FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.12.29

तदा घनच्छदा देवा भयाद्धाहेति चुक्रुशु: । जहृषुर्ये च कंसाद्या: कौणपास्त्वघबान्धवा: ॥ २९ ॥
tadā ghana-cchadā devā
[tadaa ghana-chchadaa devaa]
bhayād dhā-heti cukruśuḥ
[bhayaad dhaa-heti chukrushuh]
jahṛṣur ye ca kaṁsādyāḥ
[jahrishur ye cha kamsaadyaah]
kauṇapās tv agha-bāndhavāḥ
[kaunapaas tv agha-baandhavaah]
tadā — at that time ghana - chadāḥ — behind the clouds devāḥ — all the demigods bhayāt — on account of feeling danger because Kṛṣṇa had entered the mouth of the demon hā - hā — alas, alas iti — in this way cukruśuḥ — they exclaimed jahṛṣuḥ — became jubilant ye — those ca — also kaṁsa - ādyāḥ — Kaṁsa and others kauṇapāḥ — the demons tu — indeed agha - bāndhavāḥ — the friends of Aghāsura .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tadā ghana-cchadā devā
tadā
at that time
ghana - chadāḥ
behind the clouds
devāḥ
all the demigods
bhayād dhā-heti cukruśuḥ
bhayāt
on account of feeling danger because Kṛṣṇa had entered the mouth of the demon
hā - hā
alas, alas
iti
in this way
cukruśuḥ
they exclaimed
jahṛṣur ye ca kaṁsādyāḥ
jahṛṣuḥ
became jubilant
ye
those
ca
also
kaṁsa - ādyāḥ
Kaṁsa and others
kauṇapās tv agha-bāndhavāḥ
kauṇapāḥ
the demons
tu
indeed
agha - bāndhavāḥ
the friends of Aghāsura .
  • ghana-chadāḥ — hidden behind clouds
    Compound: ghana (cloud) + chada (cover). The devas hide — they cannot bear to watch openly. Gauḍīyas: even demigods, with their long lives and powers, have only the courage to peek. The cowherd boys, by contrast, walked in laughing.
  • hā-hā — alas, alas
    Onomatopoeic vocative of grief. The same syllables that mark śoka in classical drama. Bhāgavatam uses everyday emotional sounds; the gods grieve in plain language.
  • kaṁsa-ādyāḥ — Kaṁsa and others
    Compound: Kaṁsa + ādi (etcetera). The demoniac faction. Gauḍīyas note: Kaṁsa's enmity is in fact constant smaraṇa — he thinks of Kṛṣṇa more than most devotees do. Vairānubandha is a form of bhakti in inversion, which is why Kaṁsa too is liberated by Kṛṣṇa's hand.
  • agha-bāndhavāḥ — friends of Agha
    Compound: agha (the demon, also 'sin') + bāndhava (kin, friend). 'Friends of sin' — a phrase that double-reads. Demoniac alliance is always alliance with sin itself. Gauḍīya satsaṅga logic: one is shaped by company.
When Kṛṣṇa entered the mouth of Aghāsura, the demigods hidden behind the clouds exclaimed, “Alas! Alas!” But the friends of Aghāsura, like Kaṁsa and other demons, were jubilant.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
When Kṛṣṇa entered the mouth of Aghāsura, the demigods hidden behind the clouds exclaimed, "Alas! Alas!" But the friends of Aghāsura, like Kaṁsa and other demons, were jubilant.
Commentary

The devatas, who were hiding in the clouds out of fear of Kamsa, began shouting, fearing Krsna’s safety. Though the devatas are aware of the Lord’s powers, because they are also devotees, they shouted in anxiety. The very nature of bhakti is to have affection, and the very nature of affection is to lose ones logical discriminatory powers. Kamsa and the raksasas (kauna pa—eaters of corpses), the sons and brothers of Aghasura, rejoiced on hearing the news from messengers.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The devatās hid behind the cloud because of fear of Kaṁsa and Agha. The word ca indicates other sinful people as well. Though Kaṁsa was a daitya demon he was also a Rākṣasa. There are considered the same here to indicate their extremely evil nature. Or the sentence can indicate demons like Kaṁsa and Rākṣasa. They were all overjoyed since by nature they hated the Lord. Glee arose within their evil minds. They became joyful because Kaṁsa heard about Agha swallowing the boys and Kṛṣṇa through spies who had arrived from Vraja.

Related values
Maitri (Friendship / Goodwill)Guru Bhakti (Reverence for Teacher)Kartavya (Duty / Responsibility)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)
Related verses
When Kṛṣṇa enters the demon's mouth the demigods cry 'Alas!' while demons cheer — the same act looks like loss to one side and victory to the other. Spiritual progress will be misread by opposing audiences.
Reflection Questions
  • When I have taken a step toward Kṛṣṇa, whose 'Alas!' did I hear and whose cheering did I hear?
  • Am I more shaped by the disappointment of one camp or the cheering of the other than by Kṛṣṇa Himself?

Picture two galleries watching the same act through opposite emotions: the demigods, who love Kṛṣṇa, cry 'alas, alas' from behind their clouds; Kaṁsa's people, who hate Him, cheer. The same event is heard in opposite registers depending on whether the heart belongs to Bhagavān. Bhakti is in part a question of which audience one is in.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 12