FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.24.3

कथ्यतां मे पित: कोऽयं सम्भ्रमो व उपागत: । किं फलं कस्य वोद्देश: केन वा साध्यते मख: ॥ ३ ॥
kathyatāṁ me pitaḥ ko ’yaṁ
[kathyataam me pitah ko ’yam]
sambhramo va upāgataḥ
[sambhramo va upaagatah]
kiṁ phalaṁ kasya voddeśaḥ
[kim phalam kasya voddeshah]
kena vā sādhyate makhaḥ
[kena vaa saadhyate makhah]
kathyatām — let it be explained me — to Me pitaḥ — My dear father kaḥ — what ayam — this sambhramaḥ — flurry of activity vaḥ — upon you upāgataḥ — come kim — what phalam — the consequence kasya — for whose vā — and uddeśaḥ — sake kena — by what means vā — and sādhyate — is to be accomplished makhaḥ — this sacrifice .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kathyatāṁ me pitaḥ ko ’yaṁ
kathyatām
let it be explained
me
to Me
pitaḥ
My dear father
sambhramo va upāgataḥ
kiṁ phalaṁ kasya voddeśaḥ
kaḥ
what
ayam
this
sambhramaḥ
flurry of activity
kena vā sādhyate makhaḥ
vaḥ
upon you
upāgataḥ
come
kim
what
phalam
the consequence
kasya
for whose
vā
and
uddeśaḥ
sake
kena
by what means
vā
and
sādhyate
is to be accomplished
makhaḥ
this sacrifice .
  • kathyatām — please tell
    Passive imperative from √kath. Kṛṣṇa speaks in the polite passive — 'let it be told' — not the curt active. The form itself shows praśraya: the Lord is asking, not commanding.
  • pitaḥ — O father
    Vocative of pitṛ. The address is filial, not philosophical. Whatever doctrine is about to follow will be spoken son-to-father, inside vātsalya — Gauḍīyas note this carefully: even the dismantling of karma-kāṇḍa happens in rasa.
  • phalam — the result
    From √phal — fruit, result. The first of Kṛṣṇa's four probing questions. By asking what 'fruit' is sought, He frames the ritual as karma-kāṇḍa from word one; this will become the wedge for His whole argument.
  • uddeśaḥ — intended object
    From ud + √diś — that toward which the offering is aimed. Coupled with phalam, the pair surface the karma-kāṇḍa formula: a fruit for me, a target for the offering. Kṛṣṇa is going to show both ends are misaligned.
  • makhaḥ — the sacrifice
    A Vedic word for yajña. By using the technical term, Kṛṣṇa concedes the form of what is being done — He is not opposing yajña as such; He will only redirect its object. This same word returns in verse 25 when He proposes a new makha for Govardhana.
[Lord Kṛṣṇa said:] My dear father, kindly explain to Me what this great endeavor of yours is all about. What is it meant to accomplish? If this is a ritual sacrifice, then for whose satisfaction is it intended and by what means is it going to be executed?
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[Lord Kṛṣṇa said:] My dear father, kindly explain to Me what this great endeavor of yours is all about. What is it meant to accomplish? If this is a ritual sacrifice, then for whose satisfaction is it intended and by what means is it going to be executed?
Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Please tell me. Everyone else knows but I do not know. Tell only me. He shows inexperience in order to please his father. His father would thus listen to him. Why have all of you (vaḥ), not just some, become so busy or agitated? The other meaning of sambhramaḥ is “completely bewildered.” Though it is proper that this flurry of activity should take place far away, it is very close, almost on top of us (upa). Please tell me (verb in next verse) by whom and how the sacrifice will be accomplished?

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Please tell me. Everyone else knows but I do not know. Tell only me. He showed inexperience in order to please his father. His father would thus listen to him. Or if Nanda told others, he would remain ignorant of the truth and this would serve no purpose. Thus you should tell me. It is also a show of pride, to defeat the sacrifice to Indra. Or he addresses his father with affection so that Nanda will speak truthfully. Why have all of you (vaḥ), not just some, become so busy or agitated? The other meaning of sambhramaḥ is “completely bewildered.” Though it is proper that this flurry of activity should take place far away, it is very close, almost on top of us (upa). Please tell me (verb in next verse) by whom and how the sacrifice will be accomplished?

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Apaishunam (Non-slander)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Udyama (Industriousness / Effort)Asteya (Non-stealing / Honesty)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)Bhakti (Devotion)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Vinaya (Humility / Modesty)Prema (Divine Love)
Related verses
'My dear father, please explain — for whose satisfaction is this sacrifice, by what means executed?' The Lord names the standard questions a serious inquirer asks. Clarity about audience and method comes before performance.
Reflection Questions
  • For whom and by what means am I performing my current practice — clearly named?
  • Where could I pause and ask these two questions before continuing?

A son apprenticed in his father's workshop pauses, gestures at the half-built wheel, and asks, 'Whom is this for, and how will it be finished?' The question gathers the workshop's whole purpose into one breath. Kṛṣṇa, the apprentice-son in Nanda's household, does the same to the indra-yāga — four questions in one verse, designed to make the elders state, out loud, what they are actually doing.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 24