FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.35.2-3

श्रीगोप्य ऊचु: वामबाहुकृतवामकपोलो वल्गितभ्रुरधरार्पितवेणुम् । कोमलाङ्गुलिभिराश्रितमार्गं गोप्य ईरयति यत्र मुकुन्द: ॥ २ ॥ व्योमयानवनिता: सह सिद्धै- र्विस्मितास्तदुपधार्य सलज्जा: । काममार्गणसमर्पितचित्ता: कश्मलं ययुरपस्मृतनीव्य: ॥ ३ ॥
śrī-gopya ūcuḥ
[shree-gopya oochuh]
vāma-bāhu-kṛta-vāma-kapolo
[vaama-baahu-krita-vaama-kapolo]
valgita-bhrur adharārpita-veṇum
[valgita-bhrur adharaarpita-venum]
komalāṅgulibhir āśrita-mārgaṁ
[komalaangulibhir aashrita-maargam]
gopya īrayati yatra mukundaḥ
[gopya eerayati yatra mukundah]
vyoma-yāna-vanitāḥ saha siddhair
[vyoma-yaana-vanitaah saha siddhair]
vismitās tad upadhārya sa-lajjāḥ
[vismitaas tad upadhaarya sa-lajjaah]
kāma-mārgaṇa-samarpita-cittāḥ
[kaama-maargana-samarpita-chittaah]
kaśmalaṁ yayur apasmṛta-nīvyaḥ
[kashmalam yayur apasmrita-neevyah]
śrī - gopyaḥ ūcuḥ — the gopīs said vāma — left bāhu — on His arm kṛta — putting vāma — left kapolaḥ — His cheek valgita — moving bhruḥ — His eyebrows adhara — upon His lips arpita — placed veṇum — His flute komala — tender aṅgulibhiḥ — with His fingers āśrita - mārgam — its holes stopped gopyaḥ — O gopīs īrayati — vibrates yatra — where mukundaḥ — Lord Kṛṣṇa vyoma — in the sky yāna — traveling vanitāḥ — the ladies saha — together with siddhaiḥ — the Siddha demigods vismitāḥ — amazed tat — to that upadhārya — listening sa — with lajjāḥ — embarrassment kāma — of lust mārgaṇa — to the pursuit samarpita — offered cittāḥ — their minds kaśmalam — distress yayuḥ — they experienced apasmṛta — forgetting nīvyaḥ — the belts of their dresses .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śrī-gopya ūcuḥ
śrī - gopyaḥ ūcuḥ
the gopīs said
vāma-bāhu-kṛta-vāma-kapolo
vāma
left
bāhu
on His arm
kṛta
putting
vāma
left
kapolaḥ
His cheek
valgita-bhrur adharārpita-veṇum
valgita
moving
bhruḥ
His eyebrows
adhara
upon His lips
arpita
placed
veṇum
His flute
komalāṅgulibhir āśrita-mārgaṁ
komala
tender
aṅgulibhiḥ
with His fingers
āśrita - mārgam
its holes stopped
gopya īrayati yatra mukundaḥ
gopyaḥ
O gopīs
īrayati
vibrates
yatra
where
mukundaḥ
Lord Kṛṣṇa
vyoma-yāna-vanitāḥ saha siddhair
vyoma
in the sky
yāna
traveling
vanitāḥ
the ladies
saha
together with
siddhaiḥ
the Siddha demigods
vismitās tad upadhārya sa-lajjāḥ
vismitāḥ
amazed
tat
to that
upadhārya
listening
sa
with
lajjāḥ
embarrassment
kāma-mārgaṇa-samarpita-cittāḥ
kāma
of lust
mārgaṇa
to the pursuit
samarpita
offered
cittāḥ
their minds
kaśmalaṁ yayur apasmṛta-nīvyaḥ
kaśmalam
distress
yayuḥ
they experienced
apasmṛta
forgetting
nīvyaḥ
the belts of their dresses .
  • mukundaḥ — Lord Kṛṣṇa
    From mukti (liberation) + da (giver). The name surfaces here precisely as Kṛṣṇa is doing the opposite of granting impersonal mukti — He is binding the Siddha-wives into kāma. Gauḍīyas relish the irony: the giver of liberation steals freedom through the flute, replacing mukti with prema-bondage.
