements of science and philosophy are simply useless. They only serve to mislead human society. Andhā yathāndhair upanīyamānāḥ: in the material world, the blind simply lead the blind.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
This māyā has been created by me. By this māyā, you think you are a pure woman, a man or a eunuch. Therefore, you should see our natures as two pure entities.
“If this is so, why am I aware of all this?” It is māyā, because of which (yat) you think your self a man, sometimes a woman, and sometimes a eunuch. This also implies that sometimes you are a human, sometimes a devatā and sometimes an animal. Therefore (yat), certainly, see the svarūpa (gatim) of us two as pure entities (haṁsau).
Sometimes you think yourself man, sometimes woman, sometimes eunuch — all because of the māyā-made body. Gender and identity at the body-level are temporary roles; the spirit is none of them.
Reflection Questions
Where am I clinging to a gendered or role-based identity as if it were spiritual?
What would 'pure spiritual identity' look like in my self-introduction?
अहं भवान्न चान्यस्त्वं त्वमेवाहं विचक्ष्व भो: ।
न नौ पश्यन्ति कवयश्छिद्रं जातु मनागपि ॥ ६२ ॥
ahaṁ bhavān na cānyas tvaṁ
[aham bhavaan na chaanyas tvam]
tvam evāhaṁ vicakṣva bhoḥ
[tvam evaaham vichakshva bhoh]
na nau paśyanti kavayaś
[na nau pashyanti kavayash]
chidraṁ jātu manāg api
[chidram jaatu manaag api]
Word-for-word
aham—Ibhavān—youna—notca—alsoanyaḥ—differenttvam—youtvam—youeva—certainlyaham—as I amvicakṣva—just observebhoḥ—My dear friendna—notnau—of uspaśyanti—do observekavayaḥ—learned scholarschidram—faulty differentiationjātu—at any timemanāk—in a small degreeapi—even.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ahaṁ bhavān na cānyas tvaṁ
aham
I
bhavān
you
na
not
ca
also
anyaḥ
different
tvam
you
tvam evāhaṁ vicakṣva bhoḥ
tvam
you
eva
certainly
aham
as I am
vicakṣva
just observe
bhoḥ
My dear friend
na nau paśyanti kavayaś
na
not
nau
of us
paśyanti
do observe
kavayaḥ
learned scholars
chidraṁ jātu manāg api
chidram
faulty differentiation
jātu
at any time
manāk
in a small degree
api
even.
My dear friend, I, the Supersoul, and you, the individual soul, are not different in quality, for we are both spiritual. In fact, My dear friend, you are qualitatively not different from Me in your constitutional position. Just try to consider this subject. Those who are actually advanced scholars, who are in knowledge, do not find any qualitative difference between you and Me.
Purport
Both the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entity are qualitatively one. There is no factual difference between the two. The Māyāvādī philosophers are again and again defeated by the illusory energy because they think that there is no separation between the Supersoul and the individual soul or that there is no Supersoul. They are also misled in thinking that everything is the Supersoul. However, those who are kavayaḥ, learned scholars, actually know the facts. They do not commit such mistakes. They know that God and the individual soul are one in quality, but that the individual soul falls under the clutches of māyā, whereas the Supersoul, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the controller of māyā. Māyā is the creation of the Supreme Lord ( mayā sṛṣṭā ); therefore the Supreme Lord is the controller of māyā. Although one in quality with the Supreme Lord, the individual soul is under the control of māyā. Māyāvādī philosophers cannot distinguish between the controller and the controlled.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
I and you are different, but you are not something different from me. Ah! See without anger! The wise never see us in a faulty manner at all.
I am Paramātmā and you are jīva. You are not anything else. You are not different from me, being a conscious entity. “Why do you say such an intolerable thing?” Ah! My pure devotee! See with discretion, without anger (a-ham). Medinī says that ha means anger, Śiva, and a dog. “But I am your servant and you are the master. “Will not others criticize you when you say we are also non-difference?” The wise do never see such a fault (chidram) in our relationship. Only the foolish see contradiction.
You, individual soul, and I, Supersoul, are qualitatively one — both spiritual — though quantitatively distinct. Quality matches; quantity doesn't. Keep both halves of that statement together.
Reflection Questions
Where do I drop one half of 'qualitatively one, quantitatively distinct'?
