FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 11.18.17

मौनानीहानिलायामा दण्डा वाग्देहचेतसाम् । न ह्येते यस्य सन्त्यङ्ग वेणुभिर्न भवेद् यति: ॥ १७ ॥
maunānīhānilāyāmā
[maunaaneehaanilaayaamaa]
daṇḍā vāg-deha-cetasām
[dandaa vaag-deha-chetasaam]
na hy ete yasya santy aṅga
[na hy ete yasya santy anga]
veṇubhir na bhaved yatiḥ
[venubhir na bhaved yatih]
mauna — avoiding useless speech anīha — giving up fruitive activities anila-āyāmāḥ — controlling the breathing process daṇḍāḥ — strict disciplines vāk — of the voice deha — of the body cetasām — of the mind na — not hi — indeed ete — these disciplines yasya — of whom santi — exist aṅga — My dear Uddhava veṇubhiḥ — by bamboo rods na — never bhavet — is yatiḥ — a real sannyāsī..
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
maunānīhānilāyāmā
mauna
avoiding useless speech
anīha
giving up fruitive activities
anila-āyāmāḥ
controlling the breathing process
daṇḍā vāg-deha-cetasām
daṇḍāḥ
strict disciplines
vāk
of the voice
deha
of the body
cetasām
of the mind
na hy ete yasya santy aṅga
na
not
veṇubhir na bhaved yatiḥ
hi
indeed
ete
these disciplines
yasya
of whom
santi
exist
aṅga
My dear Uddhava
veṇubhiḥ
by bamboo rods
na
never
bhavet
is
yatiḥ
a real sannyāsī..
One who has not accepted the three internal disciplines of avoiding useless speech, avoiding useless activities and controlling the life air can never be considered a sannyāsī merely because of his carrying bamboo rods.

The word daṇḍa indicates the staff carried by those in the renounced order of life, and daṇḍa also indicates severe discipline. The Vaiṣṇava sannyāsīs accept a staff made of three bamboo rods, signifying dedication of the body, mind and words to the service of the Supreme Lord. Here Lord Kṛṣṇa says that one must first accept these three daṇḍas, or disciplines (namely control of the voice, body and mind), within oneself. The practice of anilāyāma (or prāṇāyāma, regulating the life air) is meant to control the mind, and one who always thinks of service to Lord Kṛṣṇa has certainly achieved the perfection of prāṇāyāma. Merely carrying the three external daṇḍas without assimilating the internal daṇḍas of bodily, mental and vocal discipline can never make one an actual Vaiṣṇava sannyāsī, as explained here by Lord Kṛṣṇa.

In the Haṁsa-gītā section of Mahābhārata and in Śrīla Rūpa Gosvāmī’s Upadeśāmṛta, there are instructions regarding the sannyāsa order of life. A conditioned soul who adopts only the external ornaments of tridaṇḍi-sannyāsa will not actually be able to control the senses. One who takes sannyāsa for false prestige, making a show of saintliness without actual advancement in kṛṣṇa-kīrtana, will soon be vanquished by the external energy of the Lord.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
He who has not accepted the three internal daṇdas of avoiding useless speech, avoiding useless activities and controlling the life air can never be considered a sannyāsī merely because of his carrying an external daṇda. Silence is control of words. Giving up action is control of the body. Controlling breath is control of the mind. He who does not have these three controls or internal daṇḍas is not a sannyāsī, O Uddhava.
Without controlling useless speech, useless action, and the life air, carrying bamboo rods does not make one a sannyāsī. External markers without internal discipline are theater.
Reflection Questions
  • Where in my own life are external markers covering internal lack?
  • What internal discipline could I begin today?
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 18