  • veṇum — His flute
    The hollow bamboo, emptied of itself, through which Bhagavān's breath becomes sound. Rūpa Gosvāmī treats veṇu-nāda as the central instrument of madhura-līlā: it does not preach, it does not argue — it simply rearranges every hearer's interior.
  • komala-aṅgulibhiḥ — with His tender fingers
    Compound: komala (tender, soft) + aṅgulibhiḥ (with fingers). The fingers that lift Govardhana are the same fingers that stop the flute-holes. Mādhurya does not display power; it displays softness. The gopīs notice the tenderness and the cosmos forgets itself.
  • valgita-bhruḥ — moving His eyebrows
    Compound: valgita (dancing, moving playfully) + bhruḥ (eyebrows). A specific facial gesture — Kṛṣṇa's eyebrows dance while He plays. The gopīs' close observation of this detail is itself the proof of their bhāva: only love sees this much.
  • kāma-mārgaṇa — to the pursuit of lust
    Compound: kāma (desire) + mārgaṇa (seeking, pursuit). Even the Siddha-wives, supposed to be beyond mortal lust, find their cittas pursuing it under the flute. Gauḍīyas read this not as a fall but as evidence that Kṛṣṇa's attraction overrides every spiritual achievement short of prema.
  • apasmṛta-nīvyaḥ — forgetting the belts of their dresses
    Compound: apa (away) + smṛta (remembered) + nīvyaḥ (waist-knots). The classical Sanskrit detail for a woman undone — her undergarment-knot slips and she does not notice. The flute dissolves social memory. Compare to gopīs' rāsa-līlā ornaments falling at SB 10.29.
The gopīs said: When Mukunda vibrates the flute He has placed to His lips, stopping its holes with His tender fingers, He rests His left cheek on His left arm and makes His eyebrows dance. At that time the demigoddesses traveling in the sky with their husbands, the Siddhas, become amazed. As those ladies listen, they are embarrassed to find their minds yielding to the pursuit of lusty desires, and in their distress they are unaware that the belts of their garments are loosening.

Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī states that this chapter consists of a collection of statements the gopīs made at various times as they stood in small groups here and there in Vṛndāvana.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
The gopīs said: When Mukunda vibrates the flute He has placed to His lips, stopping its holes with His tender fingers, He rests His left cheek on His left arm and makes His eyebrows dance. At that time the demigoddesses traveling in the sky with their husbands, the Siddhas, become amazed. As those ladies listen, they are embarrassed to find their minds yielding to the pursuit of lusty desires, and in their distress they are unaware that the belts of their garments are loosening.
Commentary

When Krsna, herding his cows in Vrndavana, played his flute to announce his coming to the trees, creepers, birds and beasts suffering in separation, the gopis, whose love increased on hearing that sound, spoke to their friends in twelve pairs of verses. Krsna rested his left cheek on the base of his left arm, in order to play gamakas (vibrato) in ascending and descending modes of the ragas. At that time he placed his left shank over his right shank and assumed a three fold bending form, which enchanted the three worlds, while tilting his neck. His eyebrows danced to attract the attention of Subala and others to the skillfulness of his songs. The flute was placed on the lower lip. What type of flute was it? It was equipped with seven holes which were covered by his fingers which were softer than those of others (because of not doing heavy labor) but somewhat harder than his other limbs. The wives of the siddhas flying in the sky, though accompanied by their husbands, on hearing the sound of the flute, became astonished. "We have never heard such enchanting flute playing before!" It was astonishing because it enchants us who are chaste women, and moreover, it enchants our husbands, who have given up their identity as males and become female." That was their first cause of astonishment. The women, being with their husbands, became embarrassed, thinking, "Our husbands, seeing our agitation, will have doubts about us." The husbands on the other hand became embarrassed, thinking, "Having given up our male identity and adopted female identities, our wives will have doubts about us." Then together with their husbands, they offered themselves to the arrows of lust. Seeing the arrows of love for Krsna approaching quickly, the wives said, "O arrows of love for Krsna! Pierce these hearts quickly which have been offered to you. Let us give up our faithfulness to our husbands and let Krsna enjoy with us!" The husbands said, "As we have given up our male and devata identities, immediately make us into gopis and enjoy with us." Then the women along with their husbands, so afflicted by the arrows of lust, became stunned (kasmalam). The same feelings appeared in both parties at once. Therefore, the women’s belts became loosened without their knowing, and the men’s clothes and hair became loose without their knowing. "If the devatas reach such a state, what can be said of humans? And what can be said of gopis? and what can be said of those who live with Krsna in the same village? And what can be said of those who attained his direct association? How can live without him? Even while our husbands and children watch and scold us, let us enter the forest of Vrndavana and enjoy with our beloved." This is the implication at the end of each pair of verses.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

