FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.40.8

त्वामेवान्ये शिवोक्तेन मार्गेण शिवरूपिणम् । बह्वाचार्यविभेदेन भगवन्तम् उपासते ॥ ८ ॥
tvām evānye śivoktena
[tvaam evaanye shivoktena]
mārgeṇa śiva-rūpiṇam
[maargena shiva-roopinam]
bahv-ācārya-vibhedena
[bahv-aachaarya-vibhedena]
bhagavantam upāsate
[bhagavantam upaasate]
tvām — You eva — also anye — others śiva — by Lord Śiva uktena — spoken mārgeṇa — by the path śiva - rūpiṇam — in the form of Lord Śiva bahu - ācārya — of many teachers vibhedena — following the different presentations bhagavantam — the Supreme Lord upāsate — they worship .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tvām evānye śivoktena
tvām
You
eva
also
anye
others
śiva
by Lord Śiva
uktena
spoken
mārgeṇa śiva-rūpiṇam
mārgeṇa
by the path
śiva - rūpiṇam
in the form of Lord Śiva
bahv-ācārya-vibhedena
bahu - ācārya
of many teachers
vibhedena
following the different presentations
bhagavantam upāsate
bhagavantam
the Supreme Lord
upāsate
they worship .
  • śiva-rūpiṇam — in the form of Śiva
    śiva + rūpin (having form). Even Śiva's mūrti is finally a manifestation of the one Bhagavān seen through the lens of tamas-mixed sattva. Jīva Gosvāmī (Kṛṣṇa-sandarbha) places Śiva as a śaktyāveśa-related expansion — Bhagavān-touched, not Bhagavān Himself.
  • bahu-ācārya-vibhedena — by the divisions among many teachers
    bahu (many) + ācārya (teachers) + vibheda (division). Polite naming of the splintered later traditions that drifted from Śiva's original Vaiṣṇava intent. Read with Padma Purāṇa's māyāvādam asac chāstram in mind.
  • bhagavantam — the Supreme Personality of Godhead
    ṣaḍ-aiśvarya-pūrṇa — full in six opulences (Viṣṇu Purāṇa 6.5.47, cited by Jīva). The word itself names Bhagavān; even when worshipers misaddress Him through Śiva, He alone fits the definition.
  • upāsate — they worship
    From upa + √ās — to sit near. All such worship draws the worshiper near the Lord, however indirectly. The verse is generous, not dismissive.
There are still others, who worship You, the Supreme Lord, in the form of Lord Śiva. They follow the path described by him and interpreted in various ways by many teachers.

The words tvām eva, “You also,” indicate that the path of worshiping Lord Śiva is indirect and therefore inferior. Akrūra himself is following the superior method by directly worshiping Kṛṣṇa, or Viṣṇu, with his prayers.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
There are still others, who worship You, the Supreme Lord, in the form of Lord Śiva. They follow the path described by him and interpreted in various ways by many teachers.
Commentary

This verse describes the saivites. They also worship you , though in an inferior way, through different systems (saiva, pasupat) of different acaryas. Bhagavan sam upasate or bhagavantam upasate are two versions of the last phrase of the verse.

Jīva Gosvāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The word eva indicates inferior worship to the previous worship. Just as one may call the prince the king, so here Śiva is called Bhagavān. Another version has bhagavān samupāgataḥ.

Śrīdhara Svāmī Gauḍīya
Commentary

The word eva indicates that Śiva is considered non-different from the Lord. Thus he is called the Lord (bhagavantam).

Related values
Anahankarah (Freedom from False Ego)Svadhyaya (Self-study & Scripture Study)Guru Bhakti (Reverence for Teacher)
Related verses
Concepts
Jiva
Others worship Him as Lord Śiva, following the path Śiva described, interpreted in various ways. The path through Śiva is indirect; direct Vaiṣṇava worship is the most efficient. Different routes lead Him-ward at different speeds.
Reflection Questions
  • Are you on a direct or indirect path right now, and have you been honest about which?
  • Where do you mistake longer for safer?

A devoted servant of the king's most trusted minister is, through that minister, still in service of the king. Worshipers of Śiva who keep his actual teaching — Śiva's own devotion to Viṣṇu — flow upward through their lord toward the Lord whom their lord serves.

Lord Śiva's instruction to his consort

In SB 4.24, Śiva sings the Rudra-gītā to the Pracetās, declaring Vāsudeva to be the Supreme and himself to be His servant: ahaṁ ca yas tatra bhagavān asau. Śiva preaches Viṣṇu-bhakti as his own dharma.

Akrūra's verse 8 must be read with Śiva's own confession — those who 'follow the path described by him' are, if they follow truly, Vaiṣṇavas. The trouble begins only when bahu-ācārya-vibhedena (the many later teachers) bend Śiva's path away from his own Lord.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 40