FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.49.23

पुष्णाति यानधर्मेण स्वबुद्ध्या तमपण्डितम् । तेऽकृतार्थं प्रहिण्वन्ति प्राणा राय: सुतादय: ॥ २३ ॥
puṣṇāti yān adharmeṇa
[pushnaati yaan adharmena]
sva-buddhyā tam apaṇḍitam
[sva-buddhyaa tam apanditam]
te ’kṛtārthaṁ prahiṇvanti
[te ’kritaartham prahinvanti]
prāṇā rāyaḥ sutādayaḥ
[praanaa raayah sutaadayah]
puṣṇāti — nourishes yān — which things adharmeṇa — by sinful activity sva - buddhyā — thinking them to be his own tam — him apaṇḍitam — uneducated te — they akṛta - artham — his purposes frustrated prahiṇvanti — abandon prāṇāḥ — life air rāyaḥ — wealth suta - ādayaḥ — children and others .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
puṣṇāti yān adharmeṇa
puṣṇāti
nourishes
yān
which things
adharmeṇa
by sinful activity
sva-buddhyā tam apaṇḍitam
sva - buddhyā
thinking them to be his own
tam
him
apaṇḍitam
uneducated
te ’kṛtārthaṁ prahiṇvanti
te
they
akṛta - artham
his purposes frustrated
prahiṇvanti
abandon
prāṇā rāyaḥ sutādayaḥ
prāṇāḥ
life air
rāyaḥ
wealth
suta - ādayaḥ
children and others .
  • sva-buddhyā — thinking them his own
    Sva (one's own) + buddhi (intellect). The whole error in one compound: it is not the things that fail him but the buddhi that called them sva. Echoes Gītā 2.71 on the renunciation of mama-buddhi.
  • apaṇḍitam — uneducated
    Negation of paṇḍita. The Bhāgavata's paṇḍita is not the textually learned but the one who sees rightly (Gītā 5.18); the apaṇḍita is the man whose vision has been mortgaged.
  • akṛta-artham — whose purposes are frustrated
    Compound: a (not) + kṛta (done) + artha (purpose). Even on his own terms — keeping the dependents fed — the project fails. The Bhāgavata closes every escape route from this argument.
  • prāṇāḥ — life airs
    The Upaniṣadic plural — the five prāṇas. Listed together with wealth and children precisely so the reader sees the body itself in the same category: a temporary holding.
A fool indulges in sin to maintain his life, wealth and children and other relatives, for he thinks, “These things are mine.” In the end, however, these very things all abandon him, leaving him frustrated.

In these verses, Akrūra is giving rather frank advice to Dhṛtarāṣṭra. Those who know the story of the Mahābhārata will realize how relevant and prophetic these instructions are, and how much Dhṛtarāṣṭra suffered for not accepting them. Although one tenaciously clings to his property, in the end all is lost, and the blundering soul is swept away by the wheel of birth and death.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
A fool indulges in sin to maintain his life, wealth and children and other relatives, for he thinks, "These things are mine." In the end, however, these very things all abandon him, leaving him frustrated.
Commentary

"Life, wealth (rayah) and sons, which the fool maintains by sinful actions, thinking that they are his, abandon that fool who had not attained his desires."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

He tries to increase life, wealth and sons, but cannot do so. They leave him.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

In order to maintain his life he does not follow the rules and prohibitions. Therefore he is a fool. Life, wealth and relatives, as well as friends and servants (ādayaḥ) reject him. The list is in order to increasing importance for non-rejection. Life rejects him when he dies. Though living, wealth leaves him and conscious beings like children. They give him up without regard for dharma.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)Bhakti (Devotion)
Related verses
Concepts
Dharma
A fool indulges in sin to maintain life, wealth and children, thinking 'these are mine' — but they all abandon him, leaving frustration. The very objects we sin to protect ultimately leave us.
Reflection Questions
  • What sin are you currently protecting in order to preserve something that will leave you anyway?
  • Where could honest renunciation save what attachment cannot?

The fool feeds and feeds — wealth, children, body — believing these to be his treasure. At the end, the very dependents he fed walk away, and the body itself walks away (its prāṇa departing), leaving him empty-handed at the threshold he prepared for no one.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 49