Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.14.25
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
-
rajjvām aheḥ
—
in the matter of a rope and a snake
Phrase: rajju (rope) + ahi (snake). The classical rajju-sarpa-nyāya. Used by Advaitins to argue the world's bare unreality; used here by Brahmā in a Vaiṣṇava key — the rope (Bhagavān's śakti) is real, only the snake (independent material existence) is misperception.
-
ātmatayā avijānatām
—
of those who do not know (You) as the Self
Compound: ātmatā (selfhood) + a- + vijānat (not knowing). Misidentification of the Self is the disease. The Gauḍīya cure is not de-personalization but proper personalization — knowing Bhagavān as the Self of all selves while remaining oneself.
-
bhava-abhavau
—
existence and non-existence (of saṁsāra)
Compound: bhava (existence) + abhava (non-existence). The pair — appearing and disappearing — characteristic of misperceived saṁsāra. Both poles dissolve together when ātmatā is recognized.
-
pralīyate
—
dissolves
Passive of pra-√lī. The dissolution is automatic upon recognition. Brahmā stipulates that mukti is not an attainment but a non-noticing of a misperception. The Gauḍīya extension: even this mukti is preliminary to prema.
-
bhoga
—
the body (of the snake)
From √bhuj — body, coil. The 'expanse' of the misperceived snake. Also resonates with bhoga as 'enjoyment' — the misperceived snake of material enjoyment vanishes only when its substrate is correctly seen.
Those submerged in illusion see material existence as infinite, just as one who is submerged in water sees only water all around him. For example, material scientists and philosophers, submerged deep within the ocean of material illusion, imagine that material nature extends infinitely in all directions. In fact, the material creation is a finite ocean of ignorance in which foolish living entities, such as material scientists, are unceremoniously dunked by the order of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. To be trapped in a world in which all things are born and die is certainly a fearful experience. Anyone trapped in a dark place naturally becomes fearful. Since material life is always covered by the darkness of ignorance, every conditioned soul is fearful. The material nature is not ultimate reality, and thus analysis of matter can never provide answers to ultimate questions. This dark, snakelike existence called material life immediately disappears as soon as one opens his eyes to the bright light of Kṛṣṇa consciousness.
“The ātmā, the pure jīva is the root. By ignorance of jīva one attains saṁsāra. By knowledge of ātmā one destroys saṁsāra. What is the use of knowing about the Lord?” This idea is refuted by stating the opposite. Those who do not know themselves as ātmā end up with material bodies by the agency of māyā, a devotee of the Lord who cannot tolerate fault, because of ignorance of the root svarūpa, that of the Lord (tena). By knowledge of the Lord, which destroys ignorance of the Lord, one attains knowledge of svarūpa of the jīva and this knowledge destroys ignorance caused by identity with the body. An example is given to show this destruction of ignorance. It is like thinking a rope is a snake. The details may be seen in another place: bhayaṁ dvitīyābhiniveśataḥ syād īśād apetasya viparyayo 'smṛtiḥ tan-māyayāto budha ābhajet taṁ bhaktyaikayeśaṁ guru-devate ātmā For the jīva averse to the Lord, there will be saṁsāra consisting of identity with body and lack of identity with the soul, because of his absorption in the material coverings on the soul, arising from the Lord’s māyā. Therefore, the intelligent person, taking guru as his Lord and very self, should fully worship the Lord with pure bhakti. SB 11.2.37 Śrīdhara Svāmī explains the verse. Since māyā created by the Lord creates fear, the intelligent person worships the Lord, the controller of māyā. “But fear arises because identity with body, which arises from ignorance of the ātmā. What does māyā do?” For the person ignorant of the Lord (īśād apetasy), the svarūpa of the jīva does not manifest because of māyā. Then he thinks he is the body (viparyayaḥ). Then by absorption in identity he develops fear. This is well known among people in māyā. The Lord says: daivī hy eṣā guṇa-mayī mama māyā duratyayā | mām eva ye prapadyante māyām etāṁ taranti te || My māyā made of the guṇas, fit for the jīva’s pleasure, is hard to surpass, but those who surrender to me alone can cross over this māyā. BG 7.14 Just by knowledge of the position of the Lord in general, māyā is destroyed. It does not require realization of Svayam Bhagavān Kṛṣṇa. The effects are observed in the names of Rāma. But knowledge of Kṛṣṇa, who makes his appearance in complete fullness, is the greatest knowledge and the result is the appearance of the highest prema for Kṛṣṇa. This should be understood from the verse.
This explains the ease of destroying saṁsāra. Some persons do not know (avijñānatām) that they (ātmānam) are Brahman, a svarūpa devoid of doing and experiencing (ātmatayā). For them the whole world is produced by this ignorance of ātma-jñāna alone (tena eva). This is because of coverings of matter on the ātmā. Or for those who do not know the Lord (ātmānam) as the dearest (ātmatayā), that ignorance produces samsāra. Or for those who think “I am the Lord, I am bhagavān,” that ignorance produces saṁsāra. By proper knowledge alone this world is definitely (pra) destroyed (līyate) in the most excellent way (bhuyo api). The word ca indicates that the desire for liberation is also destroyed, what to speak of the ocean of the temporary material world.
- Which fear of mine is sustained mainly by mistaken identification rather than by reality?
- What would I look at differently today if I remembered the rope is not a snake?
A man enters a dark room, sees a coiled rope, and flees in terror, sure it is a snake. A lamp is brought; the snake vanishes — there was no snake, only the rope misperceived. Bhava — material existence — is Brahmā's snake; Kṛṣṇa's knowledge is the lamp. Not 'all is one'; rather, the snake never was, and the rope is the Lord's energy correctly seen.
My note
Source: vedabase.io