FolioCorpusBhagavad-gītā

Bhagavad-gītā 15.2

అధశ్చోర్ధ్వం ప్రసృతాస్తస్య శాఖా గుణప్రవృద్ధా విషయప్రవాలా: । అధశ్చ మూలాన్యనుసన్తతాని కర్మానుబన్ధీని మనుష్యలోకే ॥ ౨ ॥
adhaś cordhvaṁ prasṛtās tasya śākhā
[adhash chordhvam prasritaas tasya shaakhaa]
guṇa-pravṛddhā viṣaya-pravālāḥ
[guna-pravriddhaa vishaya-pravaalaah]
adhaś ca mūlāny anusantatāni
[adhash cha moolaany anusantataani]
karmānubandhīni manuṣya-loke
[karmaanubandheeni manushya-loke]
adhaḥ — downward ca — and ūrdhvam — upward prasṛtāḥ — extended tasya — its śākhāḥ — branches guṇa — by the modes of material nature pravṛddhāḥ — developed viṣaya — sense objects pravālāḥ — twigs adhaḥ — downward ca — and mūlāni — roots anusantatāni — extended karma — to work anubandhīni — bound manuṣya - loke — in the world of human society .
Blended reading (Sanskrit + English inline)
adhaś cordhvaṁ prasṛtās tasya śākhā
adhaḥ
downward
guṇa-pravṛddhā viṣaya-pravālāḥ
adhaś ca mūlāny anusantatāni
ca
and
ūrdhvam
upward
prasṛtāḥ
extended
tasya
its
śākhāḥ
branches
guṇa
by the modes of material nature
pravṛddhāḥ
developed
viṣaya
sense objects
pravālāḥ
twigs
adhaḥ
downward
ca
and
mūlāni
roots
anusantatāni
extended
karmānubandhīni manuṣya-loke
karma
to work
anubandhīni
bound
manuṣya - loke
in the world of human society .
  • guṇa — the modes of material nature
    The sap of the tree. Sattva, rajas, and tamas swell every branch; no leaf opens without their feeding. The tree's vigor is not its own — it is the guṇas in motion, which is why pruning at the level of leaves never weakens the tree.
  • viṣaya — sense objects
    Pravālāḥ — the soft new shoots. Sense-objects look like the freshest, greenest part of the tree, but they are only twigs. The verse quietly demotes what the senses worship: the gleaming object is not the source, only the tip.
  • karma — to work (fruitive activity)
    Anubandhīni — 'binding behind.' Karma is here a secondary root: not the tree's origin, but the rope by which the tree ties itself to human society. Each fruitive act drops another tendril into the soil of manuṣya-loka.
  • manuṣya - loke — in the world of human society
    The human realm is named as the soil where karma's downward roots take hold. This is the realm of choice, and therefore the realm where the tree can be both fed and felled — the cutting Kṛṣṇa prescribes is uniquely possible from here.
  • anubandhīni — bound
    From anu + bandh — to bind along, bind in sequence. Not one knot but a chain of them, each karma tying to the next. The grammar quietly tells you why a single resolution never frees: the binding is serial.
The branches of this tree extend downward and upward, nourished by the three modes of material nature. The twigs are the objects of the senses. This tree also has roots going down, and these are bound to the fruitive actions of human society.

The description of the banyan tree is further explained here. Its branches spread in all directions. In the lower parts, there are variegated manifestations of living entities – human beings, animals, horses, cows, dogs, cats, etc. These are situated on the lower parts of the branches, whereas on the upper parts are higher forms of living entities: the demigods, Gandharvas and many other higher species of life. As a tree is nourished by water, so this tree is nourished by the three modes of material nature. Sometimes we find that a tract of land is barren for want of sufficient water, and sometimes a tract is very green; similarly, where particular modes of material nature are proportionately greater in quantity, the different species of life are manifested accordingly. The twigs of the tree are considered to be the sense objects. By development of the different modes of nature we develop different senses, and by the senses we enjoy different varieties of sense objects. The tips of the branches are the senses – the ears, nose, eyes, etc. – which are attached to the enjoyment of different sense objects. The twigs are sound, form, touch, and so on – the sense objects. The subsidiary roots are attachments and aversions, which are by-products of different varieties of suffering and sense enjoyment. The tendencies toward piety and impiety are considered to develop from these secondary roots, which spread in all directions. The real root is from Brahmaloka, and the other roots are in the human planetary systems. After one enjoys the results of virtuous activities in the upper planetary systems, he comes down to this earth and renews his karma, or fruitive activities for promotion. This planet of human beings is considered the field of activities.

