FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 11.22.1-3

श्रीउद्धव उवाच कति तत्त्वानि विश्वेश सङ्ख्यातान्यृषिभि: प्रभो । नवैकादश पञ्च त्रीण्यात्थ त्वमिह शुश्रुम ॥ १ ॥ केचित् षड्‌विंशतिं प्राहुरपरे पञ्चविंशतिम् । सप्तैके नव षट् केचिच्चत्वार्येकादशापरे । केचित् सप्तदश प्राहु: षोडशैके त्रयोदश ॥ २ ॥ एतावत्त्वं हि सङ्ख्यानामृषयो यद्विवक्षया । गायन्ति पृथगायुष्मन्निदं नो वक्तुमर्हसि ॥ ३ ॥
śrī-uddhava uvāca
[shree-uddhava uvaacha]
kati tattvāni viśveśa
[kati tattvaani vishvesha]
saṅkhyātāny ṛṣibhiḥ prabho
[sankhyaataany rishibhih prabho]
navaikādaśa pañca trīṇy
[navaikaadasha pancha treeny]
āttha tvam iha śuśruma
[aattha tvam iha shushruma]
kecit ṣaḍ-viṁśatiṁ prāhur
[kechit shad-vimshatim praahur]
apare pañca-viṁśatiṁ
[apare pancha-vimshatim]
saptaike nava ṣaṭ kecic
[saptaike nava shat kechich]
catvāry ekādaśāpare
[chatvaary ekaadashaapare]
kecit saptadaśa prāhuḥ
[kechit saptadasha praahuh]
ṣoḍaśaike trayodaśa
[shodashaike trayodasha]
etāvattvaṁ hi saṅkhyānām
[etaavattvam hi sankhyaanaam]
ṛṣayo yad-vivakṣayā
[rishayo yad-vivakshayaa]
gāyanti pṛthag āyuṣmann
[gaayanti prithag aayushmann]
idaṁ no vaktum arhasi
[idam no vaktum arhasi]
śrī-uddhavaḥ uvāca — Śrī Uddhava said kati — how many tattvāni — basic elements of creation viśva-īśa — O Lord of the universe saṅkhyātāni — have been enumerated ṛṣibhiḥ — by great authorities prabho — O my master nava — nine (God, the individual soul, the mahat-tattva, false ego and the five gross elements) ekādaśa — plus eleven (the ten knowledge-acquiring and working senses together with the mind) pañca — plus five (the subtle forms of the sense objects) trīṇi — plus three (the modes of goodness, passion and ignorance, making altogether a total of twenty-eight) āttha — have stated tvam — You iha — during Your appearance in this world śuśruma — so I have heard kecit — some ṣaṭ-viṁśatim — twenty-six prāhuḥ — they say apare — others pañca-viṁśatim — twenty-five sapta — seven eke — some nava — nine ṣaṭ — six kecit — some catvāri — four ekādaśa — eleven apare — still others kecit — some saptadaśa — seventeen prāhuḥ — say ṣoḍaśa — sixteen eke — some trayodaśa — thirteen etāvattvam — such calculations hi — indeed saṅkhyānām — of the different ways of counting the elements ṛṣayaḥ — the sages yat-vivakṣayā — with the intention of expressing what ideas gāyanti — they have declared pṛthak — in various manners āyuḥ-man — O supreme eternal idam — this naḥ — to us vaktum — to explain arhasi — You should please.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
śrī-uddhava uvāca
śrī-uddhavaḥ uvāca
Śrī Uddhava said
kati tattvāni viśveśa
kati
how many
tattvāni
basic elements of creation
viśva-īśa
O Lord of the universe
saṅkhyātāni
have been enumerated
saṅkhyātāny ṛṣibhiḥ prabho
ṛṣibhiḥ
by great authorities
prabho
O my master
navaikādaśa pañca trīṇy
nava
nine (God, the individual soul, the mahat-tattva, false ego and the five gross elements)
āttha tvam iha śuśruma
kecit ṣaḍ-viṁśatiṁ prāhur
apare pañca-viṁśatiṁ
saptaike nava ṣaṭ kecic
catvāry ekādaśāpare
ekādaśa
plus eleven (the ten knowledge-acquiring and working senses together with the mind)
pañca
plus five (the subtle forms of the sense objects)
kecit saptadaśa prāhuḥ
ṣoḍaśaike trayodaśa
trīṇi
plus three (the modes of goodness, passion and ignorance, making altogether a total of twenty-eight)
etāvattvaṁ hi saṅkhyānām
āttha
have stated
tvam
You
iha
during Your appearance in this world
śuśruma
so I have heard
kecit
some
ṣaṭ-viṁśatim
twenty-six
ṛṣayo yad-vivakṣayā
gāyanti pṛthag āyuṣmann
prāhuḥ
they say
apare
others
pañca-viṁśatim
twenty-five
sapta
seven
eke
some
nava
nine
ṣaṭ
six
kecit
some
catvāri
four
ekādaśa
eleven
apare
still others
kecit
some
saptadaśa
seventeen
prāhuḥ
say
ṣoḍaśa
sixteen
eke
some
trayodaśa
thirteen
etāvattvam
such calculations
hi
indeed
saṅkhyānām
of the different ways of counting the elements
ṛṣayaḥ
the sages
yat-vivakṣayā
with the intention of expressing what ideas
gāyanti
they have declared
pṛthak
in various manners
āyuḥ-man
O supreme eternal
idaṁ no vaktum arhasi
idam
this
naḥ
to us
vaktum
to explain
arhasi
You should please.
Uddhava inquired: My dear Lord, O master of the universe, how many different elements of creation have been enumerated by the great sages? I have heard You personally describe a total of twenty-eight — God, the jīva soul, the mahat-tattva, false ego, the five gross elements, the ten senses, the mind, the five subtle objects of perception and the three modes of nature. But some authorities say that there are twenty-six elements, while others cite twenty-five or else seven, nine, six, four or eleven, and even others say that there are seventeen, sixteen or thirteen. What did each of these sages have in mind when he calculated the creative elements in such different ways? O supreme eternal, kindly explain this to me.

