FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 4.20.30

मन्ये गिरं ते जगतां विमोहिनीं वरं वृणीष्वेति भजन्तमात्थ यत् । वाचा नु तन्त्या यदि ते जनोऽसित: कथं पुन: कर्म करोति मोहित: ॥ ३० ॥
manye giraṁ te jagatāṁ vimohinīṁ
[manye giram te jagataam vimohineem]
varaṁ vṛṇīṣveti bhajantam āttha yat
[varam vrineeshveti bhajantam aattha yat]
vācā nu tantyā yadi te jano ’sitaḥ
[vaachaa nu tantyaa yadi te jano ’sitah]
kathaṁ punaḥ karma karoti mohitaḥ
[katham punah karma karoti mohitah]
manye — I consider giram — words te — Your jagatām — to the material world vimohinīm — bewildering varam — benediction vṛṇīṣva — just accept iti — in this way bhajantam — unto Your devotee āttha — You spoke yat — because vācā — by the statements of the Vedas nu — certainly tantyā — by the ropes yadi — if te — Your janaḥ — the people in general asitaḥ — not bound katham — how punaḥ — again and again karma — fruitive activities karoti — perform mohitaḥ — being enamored.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
manye giraṁ te jagatāṁ vimohinīṁ
manye
I consider
giram
words
te
Your
jagatām
to the material world
vimohinīm
bewildering
varaṁ vṛṇīṣveti bhajantam āttha yat
varam
benediction
vṛṇīṣva
just accept
vācā nu tantyā yadi te jano ’sitaḥ
iti
in this way
bhajantam
unto Your devotee
kathaṁ punaḥ karma karoti mohitaḥ
āttha
You spoke
yat
because
vācā
by the statements of the Vedas
nu
certainly
tantyā
by the ropes
yadi
if
te
Your
janaḥ
the people in general
asitaḥ
not bound
katham
how
punaḥ
again and again
karma
fruitive activities
karoti
perform
mohitaḥ
being enamored.
My dear Lord, what You have said to Your unalloyed devotee is certainly very much bewildering. The allurements You offer in the Vedas are certainly not suitable for pure devotees. People in general, bound by the sweet words of the Vedas, engage themselves again and again in fruitive activities, enamored by the results of their actions.

Śrīla Narottama dāsa Ṭhākura, a great ācārya of the Gauḍīya sampradāya, has said that persons who are very much attached to the fruitive activities of the Vedas, namely karma-kāṇḍa and jñāna-kāṇḍa, are certainly doomed. In the Vedas there are three categories of activities, known as karma-kāṇḍa (fruitive activities), jñāna-kāṇḍa (philosophical research) and upāsanā-kāṇḍa (worship of different demigods for receiving material benefits). Those who are engaged in karma-kāṇḍa and jñāna-kāṇḍa are doomed in the sense that everyone is doomed who is entrapped by this material body, whether it is a body of a demigod, a king, a lower animal or whatever. The sufferings of the threefold miseries of material nature are the same for all. Cultivation of knowledge to understand one’s spiritual position is also, to a certain extent, a waste of time. Because the living entity is an eternal part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, his immediate business is to engage himself in devotional service. Pṛthu Mahārāja therefore says that the allurement of material benedictions is another trap to entangle one in this material world. He therefore frankly tells the Lord that the Lord’s offerings of benedictions in the form of material facilities are certainly causes for bewilderment. A pure devotee is not at all interested in bhukti or mukti.

The Lord sometimes offers benedictions to the neophyte devotees who have not yet understood that material facilities will not make them happy. In the Caitanya-caritāmṛta the Lord therefore says that a sincere devotee who is not very intelligent may ask some material benefit from the Lord, but the Lord, being omniscient, does not generally give material rewards but, on the contrary, takes away whatever material facilities are being enjoyed by His devotee, so that ultimately the devotee will completely surrender unto Him. In other words, the offering of benedictions in the form of material profit is never auspicious for the devotee. The statements of the Vedas which offer elevation to heavenly planets in exchange for great sacrifices are simply bewildering. Therefore in Bhagavad-gītā (2.42) the Lord says, yām imāṁ puṣpitāṁ vācaṁ pravadanty avipaścitaḥ: the less intelligent class of men ( avipaścitaḥ ), attracted by the flowery language of the Vedas, engage in fruitive activities to become materially benefited. Thus they continue life after life, in different bodily forms, to search very, very hard.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
I think that your words “Please choose a benediction” are bewildering to the world. Only because people follow your instructions, do they continue to perform such actions repeatedly, under illusion. “Then why do I ask my devotee to request benedictions?” If an immature devotee asks for some material benediction out of strong greed, he will be destroyed since he is cheated of bhakti-rasa. Typical words of the Vedas bewilder the world, by promising elevation to Pitṛloka by performing prescribed duties or elevation to Svargaloka by horse sacrifice. Oh (nu)! Unless a person is bound by your words, how can he continue to do such acts, being bewildered by the results again and again?
Your words to me are bewildering; the Vedic allurements bind people to fruitive activity. Pure devotees find even the Lord's standard offers (heaven, success) confusing because they want only Him.
Reflection Questions
  • Which of the standard 'good' benedictions am I still attracted to that a pure devotee would refuse?
  • Where could I refuse what's offered if it isn't Him?
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 20