— A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda
Viśvanātha Cakravartī Ṭhākura Gauḍīya
Translation
2. The branches, nourished by the guṇas, with sense objects for twigs, spread up and down. Secondary roots spread out everywhere in the world of men, and are causes of continued action. 3-4. The real form of this tree, its end, its beginning, and its shelter, cannot be perceived in this world. Cutting down this tree which has roots sprouting everywhere, using the axe of detachment, a person should search out the treasure, attaining which he does not return again. He should seek refuge in that original person from whom the ancient actions of saṁsāra have originated.
Commentary

The branches of this tree spread down (adhaḥ) in the form of animals and others, and upward in the form of the birth of devatās and other elevated beings. These branches increase and increase by the watering process in the form of actions of the three guṇas (guṇa-pravṛddhā). The small twigs on the branches are the sense objects such as sound (viṣaya-pravālāḥ). Moreover, it can be inferred that, at the base of the tree, unknown to all people, is some great treasure. There are external roots from the branches of the aśvattha, meaning in this case a banyan tree, [Note: The aśvattha tree does not have these secondary roots from the branches.] which is dependent for support on both the main root and the external roots. These secondary roots, the cause of continued action, spread out everywhere (anusantantāni) below Brahmaloka (adhaḥ), in the planet of humans. Karma anubandhīni means that after enjoying the results of ones actions in one life, those actions become stimulus for actions in another human birth.

Moreover, the real form of the tree cannot be perceived in the world of men. This is because of the great variety of opinions such as “The world is real. The world is false. The world is eternal.” One cannot understand its end (na antaḥ), and because it seems unlimited, one cannot understand its beginning as well. Because it seems to have no beginning, one cannot understand its shelter (sampratiṣṭhā) or support. One cannot understand what it is, because of lack of real knowledge. In any case, knowing that detachment is the weapon to cut down the tree, which is the only cause of the suffering of all jīvas, one should cut down the tree with that detachment, and should look for the treasure situated at the base of the root. The word asaṅgaḥ here means detachment, or complete renunciation. Having cut the tree down with the axe (śastreṇa) of complete detachment, separating it from oneself, one should then search (parimārgitavyam) for the object (tat-padam), Brahman, the great treasure, existing at the root. What type of thing is that? One should look for that object which having attained (yasmin gataḥ), one does not return. He then explains the method of searching. I worship (prapadye) that original person from whom the long standing (purāṇī) action of saṁsāra (pravṛttiḥ) has spread out: one should search by the process of bhakti.

Baladeva Vidyābhūṣaṇa Gauḍīya
Translation
2. The branches, nourished by the guṇas, with sense objects for shoots, spread up and down. Secondary roots spread out everywhere in the world of men and are causes of continued action. 3-4. The real form of this tree, its termination, its origin, and its shelter, cannot be perceived in this world. Cutting down this tree which has roots sprouting everywhere with the axe of detachment, one should search out the base, attaining which one does not return again, by taking refuge in that original person, Kṛṣṇa, from whom the universe has come long ago.
Commentary