What would balanced holding of both halves do to my devotional life?
yathā—aspuruṣaḥ—the living entityātmānam—his bodyekam—oneādarśa—in a mirrorcakṣuṣoḥ—by the eyesdvidhā-ābhūtam—existing as twoavekṣeta—seestathā—similarlyeva—certainlyantaram—differenceāvayoḥ—between ourselves.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yathā puruṣa ātmānam
yathā
as
puruṣaḥ
the living entity
ātmānam
his body
ekam ādarśa-cakṣuṣoḥ
ekam
one
ādarśa
in a mirror
cakṣuṣoḥ
by the eyes
dvidhābhūtam avekṣeta
dvidhā-ābhūtam
existing as two
avekṣeta
sees
tathaivāntaram āvayoḥ
tathā
similarly
eva
certainly
antaram
difference
āvayoḥ
between ourselves.
As a person sees the reflection of his body in a mirror to be one with himself and not different, whereas others actually see two bodies, so in our material condition, in which the living being is affected and yet not affected, there is a difference between God and the living entity.
Purport
Being affected by the conditioning of matter, Māyāvādī philosophers cannot see the difference between the Supreme Lord and the living entity. When the sun is reflected in a pot of water, the sun knows that there is no difference between himself and the reflected sun in the water. Those in ignorance, however, perceive that there are many small suns reflected in each and every pot. As far as the brilliance is concerned, there is brilliance both in the original sun and in the reflections, but the reflections are small, whereas the original sun is very large. Vaiṣṇava philosophers conclude that the living entity is simply a small sample of the original Supreme Personality of Godhead. Qualitatively, God and the living entities are one, but quantitatively the living entities are small fragments of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Lord is full, powerful and opulent. In the previous verse, the Lord says, “My dear friend, you and I are not different.” This nondifference refers to qualitative oneness, for it was not necessary for the Paramātmā, the Supreme Personality, to remind the conditioned soul that he is not one in quantity. The self-realized soul never thinks that he and the Supreme Personality of Godhead are one in every respect. Although he and the Supreme Personality of Godhead are one in quality, the living entity is prone to forget his spiritual identity, whereas the Supreme Personality never forgets. This is the difference between lipta and alipta. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is eternally alipta, uncontaminated by the external energy. The conditioned soul, however, being in contact with material nature, forgets his real identity; therefore when he sees himself in the conditioned state, he identifies himself with the body. For the Supreme Personality of Godhead, however, there is no difference between the body and the soul. He is completely soul; He has no material body. Although the Supersoul, Paramātmā, and the individual soul are both within the body, the Supersoul is devoid of designation, whereas the conditioned soul is designated by his particular type of body. The Supersoul is called antaryāmī, and He is extensive. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gītā (13.3) . Kṣetra-jñaṁ cāpi māṁ viddhi sarva-kṣetreṣu bhārata: “O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies.”
The Supersoul is present in everyone’s body, whereas the individual soul is conditioned in one particular type of body. The individual soul cannot understand what is taking place in another’s body, but the Supersoul knows very well what is happening in all bodies. In other words, the Supersoul is always present in His full spiritual position, whereas the individual soul is prone to forget himself. Nor is the individual soul present everywhere. Generally in his conditioned state the individual soul cannot understand his relationship with the Supersoul, but sometimes, when he is free from all conditional existence, he can see the real difference between the Supersoul and himself. When the Supersoul tells the conditioned soul, “You and I are one and the same,” it is to remind the conditioned soul of his spiritual identity as being qualitatively one. In the Third Canto of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (3.28.40) , it is said:
Fire has different features. There is flame, the sparks and the smoke. Although these are one in quality, there is still a difference between the fire, the flame, the spark and the smoke. The living entity becomes conditioned, but the Supreme Personality of Godhead is different because He does not become conditioned at any point. In the Vedas it is stated, ātmā tathā pṛthag draṣṭā bhagavān brahma-saṁjñitaḥ: ātmā is the individual soul as well as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the seer of everything. Although both are spirit, there is always a difference. In the smṛti it is also said, yathāgneḥ kṣudrā visphuliṅgā vyuccaranti: Just as sparks manifest in a large fire, similarly the small individual souls are present in the big spiritual flame. In Bhagavad-gītā (9.4) Lord Kṛṣṇa says, mat-sthāni sarva-bhūtāni na cāhaṁ teṣv avasthitaḥ: “All beings are in Me, but I am not in them.” Although all living beings are resting in Him, as small fiery sparks rest on a large flame, both are differently situated. Similarly, in the Viṣṇu Purāṇa it is said:
“Fire is situated in one place, but it distributes heat and light. Similarly, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is distributing His energies in different ways.” The living entity is but one of these energies (marginal energy). The energy and the energetic are one in one sense, but they are differently situated as energy and the energetic. Similarly, the sac-cid-ānanda form confirmed in Brahma-saṁhitā ( īśvaraḥ paramaḥ kṛṣṇaḥ sac-cid-ānanda-vigrahaḥ ) is different from that of the living entity in both his conditioned and liberated states. Only atheists consider the living entity and the Personality of Godhead equal in all respects. Caitanya Mahāprabhu therefore says, māyāvādi-bhāṣya śunile haya sarva-nāśa: “If one follows the instructions of Māyāvādī philosophers and believes that the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the individual soul are one, his understanding of real philosophy is forever doomed.”
