FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.46.16

कच्चिदङ्ग महाभाग सखा न: शूरनन्दन: । आस्ते कुशल्यपत्याद्यैर्युक्तो मुक्त: सुहृद्‍व्रत: ॥ १६ ॥
kaccid aṅga mahā-bhāga
[kachchid anga mahaa-bhaaga]
sakhā naḥ śūra-nandanaḥ
[sakhaa nah shoora-nandanah]
āste kuśaly apatyādyair
[aaste kushaly apatyaadyair]
yukto muktaḥ suhṛd-vrataḥ
[yukto muktah suhrid-vratah]
kaccit — whether aṅga — my dear mahā - bhāga — O most fortunate one sakhā — the friend naḥ — our śūra - nandanaḥ — the son of King Śūra (Vasudeva) āste — lives kuśalī — well apatya - ādyaiḥ — with his children and so on yuktaḥ — joined muktaḥ — freed suhṛt — to his friends vrataḥ — who is devoted .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kaccid aṅga mahā-bhāga
kaccit
whether
aṅga
my dear
mahā - bhāga
O most fortunate one
sakhā naḥ śūra-nandanaḥ
sakhā
the friend
naḥ
our
śūra - nandanaḥ
the son of King Śūra (Vasudeva)
āste kuśaly apatyādyair
āste
lives
kuśalī
well
apatya - ādyaiḥ
with his children and so on
yukto muktaḥ suhṛd-vrataḥ
yuktaḥ
joined
muktaḥ
freed
suhṛt
to his friends
vrataḥ
who is devoted .
  • śūra - nandanaḥ — the son of Śūra
    Compound: Śūra (Vasudeva's father) + nandana (son/delight). Nanda names Vasudeva by his patronymic — a respectful distance, the courtesy of a cowherd toward Yadu nobility. The verse preserves the social register Nanda inhabits.
  • muktaḥ — freed
    Past participle of √muc. Vasudeva was imprisoned by Kaṁsa for years; Nanda is asking after his release. Gauḍīyas note that the word mukta in 10.46 is bodily liberation from a tyrant — not the Advaitin mukti, which the chapter's later tattva-section will quietly reframe.
  • apatya - ādyaiḥ — with his children and so on
    Compound: apatya (offspring) + ādi (and so on). Nanda asks whether Vasudeva is rejoined with his sons — meaning Kṛṣṇa and Balarāma, the boys Nanda himself raised. The phrasing is generous and painful at once: he calls them Vasudeva's offspring, not his own.
  • kuśalī — well
    Nominative of kuśalin — one possessing kuśala (well-being). The standard formal opening of any inquiry. But behind the formality is a father testing whether the word 'well' is now usable in his own household at all.
  • suhṛt - vrataḥ — devoted to his friends
    Compound: suhṛt (well-wisher) + vrata (vow). Nanda credentials Vasudeva by his fidelity to friendship — the very virtue Nanda himself is now living out by receiving Vasudeva's son's messenger with such honor.
  • mahā - bhāga — O most fortunate one
    Vocative compound: mahā (great) + bhāga (share, fortune). Nanda addresses Uddhava as 'most fortunate' — and the chapter will quietly establish that the fortune in question is that of being near Kṛṣṇa, which Nanda himself once had and now does not.
[Nanda Mahārāja said:] My dear most fortunate one, does the son of Śūra fare well, now that he is free and has rejoined his children and other relatives?
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[Nanda Mahārāja said:] My dear most fortunate one, does the son of Śūra fare well, now that he is free and has rejoined his children and other relatives?
Commentary

Fearing that if he asked about Krsna, his throat would choke up and tears would come to his eyes, Nanda first asked about the welfare of Vasudeva. Vasudeva was now freed from the prison house of Kamsa, and from all sorts of dangers.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Being unable to ask directly and immediately about Kṛṣṇa because of increased grief of separation, Nanda first asks about the welfare of Vasudeva as an introduction. O greatly fortunate Uddhava! You are qualified with great fortune since you are close to Kṛṣṇa. We however are not qualified for such fortune. Thus we are suitable to be rejected by him. As the son of Śūra Vasudeva has manifested his father’s good fortune, since Kṛṣṇa acts as his son. He is free from all dangers and united with his children (Kṛṣṇa). He is surrounded by friends (including Kṛṣṇa). Is he well? In this way he asks generally about everyone and also the condition of Kṛṣṇa.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Nanda asked about Vasudeva first since he was Kṛṣṇa’s father and Nanda’s friend. Or if he asked about Kṛṣṇa first he would be overcome with pain and would not be able to ask about other things after that. Or he asked the easy questions first since the question about Kṛṣṇa would be extensive. Or he had many worries about his dear friend Vasudeva because of his affection and thus asked about him first. O fortunate one! You are greatly fortunate because you are dear to Kṛṣṇa. We however are unfortunate since he gave us up. He does not mention Vasudeva’s name directly because of his friendship and respect or because of natural affection. He also asks about children and wives (ādyaiḥ). Vasudeva has been freed from all dangers and joined with children and relatives. He is surrounded by the Yadus. He asks about the welfare of Kṛṣṇa by asking about the welfare of all the Yadus and family members like Devakī.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
Nanda asks: does the son of Śūra fare well, now free and reunited with his children and relatives? Even joyful reunion in Mathurā is worth asking about; love wants news of the loved one's situation.
Reflection Questions
  • Whose 'situation in their new city' could you inquire after with this kind of warmth?
  • Where could you ask about the people in your past in fuller detail?

After years apart, a father's first question is not about kingdoms or campaigns but: 'Is he eating? Is he with his people?' Nanda asks about Vasudeva and family before he can bring himself to ask about Kṛṣṇa Himself — the heart approaches the most painful subject by circling it.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 46