Moreover, the branches of the tree (material bodies) are spread down and up. They spread downwards by jīvas’ committing sinful acts and being born in the bodies of men and animals, and they spread upwards by jīvas’ performance of pious acts and being born as devas and gandharvas. By the actions of the three guṇas, like sprinkling water, the branches (bodies) take a gross form. The tree has shoots or buds (pravālāḥ) in the form of sense objects (viṣaya) such as sound and touch. The sense objects such as sound are considered to be shoots because of being joined to the tips of the branches, which are the senses, and because of being the abodes of enjoyment. [Note: The branches (bodies) have tips (senses) which have shoots (sense objects), which are sources of enjoyment (rāga). The word rāga also means color. Just as the new leaves give color and beauty to the tree, the sense objects give enjoyment to the senses and body. Madhusūdana Sarasvatī gives the same analogy using senses and rāga.] The tree has secondary roots spreading down and up (“up” is indicated by the word ca). [Note: These are the roots descending from the branches of the banyan tree.] These secondary roots are the impressions caused by attachment and repulsion born from enjoyment of various sense objects. The impressions are said to be roots because they are causes of man’s tendency to act according to dharma or adharma. The main root (cause of the universe) is four-headed Brahmā and the secondary roots (which cause actions and particular bodies) are the various impressions. These are compared to the tangled roots emanating from the banyan tree. What type of roots are these? They give rise to the bondage of karma. With the depletion of the enjoyment of results of previous karma (and fall of the jīva from a heavenly planet), they give rise to karma on the earth planet (karma anubandhīni). It is well known that this earth planet is the place for accruing karma. Bg 15.3, Bg 15.4, Bg 15.3-4 Na æPaMaSYaeh TaQaaePal/>YaTae NaaNTaae Na caidNaR c SaMPa[iTaṣa ) AṅTQaMaeNa& Sauivæ!MaUl/‚ MaSa(r)Xaṣe<a d*!eNa i^tva )) 3 )) TaTa" Pad& TaTPairMaaiGaRTaVYa& YaiSMaNGaTaa Na iNavTaRiNTa >aUYa" ) TaMaev caÛ& Pauṛz& Pa[PaÛe YaTa" Pa[v*ita" Pa[Sa*Taa Paura<aq )) 4 )) na rūpam asyeha tathopalabhyate nānto na cādir na ca sampratiṣṭhā aśvattham enaṁ su-virūḍha-mūlam asaṅga-śastreṇa dṛḍhena chittvā tataḥ padaṁ tat parimārgitavyaṁ yasmin gatā na nivartanti bhūyaḥ tam eva cādyaṁ puruṣaṁ prapadye yataḥ pravṛttiḥ prasṛtā purāṇī na—not; rūpam—the form; asya—of this tree; iha—in this world; tathā—also; upalabhyate—can be perceived; na—never; antaḥ—end; na—never; ca—also; ādiḥ—beginning; na—never; ca—also; sampratiṣṭhā—the foundation; aśvattham—banyan tree; enam—this; su-virūḍha—strongly; mūlam—rooted; asaṅga-śastreṇa—by the weapon of detachment; dṛḍhena—strong; chittvā—cutting; tataḥ—thereafter; padam—situation; tat—that; parimārgitavyam—has to be searched out; yasmin—where; gatāḥ—going; na—never; nivartanti—they come back; bhūyaḥ—again; tam—to Him; eva—certainly; ca—also; ādyam—original; puruṣam—the Personality of Godhead; prapadye—surrender; yataḥ—from whom; pravṛttiḥ—the beginning; prasṛtā—extended; purāṇi—very old.

