FolioCorpusŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam

Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 1.8.20

तथा परमहंसानां मुनीनाममलात्मनाम् । भक्तियोगविधानार्थं कथं पश्येम हि स्त्रिय: ॥ २० ॥
tathā paramahaṁsānāṁ
[tathaa paramahamsaanaam]
munīnām amalātmanām
[muneenaam amalaatmanaam]
bhakti-yoga-vidhānārthaṁ
[bhakti-yoga-vidhaanaartham]
kathaṁ paśyema hi striyaḥ
[katham pashyema hi striyah]
tathā — besides that paramahaṁsānām — of the advanced transcendentalists munīnām — of the great philosophers or mental speculators amala-ātmanām — those whose minds are competent to discern between spirit and matter bhakti-yoga — the science of devotional service vidhāna-artham — for executing katham — how paśyema — can observe hi — certainly striyaḥ — women.
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
tathā paramahaṁsānāṁ
tathā
besides that
paramahaṁsānām
of the advanced transcendentalists
munīnām amalātmanām
munīnām
of the great philosophers or mental speculators
amala-ātmanām
those whose minds are competent to discern between spirit and matter
bhakti-yoga-vidhānārthaṁ
bhakti-yoga
the science of devotional service
vidhāna-artham
for executing
kathaṁ paśyema hi striyaḥ
katham
how
paśyema
can observe
hi
certainly
striyaḥ
women.
You Yourself descend to propagate the transcendental science of devotional service unto the hearts of the advanced transcendentalists and mental speculators, who are purified by being able to discriminate between matter and spirit. How then can we women know You perfectly?

Even the greatest philosophical speculators cannot have access to the region of the Lord. It is said in the Upaniṣads that the Supreme Truth, the Absolute Personality of Godhead, is beyond the range of the thinking power of the greatest philosopher. He is unknowable by great learning or by the greatest brain. He is knowable only by one who has His mercy. Others may go on thinking about Him for years together, yet He is unknowable. This very fact is corroborated by the Queen, who is playing the part of an innocent woman. Women in general are unable to speculate like philosophers, but they are blessed by the Lord because they believe at once in the superiority and almightiness of the Lord, and thus they offer obeisances without reservation. The Lord is so kind that He does not show special favor only to one who is a great philosopher. He knows the sincerity of purpose. For this reason only, women generally assemble in great number in any sort of religious function. In every country and in every sect of religion it appears that the women are more interested than the men. This simplicity of acceptance of the Lord’s authority is more effective than showy insincere religious fervor.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
How can we women hope to see you, the object of bhakti for the omniscient, liberated sages?
Commentary

I am hopeless as a woman. Can even the omniscient sages, paramahaṁsas, who worship you with attraction for your sweet pastimes, being ignorant of the truth about your pastimes, know the intricacies of your pastimes? That is expressed in this verse.

Amalātmanām refers to those who are free from the contamination of material guṇas, liberated souls in this life. How can we see you, who are the object of bhakti-yoga practice (bhakti-yoga-vidhānārtham) for the paramahaṁsas? That the paramahaṁsas worship the Lord has been explained in the verse ātmārāmas ca munayaḥ. (SB 1.7.10)

Related verses
He descends to propagate devotional service in the hearts of advanced transcendentalists. He is reachable by the purified — and the question implicit is: how can the rest of us recognize Him too?
Reflection Questions
  • What discrimination (between matter and spirit) is my practice cultivating?
  • Where could I purify perception to recognize Him more easily?
📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 8