It would be difficult for all the gopīs to speak simultaneously in one gathering, since there were thousands of groups with individual realizations. Thus this chapter is a collection of statements of the devoted gopīs describing daily general pastimes addressing various devotees such as Yaśodā (for instance tava sutaḥ sate in verse 14). Though the verses do not depend on relationship to other verses, Śukadeva has gathered the verses in order of the time of day. Sometimes two or three pairs are spoken in the same assembly. The descriptions are grouped in pairs of verses, and each pair consists of a description of the pastime (Kṛṣṇa playing his flute) and then the persons who are nourished by the pastime. Kṛṣṇa’s pastimes alone are the highest goal and the persons experiencing the pastimes respond to them. Thus without taking the verses in pairs there is no satisfaction. “It is so unfortunate that we cannot enter into his pastimes.” From the time he leaves in the morning until he returns, the gopīs sing about his pastimes in the forest each according their individual realizations. In the first verse, after going out in the morning he played his flute on the road. The women from heaven, desiring to see him after he has entered his house, remained in the sky at night. First saw him clearly because they were in their vehicles in the sky, he enacted beautiful pastimes while playing his flute with expression on his face. He has his left cheek resting on his left arm and looks upwards crookedly. They were strongly agitated with prema on thinking that he was looking at them. This is described in two verses. The left arm is mentioned rather than the right arm because vāma also means attractive. Because he rests his left check on his left arm, his neck slightly turns. Because his head is turned, his glance is crooked as he looks upward. He is absorbed in playing the flute. Since he is standing in the famous pose with three bends, his right foot is placed over his left foot. His brow flutters. Bhru instead of bhrū is poetic license. Some versions have bhrū. He plays his flute offered to his lips. Or he plays a flute which is always placed on or given to his lips, as a constant configuration. It is similar to the construction āhitāgni: a person who maintains a sacrificial fire perpetually, though the order of words is reversed (adharārpita instead of arpitādhara). The lips are not compared to red bimba fruits since even without the sweetness of the pink color, just by the touch of the lips to the flute, the flute playing becomes attractive. Or, because of Kṛṣṇa’s contact with the flute at all times, the lips became angry and thus changed to a pale color. A great person is said to have hands hardened without work and feet which remain soft, though he walks on the road. But Kṛṣṇa’s fingers are described as soft in this verse. Giving up their hard aspect in comparison to other limbs, the fingers out of affection displayed their soft aspect to compare to other limbs. Out of envy the gopīs say “Those soft fingers should not touch the hard flute but rather touch our soft limbs.” Though he has a natural sweetness in his beauty, in playing the flute he shows particular sweetness by his special gestures. The great attractiveness of his flute playing is shown in this verse. O gopīs! Being very intelligent, you can understand this truth. But others cannot. Yatra means “when.” The usage indicates that the flute playing was the sole and inevitable cause of the heavenly women bewilderment. This applies to later verses also. The heavenly women were riding in the airplanes with devatās controlling the planes (siddhaiḥ). Because of the astonishing scene the women along with their husbands became astonished. Thought they were with their great husbands, their hearts became desirous of Kṛṣṇa. They were embarrassed but in spite of that, they fainted because of their desire and their garments became loose (apaṣmṛta). Or, after astonishment, when they became full of desire, they became ashamed because of their womanly nature. Then they offered their minds to Kṛṣṇa, by the force of strong desire. In that state they fainted. They were ashamed not only because their desires were aroused, but because their clothing slackened in front of their husbands. If the wives of devatās become bewildered, what about us?

