FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.88.17

इत्यादिष्टस्तमसुर उपाधावत् स्वगात्रत: । केदार आत्मक्रव्येण जुह्वानोऽग्निमुखं हरम् ॥ १७ ॥
ity ādiṣṭas tam asura
[ity aadishtas tam asura]
upādhāvat sva-gātrataḥ
[upaadhaavat sva-gaatratah]
kedāra ātma-kravyeṇa
[kedaara aatma-kravyena]
juhvāno gni-mukhaṁ haram
[juhvaano gni-mukham haram]
iti — thus ādiṣṭaḥ — instructed tam — him (Lord Śiva) asuraḥ — the demon upādhāvat — worshiped sva — his own gātrataḥ — from the bodily limbs kedāre — at the holy place Kedāranātha ātma — his own kravyeṇa — with the flesh juhvānaḥ — offering oblations agni — the fire mukham — whose mouth haram — Lord Śiva .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
ity ādiṣṭas tam asura
iti
thus
ādiṣṭaḥ
instructed
tam
him (Lord Śiva)
asuraḥ
the demon
upādhāvat sva-gātrataḥ
upādhāvat
worshiped
sva
his own
gātrataḥ
from the bodily limbs
kedāra ātma-kravyeṇa
kedāre
at the holy place Kedāranātha
ātma
his own
kravyeṇa
with the flesh
juhvāno gni-mukhaṁ haram
juhvānaḥ
offering oblations
agni
the fire
mukham
whose mouth
haram
Lord Śiva .
  • ādiṣṭaḥ — instructed
    Past participle of ā-√diś. Vṛka acts on Nārada's instruction, but without Nārada's wisdom. Gauḍīyas note: hearing the teacher's words is not the same as inheriting the teacher's heart.
  • upādhāvat — he worshiped (literally: ran toward)
    Same upa-√dhāv as v.4 and v.15. The third sounding of the verb — now it is Vṛka running at Śiva, full-tilt, with self-mutilation in hand. The chapter has been preparing this scene since verse 4.
  • kedāre — at Kedāranātha
    Specific tīrtha in the Himālayas, classical Śiva-kṣetra. Gauḍīyas honor the holy place even while critiquing the worshiper's mood — the place is real, the worshiper's intent is the variable.
  • ātma-kravyeṇa — with his own flesh
    Contiguous (ātma + kravyeṇa). Kravya = raw flesh, especially carrion. The Bhāgavatam's word-choice marks the offering as asuric, not tāpasa. Self-immolation in the wrong mood is not austerity; it is asura-grade despair.
  • agni-mukham — the fire-mouthed (Śiva)
    Contiguous (agni + mukham). Śiva accepts what is offered into the fire — the convention is real. The chapter does not deny the mechanics; it questions the mood. Same hand, different hearts.
[Śukadeva Gosvāmī continued:] Thus advised, the demon proceeded to worship Lord Śiva at Kedāranātha by taking pieces of flesh from his own body and offering them as oblations into the sacred fire, which is Lord Śiva’s mouth.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[Śukadeva Gosvāmī continued:] Thus advised, the demon proceeded to worship Lord Śiva at Kedāranātha by taking pieces of flesh from his own body and offering them as oblations into the sacred fire, which is Lord Śiva's mouth.
Commentary

He worshipped Siva by cutting off pieces of his own flesh and offering that (atma kravyena).

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Having shown the prominence of rajoguṇa in the two who satisfied Śiva, Śukadeva now shows the tamoguṇa nature of Vṛka. He sacrificed his flesh into the fire, since it is the mouth of all devatās, at Kedāra, Śiva’s sacred spot.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

None Having shown the prominence of rajoguṇa in the two who satisfied Śiva, Śukadeva now shows the tamoguṇa nature of Vṛka. He sacrificed his flesh into the fire, since it is the mouth of all devatās, at Kedāra, Śiva’s sacred spot.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomShanti (Peace / Tranquility)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Ishvara Pranidhana (Surrender to God)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)Ahimsa (Non-violence / Compassion)
Related verses
Concepts
Yoga
Vṛkāsura worships at Kedāranātha by offering pieces of his own flesh — extreme self-mortification to extract a boon. Misguided austerity is sometimes more dramatic than true devotion.
Reflection Questions
  • What dramatic spiritual gesture have I made that was actually self-serving?
  • Where could simpler devotion replace performative austerity?

A merchant who has heard that a king accepts any gift now hauls his own meat to the gate, expecting royal welcome by sheer extremity. Vṛka feeds the sacred fire — Śiva's mouth — with his own flesh, mistaking gruesomeness for devotion. Bhakti is not measured in pounds of flesh.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 88