FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.54.42

तवेयं विषमा बुद्धि: सर्वभूतेषु दुर्हृदाम् । यन्मन्यसे सदाभद्रं सुहृदां भद्रमज्ञवत् ॥ ४२ ॥
taveyaṁ viṣamā buddhiḥ
[taveyam vishamaa buddhih]
sarva-bhūteṣu durhṛdām
[sarva-bhooteshu durhridaam]
yan manyase sadābhadraṁ
[yan manyase sadaabhadram]
suhṛdāṁ bhadram ajña-vat
[suhridaam bhadram ajna-vat]
tava — your iyam — this viṣamā — biased buddhiḥ — attitude sarva - bhūteṣu — toward all living beings durhṛdām — of those who have ill intentions yat — that manyase — you wish sadā — always abhadram — evil suhṛdām — to your well-wishers bhadram — good ajña - vat — like an ignorant person .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
taveyaṁ viṣamā buddhiḥ
tava
your
iyam
this
viṣamā
biased
buddhiḥ
attitude
sarva-bhūteṣu durhṛdām
sarva - bhūteṣu
toward all living beings
durhṛdām
of those who have ill intentions
yan manyase sadābhadraṁ
yat
that
manyase
you wish
sadā
always
abhadram
evil
suhṛdāṁ bhadram ajña-vat
suhṛdām
to your well-wishers
bhadram
good
ajña - vat
like an ignorant person .
  • viṣamā-buddhiḥ — biased / unfair attitude
    Viṣama (uneven, partial) + buddhi (intelligence). The opposite of sama-buddhi which the Gītā repeatedly praises (BG 5.18, 6.32). Balarāma names Rukmiṇī's attachment to her brother as a form of viṣama-buddhi — kindly, but precisely.
  • durhṛdām — of those who have ill intentions
    Genitive plural of durhṛd. Dur (bad) + hṛd (heart). The opposite of suhṛd. Balarāma's lexicon makes the moral architecture of the situation precise: Rukmī is durhṛd toward all beings; Kṛṣṇa is suhṛd. Yet Rukmiṇī pleads for the durhṛd.
  • ajña-vat — like an ignorant person
    Ajña (ignorant) + vat (like). Balarāma does not call her ignorant; only LIKE an ignorant person. The hedge is the tenderness — He preserves her sādhvī status while still naming the cognitive distortion.
  • sarva-bhūteṣu — toward all living beings
    Sarva (all) + bhūta (being). The cosmic scope. Balarāma reminds Rukmiṇī that Rukmī's ill-will is not only toward Kṛṣṇa or toward her — it extends to all beings. This is the Bhāgavatam's standard of evil: not merely personal injury but enmity-to-all.
  • abhadram — evil / inauspicious
    A- (not) + bhadra (auspicious). To wish abhadra to one's well-wishers is exactly the inversion Balarāma is correcting. The Bhāgavatam's word-pair (bhadra / abhadra) is more about auspiciousness than moral right-wrong — a Vedic, ritual scale.
[To Rukmiṇī Balarāma said:] Your attitude is unfair, for like an ignorant person you wish good to those who are inimical to all living beings and who have done evil to your true well-wishers.
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
[To Rukmiṇī Balarāma said:] Your attitude is unfair, for like an ignorant person you wish good to those who are inimical to all living beings and who have done evil to your true well-wishers.
Commentary

"But this rule is for situations other than war. The rule in war is that the enemy should be defeated, and made insignificant." Guessing that this was Krsna’s internal thought, Balarama then spoke to Rukmini with this verse. "Krsna treatment of relatives who have evil intentions to all beings, such as shaving your brother, which you think is wrong for them, is actually correct. It is due to your biased intelligence, like that of ignorant people, though actually you have good intelligence."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Balarāma spoke to Rukmiṇī, enlightening her by means of dharma in order to pacify her. Such instructions were not necessary for Kṛṣṇa. Since she did not give up lamenting, he speaks with anger at first, enlightening her with teachings of jñāna, containing a secret message for her to have her give up lamenting. Just as you desire bad for those among all beings who appear to show animosity, you desire good for Rukmī and others who appear to show friendship. And to others you are neutral. This is disturbed intelligence, like that of ignorant people. There is another meaning in which suhrḍam modifies duhrdām. Among all beings, you wish bad fortune to Śiśupāla and others who are confirmed as enemies and you wish good to their friends like Rukmī who assist them. Thus you have disturbed intelligence. You should think of them as enemies as well and wish them bad fortune.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

Though the words for Rukmiṇī, he addressed Kṛṣṇa. However she did still not give up lamenting. Thus he stopped speaking to Kṛṣṇa and enlightened her with philosophical teachings. You wish good fortune for friends and the opposite for enemies.

Related values
Discriminative WisdomKshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Ahimsa (Non-violence / Compassion)Guru Bhakti (Reverence for Teacher)Karuna (Kindness / Compassion)Bhakti (Devotion)Satya (Truthfulness)Maitri (Friendship / Goodwill)
Related verses
Concepts
DharmaJiva
Your attitude is unfair, like an ignorant person wishing good to those inimical to all beings and evil to your true well-wishers. Inverted loyalty mistakes enemies for kin; honest analysis exposes the misalignment.
Reflection Questions
  • Where have you wished good to those inimical to the larger good?
  • How do you tell loyalty rooted in habit from loyalty rooted in dharma?

Wishing well to those who wish ill to all beings, and ill to those who wish you well — this is the unbalance of attachment. Balarāma's diagnosis is gentle but unsparing: even Rukmiṇī's love-for-her-brother carries a touch of ajñāna-vat-buddhi, the ignorance that mis-weighs the relationships of the soul.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 54