FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.46.40

सत्त्वं रजस्तम इति भजते निर्गुणो गुणान् । क्रीडन्नतीतोऽपि गुणै: सृजत्यवति हन्त्यज: ॥ ४० ॥
sattvaṁ rajas tama iti
[sattvam rajas tama iti]
bhajate nirguṇo guṇān
[bhajate nirguno gunaan]
krīḍann atīto ’pi guṇaiḥ
[kreedann ateeto ’pi gunaih]
sṛjaty avan hanty ajaḥ
[srijaty avan hanty ajah]
sattvam — goodness rajaḥ — passion tamaḥ — and ignorance iti — thus called bhajate — He accepts nirguṇaḥ — beyond the material modes guṇān — the modes krīḍan — playing atītaḥ — transcendental api — although guṇaiḥ — using the modes sṛjati — He creates avati — maintains hanti — and destroys ajaḥ — the unborn Lord .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
sattvaṁ rajas tama iti
sattvam
goodness
rajaḥ
passion
tamaḥ
and ignorance
iti
thus called
bhajate nirguṇo guṇān
bhajate
He accepts
nirguṇaḥ
beyond the material modes
guṇān
the modes
krīḍann atīto ’pi guṇaiḥ
krīḍan
playing
atītaḥ
transcendental
api
although
guṇaiḥ
using the modes
sṛjaty avan hanty ajaḥ
sṛjati
He creates
avati
maintains
hanti
and destroys
ajaḥ
the unborn Lord .
  • nirguṇaḥ — beyond the material modes
    From nir (without) + guṇa. Uddhava asserts the Lord is nirguṇa — yet immediately says He plays with the guṇas. Gauḍīya doctrine: nirguṇa here means 'not subject to,' not 'devoid of qualities.' Bhagavān has innumerable spiritual qualities (which are aprākṛta-guṇas).
  • krīḍan — playing
    Present participle of √krīḍ. Same krīḍ-root as verse 39's krīḍā-artham. The Lord's relation to creation is play, not labor. Gauḍīya bhakti-tattva: the entire material world is the Lord's krīḍā-sthala, His playground.
  • atītaḥ — transcendental
    Past participle of ati-√i (to go beyond). Same root as atīta — what has gone past. Bhagavān has, as it were, already-gone-past the guṇas; He is on the other side of them while operating within them.
  • guṇaiḥ — by means of the modes
    Instrumental plural of guṇa. The very modes He transcends become His tools. Gauḍīya: this is the answer to all 'how can the formless become formed' questions — He uses guṇa without being inside guṇa.
  • ajaḥ — the unborn
    From a + √jan. Final word of the verse; Gauḍīya commentators emphasize its position as climax: He creates, maintains, destroys — and is unborn through all of it. The verb-list ends; the adjective announces what was true throughout.
  • sṛjati-avati-hanti — He creates, maintains, and destroys
    Three verbs of the trimūrti-function, here predicated of one ajaḥ Lord. Gauḍīya: this verse compresses Brahmā-Viṣṇu-Śiva activity into Bhagavān's single play — the doctrinal source for Caitanya-line subordination of the trimūrti to one Bhagavān.
Although beyond the three modes of material nature — goodness, passion and ignorance — the transcendental Lord accepts association with them as His play. Thus the unborn Supreme Lord utilizes the material modes to create, maintain and destroy.

As stated in the Brahma-sūtra (2.1.33), loka-vat līlā-kaivalyam: “The Lord performs His spiritual pastimes as if He were a resident of this world.” Although the Lord does not favor or abuse anyone, we still observe happiness and suffering in this world. The Gītā (13.22) states, kāraṇaṁ guṇa-saṅgo ’sya: We desire to associate with various qualities of material nature, and thus we must accept the consequences. The Lord provides the field of material nature, in which we exercise our free will. Foolish nondevotees not only attempt to cheat the Lord by trying to exploit His nature, but when they suffer the reaction they blame God for their own misdeeds. This is the shameless position of those who are envious of God.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
Although beyond the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance—the transcendental Lord accepts association with them as His play. Thus the unborn Supreme Lord utilizes the material modes to create, maintain and destroy.
Commentary

"If Krsna is equal to all, and no one is dear or undear, then why did he create some people happy and some people unhappy?" "Happiness and unhappiness are created by the modes, not by Krsna." That is the intention of this verse. "Though he is without gunas, by his glance at material energy he accepts sattva, raja and tama gunas." "For what purpose?" "For his play." "But he is above all play." Uddhava desired to make Nanda understand. "Actually Krsna is above the gunas, and rather appears for pastimes with his devotees as avatara in this universe among materialistic people. Though he does not enter the gunas, he creates the universe through the gunas, so that the designated jivas can receive senses and intelligence. to reap their fruits of good and bad karma and thus enjoy and suffer. What fault is there in Krsna for this? That is the meaning of the statement "no one is dear or undear to him."" "Thus the creation is not the Lord’s but rather that of the gunas (verse 41). Due to defect in the bodily functions, a person may perceive that the earth is turning around like a potter’s wheel. Similarly, though the mind is the doer, the jiva perceives the soul as the doer due to identification with the mind. In the same way the jiva perceives the universe as the creation of the Lord, though it is actually the creation of the gunas. It should be understood however, that though the material universe is not a direct creation of the Lord, it is a creation of the lord’s maya sakti, coming from the Lord. As the Lord and his energy are non different, one can say that the Lord, in the form of his maya sakti, creates the world."

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

By proximity with the Lord, the guṇas of matter act, though it appears that the Lord is directly involved. Or, playing is the nature of the Lord. In playing, the Lord acts as if he were attracted to the material guṇas. Without connection with the material guṇas he plays. He accepts the guṇas of sattva, rajas and tamas in order to play happily, which gives happiness to his devotees. Why does he become absorbed in the guṇas? He does not become absorbed at all. He is beyond the guṇas by his qualities like his knowledge arising from his svarūpa (guṇaiḥ). Therefore, he is without transformations like birth and death (ajaḥ). The play involving the material guṇas consists of creation, maintenance and destruction.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

“Though he has no material activities, why was it said that he creates the universe (verse 3)?” Two verses explain. He acts in the world as play. That play is produces by manifesting spiritual qualities. Though the Lord is untouched by the material guṇas of sattva, rajas and tamas, and though he is without birth, he manifests qualities beyond the guṇas such as cleverness and mercy to play in this world using those qualities. He creates melodies which bewilder Brahmā and Śiva. He protects the gopīs from Śaṅkhacūḍa and other demons. He destroys Śaṅgkhacūḍa and others. Or he creates calves and cowherd boys, he maintains those forms for a year, and withdraws those forms after that.

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Kshama (Forgiveness / Patience)Aparigraha (Non-possessiveness)
Related verses
Concepts
TamasAvatara
Although beyond the three modes, the transcendental Lord accepts association with them as play, using them to create, maintain, and destroy. The Lord 'plays as if a resident of this world'; transcendence and engagement are simultaneous.
Reflection Questions
  • Where do you require Kṛṣṇa to choose between transcendence and engagement?
  • How does His simultaneous play change your reading of His worldly actions?

Though beyond the three guṇas, He plays with them — creates with rajas, maintains with sattva, destroys with tamas. The avatāra is not a guṇa-bound being but a guṇa-using being. Gauḍīya: the Lord's līlā with material energies is the play of a king with His own servants, never the slavery of being mistaken for one of them.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 46