FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.15.40

अथ तालफलान्यादन्मनुष्या गतसाध्वसा: । तृणं च पशवश्चेरुर्हतधेनुककानने ॥ ४० ॥
atha tāla-phalāny ādan
[atha taala-phalaany aadan]
manuṣyā gata-sādhvasāḥ
[manushyaa gata-saadhvasaah]
tṛṇaṁ ca paśavaś cerur
[trinam cha pashavash cherur]
hata-dhenuka-kānane
[hata-dhenuka-kaanane]
atha — then tāla — of the palm trees phalāni — the fruits ādan — ate manuṣyāḥ — the human beings gata - sādhvasāḥ — having lost their fear tṛṇam — upon the grass ca — and paśavaḥ — the animals ceruḥ — grazed hata — killed dhenuka — of the demon Dhenuka kānane — in the forest .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
atha tāla-phalāny ādan
atha
then
tāla
of the palm trees
phalāni
the fruits
ādan
ate
manuṣyā gata-sādhvasāḥ
manuṣyāḥ
the human beings
gata - sādhvasāḥ
having lost their fear
tṛṇaṁ ca paśavaś cerur
tṛṇam
upon the grass
ca
and
paśavaḥ
the animals
ceruḥ
grazed
hata-dhenuka-kānane
hata
killed
dhenuka
of the demon Dhenuka
kānane
in the forest .
  • tāla phalāni — the fruits of the palm trees
    tāla (palm) + phala (fruit). Gauḍīya: the same fruits the boys had asked for in verse 26 are now eaten — and not only by them. The harvest is shared. Bhakti's victories are public goods.
  • ādan — ate
    Imperfect plural of √ad. Gauḍīya: the eating itself is a celebration — Vraja's victories are marked by eating, not by trophies. The same theology continues in Annakūṭa (Govardhana-pūjā) feast.
  • gata-sādhvasāḥ — having lost their fear
    gata (gone) + sādhvasa (fear). Gauḍīya: gata-sādhvasa is also a description of advanced bhaktas — fear-free. Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma's protection produces nirbhayatā; the same gift the Lord gives Prahlāda (SB 7.4-9), He gives Tālavana's grass-eaters.
  • kānane — in the forest
    Locative of kānana — forest. Synonym for vana. Gauḍīya: the locative places the action precisely — in Tālavana, the formerly forbidden forest, now grazing-ground.
  • hata dhenuka — killed Dhenuka
    hata (killed) + dhenuka. Gauḍīya: the place is now known by what happened there — hata-dhenuka-kānana. Vraja's sacred geography is named by its kills; each demon's death consecrates a spot.
People now felt free to return to the forest where Dhenuka had been killed, and without fear they ate the fruits of the palm trees. Also, the cows could now graze freely upon the grass there.

According to the ācāryas, low-class people such as the pulindas ate the fruits of the palm trees, but Kṛṣṇa’s cowherd boyfriends considered them undesirable, since they had been tainted with the blood of the asses.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
People now felt free to return to the forest where Dhenuka had been killed, and without fear they ate the fruits of the palm trees. Also, the cows could now graze freely upon the grass there.
Commentary

Men began to eat the fruit from that forest. These were the pulindas and other low tribes of Vrndavana. The cowherds did not eat, since being contaminated with the blood of the demon, the fruits would invoke their disgust.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The cowherd boys did not eat the fruit since they felt repulsion because of the dead bodies. But others ate the fruit. Because the demon was there, previously no cows grazed there. Thus it was now full of grass.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Manuṣyāh refers to the cowherds. They now had no fear (gata-sādhvasāḥ) for the safety of Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma and ate (ādan) the fruit. Or all the cowherds without fear of Dhenuka ate the fruit which they could not eat previously. Or cowherds ate the fruit and other men became free of fear. The cows freely grazed where Dhekua was killed, where humans could not go because of the piles of thick grass.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)
Related verses
People return to the forest without fear, and cows graze freely. The Lord's interventions restore freedom to the commons — places once dangerous become available for ordinary life. Liberation is concretely shared.
Reflection Questions
  • What part of my life, once dangerous, is now safe enough that ordinary use should resume?
  • Where am I still treating a now-liberated area as if Dhenuka still ruled it?

After a long siege ends, villagers re-enter their own forest with baskets and grateful eyes. Tālavana opens — humans eat the fruits without fear, cows graze where they were forbidden. The līlā's social side: a demon's removal is not only a kill, it is a return of common space to the community. Bhakti restores the commons.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 15