The form of this tree as described by Me with root upward and branches downwards is not perceived in the world of men. Its destruction is not perceived: it is not understood how to destroy the network of desires. Its origin is also not perceived: from what and why it has appeared in this manner is not understood. Its shelter is not perceived. Of what does it take shelter to remain standing? Rather, all that is understood is “I am a human, the son of Yajṣadatta, the father of Devadatta. I do my actions according to that identity, and experience happiness and suffering. I am living in this province, in this village.” Because this aśvattha is not understood and is the cause of useless vows and actions, one should cut it down with the strong axe of detachment (asaṅga śastreṇa), sharpened by repeated discrimination (dṛḍhena)— with knowledge of things as they are, gained from association with devotees. Separating the tree from oneself, one should seek out the base (parimārgitavyam). The ending of the sentence is the next verse. Saṅga means desire for sense objects, and asaṅga means the opposite, detachment from sense objects. This is the weapon, because it can destroy the desires. The tree is tightly rooted (suvirūḍha), as previously described. [Note: The main root is Brahmā and the tangle of secondary roots are the countless impressions which lead to bondage of karma.] One should seek out that padam, which is situated above the root, (which is above everything else). One should seek it out by sādhana such as hearing, obtained from My devotees. What type of padam is that? Having attained it by sādhanas, people do not leave, they do not fall, in the manner of falling from svarga. The method of searching out the base is described. I surrender to that person who is the cause of all (adyam), from whom the universe has appeared long ago. What is explained here as the method of searching and attaining is hearing and other processes, along with surrender. The person who is the cause of the universe, surrendering to whom saṁsāra is destroyed, is Myself, Kṛṣṇa. ahaṁ sarvasya prabhavo mattaḥ sarvaṁ pravartate iti matvā bhajante māṁ budhā bhāva-samanvitāḥ I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who perfectly know this engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts. BG 10.8 daivī hy eṣā guṇa-mayī mama māyā duratyayā mām eva ye prapadyante māyām etāṁ taranti te This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it. BG 7.14 The Lord will also say : na tad bhāsayate sūryo na śaśāṅko na pāvakaḥ yad gatvā na nivartante tad dhāma paramaṁ mama The sun, moon and fire do not light up My supreme form. Having attained this beautiful form of Mine, they do not return. BG 15.6

Gauranga Priya Dāsa Study Key verse
Bhakti-śāstrī Notes, ISKCON Chowpatty (2009)
Theme

Material world is a tree nourished by three modes and fruitive acts

Different species manifest according to the proportions of modes (purport)
When less water – tract is barren
When more water – tract is green

PLEASE NOTE: The Remaining points of the purport are covered after Text 15.4 as a part of the Summarized

Themes 15A & 15B

Texts 15.3* – 15.4*

COMMON THEME: The real form of this tree cannot be perceived in this world. Use the axe of ‘detachment’

This tree is not real, but a reflection of the real tree
Impossible to fully understand the real tree
Solution – But we can cut down this tree with determination with the axe of detachment
Desired destination – Then one must go beyond the tree and surrender to the Supreme Person (surrendering process is explained in Text 15.5) from whom entirety has sprout

Focus of Learning

(a) Why real form cannot be understood

Because root is up and extension is at the other end
When we are entangled in material expansion one cannot see how far the tree extends and where is the beginning

(b) Finding out the cause – Father’s father’s father’s… to Brahmaloka to Garbodaksayi Vishnu to

Krishna

Krishna is the end of research work
How to search out that origin? – From association of persons in knowledge of Supreme Personality of Godhead

(c) Benefits of this knowledge

One should gradually become detached from false reflection
Cut of this connection
Actually become situated in the real tree

(d) Importance of the word “Asanga”

Attachment for sense enjoyment and lording over material nature is very strong
Therefore learn detachment by:
Discussion of sastras
Hear from those actually in knowledge – sadhus
Result of such discussion – One comes to Supreme Personality of Godhead and finally surrenders
Surrender / Devotional service results in automatic detachment

SUMMARISED THEME 15B

THE ONLY WAY OUT OF THE TREE IS DETACHMENT – HOW?

A) Find one in knowledge (15.4)

Hear properly from him,
About the relationship between the Lord and the living entity

B) Surrender to the Lord (15.5)

Through the spiritual master
No false prestige that he is lord of material nature
No in illusion
Gives up false association
Free from dualities

C) Attain the eternal abode (15.6)

SUMMARISED THEME 15A

THE BANYAN TREE
The material world: A perverted relflection of the spiritual world

(a) Reflecting medium – Original tree of spiritual world is reflected on “Desire” / analogous to

“Water” – “Desire” is the cause of things being situated in this reflected material light

(b) Roots

The real root of this material existence grows upward
This means that it begins from the total material substance, from the topmost planet of the universe, Brahmaloka
The secondary roots are in the human planetary systems (Bhuloka) and grow downward and spread in all directions
They are bound to the fruitive actions of human society
Subsidiary roots are attachments and aversions, which are by products of different varieties of suffering and sense enjoyment
Tendencies towards piety and impiety are considered to develop from these secondary roots