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Just as a man, though one entity, will the image of himself in a mirror and in the eye are different, you should see that I and you are also different.
“You have said that you and I are not different. That is intolerable.” Please do not become angry. Try to understand. The jīva (puruṣaḥ), though the same entity, in liberation or in bondage, sees himself as two different forms in a mirror and in the eye. In a polished mirror he sees a large image, bright, without change. In the eye, he sees a small image, dull, that flickers. Just as one form becomes two different forms by being uncontaminated or contaminated with the qualities of obstructing elements, so one should see difference (antaram) between the Paramātmā and jīva at all times. Amara-koṣa says antaram means opportunity, neighborhood, clothing interim, and difference. I exist in the body as Paramātmā, and you exist there as jīva. By nature I have no covering, and by my will, enter all bodies in the world as antaryāmī, with appropriate size, with full brightness, powerful, without change. Like the liberated jīva, I am never contaminated. You however, a jīva, are small in size, with small brightness, weak, and always influenced by coverings. In the liberated state, however, you are uncontaminated. You should understand that we are different at all times. It has just been said aham bhavān na cānyaḥ: I and you are not different. I am conscious, and you, my devotee are conscious. You are not dull matter. That is the meaning of the statement. The demons however can take another meaning of these two verses of Bhāgavatam, which shows different faces to the demons and devotees like Mohinī. This is wrong since the Lord himself rejects the philosophy of one ātmā. It is said in the Third Canto:
yatholmukād visphuliṅgād dhūmād vāpi sva-sambhavāt
apy ātmatvenābhimatād yathāgniḥ pṛthag ulmukāt
bhūtendriyāntaḥ-karaṇāt pradhānāj jīva-saṁjñitāt
ātmā tathā pṛthag draṣṭā bhagavān brahma-saṁjñitaḥ
Just as fire is actually different from a blazing coal, and similarly is different from the spark and the smoke, which arise from fire, though by imagination they appear to be fire, similarly, Paramātmā, possessor of inconceivable powers, who also appears as impersonal Brahman, is different from pradhāna, the conscious jīva, and the body, senses and antaḥkaraṇa, because he is the witness of the others. SB 3.28.40-41
Śruti says:
yathāgneḥ kṣudrā visphuliṅgā vyuccaranti evem evāsmād ātmānaḥ sarvāni bhūtāni vyuccaranti
Just as small sparks arise from fire, all living beings emanate from the Supreme Lord. Bṛhad-āraṇyaka Upaniṣad 2.1.20
Smṛti says:
ekadeśe sthitasyāgner jyotsnā vistāriṇī yathā
parasya brahmaṇaḥ śaktis tathedam akhilaṁ jagat
Just as fire situated in one place spreads itself in the form of light, the energy of the Supreme Lord spreads through the whole universe. Viṣṇu Purāṇa
Thus, the Supreme Lord, a form of eternity, knowledge and bliss, is without coverings at all. However, according to demonic philosophers, he is said to have a covering material knowledge, vidyā.
Like a body and its mirror reflection — same shape but different bodies — God and the living entity are in apparent unity with subtle distinction. The reflection isn't the original; oneness has a structure.
Reflection Questions
Where do I take the reflection for the original, or vice versa?
What changes when I see myself as His reflection rather than as Him?
