FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.84.17

अनीह एतद् बहुधैक आत्मना सृजत्यवत्यत्ति न बध्यते यथा । भौमैर्हि भूमिर्बहुनामरूपिणी अहो विभूम्नश्चरितं विडम्बनम् ॥ १७ ॥
anīha etad bahudhaika ātmanā
[aneeha etad bahudhaika aatmanaa]
sṛjaty avaty atti na badhyate yathā
[srijaty avaty atti na badhyate yathaa]
bhaumair hi bhūmir bahu-nāma-rūpiṇī
[bhaumair hi bhoomir bahu-naama-roopinee]
aho vibhūmnaś caritaṁ viḍambanam
[aho vibhoomnash charitam vidambanam]
anīhaḥ — exerting no endeavor etat — this (universe) bahudhā — manifold ekaḥ — alone ātmanā — by Himself sṛjati — He creates avati — maintains atti — annihilates na badhyate — is not bound up yathā — as bhaumaiḥ — by the transformations of earth hi — indeed bhūmiḥ — earth bahu — many nāma - rūpiṇī — having names and forms aho — ah vibhūmnaḥ — of the almighty Lord caritam — the activities viḍambanam — a pretense .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
anīha etad bahudhaika ātmanā
anīhaḥ
exerting no endeavor
etat
this (universe)
bahudhā
manifold
ekaḥ
alone
ātmanā
by Himself
sṛjaty avaty atti na badhyate yathā
sṛjati
He creates
avati
maintains
atti
annihilates
na badhyate
is not bound up
yathā
as
bhaumair hi bhūmir bahu-nāma-rūpiṇī
bhaumaiḥ
by the transformations of earth
hi
indeed
bhūmiḥ
earth
bahu
many
nāma - rūpiṇī
having names and forms
aho vibhūmnaś caritaṁ viḍambanam
aho
ah
vibhūmnaḥ
of the almighty Lord
caritam
the activities
viḍambanam
a pretense .
  • anīhaḥ — exerting no endeavor
    a- (not) + īhā (effort). Bhagavān creates without straining. Gauḍīyas read this as a marker of His aiśvarya: His will is enacted directly, without the labor that conditioned beings require to produce anything.
  • ekaḥ — alone, one
    Bhagavān creates alone — without a second agent. Personalist reading: not impersonal oneness, but one Person acting from His own Self. Gauḍīyas insist that the One here is Kṛṣṇa as svayaṁ-bhagavān, not a featureless Brahman.
  • bhaumaiḥ — by the transformations of earth
    From bhūmi (earth). The pots, pillars, idols. The famous Upaniṣadic analogy compressed into one ablative. Gauḍīyas use it to show that the world's variety is not an illusion — it is a transformation of the substrate, distinguishable from but not separable from the substrate.
  • viḍambanam — a pretense, mimicry
    From vi + √ḍamb (to mock, mimic). Bhagavān's humanlike activity is viḍambana — He plays at being conditioned. Gauḍīyas treat this as the doctrinal description of nara-līlā: the form is imitative; the Person within is unaffected.
Indeed, the humanlike pastimes of the Almighty are simply a pretense! Effortlessly, He alone sends forth from His Self this variegated creation, maintains it and then swallows it up again, all without becoming entangled, just as the element earth takes on many names and forms in its various transformations.

The one Supreme expands Himself as many without diminishing His completeness. He does this effortlessly, without depending on anyone or anything else. This mystic process of the Lord’s self-expansion is incomprehensible to all but Himself, but the example of the substance earth and its manifold products bears enough resemblance to provide some idea. The same example is also presented in an often-cited passage of the Chāndogya Upaniṣad (6.1), vācārambhaṇaṁ vikāro nāmadheyaṁ mṛttikety eva satyam: “Earth’s transformations are merely verbal creations of the process of naming; the substance earth itself is alone real.” Śrīla Śrīdhara Svāmī suggests that this verse of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam answers a possible objection on the part of Lord Kṛṣṇa: “How can I create, maintain and destroy the universe if I am Vasudeva’s son?” The answer is given by the words aho vibhūmnaś caritaṁ viḍambanam: “You are the perfectly complete whole, and Your birth and pastimes are only an imitation of ordinary persons’ activities in the material world. You simply pretend to be under higher control.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Indeed, the humanlike pastimes of the Almighty are simply a pretense! Effortlessly, He alone sends forth from His Self this variegated creation, maintains it and then swallows it up again, all without becoming entangled, just as the element earth takes on many names and forms in its various transformations.
Commentary

Both show of power and hiding your powers are beyond comprehension. The Lord creates this universe (etat) by himself (atmana) with many forms, but is not bound. Though the lord is one (ekah) he becomes the universe with many names and forms, just as earth is one, but becomes many as a pot or cloth. Amazing (aho) are the actions of the completely perfect lord (vibhumnah), appearing to be a controlled jiva by worshipping the sages. But it is only a pretense of being a controlled jiva (vidambanam).

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

This happens all the time, not just now. You are one, without assistance. By yourself, without the assistance of another cause, by your svarūpa, you create and destroy even the whole universe, but you are without change (anīhaḥ) by action or by transformation. There is great variety (bahudhā) by manifestation of many different universes and various times. You are complete in yourself (vibhumnaḥ). Therefore your actions mock our intelligence (viḍambanam), since you possess acintya-śakti. Śrutes tu śabda-mūlatvāt: contradictions in the Lord are explained by scripture alone. (Brahma-sūtra 2.1.27)

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The Lord is without action (anīhaḥ), unlike the potter in making the pot. Just by his desire things are accomplished. Or he has not purpose in creating the variegated universe (anīhaḥ). Alone you create by yourself (ātmanā). You are not dependent on anyone else. But you are not bound up by karma. It is just like (yathā) earth manifesting many names and forms with transformations. Aho indicates joy. The actions of the complete Lord (vibhūmnaḥ) are a pretense. “If he is complete why does he flee from Jarāsandha?” That is the pretense. By such activities he deceives the demons. Or the Lord is not at all bound up (yathā) because (hi) even earth with its names and forms is not bound by its products (bhaumaiḥ). It is not transformed. “What is the purpose in my creating the universe?” It is for the benefit of the jīvas. The activities of creation and destruction (caritam) are for supporting (vilambanam) all the jīvas. The letter L can be substituted for Ḍ.

Related values
Vairagya (Detachment / Dispassion)Discriminative WisdomShanti (Peace / Tranquility)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)Ishvara Pranidhana (Surrender to God)
Related verses
Concepts
Karma
Kṛṣṇa's humanlike pastimes are pretense — He effortlessly creates, maintains, and destroys universes. The intimacy He shows us is the gracious choice of one who needs nothing.
Reflection Questions
  • Do I receive God's intimacy as a casual grace or as His staggering choice?
  • How does the bigness of God deepen rather than diminish the sweetness of His closeness?

The element earth, going about its single business of being earth, becomes a pot, a pillar, a wall, a road, a Deity, a corpse, without ceasing to be earth. So Bhagavān, in His ekatva, sends forth the variegated worlds and reabsorbs them without being snagged by any of it. The pot does not entangle the clay.

Chāndogya Upaniṣad's earthen pot

The Chāndogya (6.1.4) uses the same image — yathā saumya ekena mṛt-piṇḍena sarvaṁ mṛn-mayaṁ vijñātaṁ syāt — by knowing one lump of clay, all earthen things are known.

Gauḍīyas read the Upaniṣad's image through acintya-bhedābheda: the names and forms are real (not māyā in the Advaitin sense), and yet the substratum is one Person. The verse here applies that image to Bhagavān's līlā.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 84