(c) Branches – Upper and lower planets

(d) Leaves – Vedic Hymns

(e) Twigs – Sense objects

(f) Tips of branches – Senses

(g) Fruits – Dharma, Artha, Kaama, Moksha

(h) Nourishment – The three modes of material nature

(i) The living entities involvement in this tree

Hops from one branch to another trying to taste the fruit
Can’t see how far the tree extends or where it ends
Although living entities are the eternal fragmental parts of Krishna, they are struggling with the senses (15.7)
Śrī Śaṅkarācārya Classical
Translation
15.2 Sakhah, the branches, as it were; tasya, of that Tree; prasrtah, extending; adhah, downwards, from the human beings to the immobile (trees etc.); ca, and; urdhvam, upwards, upto Brahma-beginning from the Creator of the Cusmos to Dharma (Death) [According to A.G. 'human beings' stands for the world of human beings, and 'Brahma ' for the 'world of Brahma' (Satva-loka). So Dharma may mean the 'world of Death' (pitr-loka).-Tr.], which, 'in accordance with their work and in conformity with their knowledge' (Ka. 2.2.7), are the results of knowledge and actions; are guna-pravrddhah, strengthened, made stout, by the alities sattva, rajas and tamas, which are their materials; and visaya-pravalah, have the sense-objects as their shoots. The sense-objects (sound etc.) sprout, as it were, like new leaves from the branches (bodies etc.) which are the results of actions. Thery the branches are said to have sense-objects as their shoots. The supreme Root, the material cause of the Tree of the World, has been stated earlier. And now, the latent impressions of attraction, repulsion, etc. born of the results of action are the subsidiary roots, as it were, which grow later on and become the cause of involvement in righteousness and and unrighteousness. And those mulani, roots; karma-anubandhini, which are followed by actions; anu-santatani, spread, enter; adhah, downwards, as compared with the world of gods; manusya-loke, into the world of human beings particularly-for it is well known that (only) here men have competence for rites and duties. They (these roots) are said to be karma-anubandhini since actions (karma) that are characterized as righteous and unrighteous follow as their product (anubandha), (i.e.) succeed the rise of those (attraction, repulsion, etc.).
Śrī Rāmānujācārya Classical
Translation
15.2 The 'secondary roots' of this tree having the main roots in the world of Brahman and its crest in men ramify below in the world of men. They bind them according to their Karma. The meaning is that the effects of acts causing bondag become roots in the world of men. For, the effect of actions done in the human state brings about the further condition of men, beasts etc., down below, and of divinities etc., up above.
Śrī Abhinavagupta Classical
Translation
15.1-2 Urdhva-mulam etc. Adhas ca etc. In other scriptural texts it is delcared 'All is the holy Fig-tree; that alone is to be meditated upon'. The present verse tells us this : What is intended by that declaration is only the religious meditation of the Brahman, the Bhagavat. Root : the one with a highly tranil nature. That is high (above) : Becasue it can be attained by him alone who has withdrawn himself from every other [lower] thing. The [Vedic] hymns are the leaves [of it] etc. : Just as the girth, height, the fruits and the taste etc. of a tree are indicated by its leaves, in the same fashion the idea of the Brahman-being is through the scriptures that are included in the 'Vedic hymns'. This is what is narrated here. With Strands : i.e., with the Sattva etc. Well developed : i.e., starting from gods down to the stationary ones. Of this tree, the roots, that are below, are the good and bad actions.
Swami Sivananda Classical
Translation
15.2 Below and above spread its branches, nourished by the Gunas; sense-objects are its buds; and below, in the world of men, stretch forth the roots, originating action.
Commentary