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Since there were many independent speakers, the verses represent different gopīs speaking. Among the groups some are present in front of Yaśodā (for instance tava sutaḥ sate in verse 14). In the first verse, after going out in the morning he played his flute on the road. The women from heaven, desiring to see him after he has entered his house, remained in the sky at night. First they saw him clearly because they were in their vehicles in the sky. He enacts beautiful pastimes while playing his flute with expression on his face. He has his left cheek resting on his left arm and looks upwards crookedly. They were strongly agitated with prema on thinking that he was looking at them. This is described in two verses. The left arm is mentioned rather than the right arm because vāma also means attractive. Because he rests his left check on his left arm, his neck slightly turns. Because his head is turned, his glance is crooked as he looks upward. He is absorbed in playing the flute. Since he is standing in the famous pose with three bends, his right foot is placed over his left foot. His brow flutters. Bhru instead of bhrū is poetic license. Some versions have bhrū. He plays his flute which is offered to his lips. Or he plays a flute which is always placed on or given to his lips, as a constant configuration. It is similar to the construction āhitāgni: a person who maintains a sacrificial fire perpetually, though the order of words is reversed (adharārpita instead of arpitādhara). The lips are not compared to red bimba fruits since even without the sweetness of the pink color, just by the touch of the lips to the flute, the flute playing becomes attractive. Or, because of Kṛṣṇa’s contact with the flute at all times, the lips became angry and thus changed to a pale color. A great person is said to have hands hardened without work and feet which remain soft, though he walks on the road. But Kṛṣṇa’s fingers are described as soft in this verse. Giving up their hard aspect in comparison to other limbs, the fingers out of affection display their soft aspect. Out of envy the gopīs say “Those soft fingers should not touch the hard flute but rather touch our soft limbs.” Though he has a natural sweetness in his beauty, in playing the flute he shows particular sweetness by his special gestures. The great attractiveness of his flute playing is shown in this verse. O gopīs! Being very intelligent, you can understand this truth. But others cannot. Yatra means “when.” The usage indicates that the flute playing was the sole and inevitable cause of the heavenly women’s bewilderment. This applies to later verses also. The heavenly women were riding in the airplanes with devatās controlling the planes (siddhaiḥ). Or they were going (yāna) in the sky. Or they were the wives of siddhas who had planes in the sky. This means that they were not close to the Lord and did not live in Vṛndāvana. They were above, at a distance. Siddha refers to a type of devatā or to jīvanmuktas, persons who would be liberated. They were devoid of bhakti-rasa. Even they were astonished since they had never experienced this. The wives of these men became embarrassed by the arousal of love and then lost control. Or the siddhas also lost control. The wives were the chief experiencers of this rasa, and the men were secondary. Thus it is said “the women with the siddhas.” The sound entered through the ears to the heart (upadhārya). First they were astonished and then by the arousal of desire, the clothing became loose. Then they became embarrassed. Their hearts, their treasures, had been offered to the five arrows of Cupid (starting with bewilderment), because of fear of death. This means their hearts were controlled by Cupid. This should be kept somewhere privately. These two verses show the great attraction of the sound of the flute and Kṛṣṇa’s form and pastimes. Though everyone should be bewildered by the flute and his beauty, particularly the wives of the siddhas are mentioned. He has his left cheek resting on his left arm and looks upwards crookedly. They were strongly agitated with prema on thinking that he was looking at them. This should be understood in later verses also. The main persons described in the verses feel the effects of Kṛṣṇa’s presence. The details are explained with each pair of verse. The two verses are connected in meaning. They feel their desires will be fulfilled when they meet with Kṛṣṇa. The first of the two verses generally describes Kṛṣṇa’s beauty and pastimes. The second verse indicates that there will be great sweetness when they can meet with him, though he is independent. All verses are filled with colorful descriptions.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Apaishunam (Non-slander)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
When Kṛṣṇa plays His flute, even celestial ladies traveling with their husbands are embarrassed to find lust rising in them — their belts loosening unnoticed. The Lord's beauty exposes hidden desires we thought we had safely managed.
Reflection Questions
  • What hidden desire has Kṛṣṇa's beauty stirred up that you thought was under control?
  • Are you willing to let that exposure be the start of honesty rather than shame?

Place a flute against Kṛṣṇa's lips and the entire cosmic order tilts — Siddha-wives flying overhead with their husbands forget what marriage means, their belts loosen mid-flight, and they cannot tell whether the shame is for what they feel or for not feeling enough. The flute is not music; it is the leak through which mādhurya floods every level of being.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 35