FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.60.40

जाड्यं वचस्तव गदाग्रज यस्तु भूपान् विद्राव्य शार्ङ्गनिनदेन जहर्थ मां त्वम् । सिंहो यथा स्वबलिमीश पशून् स्वभागं तेभ्यो भयाद् यदुदधिं शरणं प्रपन्न: ॥ ४० ॥
jāḍyaṁ vacas tava gadāgraja yas tu bhūpān
[jaadyam vachas tava gadaagraja yas tu bhoopaan]
vidrāvya śārṅga-ninadena jahartha māṁ tvam
[vidraavya shaarnga-ninadena jahartha maam tvam]
siṁho yathā sva-balim īśa paśūn sva-bhāgaṁ
[simho yathaa sva-balim eesha pashoon sva-bhaagam]
tebhyo bhayād yad udadhiṁ śaraṇaṁ prapannaḥ
[tebhyo bhayaad yad udadhim sharanam prapannah]
jāḍyam — foolishness vacaḥ — words tava — Your gadāgraja — O Gadāgraja yaḥ — who tu — even bhū - pān — the kings vidrāvya — driving away śārṅga — of Śārṅga, Your bow ninadena — by the resounding jahartha — took away mām — me tvam — You siṁhaḥ — a lion yathā — as sva — Your own balim — tribute īśa — O Lord paśūn — animals sva - bhāgam — his own share tebhyaḥ — of them bhayāt — out of fear yat — that udadhim — of the ocean śaraṇaṁ - prapannaḥ — took shelter .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
jāḍyaṁ vacas tava gadāgraja yas tu bhūpān
jāḍyam
foolishness
vacaḥ
words
tava
Your
gadāgraja
O Gadāgraja
yaḥ
who
tu
even
bhū - pān
the kings
vidrāvya śārṅga-ninadena jahartha māṁ tvam
vidrāvya
driving away
śārṅga
of Śārṅga, Your bow
ninadena
by the resounding
jahartha
took away
mām
me
tvam
You
siṁho yathā sva-balim īśa paśūn sva-bhāgaṁ
siṁhaḥ
a lion
yathā
as
sva
Your own
balim
tribute
īśa
O Lord
paśūn
animals
sva - bhāgam
his own share
tebhyo bhayād yad udadhiṁ śaraṇaṁ prapannaḥ
tebhyaḥ
of them
bhayāt
out of fear
yat
that
udadhim
of the ocean
śaraṇaṁ - prapannaḥ
took shelter .
  • siṁhaḥ yathā — as a lion
    Siṁha (lion) + yathā (as). The lion-of-Yadus (Yādava-siṁha) is one of Kṛṣṇa's traditional epithets. She uses the simile to refuse the cowering self-portrait — the lion takes; he does not flee.
  • śārṅga-ninadena — by the resounding of Śārṅga (Your bow)
    Compound: śārṅga (Kṛṣṇa's bow) + ninada (twang). Śārṅga is one of His five eternal weapons (with Sudarśana, Pāñcajanya, Kaumodakī, Nandaka). She returns His own armaments to His self-portrait.
  • jāḍyam — foolishness
    From jaḍa (inert, dull). Bold word — she calls His own speech jāḍyam. Gauḍīya tradition admires the boldness: the queen's prema licenses her to correct the Lord's pralambha by name.
  • gadāgraja — O Gadāgraja (elder brother of Gada)
    Compound vocative: gada (His brother) + agra-ja (born before, elder). One of His Dvārakā-names — establishing Him in the family register, even as she refuses His denial of the family bond.
My Lord, as a lion drives away lesser animals to claim his proper tribute, You drove off the assembled kings with the resounding twang of Your Śārṅga bow and then claimed me, Your fair share. Thus it is sheer foolishness, my dear Gadāgraja, for You to say You took shelter in the ocean out of fear of those kings.

In text 12 of this chapter Lord Kṛṣṇa said, rājabhyo bibhyataḥ su-bhru samudraṁ śaranaṁ gatān: “Terrified of those kings, We went to the ocean for shelter.” According to the ācāryas, Lord Kṛṣṇa finally provoked Rukmiṇī’s anger by glorifying other men who might have been her husband, and thus in an agitated mood she here tells Him that she is not ignorant but rather that He has spoken foolishly. She states, “Like a lion You abducted me in the presence of those kings and drove them away with Your Śārṅga bow, so it is simply foolishness to say that out of fear of those same kings You went to the ocean.” According to Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī, as Queen Rukmiṇī spoke these words she frowned and cast angry sidelong glances at the Lord.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
My Lord, as a lion drives away lesser animals to claim his proper tribute, You drove off the assembled kings with the resounding twang of Your Śārṅga bow and then claimed me, Your fair share. Thus it is sheer foolishness, my dear Gadāgraja, for You to say You took shelter in the ocean out of fear of those kings.
Commentary

Then suddenly she began to manifest the sthayi bhava of mana (anger). Having already hinted at his ignorance of her knowledge and foresight, becoming more angry because of his descriptions of the good qualities of the other kings, she clearly indicates his ignorance while showing sidelong glances and moving eyebrows. "Your words are foolish. Since you defeated the other kings and took me away as your prize, when you say that you took shelter of the ocean out of fear of them, it shows your foolishness." "But earlier you said that it was true that I took shelter of the ocean out of fear." verse 35. "True that was my foolishness to say that."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The suffix ya in jāḍyam denotes quality and work. Jāḍyam acts in apposition to the noun vacaḥ. Thus as a quality it indicates completely lifelessness of his words. And his words produce this effect. The word tu indicates opposition to Kṛṣṇa’s statement. You took me because I was your share (sva-bhāgam). O Gadāgraja! Even your younger brother Gada all alone was capable of driving them off. You are even more capable, since you are endowed with unlimited powers (īśa).

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Tu indicates that the event is contrary to perception. You stole me, because I belonged to you (sva-bhāgam). Otherwise you would lose your fame. This description is given at the end, out of embarrassment. O Gadāgraja! Even your younger brother Gada all alone was capable of driving them off. You are even more capable, since you are endowed with unlimited powers (īśa).

Related values
Dana (Charity / Generosity)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Yajña (Sacrifice / Spirit of Offering)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Santosha (Contentment)Bhakti (Devotion)
Related verses
Concepts
JivaBhava
As a lion drives lesser animals to claim tribute, You drove off the assembled kings with Your Śārṅga twang and claimed me, Your fair share — foolish to call You fearful, my dear Gadāgraja. Rukmiṇī's wit is sharp; the 'fearful' Lord is a lion.
Reflection Questions
  • Where do you accept Kṛṣṇa's self-deprecating framing when His actions reveal lion-strength?
  • Could you tease back with the truth?

A lion drives off jackals to take his proper share of the kill; the share was always his. So You drove off the kings with the twang of Śārṅga and took me — Your fair portion. To call that 'fleeing in fear' is jāḍya, foolish speech, and I will not let it stand.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 60