Lord Kṛṣṇa thoroughly explained in the previous chapter that Vedic knowledge is not meant for sense gratification but for liberation from material bondage. Now Uddhava presents some intermediate questions that must be answered so the path of liberation will be clear. Different philosophers have historically disagreed over the exact number of material elements, about the existence and nonexistence of particular external objects and about the existence of the soul itself. The jñāna-kāṇḍa section of the Vedas aims at liberation through analytic understanding of the material world and of the spirit soul as a transcendental element beyond matter. Ultimately the Supreme Lord Himself stands above all elements and maintains them by His personal potency. Uddhava mentions in numerical terms different methodologies of various sages, citing first the Lord’s own opinion. The word āyuṣman, or “possessing eternal form,” is significant in this regard. Since Lord Kṛṣṇa is eternal, He possesses all knowledge of past, present and future and is thus the original and supreme philosopher.

According to Śrīla Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura, the different analytic approaches mentioned by Śrī Uddhava are actually not contradictory, since they are different methods of categorizing the same reality. Atheistic speculation on reality does not recognize the existence of God; consequently it is a worthless attempt to explain the truth. The Lord Himself empowers different living entities to speculate and speak on reality in different ways. The actual reality, however, is the Lord Himself, who will now speak to Śrī Uddhava.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Uddhava inquired: O Lord! O master of the universe! How many different elements of creation have been enumerated by the great sages? I have heard you personally describe a total of twenty-eight—God, the jīva, the mahat-tattva, false ego, the five gross elements, the ten senses, the mind, the five subtle objects of perception and the three modes of nature. But some authorities say that there are twenty-six elements, while others cite twenty-five or else seven, nine, six, four or eleven, and even others say that there are seventeen, sixteen or thirteen elements. What did the sages have in mind when they calculated the creative elements in such different ways? O Lord with an eternal form! Kindly explain this to me. In the Twenty-second Chapter, the elements are enumerated, with clarification of any contrary explanations, and questions about prakṛti and the jīva, and about birth and death, are explained. Having clearly understood the meaning of karma-kāṇḍa, Uddhava now begins to ask about the meaning of jñāna-kāṇḍa. He first asks for a conclusion to the various statements made by different sages. Which opinions are correct among those of many sages who each claim “This is what I think.” How many elements do they list? The nine elements are the Lord, the jīva, mahat-tattva, ahaṅkāra and the five gross elements. There are ten senses and the mind. There are five tan-mātras and three guṇas. You have mentioned this total of twenty-eight items. I have heard of them. The three guṇas means prakṛti. He mentions three guṇas because it has been said that only through the three modes of prakṛti arise the two types of mahat-tattva (sattva gives rise to mahat-tattva and rajas gives rise to sūtra) and ahaṅkāra (tamas). These do not arise from prakṛti in equilibrium. I have understood your intention. You should explain with what intention others proclaim a variety of opinions about the number of elements. O Lord, who lives for all time with an eternal form! I should ask you since you alone know the intentions of all the sages who have a beginning, middle and end.
Uddhava asks how many elements the sages count; he has heard the Lord describe twenty-eight — God, jīva, mahat-tattva, false ego, five gross elements, five tanmātras, ten senses, mind, and three modes. Different schools give different counts; he wants clarity.
Reflection Questions
  • What categories do I use to map reality, and where are they incomplete?
  • What would help me hold differing maps without fragmenting my faith?
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 22