एवं स मानसो हंसो हंसेन प्रतिबोधित: ।
स्वस्थस्तद्वयभिचारेण नष्टामाप पुन: स्मृतिम् ॥ ६४ ॥
evaṁ sa mānaso haṁso
[evam sa maanaso hamso]
haṁsena pratibodhitaḥ
[hamsena pratibodhitah]
sva-sthas tad-vyabhicāreṇa
[sva-sthas tad-vyabhichaarena]
naṣṭām āpa punaḥ smṛtim
[nashtaam aapa punah smritim]
Word-for-word
evam—thussaḥ—he (the individual soul)mānasaḥ—living together within the hearthaṁsaḥ—like the swanhaṁsena—by the other swanpratibodhitaḥ—being instructedsva-sthaḥ—situated in self-realizationtat-vyabhicāreṇa—by being separated from the Supersoulnaṣṭām—which was lostāpa—gainedpunaḥ—againsmṛtim—real memory.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
evaṁ sa mānaso haṁso
evam
thus
saḥ
he (the individual soul)
mānasaḥ
living together within the heart
haṁsaḥ
like the swan
haṁsena pratibodhitaḥ
haṁsena
by the other swan
pratibodhitaḥ
being instructed
sva-sthas tad-vyabhicāreṇa
sva-sthaḥ
situated in self-realization
tat-vyabhicāreṇa
by being separated from the Supersoul
naṣṭām
which was lost
naṣṭām āpa punaḥ smṛtim
āpa
gained
punaḥ
again
smṛtim
real memory.
In this way both swans live together in the heart. When the one swan is instructed by the other, he is situated in his constitutional position. This means he regains his original Kṛṣṇa consciousness, which was lost because of his material attraction.
Purport
Here it is clearly stated, haṁso haṁsena pratibodhitaḥ: the individual soul and the Supersoul are both compared to swans ( haṁsa ) because they are white, or uncontaminated. One swan, however, is superior and is the instructor of the other. When the inferior swan is separated from the other swan, he is attracted to material enjoyment. This is the cause of his falldown. When he hears the instructions of the other swan, he understands his real position and is again revived to his original consciousness. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kṛṣṇa, comes down ( avatāra ) to deliver His devotees and kill the demons. He also gives His sublime instructions in the form of Bhagavad-gītā. The individual soul has to understand his position by the grace of the Lord and the spiritual master because the text of Bhagavad-gītā cannot be understood simply by academic qualifications. One has to learn Bhagavad-gītā from a realized soul:
tad viddhi praṇipātena paripraśnena sevayā upadekṣyanti te jñānaṁ jñāninas tattva-darśinaḥ
“Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth.” ( Bg. 4.34 )
Thus one has to select a bona fide spiritual master and become enlightened to his original consciousness. In this way the individual soul can understand that he is always subordinate to the Supersoul. As soon as he declines to remain subordinate and tries to become an enjoyer, he begins his material conditioning. When he abandons this spirit of being an individual owner or enjoyer, he becomes situated in his liberated state. The word sva-sthaḥ, meaning “situated in one’s original position,” is very significant in this verse. When one gives up his unwanted attitude of superiority, he becomes situated in his original position. The word tad-vyabhicāreṇa is also significant, for it indicates that when one is separated from God due to disobedience, his real sense is lost. Again, by the grace of Kṛṣṇa and guru, he can be properly situated in his liberated position. These verses are spoken by Śrīla Nārada Muni, and his purpose in speaking them is to revive our consciousness. Although the living entity and the Supersoul are one in quality, the individual soul has to pursue the instruction of the Supersoul. That is the state of liberation.
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
Thus one swan, after being instructed by the other swan who was situated in without material coverings, regained his memory which was lost by aversion to the Lord.
This is a summary. Svasthaḥ means the jīva not covered by prakṛti. He again attained memory which was lost by aversion to the Lord, which previously he had attained by devotion to a guru. By the discussion of non-difference and by the greater strength of the śruti concerning two birds, one should understand that the highest goal, according to Nārada, is attaining the position of prema as an associate of the Lord.
Two swans in the heart; when one (Supersoul) instructs the other (jīva), the jīva returns to its constitutional position — Kṛṣṇa consciousness. Instruction from within is the path back; the conversation is internal.
Reflection Questions
Where do I expect the other swan to speak audibly outside when His voice is inside?
What practice tunes my listening to the inner swan's instruction?
