FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 11.3.45

नाचरेद् यस्तु वेदोक्तं स्वयमज्ञोऽजितेन्द्रिय: । विकर्मणा ह्यधर्मेण मृत्योर्मृत्युमुपैति स: ॥ ४५ ॥
nācared yas tu vedoktaṁ
[naachared yas tu vedoktam]
svayam ajño ’jitendriyaḥ
[svayam ajno ’jitendriyah]
vikarmaṇā hy adharmeṇa
[vikarmanaa hy adharmena]
mṛtyor mṛtyum upaiti saḥ
[mrityor mrityum upaiti sah]
na ācaret — does not perform yaḥ — who tu — but veda-uktam — what is prescribed in the Vedas svayam — himself ajñaḥ — ignorant ajita-indriyaḥ — not having learned to control his senses vikarmaṇā — by not executing scriptural duty hi — indeed adharmeṇa — by his irreligion mṛtyoḥ mṛtyum — death after death upaiti — achieves saḥ — he.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
nācared yas tu vedoktaṁ
na ācaret
does not perform
yaḥ
who
tu
but
veda-uktam
what is prescribed in the Vedas
svayam ajño ’jitendriyaḥ
svayam
himself
ajñaḥ
ignorant
ajita-indriyaḥ
not having learned to control his senses
vikarmaṇā hy adharmeṇa
vikarmaṇā
by not executing scriptural duty
hi
indeed
adharmeṇa
by his irreligion
mṛtyor mṛtyum upaiti saḥ
mṛtyoḥ mṛtyum
death after death
upaiti
achieves
saḥ
he.
If an ignorant person who has not conquered the material senses does not adhere to the Vedic injunctions, certainly he will engage in sinful and irreligious activities. Thus his reward will be repeated birth and death.

In the previous verse it was stated that although fruitive activities are prescribed in the Vedas, the actual goal of human life is to free oneself from all materialistic activities. Therefore, one may conclude that there is no need to perform the Vedic rituals, which offer regulated sense gratification. But an ignorant person, or, in other words, one who has not understood that he is not the material body but an eternal spiritual soul, part and parcel of Kṛṣṇa, will invariably be unable to control the urges of the material senses. Therefore, if such a materially inclined person neglects the Vedic injunctions that administer regulated sense gratification, he will surely fall down into unregulated sense gratification in pāpa, or sinful life. For example, those who are affected by sexual desire are ordered to accept the vivāha-yajña, or religious marriage ceremony. We often see that because of false pride a so-called brahmacārī, or celibate student of Vedic knowledge, rejects the marriage ceremony as māyā, or material illusion. But if such a celibate student is unable to control his senses he will undoubtedly degrade himself by eventually engaging in illicit sex, which has no connection to Vedic culture. Similarly, a neophyte in Kṛṣṇa consciousness is encouraged to eat kṛṣṇa-prasādam to his full satisfaction. Sometimes an immature practitioner of bhakti-yoga tries to make a show of severe eating habits and eventually falls down into eating unregulated and abominable foodstuffs.

According to Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura, the words mṛtyor mṛtyum upaiti mean that a sinful person is awarded a free ticket to hell by the lord of death himself, Yamarāja. This is also described in the Vedas as follows: mṛtvā punar mṛtyum āpadyate ardyamānaḥ sva-karmabhiḥ. “Persons who cause themselves severe pain by their materialistic activities gain no relief at the moment of death, for they are placed again in a situation in which death will occur.” Therefore, Vedic ritualistic activities such as the wedding ceremony or the relishing of sumptuous yajña-śiṣṭa, or food remnants of sacrifice, should not be given up by those whose senses are not yet controlled.

