FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.8.34

कस्मान्मृदमदान्तात्मन् भवान्भक्षितवान्‌ रह: । वदन्ति तावका ह्येते कुमारास्तेऽग्रजोऽप्ययम् ॥ ३४ ॥
kasmān mṛdam adāntātman
[kasmaan mridam adaantaatman]
bhavān bhakṣitavān rahaḥ
[bhavaan bhakshitavaan rahah]
vadanti tāvakā hy ete
[vadanti taavakaa hy ete]
kumārās te ’grajo ’py ayam
[kumaaraas te ’grajo ’py ayam]
kasmāt — why mṛdam — dirt adānta - ātman — You restless boy bhavān — You bhakṣitavān — have eaten rahaḥ — in a solitary place vadanti — are lodging this complaint tāvakāḥ — Your friends and playmates hi — indeed ete — all of them kumārāḥ — boys te — Your agrajaḥ — older brother api — also (confirms) ayam — this .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
kasmān mṛdam adāntātman
kasmāt
why
mṛdam
dirt
adānta - ātman
You restless boy
bhavān bhakṣitavān rahaḥ
bhavān
You
bhakṣitavān
have eaten
rahaḥ
in a solitary place
vadanti tāvakā hy ete
vadanti
are lodging this complaint
tāvakāḥ
Your friends and playmates
hi
indeed
ete
all of them
kumārās te ’grajo ’py ayam
kumārāḥ
boys
te
Your
agrajaḥ
older brother
api
also (confirms)
ayam
this .
  • adānta - ātman — O restless boy (uncontrolled self)
    A (not) + dānta (subdued, from √dam) + ātman (self). Vocative. The same word that in Gītā 6.36 describes the uncontrolled mind. Yaśodā lovingly uses the contemplative vocabulary on her toddler — comic juxtaposition with rasa-density.
  • mṛdam — dirt, earth
    Accusative of mṛd. The substance of the universe Kṛṣṇa has supposedly eaten. The verse turns on the irony: the Lord who supports earth is accused of eating a clod. Earth-in-mouth foreshadows universe-in-mouth, three verses later.
  • rahaḥ — in a solitary place
    Locative-adverb of rahas. Same word as 10.8.10–11. The verse-trio of rahasi: secret saṁskāra, secret name-giving, and now secret dirt-eating. Vraja's deepest events all unfold in rahasi.
  • tāvakāḥ — Your (friends and playmates)
    From the pronoun tva — 'of you, yours'. Yaśodā stresses tava (yours): the accusers are Kṛṣṇa's own — His friends, His brother. The defense of 'they hate me' is foreclosed before it is offered.
  • agrajaḥ — older brother
    Agra (front) + ja (born) — 'born ahead'. Balarāma as the agraja gives the complaint extra weight. Vaiṣṇava: Balarāma is the original guru-tattva; when He confirms a charge, even Kṛṣṇa cannot easily deny.
Dear Kṛṣṇa, why are You so restless that You have eaten dirt in a solitary place? This complaint has been lodged against You by all Your playmates, including Your elder brother, Balarāma. How is this?

Mother Yaśodā was agitated by Kṛṣṇa’s restless misbehavior. Her house was full of sweetmeats. Why then should the restless boy eat dirt in a solitary place? Kṛṣṇa replied, “My dear mother, they have plotted together and lodged a complaint against Me so that you will punish Me. My elder brother, Balarāma, has joined them. Actually, I have not done this. Take My words as true. Do not be angry and chastise Me.”

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Dear Kṛṣṇa, why are You so restless that You have eaten dirt in a solitary place? This complaint has been lodged against You by all Your playmates, including Your elder brother, Balarāma. How is this?
Commentary

"O unsteady body, unsteady mind! Did you eat dirt? Did you not get sweets in my house? Not in my presence but stealthily (raha) you have done it. Your friends are saying this, so it cannot be false. You cannot that they are saying that as enemies, because they want me to beat you, because even Baladeva is saying this. He is standing right there saying this. So there is no doubt about this."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Her scolding is described. O boy with uncontrolled senses! You could not eat dirt in the presence of Balarāma. Therefore you have eaten it when they were not present (rahaḥ). The word hi indicates a cause or certainty. They are your intimate friends (tāvakāḥ) and therefore they have not lied. They are present now (ete) as witnesses and thus you cannot deny it. “But they are saying this as a joke.” But your elder brother also says this. There is no doubt when he also says this (ayam). Since Vasudeva and Nanda were brothers and Rohiṇī and Yaśodā were great friends, Yaśodā addresses Balarāma as the elder brother of Kṛṣṇa, taking him as her son. It is also stated out of affection for him.

Related values
Samata (Equanimity / Even-mindedness)Abhaya (Fearlessness)Sthitaprajna (Steady Wisdom)Tejas (Inner Radiance / Vigour)Hrih (Modesty / Sense of Shame)Vinaya (Humility / Modesty)Seva (Service / Selfless Action)Dana (Charity / Generosity)
Related verses
Concepts
Dana
When falsely accused, hold steady in vinaya and abhaya — Kṛṣṇa's calm under His mother's chastisement is the dhīra-bhāva you can borrow today.
Practical Applications
  • When wrongly blamed today, refuse the urge to retaliate — answer once, plainly, and let the matter rest at Kṛṣṇa's feet.
  • Notice where your own restlessness (adānta-ātman) sends you reaching for 'dirt' — petty distractions — when sweetmeats (sādhana, prasāda, kīrtana) are already in the house.
  • Speak to one elder or authority today with vinaya, even when you feel misunderstood, and offer that exchange to Kṛṣṇa as your evening's karma.

A queen, hearing her son's playmates accuse him of stealing the orchard's mud, holds him up by both arms and asks why — and behind her stern voice is a love so heavy it nearly cracks the question itself. Yaśodā's reproach is exactly such weight: every word a hammer struck on the anvil of vātsalya.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 8