बर्हिष्मन्नेतदध्यात्मंपारोक्ष्येणप्रदर्शितम् ।
यत्परोक्षप्रियो देवो भगवान् विश्वभावन: ॥ ६५ ॥
barhiṣmann etad adhyātmaṁ
[barhishmann etad adhyaatmam]
pārokṣyeṇa pradarśitam
[paarokshyena pradarshitam]
yat parokṣa-priyo devo
[yat paroksha-priyo devo]
bhagavān viśva-bhāvanaḥ
[bhagavaan vishva-bhaavanah]
Word-for-word
barhiṣman—O King Prācīnabarhietat—thisadhyātmam—narration of self-realizationpārokṣyeṇa—indirectlypradarśitam—instructedyat—becauseparokṣa-priyaḥ—interesting by indirect descriptiondevaḥ—the Supreme Lordbhagavān—the Personality of Godheadviśva-bhāvanaḥ—the cause of all causes.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
barhiṣmann etad adhyātmaṁ
barhiṣman
O King Prācīnabarhi
etat
this
adhyātmam
narration of self-realization
pārokṣyeṇa pradarśitam
pārokṣyeṇa
indirectly
pradarśitam
instructed
yat parokṣa-priyo devo
yat
because
parokṣa-priyaḥ
interesting by indirect description
devaḥ
the Supreme Lord
bhagavān viśva-bhāvanaḥ
bhagavān
the Personality of Godhead
viśva-bhāvanaḥ
the cause of all causes.
My dear King Prācīnabarhi, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the cause of all causes, is celebrated to be known indirectly. Thus I have described the story of Purañjana to you. Actually it is an instruction for self-realization.
Purport
There are many similar stories in the Purāṇas for self-realization. As stated in the Vedas, parokṣa-priyā iva hi devāḥ. There are many stories in the Purāṇas that are intended to interest ordinary men in transcendental subjects, but actually these refer to real facts. They are not to be considered stories without a transcendental purpose. Some of them refer to real historical facts. One should be interested, however, in the real purport of the story. Indirect instruction is quickly understandable for a common man. Factually the path of bhakti-yoga is the path of hearing directly about the pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead ( śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ ), but those who are not interested in hearing directly about the activities of the Lord, or who cannot understand them, can very effectively hear such stories and fables as this one narrated by Nārada Muni.
The following is a glossary of some of the important words in this chapter.
Ādeśa-kārī. The actions resulting from sinful activities.
Agastya. The mind.
Amātya. The governor of the senses, the mind.
Arbuda-arbuda. Various types of śravaṇa and kīrtana of the Supreme Lord’s name, quality, form and so on.
Ari. Impediments like disease.
Bhoga. Enjoyment. Herein this word refers to real enjoyment in spiritual life.
Bhṛtya. The servants of the body, namely the senses.
Draviḍa-rāja. Devotional service or a person eligible to act in devotional service.
Dvāra. The doors of the body, such as the eyes and ears.
Gṛha. Home. For spiritual cultivation one requires an undisturbed place or the good association of devotees.
Idhmavāha. The devotee who approaches the spiritual master. Idhma refers to wood that is taken to burn as fuel for a fire. A brahmacārī is supposed to take this idhma to ignite the fire used in performing sacrifices. By spiritual instruction a brahmacāri is trained to ignite a fire and offer oblations in the morning. He is supposed to go to the spiritual master to take lessons on transcendental subject matter, and the Vedic injunction is that when approaching the spiritual master one must carry with him fuel to perform yajñas, or sacrifices. The exact Vedic injunction is as follows:
tad-vijñānārthaṁ sa gurum evābhigacchet samit-pāṇiḥ śrotriyaṁ brahma-niṣṭham
“To learn transcendental subject matter, one must approach the spiritual master. In doing so, he should carry fuel to burn in sacrifice. The symptom of such a spiritual master is that he is expert in understanding the Vedic conclusion, and therefore he constantly engages in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.” ( Muṇḍaka Upaniṣad 1.2.12) By serving such a bona fide spiritual master, gradually a conditioned soul becomes detached from material enjoyment and invariably makes progress in spiritual realization under the direction of the spiritual master. Those who are misled by the illusory energy are never interested in approaching a spiritual master to make life successful.
Jāyā. Intelligence.
Jīrṇa-sarpa. The fatigued air of life.
Kālakanyā. The invalidity of old age.
Kāma. A high fever.