The previous verse gave the example of a father’s administering candy to his son to induce the child to take medicine. If the child rejects the father’s offer, thinking that the candy is unnecessary, the child also misses the opportunity to take the medicine that will cure him. Similarly, if a materialistic person rejects the Vedic injunctions that administer prescribed sense gratification, he will not be purified but instead will be further degraded. Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī has described a materialistic person as one whose mind and intelligence are not faithfully fixed in the message of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In Bhagavad-gītā Śrī Bhagavān, Lord Kṛṣṇa, gives wonderful explanations to the conditioned souls, represented by Arjuna, concerning the actual goal of life. One who cannot fix his mind on these instructions is to be considered a materialistic person who is inclined toward sinful activities and who must therefore submit himself to the standard Vedic injunctions. Such Vedic injunctions, even though fruitive, are considered puṇya, or pious, according to Śrīla Jīva Gosvāmī, and thus one who strictly performs them will not go to hell. Lord Kṛṣṇa Himself states in the Bhāgavatam (11.20.9) :

tāvat karmāṇi kurvīta na nirvidyeta yāvatā mat-kathā-śravaṇādau vā śraddhā yāvan na jāyate

“One should continue to perform the Vedic ritualistic activities until one actually becomes detached from material sense gratification and develops faith for hearing and chanting about Me.”

Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura explains that the Vedas prescribe that one rise early in the morning, bathe, and chant the Gāyatrī mantra. If one artificially gives up such a disciplined, regulated life, one will gradually become a victim of activities for gross sense gratification, such as eating in restaurants and indulging in illicit connections with women. Thus losing control of his senses, he becomes just like an animal, engaging from the early morning until the night in dangerous activities. Śrīla Madhvācārya has commented in this regard, ajñaḥ sann ācarann api. Although in ignorance, one continues to act, not considering the future result of one’s activities. Such indifference to the future result of one’s activities is described in Bhagavad-gītā to be a symptom of the mode of ignorance. Just as an intelligent man will not drive his car on a highway if he knows the highway will lead him to danger, an intelligent man will not perform non-Vedic activities if he knows that the ultimate result will be the disaster described here by the words mṛtyor mṛtyum upaiti. Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura has stated that ignorant persons sometimes think that after death one automatically attains everlasting peace. But by the powerful reactions of one’s sinful activities one comes to a most unpeaceful condition, for one must suffer hellish miseries in exchange for the meager temporary fruits of material work. Such hellish reactions occur not once but perpetually, as long as one is indifferent to the Vedic injunctions.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
If an ignorant person who has not conquered the material senses does not adhere to the Vedic injunctions, certainly he will engage in sinful and irreligious activities and attain repeated birth and death. “If the goal is freedom from karma, in the beginning, the Vedas should tell people to give up karma.” If a person does not perform karma-yoga such as early morning bath or sandhyā rites, he will engage in sinful acts such as irregular eating and association with women from the early morning, like an animal, because of being unable to remain without performing actions every day. The Lord has said na hi kaścit kṣaṇam api jātu tiṣṭhaty akarma-kṛt: the jīva cannot remain without performing action for a moment. (BG 3.6) Because he loses discrimination by performing sinful acts known as adharma, forbidden in the scriptures, he will obtain death from Yama (mṛtyoḥ)—hell. The śruti says mṛtvā punar mṛtyum āpadyate ardyamānāḥ sva-karmabhiḥ: a person obtains repeated death with suffering by his actions.
If you have not conquered the senses, do not abandon the Vedic guard-rails — without them, an ignorant person falls into sin and repeated death.
Practical Applications
  • Name one regulation you have quietly dropped — morning bath, japa before food, prescribed timing — and reinstate it today as a fence against drift.
  • Refuse the false-renunciate move of skipping a duty (regular meals of prasādam, marriage, daily sādhana) just to look advanced before others.
  • Before any indulgence today, ask whether it is the regulated form sanctioned by guru and śāstra, or the unregulated form that leads to mṛtyor mṛtyum.
Reflection Questions
  • Which Vedic injunction have I rejected as 'unnecessary,' and is my rejection coming from real detachment or from ajṣa pride masquerading as detachment?
  • Where in my life am I treating the candy of regulated sense gratification as beneath me, while still secretly needing the medicine it was meant to deliver?
For Each Age Group
youth
  • Do not drop your daily structure — sleep schedule, study hours, fixed mealtimes, japa — under the romantic idea that 'rules are for ordinary people'; this verse says the unconquered senses will collect the bill.
  • Refuse the campus pose of rejecting marriage, family, or 'tradition' as māyā when you have not yet handled even your phone, food, or scrolling habits.
  • When peers mock the regulated path — temple visits, prasādam, modest conduct — remember Prabhupāda's image of the candy and the medicine, and stay on the prescribed track.
householder
  • Treat your gṛhastha duties — marriage, providing for family, regulated income, raising children in Kṛṣṇa consciousness — not as 'lower' than renunciation but as the very Vedic injunctions this verse says you must not abandon.
  • Refuse the fantasy of walking away from job or family to 'just chant,' if the senses are not actually conquered; this verse warns that such abandonment leads downward, not upward.
  • Build your home around the prescribed disciplines Prabhupāda lists — rising early, bathing, Gāyatrī, regular prasādam — so that the children inherit fences, not just sermons.
senior
  • As age loosens roles, do not loosen the regulated disciplines along with them — keep early rising, bathing, japa, and prasādam timings firm, because the senses do not retire when the body slows.
  • Resist the late-life temptation to call comfort-eating, daytime sleep, or unregulated TV 'harmless at my age'; this verse insists the unconquered senses still pull toward mṛtyor mṛtyum.
  • Mentor younger devotees away from premature renunciation by telling them, from your own life, where dropping the regulations cost you — make your experience a fence for them.
Common Pitfalls
  • Mistaking premature renunciation of prescribed duties (marriage, eating prasādam to satisfaction, household responsibilities) for advancement, when the senses are still unconquered.
  • Reading 'abandon all dharmas' from elsewhere and using it to bypass the regulated stage this verse insists the materially inclined still need.
  • Assuming that simply stopping sinful acts is enough, while neglecting the positive Vedic disciplines — early rising, bathing, Gāyatrī, sādhana — that keep the senses from re-asserting themselves.
Discussion Prompts
  • Share a regulation you once dropped thinking you were 'beyond it,' and what actually happened to your sense life afterward — was the fall gradual or sudden?
  • Where is the honest line for each of us between healthy regulated sense gratification (as Prabhupāda describes here) and the indulgence that degrades — and do we trust ourselves to draw it alone?
  • If a friend in our saṅga announced they were giving up marriage, regular meals, or daily sādhana as 'māyā,' how would we lovingly challenge them using this verse?
Role Play

