FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 12.4.28

यत् सामान्यविशेषाभ्यामुपलभ्येत स भ्रम: । अन्योन्यापाश्रयात् सर्वमाद्यन्तवदवस्तु यत् ॥ २८ ॥
yat sāmānya-viśeṣābhyām
[yat saamaanya-visheshaabhyaam]
upalabhyeta sa bhramaḥ
[upalabhyeta sa bhramah]
anyonyāpāśrayāt sarvam
[anyonyaapaashrayaat sarvam]
ādy-antavad avastu yat
[aady-antavad avastu yat]
yat — whatever sāmānya — in terms of general cause viśeṣābhyām — and specific product upalabhyeta — is experienced saḥ — that bhramaḥ — is illusion anyonya — mutual apāśrayāt — because of dependence sarvam — everything ādi-anta-vat — subject to beginning and end avastu — unreal yat — which.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
yat sāmānya-viśeṣābhyām
yat
whatever
sāmānya
in terms of general cause
viśeṣābhyām
and specific product
upalabhyeta sa bhramaḥ
upalabhyeta
is experienced
saḥ
that
bhramaḥ
is illusion
anyonyāpāśrayāt sarvam
anyonya
mutual
apāśrayāt
because of dependence
sarvam
everything
ādy-antavad avastu yat
ādi-anta-vat
subject to beginning and end
avastu
unreal
yat
which.
Anything experienced in terms of general cause and specific effect must be an illusion, because such causes and effects exist only relative to each other. Indeed, whatever has a beginning and an end is unreal.

The nature of a material cause cannot be perceived without perception of the effect. For example, the burning nature of fire cannot be perceived without observing the effect of fire, such as a burning object or ashes. Similarly, the saturating quality of water cannot be understood without observing the effect, a saturated cloth or paper. The organizational power of a man cannot be understood without observing the effect of his dynamic work, namely a solid institution. In this way, not only do effects depend upon their causes, but the perception of the cause also depends upon observation of the effect. Thus both are defined relatively and have a beginning and an end. The conclusion is that all such material causes and effects are essentially temporary and relative, and consequently illusory.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, although the cause of all causes, has no beginning or end. Therefore He is neither material nor illusory. Lord Kṛṣṇa’s opulences and potencies are absolute reality, beyond the interdependence of material cause and effect.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
What is experienced as cause and effect is an illusion since they are mutually dependent. Everything has a beginning and end and therefore is unreal. According to vivarta-vāda (theory of illusion), just as the effect of Brahman, the universe, is unreal, so Brahman as the cause is also unreal. What is perceived as cause and effect is perceived through error since they are mutually dependent, and thus impossible to determine. The meaning is this. Just as one mistakes a rope for a snake out of ignorance, (the rope is the cause and the effect snake, is false), so Brahman is mistaken to be the universe out of ignorance. How can Brahman be the cause, when it is dependent on the effect, the universe, which does not exist?
Cause and effect, as ordinarily known, depend on each other and both have a beginning and an end — so both are, in essence, illusory. Only what is beyond this mutual dependence — Krsna Himself — is fully real and lasting.
Reflection Questions
  • Which of my certainties depend on conditions that themselves are passing?
  • Where can I rest that doesn't rely on conditions?
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 4