FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.54.38

मैवास्मान् साध्व्यसूयेथा भ्रातुर्वैरूप्यचिन्तया । सुखदु:खदो न चान्योऽस्ति यत: स्वकृतभुक् पुमान् ॥ ३८ ॥
maivāsmān sādhvy asūyethā
[maivaasmaan saadhvy asooyethaa]
bhrātur vairūpya-cintayā
[bhraatur vairoopya-chintayaa]
sukha-duḥkha-do na cānyo ’sti
[sukha-duhkha-do na chaanyo ’sti]
yataḥ sva-kṛta-bhuk pumān
[yatah sva-krita-bhuk pumaan]
mā — please do not eva — indeed asmān — toward Us sādhvi — O saintly lady asūyethāḥ — feel inimical bhrātuḥ — of your brother vairūpya — over the disfigurement cintayā — out of concern sukha — of happiness duḥkha — and unhappiness daḥ — bestower na — not ca — and anyaḥ — anyone else asti — there is yataḥ — since sva — of his own kṛta — action bhuk — the sufferer of the reaction pumān — a man .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
maivāsmān sādhvy asūyethā
mā
please do not
eva
indeed
asmān
toward Us
sādhvi
O saintly lady
asūyethāḥ
feel inimical
bhrātur vairūpya-cintayā
bhrātuḥ
of your brother
vairūpya
over the disfigurement
cintayā
out of concern
sukha-duḥkha-do na cānyo ’sti
sukha
of happiness
duḥkha
and unhappiness
daḥ
bestower
na
not
ca
and
anyaḥ
anyone else
asti
there is
yataḥ sva-kṛta-bhuk pumān
yataḥ
since
sva
of his own
kṛta
action
bhuk
the sufferer of the reaction
pumān
a man .
  • sādhvi — O saintly lady
    Feminine vocative of sādhu. Balarāma honors Rukmiṇī by the strongest dharma-title even as He corrects her grief. The Bhāgavatam shows that loving rebuke must begin with honorific address.
  • sva-kṛta-bhuk — the sufferer of his own deeds
    Sva (own) + kṛta (done) + bhuj (experience). 'One who eats his own cooking.' The compound is karma-doctrine in three syllables. Cf. BG 5.15: 'na ādatte kasyacit pāpaṁ na caiva sukṛtaṁ vibhuḥ.' The Lord does not assign sin or virtue; the soul harvests its own.
  • asūyethāḥ — (please do not) feel inimical / envious
    Aorist optative of √sūy with a- prefix. Asūyā is one of the six enemies of the soul in Gauḍīya catalogues. Balarāma asks Rukmiṇī not to fall into even momentary asūyā — the verse's tenderness disguises a rigorous spiritual point.
  • sukha-duḥkha-daḥ — bestower of happiness and unhappiness
    Sukha (joy) + duḥkha (misery) + da (giver). Compound. Balarāma denies any 'other' as the bestower — but the Bhāgavatam reading is that the Lord, working through karma, is the bestower-through-justice. There is no third party.
  • pumān — a man / person
    Puruṣa-singular. The same word as the cosmic Puruṣa. The jīva is a tiny puruṣa within the big Puruṣa, accountable for his own actions in the field He shares with the Lord.
Saintly lady, please do not be displeased with Us out of anxiety for your brother’s disfigurement. No one but oneself is responsible for one’s joy and grief, for a man experiences the result of his own deeds.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Saintly lady, please do not be displeased with Us out of anxiety for your brother's disfigurement. No one but oneself is responsible for one's joy and grief, for a man experiences the result of his own deeds.
Commentary

In order to remove the sorrow of Rukmini, he reasons with her in this verse. "Every jiva must enjoy of suffering the results of his acts. So what is this useless affection for a person who is evil and who acts against your husband?" He gives a hint of scolding to Rukmini.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Though Balarāma spoke to Kṛṣṇa in this way, Rukmiṇī did not give up her grief. He then consoled her directly in this verse. Do not ascribe fault to Kṛṣṇa and others. Do not ascribe fault at all (eva), even if there is cause. On the other hand (ca), happiness and distress are not caused by others, but by oneself since the jīva (pumān) enjoys the result of his karma.

Related values
Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)Bhakti (Devotion)Yajña (Sacrifice / Spirit of Offering)Vinaya (Humility / Modesty)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)
Related verses
Concepts
KarmaJiva
Saintly lady, do not be displeased — no one but oneself is responsible for joy and grief; one experiences the result of one's own deeds. Even relatives' suffering tracks back to their own karma; comfort points to that truth.
Reflection Questions
  • Where do you blame circumstances when your karma is the actual author?
  • How do you console someone with karma-truth without sounding dismissive?

Each man is the sole bestower of his own joy and sorrow — a sentence as Vedic as the Upaniṣads and as Buddhist-sounding as the Dhammapada. The Gauḍīya wrinkle: the doer-of-actions remains the soul, but the supplier-of-results is the Lord. Karma is real; impersonal karma is not.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 54