A college-age devotee tells their mentor they are skipping the upcoming family wedding ceremony and giving up cooked meals — calling both 'material' — because they want to be a pure brahmacārī. One student plays the mentor and must apply this verse: explain why rejecting the regulated form, while the senses are unconquered, is precisely the path to mṛtyor mṛtyum, not above it.

Objections & Responses
  • This sounds like fear-based religion — obey the Vedic rules or go to hell. Why would a loving tradition threaten repeated death?
    It is not a threat but a diagnosis. Prabhupāda uses the father-and-candy image: the candy of regulated sense gratification is given because the child will not otherwise take the medicine. The 'hell' is simply the natural trajectory of unregulated senses in a soul that still has them — Krishna and the ācāryas are warning, not punishing.
  • Vedic injunctions are ancient cultural rules — surely a modern, sincere seeker can skip the rituals and go straight to bhakti and self-realization.
    The verse is precisely about that shortcut. As long as one's mind is not yet fixed on hearing and chanting about Kṛṣṇa — the standard Jīva Gosvāmī gives — one is still 'materialistic' in the technical sense, and the regulations are the support that keeps such a person from falling into unregulated sense life. The shortcut is real only for those who have actually developed śraddhā in hearing Kṛṣṇa's message; for everyone else it is self-deception.
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 3