FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.84.38

वित्तैषणां यज्ञदानैर्गृहैर्दारसुतैषणाम् । आत्मलोकैषणां देव कालेन विसृजेद्ब‍ुध: । ग्रामे त्यक्तैषणा: सर्वे ययुर्धीरास्तपोवनम् ॥ ३८ ॥
vittaiṣaṇāṁ yajña-dānair
[vittaishanaam yajna-daanair]
gṛhair dāra-sutaiṣaṇām
[grihair daara-sutaishanaam]
ātma-lokaiṣaṇāṁ deva
[aatma-lokaishanaam deva]
kālena visṛjed budhaḥ
[kaalena visrijed budhah]
grāme tyaktaiṣaṇāḥ sarve
[graame tyaktaishanaah sarve]
yayur dhīrās tapo-vanam
[yayur dheeraas tapo-vanam]
vitta — for wealth eṣaṇām — the desire yajña — by sacrifices dānaiḥ — and by charity gṛhaiḥ — by engagement in household affairs dāra — for wife suta — and children eṣaṇām — the desire ātma — for oneself loka — for an exalted planet (in the next life) eṣaṇām — the desire deva — O saintly Vasudeva kālena — because of time visṛjet — one should renounce budhaḥ — who is intelligent grāme — for household life tyakta — who renounced eṣaṇāḥ — their desires sarve — all yayuḥ — they went dhīrāḥ — sober sages tapaḥ — of austerities vanam — to the forest .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
vittaiṣaṇāṁ yajña-dānair
vitta
for wealth
eṣaṇām
the desire
yajña
by sacrifices
dānaiḥ
and by charity
gṛhair dāra-sutaiṣaṇām
gṛhaiḥ
by engagement in household affairs
dāra
for wife
suta
and children
eṣaṇām
the desire
ātma-lokaiṣaṇāṁ deva
ātma
for oneself
loka
for an exalted planet (in the next life)
eṣaṇām
the desire
deva
O saintly Vasudeva
kālena visṛjed budhaḥ
kālena
because of time
visṛjet
one should renounce
budhaḥ
who is intelligent
grāme tyaktaiṣaṇāḥ sarve
grāme
for household life
tyakta
who renounced
eṣaṇāḥ
their desires
sarve
all
yayur dhīrās tapo-vanam
yayuḥ
they went
dhīrāḥ
sober sages
tapaḥ
of austerities
vanam
to the forest .
  • eṣaṇām — desire, craving
    From √iṣ (to desire). The technical Upaniṣadic word (Bṛhad-āraṇyaka 3.5) for the three primal cravings — vitta, putra, loka. Gauḍīyas note that bhakti, when developed, dissolves all three by the substitute desire for Kṛṣṇa.
  • ātma-loka-eṣaṇām — the desire for a higher planet for oneself
    ātma (self) + loka (planet) + eṣaṇā (desire). Even the desire for Svarga must be renounced. Gauḍīyas hold that this verse implicitly contains the entire BG 9.21 teaching — kṣīṇe puṇye martya-lokaṁ viśanti — Svarga is impermanent.
  • tapaḥ-vanam — to the forest of austerity
    tapas (austerity) + vana (forest). The vānaprastha destination. Gauḍīyas read this as one of two valid late-life paths — the other being a Vaiṣṇava ashram of bhajana, the second often preferred in Kali-yuga.
  • dhīrāḥ — sober sages
    From √dhṛ (to hold, sustain). The steadied one — the same dhīra of BG 2.13 (dhīras tatra na muhyati). Gauḍīyas hold that dhairya is one of the six limbs of śaraṇāgati (rakṣiṣyatīti viśvāsaḥ rests on dhairya).
An intelligent person should learn to renounce his desire for wealth by performing sacrifices and acts of charity. He should learn to renounce his desire for wife and children by experiencing family life. And he should learn to renounce his desire for promotion to a higher planet in his next life, O saintly Vasudeva, by studying the effects of time. Self-controlled sages who have thus renounced their attachment to household life go to the forest to perform austerities.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
An intelligent person should learn to renounce his desire for wealth by performing sacrifices and acts of charity. He should learn to renounce his desire for wife and children by experiencing family life. And he should learn to renounce his desire for promotion to a higher planet in his next life, O saintly Vasudeva, by studying the effects of time. Self-controlled sages who have thus renounced their attachment to household life go to the forest to perform austerities.
Commentary

One cannot destroy karma without giving up all desires. One can give up all desires by the following process. One should give up the desire for wealth by sacrifice and charity which are the result of the wealth. He then thinks "what is the use of wealth, if it just gets spent in sacrifice and charity?" One should give up the desire for children and enjoyment with wife by enjoying according to the rules of household life. By the experience itself one gives up the desire for it. One should give up the desire for svarga loka by understanding that it is temporary, since the body is subject to death. O Vasudeva (deva), there is proof of such conduct. Giving up their desires in the house, the wise went to the forest.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

By offering various objects to the Lord, by his mercy, one gives up desire for the objects. One gives up desire for wealth by performing sacrifices whose actions expend wealth for the purpose of worship of the Lord. One gives up desire for wife and sons by household life with wife and children meant as worship of the Lord. One should give up desire for selfish reasons or for enjoyment in this life and the next at all opportunities (kālena), looking for opportunities to worship the Lord, using time for the Lord. O Lord (deva)! Or one should give up desires for enjoyment in this life and the next by spending time in worshipping the Lord (deva). The person with discrimination should give up these desires. This means the wealthy householder will not perfect hearing and other devotional process properly by having a disturbed mind. If the attached person suddenly gives up his house without destroying desires for the gṛhasthāśrama, he cannot perfect hearing and meditation on the Lord. He will later give them up.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

By this method the desire for wealth decreases. There is no other way. Examples are given of householders. The discriminating person should act in this way. Otherwise, the wealthy man, with an impure mind, cannot practice bhakti with hearing etc. He should give up his house with it wealth to perfect pure hearing. Thus giving up everything, the intelligent householed (dhīraḥ) goes to the forest. This means that a person who has not become detached, and does not give his desire for wealth, should not renounce.

Related values
Sthitaprajna (Steady Wisdom)Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomShanti (Peace / Tranquility)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)
Related verses
Concepts
Karma
An intelligent person renounces desire for wealth by sacrifice and charity. The cure for greed is structured generosity — discipline reshapes desire, not denial alone.
Reflection Questions
  • What structured act of giving could begin to dissolve a grip I have on wealth?
  • Where am I trying to renounce inwardly without changing outward patterns?

The intelligent householder uses each phase of life as a small fire that burns off the corresponding eṣaṇā — yajña and dāna burn off the desire for wealth; family experience burns off the desire for spouse and children; the study of time burns off the desire for heaven. By the time the forest beckons, there is little left to renounce.

Yudhiṣṭhira walking north

At the end of the Mahābhārata (Mahāprasthānika-parva), Yudhiṣṭhira, having performed his sacrifices and seen his kingdom settled, walks toward the Himalayas with his brothers and Draupadī. The forest is not an escape — it is the after-image of completed eṣaṇā-renunciation.

Gauḍīyas treat his walk as the operating procedure this verse describes: the sage moves to tapas-vana only after eṣaṇās are quietly burned.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 84