15.2 अधः below? च and? ऊर्ध्वम् above? प्रसृताः spread? तस्य its? शाखाः branches? गुणप्रवृद्धाः nourished by the Gunas? विषयप्रवालाः senseobjects (are) its buds? अधः below? च and? मूलानि the roots? अनुसन्ततानि are stretched forth? कर्मानुबन्धीनि originating action? मनुष्यलोके in the world of men.Commentary The countless objects? large and small? which life needs are all products of the five elements through the activity of the alities. This tree of Samsara is nourished by the three alities of Nature. The senseobjects are its buds and the roots which grow downwards are the bonds of Karma for those who lead a life of passion and attachment in this world? who are under the sway of likes and dislikes. The sprouts of this marvellous tree are the charming objects of the senses with their characteristics of sound? touch? colour? taste and smell. The roots? the Karmic tendencies from the past lives? grow downwards to generate the bonds of Karma in the world of men. These roots strengthen the bondage by further actions.The primal root is ignorance from which arises the eightfold Nature -- the five elements? mind? intellect and egoism. From the stem of the tree spring four branches called Svedaja? Andaja?,Jarayuja and Udbhijja. Eightyfour lakhs (eight million and four hundred thousand) of species came into being.One branch shoots straight upwards. This is the branch of Dharma which yields the fruit of enjoyment in heaven. Another branch is the branch of dispassion which yields the fruit of Selfrealisation. The sun? the planets? the manes and the sages have also come out of this wonderful tree. Above them are the branches of the worlds of Indra and the gods. Still higher are those of the sages and the men of austerities and penance. Still higher is the Satyaloka where Hiranyagarbha dwells.From man down to the immovable objects below and from him up to the realm of the Creator above? whatever regions are attained in accordance with the nature of knowledge or action? they are the ramifying branches of the tree of Samsara. They are nurtured and fattened by the three Gunas which form their material base.The senseobjects such as sound? touch? colour? taste and smell represent the buds that sprout from the branches of the physical bodies which are the products of actions.The highest root of this wondeful tree is Brahman. The secondary roots are the latent impressions (Samskaras) of likes and dislikes? which spread in this world of men and impel them to perform virtuus and vicious actions and bind them fast to actions.Now listen to the way by which this tree can be cut off. Only he who thus cuts his bondage to this tree of Samsara can be happy even in this world. He has the highest wisdom because he stands as a spectator of this tree and knows it as it is? without being tied to it.

Swami Gambhīrānanda Classical
Translation
15.2 The branches of that (Tree), extending down-wards and upwards, are strengthened by the alities and have sense-objects as their shoots. And the roots, which are followed by actions, spread down-wards in the human world [According to A.G. and M.S. manusya-loke means a body distinguished by Brahminhood etc.].
Shri Purohit Swami Classical
Translation
15.2 Its branches shoot upwards and downwards, deriving their nourishment from the Qualities; its buds are the objects of sense; and its roots, which follow the Law causing man's regeneration and degeneration, pierce downwards into the soil.
Related values
Tyaga (Renunciation / Letting Go)Ahimsa (Non-violence / Compassion)Tapas (Austerity / Discipline)Daksya (Resourcefulness / Skill)Abhaya (Fearlessness)
Related verses
BG 15.1 BG 14.5 BG 3.39 SB 11.22.10 SB 3.25.15 SB 5.14.2 CC Madhya 20.118 CC Madhya 19.151 CC Madhya 22.24 Kaṭha Upaniṣad 1.3.10Śvetāśvatara Upaniṣad 4.5
The tree's branches extend down and up, nourished by the modes; the twigs are sense-objects; the secondary roots bind man to fruitive activity.
Practical Applications
  • See your own attachments as branches of this universal tree.
  • Recognize sense-objects as twigs, not trunk.
  • Don't waste effort on twigs.
Reflection Questions
  • What twig of mine has stolen the attention belonging to the trunk?
  • How would I redirect?

A vine in a damp jungle sends roots out of every joint — some climbing toward light, some plunging downward into rotting wood, drawing nourishment from whatever it touches. The three guṇas are the rain, the sense-objects the green tips probing outward, and karma the secondary aerial roots that lash the climber to the trunks of countless future bodies. Each new desire drops another rootlet into the human world.

📝 My note

← Read full Chapter 15