Kulācala. The place where there is no disturbance.
Kuṭumbinī. Intelligence.
Madirekṣaṇā. Madirekṣaṇā refers to one whose eyes are so attractive that one who observes them becomes maddened by her. In other words, madirekṣaṇā means a very beautiful young girl. According to Jīva Gosvāmī, madirekṣaṇā means the personified deity of bhakti. If one is attracted by the bhakti cult, he becomes engaged in the service of the Lord and the spiritual master, and thus his life becomes successful. Vaidarbhī, the woman, became a follower of her husband. As she left her comfortable home for the service of her husband, a serious student of spiritual understanding must give up everything for the service of the spiritual master. As stated by Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura, yasya prasādād bhagavat-prasādaḥ: if one wants actual success in life, he must strictly follow the instructions of the spiritual master. By following such instructions, one is sure to make rapid progress in spiritual life. This statement by Viśvanātha Cakravartī is in pursuance of the following injunction from the Śvetāśvatara Upaniṣad (6.23):
yasya deve parā bhaktir yathā deve tathā gurau tasyaite kathitā hy arthāḥ prakāśante mahātmanaḥ
“Only unto those great souls who have implicit faith in both the Lord and the spiritual master are all the imports of Vedic knowledge automatically revealed.” In the Chāndogya Upaniṣad it is said, ācāryavān puruṣo veda: “One who approaches a bona fide spiritual master can understand everything about spiritual realization.”
Malayadhvaja. A nice devotee who is like sandalwood.
Pañcāla. The five sense objects.
Paricchada. The total aggregate of the senses.
Paura-jana. The seven elements that constitute the body.
Pautra. Patience and gravity.
Prajvāra. A kind of fever called viṣṇu-jvāra.
Pratikriyā. Counteracting agents such as mantras and medicines.
Pura-pālaka. The life air.
Putra. Consciousness.
Sainika. The condition of threefold miseries.
Sapta-suta. The seven sons, namely hearing, chanting, remembering, offering prayers, serving the lotus feet of the Lord, worshiping the Deity and becoming a servant of the Lord.
Sauhṛdya. Endeavor.
Suta. The son of Vaidarbhī, or, in other words, one who is somewhat advanced in fruitive activities and who comes in contact with a devotee spiritual master. Such a person becomes interested in the subject matter of devotional service.
Vaidarbhī. The woman who was formerly a man but took birth as a woman in his next life because of too much attachment to woman. Darbha means kuśa grass. In fruitive activities, or karma-kāṇḍīya ceremonies, one requires kuśa grass. Thus vaidarbhī refers to one who takes birth in a family of karma-kāṇḍīya understanding. However, if by karma-kāṇḍa activities one by chance comes in contact with a devotee, as Vaidarbhī did when she married Malayadhvaja, his life becomes successful. He then pursues the devotional service of the Lord. The conditioned soul becomes liberated simply by following the instructions of the bona fide spiritual master.
Vidarbha-rājasiṁha. The best of persons who are expert in fruitive activities.
Vīrya. One who has mercy.
Yavana. The servant of Yamarāja.
Thus end the Bhaktivedanta purports of the Fourth Canto, Twenty-eighth Chapter, of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, entitled “Purañjana Becomes a Woman in the Next Life.”
— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Gauḍīya Ācāryas
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura
Gauḍīya
Translation
O King Prācīnabarhi! I have given spiritual instructions indirectly through an allegory, since the Lord, acting for the welfare of the universe, is fond of indirect expression.
Do not take this to be simply a story. On the pretext of telling a story about a king (pārokṣyeṇa) I have given spiritual instruction. The reason is given. The Lord is fond of indirect expression. I have told a story to you which is beyond the limits of time.
Thus ends the commentary on the Twenty-eighth Chapter of the Fourth Canto of the Bhāgavatam for the pleasure of the devotees, in accordance with the previous ācāryas.
Chapter Twenty-nine
The Meaning of the Story of King Purañjana
His Holiness Prabodhananda Sarasvati Swami· 2011-04-16· English
Personal Guidance
Supreme Lord is celebrated to be known indirectly — through parable. The whole Purañjana story is an instruction for self-realization. Some teachings only work as story; resist the urge for direct doctrine.
Reflection Questions
Which parable in scripture am I reading as story when it's actually a manual for me?
Where could I receive teaching better through story than through doctrine?