FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.47.40

कच्चिद् गदाग्रज: सौम्य करोति पुरयोषिताम् । प्रीतिं न: स्‍निग्धसव्रीडहासोदारेक्षणार्चित: ॥ ४० ॥
kaccid gadāgrajaḥ saumya
[kachchid gadaagrajah saumya]
karoti pura-yoṣitām
[karoti pura-yoshitaam]
prītiṁ naḥ snigdha-savrīḍa-
[preetim nah snigdha-savreeda-]
hāsodārekṣaṇārcitaḥ
[haasodaarekshanaarchitah]
kaccit — perhaps gada - agrajaḥ — Kṛṣṇa, the elder brother of Gada saumya — O gentle (Uddhava) karoti — is giving pura — of the city yoṣitām — for the women prītim — loving happiness naḥ — which belongs to us snigdha — affectionate sa - vrīḍa — and bashful hāsa — with smiles udāra — generous īkṣaṇa — by their glances arcitaḥ — worshiped .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kaccid gadāgrajaḥ saumya
kaccit
perhaps
gada - agrajaḥ
Kṛṣṇa, the elder brother of Gada
saumya
O gentle (Uddhava)
karoti pura-yoṣitām
karoti
is giving
pura
of the city
yoṣitām
for the women
prītiṁ naḥ snigdha-savrīḍa-
prītim
loving happiness
naḥ
which belongs to us
snigdha
affectionate
sa - vrīḍa
and bashful
hāsodārekṣaṇārcitaḥ
hāsa
with smiles
udāra
generous
īkṣaṇa
by their glances
arcitaḥ
worshiped .
  • gada-agrajaḥ — the elder brother of Gada
    Compound: gada (Kṛṣṇa's younger brother) + agrajaḥ (elder-born). The gopīs name Kṛṣṇa by His Yadu-family role — pointedly NOT by Nanda-suta. Every title-choice in this chapter is theological.
  • pura-yoṣitām — for the women of the city
    Compound: pura (city) + yoṣitām (women). The pura-yoṣit / vraja-yoṣit binary returns. Gauḍīyas note that pura-yoṣit denotes the future queens of Dvārakā — Rukmiṇī, Satyabhāmā, the 16,108 — bhāktas in vidhi-mārga, not in rāga.
  • snigdha-sa-vrīḍa-hāsa-udāra-īkṣaṇa — with affectionate, bashful, smiling, generous glances
    Compound (contiguous chain): snigdha (affectionate) + sa-vrīḍa (with shyness) + hāsa (smile) + udāra (generous) + īkṣaṇa (glance). The gopīs catalog precisely the glance-vocabulary of mādhurya-courtship — confirming they know exactly what they have lost.
Gentle Uddhava, is the elder brother of Gada now bestowing on the city women the pleasure that actually belongs to us? We suppose those ladies worship Him with generous glances full of affectionate, shy smiles.

The name Gadāgraja indicates Kṛṣṇa, the elder brother ( agraja ) of Gada, the first son of Devarakṣitā. She was a sister of Devakī’s who was also married to Vasudeva. The gopīs, by addressing Kṛṣṇa in this way, indicate that He now thinks of Himself mostly as the son of Devakī, the implication being that His connection with Vṛndāvana has now slackened. Because of intense love, the gopīs could not stop thinking of Kṛṣṇa for a moment.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Gentle Uddhava, is the elder brother of Gada now bestowing on the city women the pleasure that actually belongs to us? We suppose those ladies worship Him with generous glances full of affectionate, shy smiles.
Commentary

Some gopis, other than those who were prevented from going to the rasa lila, then spoke with bitterness. Gada was the son of Devaraksita, the daughter of Devaka and one of the wives of Vasudeva. They address Krsna as the elder brother of Gada, indicating that Krnsa thinks of himself as the son of Devaki and elder brother of Gada, and his relationship with those in Gokula has weakened. "We worshipped him with our pleasing, shy smiles and generous glances. Is he now stimulating the love of the women of Mathura with his bold glances? Is he worshipping them? O Siva! Siva! His worshippable by us, but he is worshipping them. It is our great misfortune!"

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Different gopīs speak these verses, but there is a connection between them since they were of the same mind. They ask about his happiness out of intense prema. They display hatred for the women of Mathurā, thinking of them as competitors, on remembering the Mathurā women after having a sphūrti of his pastimes with the gopīs. The possessive case (yoṣitām) is used to indicate the locative case. Gada was the first son of Devarakṣita, a wife of Vasudeva. He was younger than Kṛṣṇa. The gopīs had heard that Kṛṣṇa had great affection for him as a younger brother. This hints at a slackening of his attraction for Gokula, a slackening of affection for the gopīs, and an increased affection for the women of Mathurā. Udāra means excellent.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

In classifying the varioius speakers by the different statements, some connection between the statements can be made. They ask about his comfortable situation with eagerness and greed for prema. Since he associates with the city women they describe the pleasing conduct of the city women. They have excellend (udāra) glances and shy smiles. Does our (naḥ) master, the elder brother of Gada, please the city women? Or they ask with pain in prema, “Now will he be merciful to us?” Though worshipped by the shy smiles and excellent glances of the city women, will he give pleasure to us (nah)? Present tense is used for the future to indicate that it will happen soon.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
Is Gada's elder brother bestowing the city women the pleasure that belongs to us? They worship Him with shy generous smiles. The gopīs still wrestle with comparison; healed love sometimes reverts to old wounds.
Reflection Questions
  • Where do you revert to comparison even after generosity has briefly broken through?
  • How patient are you with your own non-linear progress?

'Is the elder brother of Gada giving the city women the pleasure that belongs to us?' the gopīs ask. The question is rhetorical, the wound is exact. Vraja's monopoly on mādhurya is being audited.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 47